# Enneagram Research Library

A free list of 1,034 published Enneagram studies (1975 to 2026) and 46 books worth reading, compiled by Business Enneagram Asia and updated every week.

Web page: https://businessenneagramasia.com/research/  ·  Data (JSON): https://businessenneagramasia.com/research/data/papers.json

Please read: the Enneagram is a framework for self-awareness and development. It is not a diagnostic tool, a treatment, or a basis for hiring decisions.

## Common questions

**Is the Enneagram scientific?**
The research is still growing. This library lists 1,034 published Enneagram studies from 1975 to 2026. 195 report results in the direction the theory predicts, 814 are mixed and 25 are critical. 16 are systematic reviews or meta-analyses, and 102 use a comparison group or follow people over time.

**Where does Enneagram research come from?**
Most studies come from East Asia. By region: East Asia (607), Middle East (117), Americas (108), Europe (65), Southeast Asia (23), Africa (7), South Asia (6), Multi-country (4). Very little comes from Malaysia, Singapore or mainland China so far.

**Can the Enneagram be used to diagnose people or to make hiring decisions?**
No. The Enneagram is a framework for self-awareness and development. It is not a diagnostic tool, a treatment, or a basis for hiring decisions. Studies with clinical groups are listed so the record is complete; their use belongs to licensed health professionals.

**Who compiles this list and how often is it updated?**
Business Enneagram Asia (Kuala Lumpur) compiles it from the main research databases and updates it every week. 733 of the 1,034 studies have been checked against the journal record. Summaries are short and in our own words, with a link to each original.

## Studies by period
- 1975–89: 7
- 1990s: 23
- 2000–04: 55
- 2005–09: 153
- 2010–14: 214
- 2015–19: 264
- 2020–24: 227
- 2025–26 so far: 90

56% of all studies appeared in 2015 or later, led by South Korea, Turkey and the US. Many are small theses and programme evaluations.

## How to read this list

Evidence level: A = Review (16); B = Controlled or long-term (102); C = Validation or correlation (519); D = Before-and-after (146); E = Theory or case (251).

Result: Supportive = points the way the theory predicts (195); Mixed = some parts hold, some do not (814); Critical = does not support the theory (25).


## Level A · Review (16 studies)

- 2026 · Kim, J. Y. · *A study on the effects of Enneagram-based programs on stress reduction and coping* · Asia Counseling and Coaching Review, 8(3), 53-70 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.47018/accr.2026.8.3.53
  Found: Enneagram programmes tended to lower stress (effect size 0.87) and raise active coping (0.72, not significant), but passive coping such as wishful thinking also increased (-0.51); none of the effects held up across estimation methods, so the author treats them as tentative.
- 2025 · Jang, J. · *An exploratory study on the use of the Enneagram in career education for university students* · Asia Counseling and Coaching Research, 7(2), 101 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.47018/accr.2025.7.2.101
  Found: Korean studies report that Enneagram-based career programmes improved career identity, self-efficacy and career maturity; the evidence base is small.
- 2025 · 이주영 (Lee, Ju-young); 이송이 (Lee, Song-yi) · *A scoping review on the use of the Enneagram in military organisations [군(軍) 조직 내 에니어그램 활용에 대한 주제범위 문헌고찰]* · 한국군사학논총 (Korean Journal of Military Science), 14(1), 97-120 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A109617848
  Found: Identified 14 military Enneagram studies (9 articles, 4 master's theses, 1 report): 6 quantitative, 3 qualitative, 5 programme-development; mostly officers. Evidence base is small and largely descriptive.
- 2024 · Park, G. · *An exploratory study on coaching using personality types* · Asia Counseling and Coaching Review · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.47018/accr.2024.6.2.47
  Found: 12 of the 14 coaching papers used the Enneagram, but most focused on verifying or explaining types and said little about actual coaching application; few programme or scale studies were followed up.
- 2023 · Lee, N. S. · *A study on the effects of Enneagram parent education program through meta-analysis* · Asia Counseling and Coaching Research, 5(1), 48-62 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.47018/accr.2023.5.1.48
  Found: Overall effect size of Enneagram parent-education programmes was 0.40 (moderate); coping with parenting stress showed 0.72. Based on only 8 small local studies.
- 2022 · Okur Karali, R. B.; Meydan, H. · *A review of Turkish Enneagram literature in value education perspective* · Sakarya University Journal of Education, 22(2), 174-190 · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.53629/sakaefd.1128868
  Found: Mapped 24 Turkish studies and concluded the model can be used for understanding students, guidance and education management (e.g. Type 4 and 5 teachers perceived lower power distance).
- 2021 · Hook, J. N.; Hall, T. W.; Davis, D. E.; Van Tongeren, D. R.; Conner, M. · *The Enneagram: A systematic review of the literature and directions for future research* · Journal of Clinical Psychology, 77(4), 865-883 · Result: Mixed · Multi-country · https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.23097
  Found: Found mixed evidence of reliability and validity. Big Five links were consistent with theory (e.g. Type 1-conscientiousness in 9/9 studies), but factor analyses usually found fewer than nine factors, no study derived nine types by clustering, and wings/arrows lack support. Only 9 studies appeared in mainstream psychology journals.
- 2020 · Jung, S. A.; Wang, H. J. · *Meta-analysis of the effectiveness of the Enneagram group program: focusing on university students* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.22839/adp.2020.9.1.117
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 · 지미선 · *Research trends in Korean journal articles on the Enneagram: a semantic network analysis [의미연결망 분석을 통한 에니어그램 키워드 중심 국내 학술지 연구 동향 분석]* · 에니어그램연구 (Enneagram Research) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A345294
  Found: Found eight clusters in Korean Enneagram research, including the Korean Enneagram, trait differences, case studies, character analyses and validation. The heart centre and mothers were the most studied, and the author calls for more qualitative work and type-specific studies.
- 2015 · Lee, M. R. [이미련] · *Analysis of research trends in Enneagram program studies [에니어그램 프로그램 관련 연구동향 분석]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Journal of Enneagram Studies) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A260482
  Found: Of 172 papers, 30 applied Enneagram programmes, mostly quantitative, typically 7-8 sessions of 120 minutes over 4-8 weeks; calls for more varied targets and qualitative studies.
- 2014 · Do, K.; Kim, D.; Kim, M.; Kim, J.; Kim, H.; Shin, Y.; Lee, E.; Yoo, S.; Lee, J. · *An integrative review of Korean studies on Enneagram programmes for children and adolescents [아동ㆍ청소년 에니어그램 프로그램 국내논문의 통합적 고찰]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A228851
  Found: Classified 23 Korean child/adolescent Enneagram programme studies by area, subject and design to guide better programme development.
- 2014 · Lee, M. · *Trends in Enneagram research: an analysis of papers in the Korean Journal of Enneagram Studies, 2004–2013 [에니어그램연구 게재 논문 분석을 통한 에니어그램 연구동향]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A229735
  Found: Most studies were surveys of college students or adults using adapted foreign tools and t-tests. Self-esteem, self-efficacy and parenting attitude were the most common variables.
- 2013 · Lee, S. Y.; Jung, J. A. · *A study on the research approaches utilizing the Enneagram: Focusing on parents as research objects* · Korean Journal of Family Welfare, 18(4), 657-679 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.13049/kfwa.2013.18.4.657
  Found: Classified Korean Enneagram research into seven approaches. Since 2009, experimental studies have dominated and continued to grow in Enneagram research on parents.
- 2010 · Lee, M. · *Analysis of Korean research on the Enneagram and spirituality [에니어그램과 영성 관련 국내연구의 분석]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A134178
  Found: Reviewed 12 theses on spirituality, spiritual counselling, spiritual practice and spiritual maturity; they are largely descriptive or theological rather than empirical.
- 2009 · Lee, S.; Jung, C. · *Research trends of the Enneagram and a meta-analysis of the effects of Enneagram programmes: Focusing on children, adolescents and parents [에니어그램 연구동향 분석과 프로그램 효과에 관한 메타분석]* · Korean Journal of Family Welfare · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://dspace.kci.go.kr/handle/kci/1276767
  Found: The overall effect size of family-related Enneagram programmes was 0.80, highest for high school students (0.94) and self-related variables (0.98); the primary studies are mostly small Korean quasi-experiments.
- 2002 · Lee, K. J. · *The application of Enneagram in the psychiatric nursing* · Journal of Korean Academy of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 11(3), 285-303 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.12934/jkpmhn.2002.11.3.285
  Found: Korean Enneagram research began in the late 1990s. Most studies were uncontrolled before-and-after workshop studies reporting positive change. The review recommends uses in psychiatric nursing.

## Level B · Controlled or long-term (102 studies)

- 2026 · Holder, L.; Buerster, K. B.; Zeringue, A.; Rippy, M. G.; Giles, W.; Bhattacharya, S. · *Not my type: A critical look at Enneagram use in resident education* · Journal of Surgical Research · Result: Critical · USA · https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2026.04.023
  Found: Types did not cluster by specialty, and under 25% of residents reported lasting benefit in communication, professionalism or wellbeing after a single Enneagram session.
- 2026 · Sousa, A. I. P. · *Medium-term impact of a self-knowledge programme on the well-being and stress of young people [Impacto a médio prazo de um programa de autoconhecimento no bem-estar e stress dos jovens]* · University of Coimbra, Faculty of Medicine (Integrated Master's in Medicine final thesis) · Result: Supportive · Portugal · https://hdl.handle.net/10316/123562
  Found: Participants reported lasting autonomy, better relationships, more empathy and better stress adaptation; current WHO-5 well-being positive and stress low-moderate. Retrospective, tiny, self-selected sample.
- 2026 · 이한얼 · *Effects of Enneagram group art therapy on newlyweds' marital communication and satisfaction [에니어그램 집단미술치료가 신혼부부의 부부의사소통능력과 부부만족도에 미치는 영향]* · Sookmyung Women's University Graduate School of Psychotherapy (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T17550687
  Found: Tests Enneagram-based group art therapy against controls; very small sample, results not in retrieved excerpt.
- 2025 · Song, J.-M.; Jang, E.; Kim, J. · *Effects of a horticultural therapy program incorporating the Enneagram on self-understanding and stress levels of university students* · Journal of People, Plants, and Environment, 28(3), 263-274 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.11628/ksppe.2025.28.3.263
  Found: Adding Enneagram content to horticultural therapy improved self-understanding (p < .01) and reduced stress (p < .05); the comparison group without it did not change.
- 2025 · Anderson, J.; Bartscher, B.; Medenwaldt, J. · *The Enneagram & the Barnum effect* · Northwestern College (Iowa) Celebration of Research 2025 · Result: Mixed · USA · not yet checked · https://nwcommons.nwciowa.edu/celebrationofresearch/2025/researchprojects2025/34
  Found: Tests whether perceived accuracy of Enneagram descriptions reflects the Barnum effect (top-three types rated equally accurate and above the bottom three); results not reported in the abstract. Check the full text before citing.
- 2025 · Vander Schee, B. A.; VanMeter, R. A.; Coleman, J. T. · *Using a self-assessment project and instructor self-disclosure to support student personal branding* · Marketing Education Review · Result: Supportive · USA · https://doi.org/10.1080/10528008.2025.2537023
  Found: Students rated the Enneagram self-assessment activity as valuable and self-expanding; sections whose instructor disclosed their own Enneagram results showed significant gains in self-awareness and personal-growth motivation that the control sections did not. Self-report data, and sections were not randomised.
- 2025 · Simão, F. I. L. S.; Rosendo, I.; Paiva, P. · *The impact of self-knowledge on the well-being of healthcare professionals and hospital teams* · Authorea (preprint, not peer-reviewed) · Result: Mixed · Portugal · https://doi.org/10.22541/au.174645726.64138123/v1
  Found: Qualitative answers described gains in self-awareness, relationships, empathy and teamwork, but quantitative results were mixed: the control group ended with higher insight than the intervention group. Very small, heterogeneous sample, and the paper is not yet peer-reviewed.
- 2025 · Cruz, A. I. R. · *Fibromyalgia: impact of self-knowledge on the well-being of people with fibromyalgia [Fibromialgia: impacto do autoconhecimento no bem-estar de pessoas com fibromialgia]* · University of Coimbra, Faculty of Medicine (Integrated Master's in Medicine final thesis) · Result: Mixed · Portugal · https://hdl.handle.net/10316/119549
  Found: No significant differences in quality of life, psychological flexibility or self-reflection within or between groups; 'extremely severe' depression fell from 42.9% to 14.3% (n.s.). Qualitative reports of better emotional regulation.
- 2025 · Henrique Ferreira, J. · *Academic performance and personality: a study of Enneagram archetypes in Brazilian high schools* · The Lens Journal, 3(3) · Result: Critical · Brazil · https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17223193
  Found: GPA differed descriptively across the nine types but differences were not statistically significant, and correlations were weak; author concludes type does not reliably predict achievement. Journal peer-review status unclear.
- 2024 · Mengual Martínez, G. M. · *The Enneagram as a methodological resource for grouping in the third cycle of primary education [El eneagrama como recurso metodológico para el agrupamiento en el tercer ciclo de Educación Primaria]* · Universidad de Murcia (thesis) · Result: Mixed · Spain · http://hdl.handle.net/10201/145584
  Found: Triad-based grouping coincided with high positive affect and task motivation, but similar results appeared in the control group, so the author does not attribute the benefit to the Enneagram.
- 2024 · Matos, I. G. · *Impact of self-knowledge on the well-being of health teams [Impacto do auto-conhecimento no bem-estar das equipas de saúde]* · University of Coimbra, Faculty of Medicine (Integrated Master's in Medicine final thesis) · Result: Mixed · Portugal · https://hdl.handle.net/10316/115791
  Found: Main quantitative finding was a significant change in the self-kindness subscale (p=.033); other stress/well-being outcomes largely non-significant, with qualitative reports of perceived benefits. Controls measured only once.
- 2024 · Teles, A. R. C. · *Stress and self-compassion in a group of young people – effectiveness of a self-knowledge-based intervention (2022/23 cohort) [Stress e autocompaixão num grupo de jovens – eficácia de uma intervenção baseada no autoconhecimento]* · University of Coimbra, Faculty of Medicine (Integrated Master's in Medicine final thesis) · Result: Mixed · Portugal · https://hdl.handle.net/10316/115938
  Found: Mixed-methods evaluation of the second cohort of the course; small quantitative sample with qualitative focus-group evidence of perceived benefits. Abstract truncated; check full text for effect sizes.
- 2024 · Vargas Delgado, J. J.; Sacaluga Rodríguez, I.; Pérez Sánchez, J. · *Exploring the neurocommunicative confluence: interdependence between personality traits and information-consumption patterns in fake-news detection among journalism and communication students [Explorando la confluencia neurocomunicativa]* · Revista Latina de Comunicación Social, 82, 1-16 · Result: Mixed · Spain · https://doi.org/10.4185/rlcs-2024-2281
  Found: Mean detection accuracy was 59%; Types 4 and 5 had more difficulty detecting disinformation while Types 3 and 9 identified it more often. Self-typed student sample; descriptive group comparisons.
- 2024 · 라성윤 · *Effects of a Korean Enneagram and Co-Active coaching programme on self-esteem and parenting attitudes of female single parents [한국형 에니어그램과 Co-Active 코칭 프로그램이 여성 한부모 자아존중감과 양육태도에 미치는 영향]* · 인격교육 (Korean Journal of Character Education), 18(3), 31-62 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.18015/edumca.18.3.202408.31
  Found: Experimental group improved more than controls in self-esteem (F=4.82, p<.05) and parenting attitude (F=7.15, p<.05); very small sample.
- 2023 · Monteiro, J. C. V. · *Stress and self-compassion in a group of young people – effectiveness of a self-knowledge-based intervention [Stress e autocompaixão num grupo de jovens – eficácia de uma intervenção baseada no autoconhecimento]* · University of Coimbra, Faculty of Medicine (Integrated Master's in Medicine final thesis) · Result: Mixed · Portugal · https://hdl.handle.net/10316/111576
  Found: Within-group improvement only on two subscales (over-identification p=.046; involvement in self-reflection p=.034). Very small sample; largely null between-group results.
- 2023 · Palanci, M. · *Change in the learning motivations and attention orientations of students in the pre- and post-COVID-19 periods: a longitudinal study* · ERIC (ED649501), online submission · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED649501
  Found: Learning motivation and attention declined across the pandemic periods; findings discussed by temperament/Enneagram profile. Not peer reviewed; Enneagram effects not quantified in the abstract.
- 2022 · Kheasa-ard, M. M.; Srikhruedong, S.; Kaewnak, N.; Nakornri, O.; Abhinando, P. A. · *A Dependent Origination programme and contemporary-psychology (Enneagram) model for creating mindful happiness among working women in Thai society [โปรแกรมปฏิจจสมุปบาทแบบจำลองลักษณ์จิตวิทยาร่วมสมัยสร้างสุขด้วยสติของสตรีวัยทำงานในสังคมไทย]* · Journal of MCU Ubon Review · Result: Mixed · Thailand · https://so06.tci-thaijo.org/index.php/mcjou/article/view/257195
  Found: A Buddhist Dependent Origination programme that used the Enneagram to identify nine personalities showed a significant difference between experimental and control groups at the follow-up phase (p<.01). Small sample, and the Enneagram is one component of a broader religious programme.
- 2022 · Costa, I. S. R. · *Long-term impact of self-knowledge on stress, burnout, self-compassion and compassion in medical students – controlled clinical trial [Impacto a longo prazo do autoconhecimento no stress, burnout, autocompaixão e compaixão em estudantes de medicina – ensaio clínico controlado]* · University of Coimbra, Faculty of Medicine (Integrated Master's in Medicine final thesis) · Result: Supportive · Portugal · https://hdl.handle.net/10316/102382
  Found: At 9 months the intervention group still showed gains in quality of life (p=.014), perceived stress (p=.018) and insight (p=.002); between-group differences were limited to self-reflection measures. Non-randomised, volunteer sample.
- 2022 · Roxo, M. E. G. P. · *Stress in young people and its relationship with self-knowledge and self-compassion – pilot clinical trial [Stress nos jovens e a sua relação com autoconhecimento e autocompaixão – estudo piloto de ensaio clínico]* · University of Coimbra, Faculty of Medicine (Integrated Master's in Medicine final thesis) · Result: Mixed · Portugal · https://hdl.handle.net/10316/102352
  Found: Baseline data only: stress correlated with self-awareness dimensions (rumination, self-reflection, insight); groups were homogeneous. No intervention outcomes reported yet.
- 2022 · Mendes, T. C. · *Enneagram as a didactic resource for group formation: a case study of experimentation in Physics teaching [Eneagrama como recurso didático na formação de grupos: um estudo de caso para a experimentação no ensino de Física]* · Universidade Federal de Mato Grosso do Sul (Doctoral thesis) · Result: Supportive · Brazil · https://repositorio.ufms.br/handle/123456789/5008
  Found: Enneagram-formed groups made more theory-practice links and scored higher on lab reports than self-selected groups; same-type/same-centre groups scored highest; Emotional-centre students scored lower. Single-school case study.
- 2021 · Navabifar, F.; Atashpour, S. H.; Golparvar, M. · *Investigating the efficacy of nine types of personality (Enneagram) training on self-control of marriage applicants* · Health System Research (تحقیقات نظام سلامت) · Result: Supportive · Iran · http://hsr.mui.ac.ir/article-1-1289-en.html
  Found: ANCOVA showed the Enneagram training improved initial, preventive and total self-control (Tangney SCS) versus controls. Small purposive sample, self-report, 45-day interval only.
- 2021 · Rodrigues, S. M. S. · *Stress and burnout in health professionals: self-knowledge as a prevention strategy – pilot clinical trial [Stress e Burnout nos Profissionais de Saúde: Autoconhecimento como Estratégia de Prevenção – estudo piloto de ensaio clínico]* · University of Coimbra, Faculty of Medicine (Integrated Master's in Medicine final thesis) · Result: Mixed · Portugal · https://hdl.handle.net/10316/98315
  Found: No significant differences between groups on stress, burnout or quality of life; qualitative feedback was positive. Small non-randomised pilot.
- 2021 · Martinho, A. C. M. · *Impact of self-knowledge on stress, burnout, self-compassion and compassion in medical students – controlled clinical trial [Impacto do autoconhecimento no stress, burnout, autocompaixão e compaixão em estudantes de medicina – ensaio clínico controlado]* · University of Coimbra, Faculty of Medicine (Integrated Master's in Medicine final thesis) · Result: Supportive · Portugal · https://hdl.handle.net/10316/98422
  Found: Within the intervention group quality of life (p=.002), perceived stress (p=.001) and self-compassion (p=.030) improved; between-group difference only on self-reflection after the course (p=.044), with a baseline imbalance. Volunteers, not randomised.
- 2021 · 이규숙 (Lee, Gyu-Sook) · *Effects of an Enneagram workshop on elementary students' self-concept [에니어그램 워크숍이 초등학생의 자아개념에 미치는 영향]* · 교육연구 (Hannam University Institute of Education), 27, 28-53 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A107980972
  Found: Workshop improved physical, social and personal self-concept (academic self-concept rose but not significantly), extending findings from older students.
- 2021 · 이용오 · *Applying Enneagram theory to group counselling: A character-education programme for elementary pupils [에니어그램의 이론적 고찰을 통한 집단상담 적용에 관한 연구]* · Korean Bible University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15774325
  Found: Experimental and control groups compared after an Enneagram character-education programme; result figures not in retrieved abstract.
- 2020 · Shin, E. S.; Lee, S. · *Effects of care promotion program based on nursing students' self-understanding: Application of Enneagram group education* · Journal of Korean Academic Society of Nursing Education, 26(2), 132 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.5977/jkasne.2020.26.2.132
  Found: Intervention improved college adjustment (F = 28.74), emotional intelligence (F = 15.66) and caring behaviour (F = 9.37), all p < .01, versus controls.
- 2020 · عبد الرؤف, مصطفى محمد الشيخ · *التفاعل بين تدريس الفيزياء المستند إلى نظرية الذکاء الناجح وأنماط نظام الإنيجرام Enneagram وتأثيره فى تنمية مهارات التفکير المنتج وحل المسائل الفيزيائية وخفض العبء المعرفى المصاحب لها لدى طلاب المرحلة الثانوية* · المجلة المصرية للتربية العلمية · Result: Supportive · Egypt · https://doi.org/10.21608/mktm.2020.113519
  Found: Productive thinking, physics problem-solving and cognitive load differed significantly by teaching method and by Enneagram head-centre type (5, 6, 7), with a significant interaction between them. The design is quasi-experimental with small cells.
- 2020 · Simões, M. J. C. · *The importance of self-knowledge on stress, burnout, self-compassion and compassion in medical students – pilot clinical trial [A importância do autoconhecimento no stress, burnout, autocompaixão e compaixão em estudantes de medicina – estudo piloto de ensaio clínico]* · University of Coimbra, Faculty of Medicine (Integrated Master's in Medicine final thesis) · Result: Mixed · Portugal · https://hdl.handle.net/10316/97643
  Found: Intervention group improved on all burnout dimensions, self-compassion and self-reflection/insight (p≈.03–.04) but showed no significant differences versus controls. Very small, non-randomised pilot.
- 2020 · Carvalhos, C. M. A. M. · *Stress and burnout in family doctors: self-knowledge as a prevention strategy – pilot clinical trial [Stress e burnout nos médicos de família: auto-conhecimento como estratégia de prevenção – estudo piloto de ensaio clínico]* · University of Coimbra, Faculty of Medicine (Integrated Master's in Medicine final thesis) · Result: Mixed · Portugal · https://hdl.handle.net/10316/97840
  Found: Feasibility pilot: controls worsened on stress and quality of life (p=.042) while burnout fell non-significantly in both groups; no significant self-reflection differences. Too small to judge efficacy.
- 2020 · 홍지원 · *Effects of an Enneagram career-exploration programme on middle-school students' career identity and career maturity [에니어그램 진로탐색 프로그램이 중학생의 진로정체감과 진로성숙도에 미치는 영향]* · Catholic University of Korea Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15615632
  Found: Evaluates career identity and maturity against controls with follow-up; result figures not in retrieved abstract.
- 2019 · Oh, D.-Y. · *Effects of Enneagram ‘Self-Discovery Process’ Centered for Psychodrama on Burnout of Elementary School Teachers* · The Korean Journal of Elementary Counseling · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.28972/kjec.2019.18.4.463
  Found: Burnout fell significantly in the experimental group and was lower than in the control group after the programme. The groups are very small and the follow-up was short.
- 2019 · Linarez-Placencia, G.; Espinoza-Castelo, L. M. · *Neurociencia y eneagrama: Reconfigurando los equipos de trabajo* · Revista de Pedagogía Critica · Result: Supportive · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.35429/jcp.2019.8.3.6.16
  Found: The authors report that teams formed by Enneagram type performed better than traditional teams and that physiological data supported Enneagram precepts. As a quasi-experiment, it gives limited detail on controls.
- 2019 · Üstündağ, M. F.; Yılmaz, E. D.; Uğur, K.; Ünal, Ö.; Herdem, A.; Aydın, O. · *Evaluating individual differences in patients with major depressive disorder focused on the Nine Types Temperament Model* · Klinik Psikiyatri Dergisi (Journal of Clinical Psychiatry) · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.5505/kpd.2019.50470
  Found: Nine Types Temperament (Enneagram-derived) Types 1, 2, 3, 4, 6 and 8 were associated with MDD, and specific types were linked to MDD specifiers (e.g. melancholic with Types 1, 5 and 6; seasonal with Type 4). Cross-sectional associations only.
- 2019 · Kim, S.-J.; Jeong, I.-J.; Kim, B. · *Effects of the Enneagram group counseling program on interpersonal relationship, self-esteem and stress coping strategy in nursing students [에니어그램 집단상담 프로그램이 간호대학생의 대인관계, 자아존중감 및 스트레스 대처에 미치는 영향]* · Journal of the Korea Convergence Society, 10(10), 347 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.15207/jkcs.2019.10.10.347
  Found: Compared with controls, the experimental group improved in interpersonal relationships (t=3.41, p=.001) and self-esteem (t=2.60, p=.012) but not in stress coping (t=0.10, p=.925). Self-report outcomes.
- 2019 · Kong, J.-H.; Lee, M.-H. · *The effect of Enneagram personalised reading instruction by personality type on emotional intelligence and vocational maturity of adolescents* · Journal of the Korean BIBLIA Society for Library and Information Science, 30(4), 115–134 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.14699/kbiblia.2019.30.4.115
  Found: The type-matched reading programme was reported as improving emotional intelligence and vocational maturity in Type 6 students, but the abstract gives no statistics. The authors call for larger samples.
- 2019 · 오대연 · *Effects of a psychodrama based on the Enneagram 'process of self-discovery' on elementary school teachers' burnout [에니어그램 ‘자아발견과정’ 중심 심리극이 초등교사의 소진에 미치는 효과]* ·  · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A364112
  Found: Burnout decreased significantly within the experimental group and differed significantly from controls after the programme. Very small groups.
- 2019 · Chiappetta, L. · *Impact of Enneagram training on self-concept clarity, self-efficacy and career adaptability [L'impact d'une formation à l'Ennéagramme sur la clarté du concept de soi, le sentiment d'efficacité personnelle et l'adaptabilité de carrière]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Mixed · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/20159
  Found: Abstract describes design only (training vs control on self-concept clarity, self-efficacy, career adaptability); results not given in the abstract – check full text.
- 2019 · 윤애란 · *Development and effectiveness of a Korean Enneagram marital-enhancement programme based on Imago dialogue [이마고대화법 기반 한국형에니어그램 부부관계 향상 프로그램 개발 및 효과 검증]* · Sun Moon University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15085898
  Found: Measured marital satisfaction, resilience, intimacy and conflict coping pre/post with qualitative reports; result figures not in retrieved abstract.
- 2018 · Kim, E.-J. · *Effect of the Enneagram Program on the Self-Understanding of University Students* · Journal of Korean Coaching Research · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.20325/kca.2018.11.2.23
  Found: Self-understanding scores rose significantly after the programme (stability, goal orientation, role recognition, self-acceptance, self-assertion). With no control group, the gains cannot be firmly credited to the programme.
- 2018 · Hollek, C. J. · *Enneagram training intervention's effect on college golfers' scores* · Goucher College (M.Ed. action research paper) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://doi.org/10.13016/m2m03z21b
  Found: Tournament scores improved significantly after the Enneagram-informed training, but the author notes other factors could explain the change. Six participants, no control group.
- 2018 · 김순천 · *Effects of a vision Enneagram teacher coaching programme on job performance of childcare teachers [보육교사의 직무수행 증진을 위한 에니어그램을 활용한 교사코칭프로그램 효과]* ·  · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://db.koreascholar.com/Article?code=360243
  Found: Compared with controls, teachers in the Enneagram coaching programme improved job-performance attitude (p<.05), competency (p<.01) and development skills (p<.01). Small sample, self-report outcomes.
- 2017 · Memarzadeh, M.; Khodabakhshi-Koolaee, A.; Khatiban, M. · *The effect of training the nine Enneagram personality types on spouse selection criteria and marital attitude of single girls* · Journal of Education and Community Health, 3(4), 24-30 · Result: Supportive · Iran · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.21859/jech.3.4.24
  Found: Tested Enneagram training on spouse-selection criteria and attitudes to marriage; the abstract reports a training effect, but detailed statistics were not retrieved.
- 2017 · 신은선 · *Effects of an Enneagram-based interpersonal caring programme on nursing students' college adjustment, emotional intelligence, anxiety and caring behaviour [에니어그램기반 사람돌봄프로그램이 간호대학생의 대학생활적응, 정서지능, 불안 및 돌봄행위에 미치는 효과]* · Dankook University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T14754226
  Found: Improvements in college adjustment, emotional intelligence, anxiety and caring behaviour were maintained one month after the programme.
- 2016 ·  · *Enneagram personality system as an effective model in prediction of risk of cardiovascular diseases: A case-control study* · Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Medicine (Mashhad University of Medical Sciences) · Result: Supportive · Iran · not yet checked · https://jctm.mums.ac.ir/article_7403.html
  Found: CVD patients scored higher on type 1 (F = 9.48, p = .003) and lower on type 5 (F = 6.23, p = .014) than healthy controls. Authors (Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences) and year not confirmed.
- 2015 · Sutton, A.; Williams, H. M.; Allinson, C. W. · *A longitudinal, mixed method evaluation of self-awareness training in the workplace* · European Journal of Training and Development, 39(7), 610-627 · Result: Mixed · UK · https://doi.org/10.1108/EJTD-04-2015-0031
  Found: Self-awareness was linked to job-related well-being. Employees reported more appreciation of diversity, better communication with colleagues and more confidence, but the small sample limited the ability to detect weak effects.
- 2015 · Kim, W.-G.; Cho Chung, H.-I. · *Effects of Korean Enneagram program on the ego-identity, interpersonal relationship, and self-leadership of nursing college students* · Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing Administration, 21(4), 393 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.11111/jkana.2015.21.4.393
  Found: Eight weeks after the programme, the intervention group scored higher than controls on ego identity (t=3.97, p<.001), interpersonal relationships (t=3.26, p=.002) and self-leadership (t=2.91, p=.007). The design was not randomised.
- 2015 · Kang, M. J. · *Effects of Enneagram program for self-esteem, interpersonal relationships, and GAF in psychiatric patients* · Journal of Korean Academy of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 24(2), 116 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.12934/jkpmhn.2015.24.2.116
  Found: Compared with routine nursing activities, the Enneagram group improved self-esteem (t = 3.73, p = .001), interpersonal relationships (t = 2.63, p = .012) and global functioning (t = 2.43, p = .019).
- 2015 · Hendrati, F. · *Improving marital harmony for husband-wife of different cultures in the early marriage years* · International Journal of Social and Local Economic Governance, 1(2) · Result: Mixed · Indonesia · https://doi.org/10.21776/ub.ijleg.2015.001.02.8
  Found: Abstract describes the design of a modified Enneagram programme for intercultural couples but does not report results.
- 2015 · Kim, E. Y.; Lee, J. M. [김은영; 이지명] · *Effects of Enneagram-based group art therapy on marital communication and marital satisfaction of married women [에니어그램 중심 집단 미술치료가 기혼여성의 부부의사소통과 결혼만족도에 미치는 효과]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Journal of Enneagram Studies) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A260476
  Found: Enneagram-based group art therapy significantly improved marital communication and marital satisfaction versus control; very small sample.
- 2015 · 오명숙 · *Effects of a Korean Enneagram career guidance programme on career identity, self-efficacy and career maturity [한국형에니어그램 진로지도프로그램이 진로정체감과 자기효능감 및 진로성숙도에 미치는 영향]* · Sun Moon University (doctoral dissertation); also 에니어그램연구 12(2), 73-98 (with 윤운성) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T13740187
  Found: Examines programme effects on career identity, self-efficacy and career maturity against a control class (scale alphas .80-.91); result figures not in retrieved abstract.
- 2014 · Paek, J.-H.; Han, Y.-O. · *A study on effect of reading guidance program based on Enneagram of personality* · Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science, 48(2), 45-64 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.4275/kslis.2014.48.2.045
  Found: Self-encouragement, self-efficacy and sociality all improved in the experimental group compared with the control class. Small, non-random sample.
- 2014 · Sepehrian Azar, F.; Fatahy, O. · *Efficacy of enneagram personality types teaching on educational adjustment of students* ·  · Result: Supportive · country not stated · not yet checked · https://doaj.org/article/b82661cd8b7b437fa1072ea7c0091c93
  Found: ANCOVA showed the Enneagram-trained group had significantly higher educational adjustment than controls at post-test. Self-report outcome, no follow-up.
- 2014 · Baek, J.; Han, Y. · *Effects of reading guidance applying Enneagram personality types for 6th-grade elementary students [에니어그램 성격유형을 적용한 독서지도의 효과 연구]* · 한국문헌정보학회지 (Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.dbpia.co.kr/journal/articleDetail?nodeId=NODE02418126
  Found: Self-encouragement, self-efficacy and sociability all improved more in the Enneagram reading class than in the control class. Convenience classes, not randomised. A version also appeared in 에니어그램연구 (2014).
- 2014 · Kim, M. S.; Yoon, U. · *Development and effectiveness of an Enneagram group counselling programme to reduce violence-triggering factors in domestic-violence perpetrators [가정폭력행위자들의 폭력유발요인을 감소시키기 위한 에니어그램 집단상담 프로그램 개발 및 효과성 검증]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://www.earticle.net/Article.aspx?sn=240361
  Found: Compared with controls, the programme group improved in stress coping, self-esteem and communication and reduced drinking and pro-violence attitudes. Gains held at 4-week follow-up.
- 2014 · 최진태; 이정원 · *Effects of an Enneagram-based Satir family therapy programme on congruence and self-esteem of middle-aged women [에니어그램에 기반한 사티어 가족치료프로그램이 중년기 여성의 일치성과 자아존중감 향상에 미치는 효과 연구]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 11(2), 175-206 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A100325195
  Found: Programme improved self-esteem and congruence, with effects maintained at follow-up; small sample and programme combines Satir therapy with Enneagram, so the Enneagram's specific contribution is unclear.
- 2014 · 오명숙; 윤운성 · *Effects of a Korean Enneagram education programme on self-efficacy and life satisfaction [한국형에니어그램 교육프로그램이 자기효능감과 생활만족도에 미치는 효과]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 11(2), 115-139 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A100325193
  Found: Experimental group exceeded controls on self-efficacy (F=7.49, p<.01) and life satisfaction (F=7.29, p<.01); very small sample.
- 2013 · Lee, J. S.; Yoon, J. A.; Do, K. J. · *Effectiveness of Enneagram group counseling for self-identification and depression in nursing college students [에니어그램 집단상담]* · Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing, 43(5), 649-657 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.4040/jkan.2013.43.5.649
  Found: Self-identity improved significantly more than in controls, but depression scores did not differ between groups (a null result on depression).
- 2013 · 김유진; Ryu, K. H. · *Effects of the Enneagram group program on the job stress and teacher efficacy of special-education teachers* · The Journal of Special Children Education, 15(2), 129-145 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.21075/kacsn.2013.15.2.129
  Found: Compared with controls, the programme group showed lower job stress (student guidance, administrative support) and higher teacher efficacy (self-regulation, task-difficulty preference). Small single-school sample.
- 2013 · Keşan, C.; Kabak, S. · *A research on the effect of Enneagram on group work in 7th grade mathematics teaching* · International Journal of New Trends in Arts, Sports & Science Education (IJTASE) · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://www.ijtase.net/index.php/php/article/view/399
  Found: Achievement did not differ significantly between Enneagram-based and regular group work, though the Enneagram group's mean was higher. Small sample.
- 2013 · Kim, Y.; Ryu, K. · *Effects of an Enneagram group programme on special-education teachers' job stress and teacher efficacy [에니어그램을 이용한 집단프로그램이 특수교사의 직무스트레스와 교사효능감에 미치는 효과]* ·  · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3144322
  Found: Compared with controls, participants showed lower job stress (student guidance, administrative support) and higher teacher efficacy (self-regulation, task-difficulty preference). Single-school sample.
- 2013 · 최미숙 · *Effects of a children's Enneagram programme on self-acceptance and acceptance of others [아동용 에니어그램 프로그램이 초등학생의 자기수용 및 타인수용에 미치는 효과]* · Changwon National University (master's thesis) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T13261948
  Found: Experimental group scored significantly higher than controls on self- and other-acceptance, with no decline at follow-up.
- 2012 · Hendrati, F.; Walgito, B. · *Improving marital harmony in Catholic couples in early marriage through a modified Enneagram programme [Peningkatan keharmonisan perkawinan pada pasangan suami-istri Katolik ... melalui penerapan program Enneagram yang dimodifikasi]* · Universitas Gadjah Mada · Result: Mixed · Indonesia · https://repository.ugm.ac.id/99017/
  Found: Tested a modified Enneagram programme on marital harmony in Catholic couples married 1–10 years. The retrieved abstract describes the design but not the results.
- 2012 · Kang, H. · *Effects of an Enneagram programme on the empowerment of domestic-violence counsellors [에니어그램 프로그램이 가정폭력전문상담원의 임파워먼트에 미치는 효과]* · 한국가족복지학 (Korean Journal of Family Welfare) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://dspace.kci.go.kr/handle/kci/1465704?show=full
  Found: Counsellors in the programme improved significantly more than controls in self, organisational and client-change empowerment, and rated the programme positively. Very small sample.
- 2012 · 김미화 · *Development and effectiveness of an Enneagram parent-coaching programme [에니어그램 부모코칭 프로그램 개발 및 효과 검증]* · Daejeon University (master's thesis) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12918383
  Found: Mothers' perceived cognitive and affective empathy improved and children reported less maternal coldness; effects differed by whether mother and child shared an energy centre. Small sample.
- 2012 · 이미희 · *The effect of a career exploration programme using the Enneagram on high-school students' career decision-making self-efficacy [에니어그램을 활용한 진로탐색프로그램이 고등학생의 진로결정 자기효능감에 미치는 효과]* · Korea International University (master's thesis); also 에니어그램연구 9(1), 69-105 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12755023
  Found: Experimental group showed significantly greater gains in career decision-making self-efficacy than controls; students' reflections were positive.
- 2011 · Kim, E.; Park, H. · *Effects of an Enneagram group counselling programme on the psychological adjustment of adolescents on probation [에니어그램 집단상담 프로그램이 보호관찰 청소년의 심리적 적응에 미치는 효과]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A163249
  Found: Reports significant improvements in depression, psychological and spiritual well-being, gratitude and stress coping after the programme.
- 2011 · Choi, J. · *Using the Enneagram as a pastoral counselling tool to support ego integrity in midlife [중년기 자아통합을 돕는 목회상담적 도구로서 에니어그램 활용에 관한 연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A163239
  Found: Concludes the Enneagram is a suitable pastoral counselling tool for midlife ego integrity and spiritual growth; small, uncontrolled application.
- 2011 · Lee, J. S. · *Effects of an Enneagram parent education programme on child-rearing attitudes [에니어그램 부모교육 프로그램이 자녀양육태도에 미치는 영향]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A163237
  Found: Improved affectionate and autonomy-granting attitudes; groups were not equivalent at baseline on autonomy, and the sample was tiny.
- 2011 · Lee, O.; Lee, D. · *Effects of Enneagram group counselling during morning self-study time on male high school students' empathy, interpersonal relationships and ego-identity [아침자율학습시간을 이용한 에니어그램 집단상담이 남고생의 공감능력, 대인관계 및 자아정체감에 미치는 효과]* · Human Understanding (인간이해) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://dspace.kci.go.kr/handle/kci/229320
  Found: Empathy and interpersonal sensitivity and openness improved relative to the comparison group; ego-identity did not change significantly.
- 2011 · 이미련 · *Effects of an Enneagram group counselling programme on ego-resilience and empathy in nursing students [에니어그램 집단상담 프로그램이 간호대학생의 자아탄력성과 공감능력에 미치는 효과]* · 가야대학교 논문집 (Kaya University), 19, 281-293 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A60119600
  Found: Empathy improved significantly versus control, but ego-resilience did not differ.
- 2010 · Yang, J. · *Effects of an Enneagram group workshop on self-understanding and interpersonal relationships [에니어그램 집단워크샵이 자기이해와 대인관계에 미치는 효과]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A134175
  Found: The workshop group improved more than controls in self-understanding and interpersonal relationships, and gains held at 2-week follow-up.
- 2010 · Cho, M. · *Effects of an Enneagram training programme on childcare teachers' self-efficacy and interpersonal relationships [에니어그램 훈련프로그램이 보육교사의 자기효능감과 대인관계에 미치는 효과에 관한 연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A134176
  Found: Self-efficacy and interpersonal relationships improved significantly more than in the control group; small sample.
- 2010 · Kim, E. · *Changes in play-school operators' qualities through an Enneagram leadership programme [에니어그램 리더십 프로그램을 통한 유아 놀이학교 운영자의 자질 변화 연구]* · The Institute for Educational Research · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4010023674634
  Found: Abstract truncated in record; check the full text before citing.
- 2010 · 김형희 · *Effects of Enneagram group counselling on nurses' work-family conflict [에니어그램 집단상담이 간호사들의 직장-가정 갈등에 미치는 영향]* · Jeju National University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12261181
  Found: Abstract excerpt describes the programme; outcome figures not retrieved – check the full text.
- 2010 · 황정희 · *Effects of an Enneagram parent programme on communication style, child-rearing attitude and self-esteem [에니어그램을 활용한 부모교육 프로그램이 의사소통, 양육태도 및 자아존중감에 미치는 효과]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 7(2), 37-75 (from Yeungnam University doctoral dissertation, 2008) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A82508174
  Found: Enneagram group improved mother-child communication and affectionate/autonomous parenting relative to both comparison groups, and self-esteem increased.
- 2010 · 김윤효 · *Effect of an Enneagram and group art therapy programme on attention and self-esteem of children from broken families [에니어그램과 집단미술치료를 활용한 프로그램이 결손가정아동의 주의집중 및 자아존중감에 미치는 효과]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 7(1), 87-104 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A82508154
  Found: Both groups improved, but the Enneagram + art therapy group improved more, especially in self-esteem; very small sample.
- 2010 · 김은아 · *Effects of an Enneagram programme on middle-school students' self-acceptance and acceptance of others [에니어그램 프로그램이 중학생의 자기수용 및 타인수용에 미치는 효과]* · Chonnam National University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11930596
  Found: Rare design with an active psychoeducation comparison and wait-list; outcome figures not in retrieved abstract – check full text.
- 2010 · 박경애 · *Effects of Enneagram group counselling on elementary students' social competence [에니어그램을 적용한 집단상담이 초등학생의 사회적 능력에 미치는 효과]* · Gwangju National University of Education Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12183194
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract excerpt; small sample.
- 2010 · 이리경 · *Effects of an Enneagram programme on academic self-efficacy of under-achieving high-school students [에니어그램 프로그램이 학습부진 고등학생의 학업적 자기효능감에 미치는 효과]* · Changwon National University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11928764
  Found: Tests academic self-efficacy gains versus untreated controls; result figures not in retrieved abstract.
- 2009 · 박경원 · *Effects of Enneagram group counselling on elementary students' stress coping and school-life satisfaction [에니어그램 집단상담이 초등학생의 스트레스 대처방식과 학교생활만족도에 미치는 영향분석]* · Cheongju National University of Education Graduate School of Education (master's thesis); also 학생생활연구 16 (with 박성희) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11589702
  Found: Increased social-support coping and reduced passive emotional coping; wishful-thinking coping unchanged.
- 2009 · 박수식 · *Effects of an Enneagram programme on academic high-school students' career identity and career decision level [에니어그램 프로그램이 인문계 고등학생의 진로정체감 및 진로결정수준에 미치는 효과]* · Changwon National University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11726088
  Found: Result figures not in retrieved abstract.
- 2008 · Kim, H. J. · *Effects of Enneagram group counselling on university students' ego-identity and interpersonal relationships [에니어그램을 활용한 집단상담이 대학생의 자아정체감과 대인관계에 미치는 효과]* · Journal of Oriental Neuropsychiatry / East-West Mental Science (동서정신과학) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://kiss.kstudy.com/journal/thesis_name.asp?key=2986446
  Found: Ego-identity and interpersonal relationships improved significantly; tiny, non-random groups.
- 2008 · 김경림 · *Effects of an Enneagram workshop on volunteers' self-esteem and interpersonal relations [에니어그램 워크샵 프로그램이 자원봉사자의 자아존중감 및 대인관계 개선에 미치는 효과]* · Sangju National University Graduate School of Industry (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11218497
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract excerpt – check full text.
- 2008 · 조유지 · *Teacher-infant relationships and social development: An Enneagram analysis [교사·영아관계가 사회성 발달에 미치는 영향]* · Pai Chai University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11518107
  Found: Applies Enneagram-informed caregiver practices to infants' social development; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2008 · 이옥순 · *Effects of brief Enneagram group counselling on male high-school students' identity, empathy and interpersonal relations [단기 에니어그램 집단상담이 남자고등학생의 자아정체감, 공감능력 및 대인관계에 미치는 효과]* · Yonsei University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11385044
  Found: Tests a very brief classroom programme against controls; result figures not in retrieved abstract.
- 2007 · Ahn, J. · *Effects of a children's Enneagram programme on elementary school students' school adjustment [아동용 에니어그램 프로그램이 초등학생의 학교생활 적응에 미치는 효과]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A55413
  Found: The programme group improved school adjustment more than controls on every subdomain except teacher-student relations, with peer relations showing the strongest effect.
- 2007 · 박소희 · *Effects of an Enneagram career-exploration programme on middle-school students' career maturity [에니어그램 진로탐색 프로그램이 중학생의 진로의식성숙에 미치는 효과]* · University of Ulsan Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11044612
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract excerpt – check full text.
- 2007 · 김기성 · *Effects of an Enneagram programme on high-school students' self-acceptance and acceptance of others [에니어그램 프로그램이 고등학생의 자아수용 및 타인수용에 미치는 효과]* · Changwon National University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11025880
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract excerpt – check full text.
- 2007 · 권혁자 · *Effects of an Enneagram workshop on self-actualisation of housewife college students [에니어그램 워크샵이 주부 전문대학생의 자아실현에 미치는 효과]* · Changwon National University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10862408
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract excerpt – check full text.
- 2007 · 하영희 · *Effects of an Enneagram programme on academic high-school students' career maturity [에니어그램 프로그램이 인문계 고등학생의 진로성숙도에 미치는 효과]* · Changwon National University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11025882
  Found: Tests career-maturity gains versus controls; result figures not in retrieved abstract.
- 2007 · Villasante, A. C. · *Making good people better: Enhancing self-esteem and personal growth initiative among SVD college seminarians using the Enneagram* · De La Salle University, Manila (master's thesis, Counseling) · Result: Mixed · Philippines · https://animorepository.dlsu.edu.ph/etd_masteral/3508/
  Found: Self-esteem (F=10.42) and personal growth initiative (F=5.98) changed significantly over repeated measurements and gains were fairly stable; no comparison group and reported df look inconsistent with N.
- 2006 · 김종창 · *Effects of an Enneagram programme on high-school students' ego-identity and self-efficacy [에니어그램 프로그램이 고등학생의 자아정체감과 자기효능감에 미치는 효과]* · Changwon National University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10699199
  Found: Hypothesised gains in self-efficacy and ego-identity subscales; result figures not in retrieved abstract.
- 2005 · 윤운성; 김의일 · *에니어그램 집단상담프로그램이 초등학교 학생들의 사회성 발달에 미치는 영향* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A24968
  Found: The experimental group improved significantly more than controls in overall social development, with gains in cooperation, sociability and autonomy but not law-abidingness.
- 2005 · 황경란 · *Effects of an Enneagram-based parent education programme on parenting attitudes [에니어그램을 활용한 부모교육프로그램이 부모양육태도에 미치는 효과]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 2(2), 91-122 (from Inje University master's thesis, 2004) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75270822
  Found: Between groups only affectionate parenting improved; within the experimental group affection, rejection and autonomy improved (p<.05) but control-style parenting did not.
- 2005 · 김현숙 · *Effects of an Enneagram programme on self-esteem, anxiety, defence mechanisms and interpersonal relations [에니어그램 프로그램이 자아존중감, 불안, 방어기제 및 대인관계에 미치는 효과]* · Sogang University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10011365
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract excerpt – check full text.
- 2005 · 강성덕 · *Effects of an Enneagram education programme on middle-school students' self-esteem, sociality and interpersonal relations [에니어그램 교육프로그램이 중학생의 자아존중감, 사회성 및 대인관계에 미치는 영향]* · Sogang University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10864744
  Found: Sociality subscales of responsibility, conformity and goodwill did not change; self-control decreased significantly (t=-3.29), which the author interprets positively.
- 2004 · Lee, J. S.; Kim, Y. W. · *The Enneagram program effect for stress management of college students* · Journal of Korean Academy of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 13(4), 438 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.12934/jkpmhn.2004.13.4.438
  Found: Improvements only in some stress domains (e.g., self-understanding/future, t = -7.26); effects were partial, and with no control group the design is weak.
- 2004 · 전미경 · *Effects of a children's Enneagram programme on peer relationships [아동용 에니어그램 프로그램이 교우관계 개선에 미치는 효과]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 1(2), 65-80 (from Changwon National University master's thesis) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75270808
  Found: The children's programme improved peer relationships (e.g., respect among peers), with greater effect when self- and other-understanding were addressed in sequence.
- 2004 · 김순자 · *Effects of Enneagram group counselling on self-efficacy and interpersonal relations [에니어그램을 활용한 집단상담이 자기효능감과 대인관계에 미치는 영향]* · Seokyeong University Graduate School of Social Science (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10665562
  Found: Interpersonal relations improved significantly, but overall self-efficacy did not (only the self-control subscale improved).
- 2004 · 유안선 · *Effects of an Enneagram workshop on elementary students' friendships [에니어그램 워크숍이 초등학생의 교우관계에 미치는 영향]* · Hannam University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10034461
  Found: Result figures not in retrieved abstract.
- 2002 · 윤운성 · *에니어그램 훈련프로그램이 자아정체감과 생활만족도에 미치는 영향* · 교육심리연구, 16(2), 93-111 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.dbpia.co.kr/Article/NODE06763334
  Found: Trained students scored significantly higher on one ego-identity subscale (sense of self-existence) but there was no difference in life satisfaction. Very small sample.
- 1996 · Lee, H.-C. R. · *Enhancing psychological security and academic performance of college underachievers through Enneagram and neurolinguistic programming* · De La Salle University, Manila (doctoral dissertation, Counseling Psychology) · Result: Mixed · Philippines · https://animorepository.dlsu.edu.ph/etd_doctoral/751/
  Found: Both treatments raised psychological security (no immediate difference between them); only the combined treatment's gain persisted at one month, with slight GPA improvement. Very small treatment groups.

## Level C · Validation or correlation (519 studies)

- 2026 · Sapci, E.; Gungormus, Z. · *Enneagram at work: A novel scale for measuring occupational personality characteristics* · WORK: A Journal of Prevention, Assessment & Rehabilitation · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.1177/10519815261445918
  Found: Content validity index .93; variance explained 42-51%; alphas .79-.84; split-half .69-.78. No test-retest reported.
- 2026 · Buford, M.; Owens, M.; Novkov, V. · *Enneagram Personality Test: Technical report* · Truity Psychometrics LLC · Result: Mixed · International (online users) · https://www.truity.com/sites/default/files/uploads/EnneagramTechnicalDocument.pdf
  Found: Facet alphas .70-.87 and parallel analysis supported 21 facets, but CFA fit was weak by usual standards (CFI .79, TLI .78) despite RMSEA .043. Vendor-produced, not peer reviewed; no test-retest.
- 2026 · Aydoğan, G.; Özdemir, M. · *Evaluations of architectural students performance in design studio related with their personal type: A view from Enneagram* · International Journal of Art & Design Education, 45(3), 754-768 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.1111/jade.70025
  Found: Personality type appeared related to studio performance; the authors call the findings preliminary given the small, context-specific sample.
- 2026 · Kayserili, M. · *The Enneagram in the organizational behavior literature: A bibliometric analysis (Örgütsel davranış literatüründe Enneagram: Bibliyometrik bir analiz)* · Uluslararası Ekonomi, İşletme ve Politika Dergisi (International Journal of Economics, Business and Politics), 10(2), 1044-1067 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.29216/ueip.1983401
  Found: Mapped 102 Enneagram papers in organisational behaviour and found the field moving from early spiritual approaches towards empirical work on topics such as strategic leadership, nearing maturity by about 2023. Calls for longitudinal studies, AI-supported personality models and more international collaboration; it describes the literature rather than testing the Enneagram's validity.
- 2026 · Demirel, M. M.; Kasım, İ.; Şimşek, E. · *Evaluation of family medicine identity levels and personality types among family medicine residents and specialists* · Turkish Journal of Family Practice, 30(3), 255-269 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.54308/tjfp.2026.963
  Found: Professional identity scores did not differ by dominant Enneagram type on any scale (all p>.05; effect sizes η² .008-.045). Types 1 (27.9%) and 2 (25.1%) were most common.
- 2026 · Chalwal, V. · *Relationship between Enneagram personality types and psychological well-being dimensions among adolescents* · Journal of the Indian Academy of Applied Psychology, 52(1), 234-241 · Result: Supportive · India · https://jiaap.in/blog/relationship-between-enneagram-personality-types-and-psychological-well-being-dimensions-among-adolescents
  Found: Types 1, 2, 3, 6, 7 and 9 correlated positively with well-being across most of Ryff's six dimensions; Type 5 showed negligible or negative links, especially with personal growth. Coefficients not given in the abstract.
- 2026 ·  · *回答時間と確信度との相関に基づくエニアグラムを拡張した自己内省支援システムの開発* · エンタテインメントコンピューティングシンポジウム2026論文集 (Entertainment Computing Symposium 2026) · Result: Mixed · Japan · https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1050027897321470464
  Found: Built a system that records answer time and confidence alongside Enneagram responses, so that items causing hesitation or high cognitive load can be measured. The abstract reports no validation data.
- 2026 · Louw, A.; Rico, D.; Ho-Tran, M. H.; Smith, K. · *Personality types according to Enneagram typology and choice of fellowship in physical therapy* · Journal of Yoga and Physiotherapy, 13(1) · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.19080/jyp.2026.13.555852
  Found: Types 2 (27.1%) and 3 (22.9%) dominated; pain fellows were mostly type 2 (34.5%) and orthopedic fellows mostly type 3 (36.8%). Small convenience sample, descriptive only.
- 2026 · Nario, C. A. · *Leadership and the Enneagram personality model: A multiple rater, multiple outcome perspective* · Manchester Metropolitan University (doctoral thesis) · Result: Critical · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.83056/mmu.32483973
  Found: The overall Enneagram-leadership relationship was weak to insignificant; links with self-rated leadership were stronger than with other-rater or company measures, and only a few type-variable relationships were significant and weak. HPEI reliability was modest (3 of 9 subscales had alpha >.70, one .55).
- 2026 · Restoff, S. A. · *Accounting student personality types: An Enneagram study on students' major and career choices* · Murray State University Scholars Week (honors presentation) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://digitalcommons.murraystate.edu/scholarsweek/Spring2026/HON/15
  Found: Tests links between Enneagram type, initial career choice and accounting specialisation; the abstract mentions evidence on students' sociability but gives no figures.
- 2026 · 이해진 · *Enneagram-based customised coaching strategies for taekwondo instructors [에니어그램(Enneagram) 기반 태권도 지도자의 맞춤형 코칭 전략]* · Kyung Hee University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T17391641
  Found: Mapped type and wing distributions by specialty and position and derived type-based coaching strategies from focus groups; descriptive, no outcome testing.
- 2026 · زايد، أماني مصطفى عزت; سنوسي، علي · *Integrating digital, experiential and green marketing in the furniture industry: User behaviour in light of trends and Enneagram types [التكامل بين التسويق الرقمي والتسويق التجريبي والأخضر في صناعة الأثاث]* · مجلة العمارة والفنون والعلوم الإنسانية · Result: Mixed · Egypt · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.21608/mjaf.2026.507547.4075
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2026 · Gür, F. N. · *An Enneagram personality analysis of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe based on his autobiographical work [Johann Wolfgang von Goethe'nin Otobiyografik Yapıtından Hareketle Enneagram Modeli Kişilik Çözümlemesi]* · Korpusgermanistik, 5(1), 23-29 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.62425/korpus.1944375
  Found: Reviews the Enneagram's history and concepts, then types Goethe from his life story and concludes he closely matches Type 7. A single-case literary analysis with no measurement or validity test.
- 2026 · Karagül, H. H.; Sezgin, E. · *Exploring the impact of parental temperament and self-efficacy on socio-emotional development in children aged 1–3 [Ebeveyn mizacı ve öz yeterliğin 1–3 yaş arası çocukların sosyal-duygusal gelişimlerine etkisi]* · Fırat Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 36(3), 1173-1196 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.18069/firatsbed.1701798
  Found: Parental type made no difference to children's overall social-emotional scores (F=0.96, p=.47), only to coping and adaptation (F=2.26, p=.029), where children of Type 2 parents scored lowest (mean 34 vs 41–48). Type 2 parents also reported the lowest parenting self-efficacy (mean 187 vs about 203 for Types 5, 8, 9 and 1).
- 2026 · Yanartaş, Ö.; Akça, E.; Ilgın, S. E.; Şahin Çam, C. · *The mediating role of psychological flexibility in the relationship between Enneagram personality system and mental well-being: A structural equation modeling approach* · Marmara Medical Journal, 39(3), 186-194 · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.5472/marumj.2070905
  Found: Types 7 and 3 had the strongest positive links with wellbeing and Types 6 and 4 negative links; psychological flexibility (especially living by one's values) explained much of these links, with the Social subtype showing the largest indirect effect.
- 2025 · Alsoudi, S.; Benkouider, A.; Joma, A.; Al Tobi, M.; Al Habsi, A. · *Constructing an Arabic version of the Enneagram personality type scale* · Social Sciences & Humanities Open, 12, 102150 · Result: Supportive · Oman · https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssaho.2025.102150
  Found: Alphas .69-.83, split-half .73-.88, test-retest .62-.73; CFA fit acceptable (CFI .92, RMSEA .05, SRMR .07).
- 2025 · Buyuktaskapu Soydan, S.; Aliu, E. N.; Mutlu, K. · *Validation and reliability of the Turkish adaptation of the Observation Inventory of the Preschool Children Enneagram* · Theory and Practice in Child Development, 5(1), 115-137 · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.46303/tpicd.2025.7
  Found: EFA confirmed a nine-factor structure, all alphas above .70, and CFA fit acceptable. Observer ratings of young children, not self-report.
- 2025 · Ercin, H. S.; Dagcioglu, B. F. · *Evaluation of the relationship between the Enneagram personality types and the Health-Promoting Lifestyle Profile (HPLP-II)* · Scholars Journal of Applied Medical Sciences, 13(6), 1264-1271 · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.36347/sjams.2025.v13i06.005
  Found: Type 7 had higher health-promoting lifestyle scores than type 5 (p = .008); type 1 respondents were more likely to have quit smoking.
- 2025 · Lim, H.-J. · *A Subjectivity Study of Parents’s the Happiness according to Enneagram Type : Application of the Q methodology* · JOURNAL OF THE KOREA CONTENTS ASSOCIATION · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.5392/jkca.2025.25.02.610
  Found: Five subjective types of parental happiness by Enneagram type were identified (e.g., trust and respect, achievement and effort, independence and health).
- 2025 · Wang, Q.; Wu, W. · *Research on Text Sentiment Recognition Algorithm Integrated Enneagram and BiGRU-attention-CNN* · Authorea (preprint) · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.22541/au.174599897.76003627/v1
  Found: The model with Enneagram features reached 91.4% and 90.6% accuracy (F1 92.3% and 91.7%) on IMDB and MR. It is a preprint, and the gain from the Enneagram features themselves is not isolated in the abstract.
- 2025 · Estacio, R. D.; Angeles, H. G. V. · *Teaching Efficacy and Enneagram Personality Types: A Correlational Study Among Pre-Service Early Childhood Educators in Quezon City University* · International Journal of Research and Innovation in Social Science · Result: Mixed · Philippines · https://doi.org/10.47772/ijriss.2025.90400497
  Found: Types 2 and 9 were most common, but Enneagram type was not significantly correlated with teaching efficacy.
- 2025 · Gayta, T. J. · *Self-Awareness Experiences of the Teachers in Manay National High School Using Enneagram System* · International Journal of Research and Innovation in Social Science · Result: Mixed · Philippines · https://doi.org/10.47772/ijriss.2025.905000139
  Found: Teachers described mindfulness, self-management and self-transformation after an Enneagram self-awareness workshop. The evidence is qualitative self-report from six informants.
- 2025 · Kang, H. Y. · *Inductive Content Analysis of the Meaning of Dogs to Dog Owners - Focusing on Enneagram Types 3, 6, and 9 -* · Asia Counseling and Coaching Society · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.47018/accr.2025.7.1.33
  Found: Type 3 owners saw dogs as sources of support and growth, Type 6 sought stability through responsibility, and Type 9 prioritised harmony and bonding.
- 2025 · Çelik, O. · *Enneagram temperament model-based family counselling: A case report [Enneagram Mizaç Modeli Temelli Aile Danışmanlığı: Bir Olgu Sunumu]* · Aile Psikolojik Danışmanlığı Dergisi · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.58434/apdad.1767879
  Found: Family members came to understand one another's temperaments, and communication and family bonds improved. This is a single case with no standardised outcome measures reported.
- 2025 · Ateş, B.; Tarlacı, S. · *Evaluating alcohol and smoking habits through Enneagram personality traits in the context of emotion management [Enneagram Kişilik Özelliği Aracılığı ile Alkol ve Sigara Kullanım Alışkanlığının Duygu Yönetimi Çerçevesinde Değerlendirilmesi]* · İstanbul Gelişim Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.17336/igusbd.1576141
  Found: Alcohol use was significantly associated with feeling-centred and insight-centred types, and smoking with heart-centre (feeling triad) types.
- 2025 · Barnes, K.; Hardinger-Braun, K.; Graham, M.; Guthrie, K. · *Understanding Pharmacy Student Personalities: Insights from the Enneagram Model* · American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajpe.2025.101692
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2025 · Yüksel, A.; Kızılgeçit, M. · *Enneagram and religiosity [Enneagram ve Dindarlık]* · Gumushane Universitesi Ilahiyat Fakultesi Dergisi (GIFAD) · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.53683/gifad.1636230
  Found: The abstract describes a quantitative study of Enneagram types and dimensions of religiosity, but gives no sample size or results; check the full text.
- 2025 · Sacaluga Rodríguez, I.; Vargas Delgado, J. J. · *Pensamiento crítico y toma de decisiones en periodismo: enfoque desde el eneagrama* · Revista Venezolana de Gerencia · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.52080/rvgluz.30.especial13.14
  Found: No data. The authors argue that combining critical thinking with the Enneagram as a self-awareness tool can improve ethical decision-making in journalism and media management.
- 2025 · Tosun, E.; Atayoğlu, A. T. · *Towards understanding the relationship between personality types and homeopathic remedies in an integrative health approach* · Journal of Mind and Medical Sciences, 12(1), 17 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.3390/jmms12010017
  Found: Forty rubrics yielded nine remedies scoring four points, with polychrest remedies most frequent in top-five rankings. Theoretical mapping exercise, not tested on patients.
- 2025 · Norton Schamber, J. · *Investigating personality themes and constructs among professional horse trainers* · Liberty University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/doctoral/7758
  Found: The most common types were Eight (30.8%), Six (23.1%) and Three (19.2%); trainers scored high on Openness and Conscientiousness, and interviews described them as introverted, calm, conscientious and open. Small descriptive sample.
- 2025 · Alan, E.; Arditi, D.; Günaydın, H. M.; Akçay, E. C. · *Design team effectiveness and architects' personality types* · Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management · Result: Supportive · USA · https://doi.org/10.1108/ecam-12-2023-1264
  Found: Type 6 and Type 3 architects placed the most importance on team effectiveness and Type 7 the least; the authors suggest Type 1 and Type 8 members in one team may clash. Outcomes are self-rated importance, not measured team performance.
- 2025 · Kim, Y.; Chung, H. S. · *A study on the correlation between color association images and personality types: Focusing on college students* · Illustration Forum (Journal of Korea Society of Illustration Research) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.37379/jksir.2025.85.03
  Found: Each QUEST grouping favoured distinct colours (for example, 'assertive' chose warm, high-visibility colours and 'withdrawn' chose cool mid-value colours), and colour associations also differed by gender. Descriptive associations only.
- 2025 · Castro, A. D. M. · *Relationship between personality and decision style in high-involvement purchasing [Relação entre personalidade e estilo de decisão em processo de compra de alto envolvimento]* · Universidade Municipal de São Caetano do Sul (USCS), Doctoral thesis in Administration · Result: Supportive · Brazil · https://repositorio.uscs.edu.br/handle/123456789/526
  Found: Found associations between Enneagram type and consumer decision style (e.g., Fours and Eights with brand/quality consciousness, Sixes with habitual buying), offered as hypotheses for further testing. Non-representative sample.
- 2025 · Rizzi, V. N. · *Strategic decision-making under uncertainty: dynamic balance between causation and effectuation considering cognitive and motivational aspects [Tomada de decisão estratégica em contextos de incerteza]* · Universidade do Vale do Rio dos Sinos (UNISINOS), Professional Master's · Result: Mixed · Brazil · http://repositorio.jesuita.org.br/handle/UNISINOS/13927
  Found: Decision-making followed three phases; cognitive style was shaped by a motivational base of desires, fears and beliefs (Enneagram-informed), moderated by awareness; produced a practitioner tool. Small qualitative sample.
- 2025 · Atsou, L. · *Contribution to validating the Enneagram: normative vs ipsative question formats in the HPEI [Contribution à la validation de l'Ennéagramme : analyse comparée de l'impact du type de question, normative versus ipsative]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Mixed · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/43775
  Found: Profiles were sensitive to response format, especially bases 3, 6 and 8; respondents found the ipsative format more demanding but more introspective. Highlights measurement-format effects on Enneagram typing.
- 2025 · Fery, N. · *From outside to inside: how Enneagram training can support identity reconstruction and reintegration of incarcerated people [Du dehors au dedans : entre prison mentale et prison carcérale]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Educational Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Supportive · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/43950
  Found: Enneagram used as an educational mediator appeared to foster introspection, self-reconstruction, remobilisation and psychosocial skills in a safe group setting. Qualitative, no comparison group.
- 2025 · Scholtz, W. E. · *What hath Jerusalem to do with Chile: towards an evangelical understanding of the Enneagram and its usage for spiritual development* · Liberty University (Doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/doctoral/6467
  Found: Gender, denomination, ministry role and location significantly predicted awareness, use and scepticism of the Enneagram (p<.05); qualitative responses showed general acceptance but cautioned against treating it as a universal tool. Descriptive survey of usage, not validity.
- 2025 · Paixão, S. P.; Biz, D.; Barros, B. A. C.; Gondo, R.; Monteiro Júnior, S. · *Associations among personality, satisfaction, and maxillary incisors shape: a cross-sectional study* · Pesquisa Brasileira em Odontopediatria e Clínica Integrada, 25 · Result: Critical · Brazil · https://revista.uepb.edu.br/PBOCI/article/view/4551
  Found: Enneagram type was not associated with patients' preferred tooth shape (p=.642) or dentist-rated morphology (p=.096); 77.4% were satisfied with their incisors.
- 2025 · شهدة، دعاء عبد الفتاح حسن; محمد، عمرو محمد إسماعيل · *Enneagram personality types and cognitive miserliness among Egyptian university faculty [أنماط الشخصية وفق نظرية الإنيكرام وعلاقتها بالبخل المعرفي لدي أعضاء هيئة التدريس بالجامعات المصرية]* · مجلة كلية التربية بدمياط (Damietta University Faculty of Education), 40(92) · Result: Critical · Egypt · https://doi.org/10.21608/jsdu.2024.328557.1497
  Found: No correlation between Enneagram type scores and cognitive miserliness; types did not differ by gender or academic rank.
- 2025 · عبدالواحد، فاطمة الزهراء عبدالباسط; السيد، ماجدة عبدالسلام عبدالمجيد · *Psychological richness and better being in relation to Enneagram personality types among mothers of children with special needs [الثراء النفسى والوجود الأفضل وعلاقتهما بأنماط الإنيجرام للشخصية لدى أمهات الأطفال ذوى الاحتياجات الخاصة]* · مجلة البحث العلمي في التربية (Ain Shams University), 26(3), 72-132 · Result: Mixed · Egypt · https://doi.org/10.21608/jsre.2025.348229.1756
  Found: Psychological richness and better-being correlated positively with some types, negatively with others and not with the rest; type scores did not differ by education.
- 2025 · 박지영 · *Phenomenological study of college students' ego-identity exploration through Enneagram experience [에니어그램 경험을 통한 대학생의 자아 정체성 탐색 과정에 관한 현상학적 연구]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램학회), 22(2), 39-67 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A110133016
  Found: Describes how Enneagram self-analysis shaped identity exploration; qualitative.
- 2025 · 김성환 · *Implications of the Enneagram through its relationship with TCI: University students [TCI와의 관련성으로 살펴본 에니어그램의 함의 : 대학생을 중심으로]* · 단국대학교 대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T17182767
  Found: Expected links emerged (e.g., novelty seeking with types 4/7/8, harm avoidance with type 6, reward dependence with type 2, persistence with 1/3/5; self-directedness positive for 1/3/7/8, negative for 6/9), supporting convergent validity.
- 2025 · Park, J. Y. · *에니어그램 경험을 통한 대학생의 자아 정체성 탐색 과정에 관한 현상학적 연구 [A phenomenological study of college students' ego-identity exploration through Enneagram experience]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Journal of Enneagram Studies), 22(2), 39-67 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A478318
  Found: Identified 6 core themes and 12 sub-themes: students used the Enneagram to name core motives, reframe past limitations with less self-blame, notice imbalances across head/heart/gut, understand others, and clarify career identity. Qualitative and self-reported, with no outcome measures.
- 2025 · Goh, K. M.; Madawan Nair, L. N.; Junior Lee, H. L. · *Linking personality traits and organizational culture preferences among Malaysian primary school educators in Perak* · Jurnal Pemikir Pendidikan (Journal of Educational Thinkers), 13(1), 200-225 · Result: Supportive · Malaysia · https://doi.org/10.51200/jpp.v13i1.6844
  Found: Types lined up with culture preferences as theory predicts: Types 1, 5 and 6 with bureaucratic culture (r=.35-.44), Types 3, 4, 7 and 8 with innovative culture (r=.46-.55), Types 2, 6 and 9 with supportive culture (r=.38-.51); types explained 46-58% of variance. Self-built measure, single state and some reporting inconsistencies, so treat as preliminary.
- 2024 · Abdelhamid, E.; Ismail, S.; Aref, M. · *Ontology-based Enneagram personality prediction system* · Human-Centric Intelligent Systems, 4(2), 278-285 · Result: Mixed · Egypt · https://doi.org/10.1007/s44230-024-00065-3
  Found: Per-type F1 ranged 7%-62% (accuracy 78-91% per type, inflated by class balance); Helper and Loyalist types were poorly detected.
- 2024 · Ferretti, A.; Greenberg, S.; Nnaemeka, E. · *How accurate are popular personality test frameworks at predicting life outcomes? A detailed investigation* · Clearer Thinking (research report) · Result: Critical · USA · https://www.clearerthinking.org/post/how-accurate-are-popular-personality-test-frameworks-at-predicting-life-outcomes-a-detailed-investi
  Found: Big Five predicted outcomes substantially better (average R = 0.23) than the Enneagram; Enneagram type did better than binary Jungian/MBTI-style types (average R = 0.11).
- 2024 · Karaduman, P.; Çetin, M. · *Teachers' Enneagram personality types, their perceived organizational culture and mediation attitudes* · Education Quarterly Reviews, 7(1) · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.31014/aior.1993.07.01.797
  Found: Types 9, 8 and 1 predicted attitudes towards conflict mediation, and perceived organisational culture mediated the link between type and mediation attitude.
- 2024 · Bacık, F.; Yılmaz, T. E.; Taştan, K. · *The relationship between doctors' personality types according to Enneagram typology and their choice of medical specialty* · Ankara Medical Journal, 2024(4), 346-355 · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.5505/amj.2024.87847
  Found: Types differed between surgical and internal-medicine residents (more 3s and 8s in surgery), and type distributions also differed by gender. This supports a link between type and career choice.
- 2024 · Everett, H. M.; Harrell, K. N.; Giles, W. H.; Bhattacharya, S. D. · *The Enneagram as a tool for resident wellness and correlation with Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education milestone achievements* · Journal of Surgical Research, 296, 337-342 · Result: Critical · USA · https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2023.12.025
  Found: Type did not predict supervisor-rated professionalism (p=0.322) or communication skills (p=0.645).
- 2024 · Özen, B.; Ilgin, E.; Akça, E.; Özercan, A.; Seçgin, P.; Yanartaş, Ö. · *Explanation of the personality factor with the Enneagram in the selection of the specialty branch of the intern doctors* · European Psychiatry, 67(S1) · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.1192/j.eurpsy.2024.1365
  Found: Type 2 was most common (39.3%); type was significantly linked to intended specialty (p < .001), e.g., type 3 with surgery and type 4 with psychiatry.
- 2024 · Eravcı, H.; Doğuer, Ç. · *Investigation of the relationship between the Enneagram personality types and food choice: A cross-sectional study* · Süleyman Demirel University Journal of Health Sciences, 15(1), 62-71 · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.22312/sdusbed.1431746
  Found: Type linked to food choice: Type 2 most with mood, convenience, appearance and price; Type 3 most with health, weight control and ethics; emotional eating tied to Types 2 and 9.
- 2024 · Durmuş, G.; Karacan Doğan, P.; Ceyhun, S. · *Examining the relationship between Enneagram personality types and multi-frame leadership orientations of sport sciences academics with administrative duties [İdari Göreve Sahip Spor Bilimleri Akademisyenlerinin Enneagram Kişilik Tipleri ile Çok Yönlü Liderlik Yönelimleri Arasındaki İlişkinin İncelenmesi]* · Akdeniz Spor Bilimleri Dergisi · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.38021/asbid.1374289
  Found: Perfectionist and Leader scores were highest and Helper lowest. Leadership-orientation scores rose with Enneagram scores, and some administrative roles aligned with particular types.
- 2024 · Unal Karaguven, M. H. · *Relation between Resilience and Enneagram Personality Types* · Educational Policy Analysis and Strategic Research · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.29329/epasr.2024.655.2
  Found: Resilience correlated positively with six types (achiever, original, observer, adventurer, leader, accommodator). Because the links are spread across many types, they are not very type-specific.
- 2024 · Yağcı, F.; Arıcı Doğan, D.; Kütük, H.; Acarkan, İ. · *Examining the relationship between Enneagram personality types and thinking styles of university students [Üniversite Öğrencilerinin Enneagram Kişilik Tipleri ile Düşünme Stilleri Arasındaki İlişkinin İncelenmesi]* · İstanbul Gelişim Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.17336/igusbd.1197620
  Found: Overall thinking style and two thinking-style subdimensions differed significantly by Enneagram type. The data are self-report and cross-sectional.
- 2024 · İhtiyaroğlu, N.; Aydilek, S.; Öztürk, Y. · *Examining the relationship between teachers' Enneagram personality types and classroom management skills [Öğretmenlerin Enneagram Kişilik Tipleri ile Sınıf Yönetimi Becerileri Arasındaki İlişkinin İncelenmesi]* · Ihlara Eğitim Araştırmaları Dergisi · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.47479/ihead.1409084
  Found: The strongest links (moderate) were Type 9 with communication and Type 3 with teaching and motivation. Types 3 and 7 significantly predicted classroom-management skills.
- 2024 · Kang, M.; Kim, H. · *A Study on the Musical Preferences of Twenties by Enneagram Personality Type* · Studies on Humanities and Social Sciences · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.62783/shss.6.4.29
  Found: Preferred music activities, mood, lyric content and listening purpose differed significantly by Enneagram type, and music preferences were linked to the centres.
- 2024 · Erkan, İ.; Şirin, T. · *The relationship between pre-service teachers' Enneagram personality types and classroom management self-efficacy beliefs [Öğretmen Adaylarının Enneagram Kişilik Tipleri ile Sınıf Yönetimi Öz-Yeterlik İnançları Arasındaki İlişki]* · İnsan ve Toplum Bilimleri Araştırmaları Dergisi · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.15869/itobiad.1379771
  Found: Classroom-management self-efficacy differed by type: Type 5 scored higher than Type 9, and higher than Type 4 on outcome expectancy.
- 2024 · Kim, M.-J.; Kim, Y.-C. · *Analysis of Domestic Books on Enneagram Coaching* · JOURNAL OF THE KOREA CONTENTS ASSOCIATION · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.5392/jkca.2024.24.11.864
  Found: All 15 books covered core Enneagram concepts, but few dealt with coaching concepts from coaching science. The authors call for stronger academic grounding of Enneagram coaching.
- 2024 · Jung, H.-R.; Byun, S.-H. · *How Parents' Enneagram Types Influence Perceived Positive Parenting Attitudes and Parent-Child Communication: The Moderating Role of Children's Emotional Intelligence* · Korean Youth Counseling Association · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.51613/jkyca.2024.5.4.185
  Found: Heart- and head-centred parents reported more positive parenting attitudes, which predicted better parent-child communication; children's emotional intelligence moderated this link. The data are cross-sectional self-report.
- 2024 · Ch, S. C.; Bhaskar, N.; Gupta, S. · *Evaluation of leadership styles of management leaders using Enneagram framework* · Journal of Advanced Zoology · Result: Mixed · India · https://jazindia.com/index.php/jaz/article/view/3790
  Found: Applied the Enneagram to assess leadership styles of SME leaders and reports relationships between leadership traits and Enneagram mean scores; no figures in the abstract. The venue is an unusual one for management research, so check the full text before citing.
- 2024 · Akar, Ö. · *Development of the temperament characteristics scale of preschool children within the scope of the Enneagram model [Enneagram Modeli Kapsamında Okul Öncesi Dönemdeki Çocukların Mizaç Özellikleri Ölçeğinin Geliştirilmesi]* · KTO Karatay University (master's thesis) · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12498/12107
  Found: Nine-factor structure with factor loadings .52-.89 and subscale alphas .93-.96; the author concludes the scale can assess temperament in 4-6-year-olds. Note that all factors correlated positively with one another, which raises questions about how well the types are distinguished.
- 2024 · Kesme, A. · *The relationship between Enneagram personality traits and religiousness and life satisfaction in adults [Yetişkinlerde Enneagram Kişilik Özelliklerinin Dindarlık ve Hayat Memnuniyeti ile İlişkisi]* · Sakarya University, Institute of Social Sciences (thesis) · Result: Mixed · Turkey · not yet checked · https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12619/102831
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2024 · Özkal Eminoğlu, D.; Taştan, K.; Aydın, S.; Aydın, T. · *Evaluation of the relationship between dentists' personality type and specialisation preferences [Diş Hekimlerinin Kişilik Tipi ile Branşlaşma Tercihleri Arasındaki İlişkinin Değerlendirilmesi]* · Selcuk Dental Journal · Result: Critical · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.15311/selcukdentj.1313681
  Found: The most common types were perfectionist and helper, but personality type was not related to choice of dental specialty.
- 2024 · 정해란 · *Effects of parents' Enneagram types on children's emotional intelligence: Mediation by parenting attitude and communication [에니어그램 부모 유형이 자녀의 정서지능에 미치는 영향]* · Seoul Venture University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T17304420
  Found: Tested paths from parents' centre type through parenting attitude and communication to children's emotional intelligence; self-report, single informant.
- 2024 · رشوان، ربيع عبده أحمد; الربيعان، مناهل حمد عبد الرحمن · *Psychometric properties of the Riso-Hudson nine personality types scale (RHETI) in the Saudi environment [الخصائص السيكومترية لمقياس ريسو- هيدسن لأنماط الشخصية التسعة (الإنيجرام) في البيئة السعودية]* · مجلة العلوم التربوية والدراسات الإنسانية (Journal of Educational Sciences and Human Studies), 36, 268-291 · Result: Supportive · Saudi Arabia · https://doi.org/10.55074/hesj.vi36.943
  Found: Authors report good validity (incl. confirmatory factor analysis) and reliability (α and ω) for the Arabic RHETI in a large Saudi sample; ipsative-format limitations not discussed in abstract.
- 2024 · شعيب، مها جلال علي; سلام، نجلاء محمد عبدالفتاح · *A structural predictive model of academic and research growth mindset from overexcitabilities and Enneagram head-centre types [النموذج البنائي التنبؤي لعقلية الإنماء الأكاديمية والبحثية في ضوء الاستثارة الفائقة وأنماط مركز التفكير وفق نظام الإنيكرام]* · مجلة التربية النوعية والتكنولوجيا (Kafrelsheikh University), 16-77 · Result: Mixed · Egypt · https://doi.org/10.21608/maat.2024.304760.1159
  Found: Investigator was the dominant head-centre type; Loyalist and Enthusiast (not Investigator) correlated positively with growth mindset and jointly predicted it with overexcitabilities.
- 2024 · Sen, C.; Chalwal, V. · *Understanding the impact of Enneagram personality traits on adolescent well-being: A comprehensive descriptive study* · Psychology Communique, 1(1), 22-32 · Result: Mixed · India · https://www.apricusjournals.com/index.php/psychologycommunique/article/view/205
  Found: Describes links between Enneagram types, adolescents' daily life, social relationships and well-being and recommends Enneagram training; no quantitative data reported in the abstract.
- 2024 · 신은선 · *Nursing competency, clinical reasoning and empathy of nursing students by Enneagram centre [에니어그램 힘의중심에 따른 간호대학생의 간호역량, 임상추론역량 및 공감능력의 관계]* · 문화기술의 융합 (국제문화기술진흥원), 10(2), 373-382 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.17703/jcct.2024.10.2.373
  Found: Gut-centre students scored highest on nursing competency, head-centre on clinical reasoning and heart-centre on empathy; correlational.
- 2024 · 김은남; 김민선; 방미나; 안순주 · *Concept mapping of teachers' experiences of Enneagram online training combined with mindfulness meditation [마음챙김명상을 병행한 에니어그램 온라인 연수에 참여한 교사들의 경험에 대한 개념도 연구]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램학회), 21(1), 49-67 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A109143090
  Found: Experiences clustered on two dimensions: self/other understanding and in-training experience vs post-training change; no outcome measures.
- 2023 · Gungormus, Z.; Aydin Avci, I.; Dagidir, H.; Orak, O. S.; Afyonkale Talay, N. · *Study of validity and reliability of the GADOT Personality Types Determination Scale developed based on Enneagram* · International Journal of Caring Sciences, 16(1), 289-301 · Result: Supportive · Turkey (Arab immigrants) · https://www.internationaljournalofcaringsciences.org/docs/28.orak.pdf
  Found: Type alphas .70-.84 and test-retest ICC .70-.84; snowball sample limits generalisability.
- 2023 · Radisavljević, D.; Rzepka, R.; Araki, K. · *Personality types and traits: Examining and leveraging the relationship between different personality models for mutual prediction* · Applied Sciences, 13(7), 4506 · Result: Mixed · Japan · https://doi.org/10.3390/app13074506
  Found: Adding predicted MBTI/Enneagram types and psycholinguistic features improved text-based Big Five prediction modestly (about 1.2-3.3% in Pearson r).
- 2023 · Radisavljevic, D. · *A study on machine learning-based approaches for personality identification and translation [人格特性の識別と翻訳のための機械学習アプローチに関する研究]* · Hokkaido University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · Japan · https://doi.org/10.14943/doctoral.k15665
  Found: A transformer model identified speakers from text with F1 above 70%, and a simple method for translating MBTI and Enneagram data into Big Five scores raised per-measure correlation strength by up to 13.2%. The Enneagram is one of several models used; this is a computational study, not a test of Enneagram validity.
- 2023 · Yoo, S. H.; Lee, S. H. · *Development and Validation of a Parental Feedback Scale based on Enneagram Personality Types* · Journal of Korean Coaching Research · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.20325/kca.2023.16.2.51
  Found: A 107-item parental feedback scale showed Cronbach's alpha of .93 overall and .56 to .84 by type. Concurrent validity was checked against the VETI-A.
- 2023 · Han, S. H.; Lee, S. H. · *Development of a Mother’s Parenting Burnout Scale Based on the Personality Type of Enneagram* · The Korea Parents Education Association · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.61400/jpe.2023.20.2.59
  Found: The 107-item VETI-MB parenting-burnout scale had Cronbach's alpha of .875 to .941 and was validated against the VETI-A and VETI-M.
- 2023 · Kara, N. Ş.; Dönmez, A.; Kara, M. · *THE PREDICTOR OF MOTIVATION IN SPORTS: ENNEAGRAM PERSONALITY* · The Online Journal of Recreation and Sports · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.22282/tojras.1333242
  Found: Most types correlated positively with intrinsic motivation, but also with extrinsic motivation and amotivation. Adventurous (7) predicted motivation, and Helper (2) and Observer (5) predicted extrinsic motivation and amotivation. The correlations do not separate the types well.
- 2023 · Lee, J.; Lee, S. · *A Study on the Perception Types Regarding Difficulties in Interpersonal Relationships of Enneagram Type 2* · The Korean Society of Culture and Convergence · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.33645/cnc.2023.10.45.10.635
  Found: Five ways that Enneagram Twos perceive interpersonal difficulties were identified (e.g., 'I'd rather suffer silently than express myself'). The study is exploratory and descriptive.
- 2023 ·  · *Enneagram analizi mizaç envanterinin geliştirilmesi [Development of the Enneagram Analysis Temperament Inventory]* · Journal of Science and Innovative Technologies · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.30546/2616-4418.28.2023.12
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2023 · Karaalp, Ö. · *Examination of Enneagram in religious and non-religious individuals* · Çanakkale Onsekiz Mart University (thesis) · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://tez.yok.gov.tr/UlusalTezMerkezi/TezGoster?key=a0OMTmEd_3mfOBxT8SiBTBj5PZmLDFGloiMYjvXgM5jaePpIF159G0lWHZPCQYeN
  Found: Found statistically significant positive relationships between Enneagram personality types and all dimensions of religious attitude, plus differences by socio-demographic variables. Cross-sectional self-report data.
- 2023 · Karaduman, P.; Çetin, M. · *Examination of teachers' Enneagram personality types in terms of various variables [Öğretmenlerin Enneagram Kişilik Tiplerinin Çeşitli Değişkenler Açısından İncelenmesi]* · Eğitim Yönetimi ve Politikaları Dergisi (DergiPark) · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/pub/eypd/issue/82338/1355118
  Found: Teachers' Enneagram types did not differ by gender or education level but did differ by age, marital status, length of service, school type, tenure at the institution and number of teachers at the school. Descriptive cross-sectional design.
- 2023 · Özçiçek, A. · *Enneagram personality types and their predictive role in barriers to seeking mental health counseling* · Ibn Haldun University (conference paper) · Result: Supportive · Turkey · http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12154/3971
  Found: Specific types predicted specific help-seeking barriers (for example, investigator and enthusiast predicted 'negative perceived value', and challenger predicted cultural barriers); no type predicted 'lack of access'. Single cross-sectional self-report sample.
- 2023 · Chimthongdee, W.; Koraneekij, P.; Na-Songkhla, J. · *Unveiling the essential features of an Enneagram coaching system for teacher instructional abilities development: A survey analysis approach* · Journal of Roi Kaensarn Academi · Result: Mixed · Thailand · https://so02.tci-thaijo.org/index.php/JRKSA/article/view/264256
  Found: Identified preferred e-coaching features (resource library, appointment tool, tracking tool, learning sharing, accessibility); preferences for the tracking tool and learning sharing differed significantly by Enneagram type (p<.05), while others did not.
- 2023 · Lotfi, A.; Seif Barghi, T.; Dargahi, H.; Memari, A. H.; Rakhshan, A. · *Investigating the mediating role of leadership style in the relationship between personality type and the performance of the staff, captains, supervisors, and medics in Tehran's soccer clubs* · Asian Journal of Sports Medicine · Result: Mixed · Iran · https://doi.org/10.5812/asjsm-127311
  Found: Most members were Type B and Enneagram types 1, 2, 5 and 7; personality type was significantly related to team performance areas, and types 1, 2, 5 and 7 were related to training/exercising and social-support leadership styles (p≈.04). Cross-sectional self-report data.
- 2023 · Kaya, A.; Atayoğlu, A. T. · *Holistic approach in stroke patients: A clinical trial* · Medical Science and Discovery · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.36472/msd.v10i10.1064
  Found: Cognitive and physical function scores were correlated, but Enneagram personality types and coping attitudes did not significantly relate to cognitive or physical function. Very small sample.
- 2023 · Sanlı, A.; Irlayıcı Çakmak, P. · *Developing resilient construction professionals in the COVID-19 era* · Routledge (edited book) · Result: Supportive · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1201/9781003278368-17
  Found: Reported significant relationships between Enneagram types and resilience skills and pandemic-related stress factors. Small cross-sectional student sample.
- 2023 · Lee, J.; Kwon, K.; Park, S.; Yu, D. K.; Lee, G. · *A study on persona design strategies to reflect customers' actual needs: Focusing on customers buying housing products for camping* · Journal of Communication Design · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.25111/jcd.2023.82.28
  Found: Used the nine Enneagram types to profile camping customers, then grouped them into three core personas by need and purchase motivation; presented as a persona-building method for marketing and service strategy. Descriptive, no validation data.
- 2023 · Vargas Delgado, J. J.; Sacaluga Rodríguez, I.; García García, F. · *Intersection between disinformation, populism and enneagrams: A holistic approach to fake-news management in university students [Intersección entre desinformación, populismo y eneagramas]* · Historia y Comunicación Social · Result: Mixed · Spain · https://doi.org/10.5209/hics.88862
  Found: Explores how enneatypes and emotional inclinations may shape perception and handling of fake news and links to populism; the abstract reports no specific results.
- 2023 · Grau-Grau, A. J.; Bel Oms, I.; Rodrigo González, A. · *Application of the Enneagram to team formation among university students and its impact on academic performance in finance [Aplicación del eneagrama a la formación de equipos entre estudiantes universitarios y su impacto sobre el rendimiento académico en finanzas]* · In: Innovación en la formación docente y en el desarrollo de competencias en el aprendizaje de las ciencias económicas y empresariales (pp. 539-568). ISBN 978-84-1170-359-8 · Result: Mixed · Spain · not yet checked · https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=9238668
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2023 · Huber, D. A. · *What's your type? The relationship between Enneagram personality style and psychiatric diagnosis* · Florida Institute of Technology (Doctoral dissertation, Clinical Psychology) · Result: Supportive · USA · https://repository.fit.edu/etd/1520
  Found: Several significant associations were found between Enneagram types and DSM-5-TR diagnostic categories, broadly in line with Palmer's theorised links. Brief type measure, self-reported diagnoses, heavily female sample.
- 2023 · Kam, C. · *Conscious and unconscious interpersonal complexity in The Narrative Enneagram workshop participants* · Saint Paul University, Ottawa (PhD in Counselling and Spirituality) · Result: Supportive · Canada · https://ruor.uottawa.ca/bitstreams/31d936c0-156c-4c58-a36d-c7bd258caf25/download
  Found: Experienced participants scored significantly higher on conscious and unconscious interpersonal complexity than novices; interviewees described workshops as a safe space for growth. Cross-sectional group comparison, so self-selection cannot be ruled out.
- 2023 · Hawk, R. B. · *Exploring the relationship between church planters' Enneagram personality type and church growth* · Northwest University, Center for Leadership Studies (PhD in Organizational Leadership) · Result: Supportive · USA · https://archives.northwestu.edu/handle/nu/65443
  Found: Types 3, 7 and 8 were the common profile among planters whose churches passed 200 weekly attendance (76% of cases). Small sample; outcome is a single growth threshold.
- 2023 · Nazarkina, V. A. · *Psychographic consumer segmentation in the commercial real estate market: methodological and practical aspects* · Upravlenets (The Manager), 14(4), 100-114 · Result: Mixed · Russia · https://doi.org/10.29141/2218-5003-2023-14-4-7
  Found: Proposes an Enneagram-based investor segmentation and a marketing programme for one priority type; practical case evidence only, no validation of the typing.
- 2023 · Dust, S.; Markowski, A. · *Enneagram assessment construct validity (Cloverleaf RHETI data)* · Cloverleaf help-centre technical note (page last modified Nov 2023) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://help.cloverleaf.me/en/articles/8583761-enneagram-assessment-construct-validity
  Found: Alphas ranged .31–.73 (Types 3, 5 and 6 low, Type 9 highest at .73); 35 of 36 type pairs diverged as expected; no significant test-retest mean differences. Self-published, vendor data, no external criterion.
- 2023 · 조주영 · *Effects of integrated Enneagram and Brainspotting healing on the quality of life of cancer patients [에니어그램과 Brainspotting을 통합한 마음치유가 암환자의 삶의 질에 미치는 효과]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 20(1), 55-84 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A108723333
  Found: Distress (SUDS) on presented issues decreased and quality of life improved; two cases, combined intervention.
- 2023 · سباق، أسماء محمود أحمد · *Cognitive biases and their relation to the Enneagram thinking (head) centre among master's and doctoral students [أنماط التحيزات المعرفية وعلاقتها بمركز التفكير في نظام الإنيكرام]* · المجلة التربوية لكلية التربية بسوهاج (Sohag University Faculty of Education), 108, 291-386 · Result: Mixed · Egypt · https://doi.org/10.21608/edusohag.2023.296486
  Found: Stereotyping, false-consensus and ambiguity-avoidance biases were highest; relationships between head-centre types and bias patterns were examined (small sample).
- 2023 · 박진윤 · *Travel motives and preferences by Enneagram type for integration and growth [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 통합과 성장을 위한 여행 여행 동기 및 여행 선호도 연구]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램학회), 20(1), 29-53 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A108722682
  Found: Identified travel motives and preferred destinations by type and proposed growth-oriented travel styles; descriptive.
- 2022 · Yanartas, O.; Malakcioglu, C.; Acarkan, I.; Akca, E. · *Validity and reliability of enneagram personality types and subtypes inventory in a Turkish sample* · Anatolian Clinic Journal of Medical Sciences, 27(3), 248-259 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.21673/anadoluklin.1104082
  Found: CFA fit good/acceptable; alphas .67 (Type 5) to .87 (Type 8) and .75-.78 for subtypes; but 4-week test-retest was low (.29-.51). Sample heavily female.
- 2022 · Ramos-Vera, C.; Barrientos, A. S.; Banos-Chaparro, J.; Saldarriaga, J. V.; Saintila, J. · *Enneagram typologies and healthy personality to psychosocial stress: A network approach* · Frontiers in Psychology, 13, 1051271 · Result: Mixed · Peru · https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.1051271
  Found: Types 4, 5 and 6 were most strongly interlinked and Type 6 was most predictable; healthy stress-coping personality and Type 7 acted as bridges. Shows Enneagram scales overlap rather than forming independent types.
- 2022 · Lee, J. Y.; Lee, S. Y. · *A subjectivity study on leadership types perceived by SME managers: The Enneagram belly type* · Journal of Korean Coaching Research, 15(1), 75-94 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.20325/kca.2022.15.1.75
  Found: Identified four leadership patterns among gut-centre managers: vision/follower development, responsibility to followers, people over task, and self-management/role-model. The study is descriptive and exploratory.
- 2022 · Enneagram in Business Network · *The Enneagram in Organizations Survey Results 2022* · Enneagram in Business Network (practitioner survey report) · Result: Supportive · 49 countries · https://theenneagraminbusiness.com/enneagram-resources/books-research-and-case-studies/
  Found: Most respondents reported benefits: 83% working on self-growth, 81% more empathy, 79% better workplace relationships and 72% more team trust. It is a self-selected sample of enthusiasts with no comparison group.
- 2022 · Kim, M.-H. · *A Study on the Relationship among Mothers' Enneagram Personality Type and Type of Play Participation, and Infants' Social Development* · The Association of Korea Counseling Psychology Education Welfare · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.20496/cpew.2022.9.2.213
  Found: Mothers' Enneagram type and play participation correlated with infants' social development; head-centre mothers showed the highest correlation. Types 1, 2, 3, 5, 6 and 9 predicted infant sociality. The data are self-report and correlational.
- 2022 · Kim, K. H.; Lee, S. · *Stress Coping Strategies and Horticultural Preferences of Middle-Aged Women Based on Their Enneagram Personality Type* · Flower Research Journal · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.11623/frj.2022.30.2.03
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2022 · Je, K. J.; Lee, S. H. · *The Dopevelment and Validation of a Couple's Argument Scale based on the Enneagram Personality Types* · The Korea Parents Education Association · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.61400/jpe.2022.19.2.81
  Found: A 90-item couple-argument scale based on Enneagram type was developed. Item-total correlations were significant and positive for each type, but the abstract reports no reliability coefficients.
- 2022 · Ahn, H. J.; Lee, S. H. · *Development and Validation of Couples' Role Based on Enneagram Personality Types* · The Korea Parents Education Association · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.61400/jpe.2022.19.4.05
  Found: A 90-item couples' role scale showed Cronbach's alpha of .911 overall and .686 to .848 by type, and was cross-validated against the Vision Enneagram adult scale.
- 2022 · Yelpaze, I. · *The determinants of Enneagram personality: Horoscopes vs. parental attitude* · International Journal of Curriculum and Instruction · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1331568
  Found: Enneagram traits did not differ by horoscope; warm parental attitude related to many traits while rejecting attitude did not; men scored higher on perfectionist and peacemaker traits. Convenience sample, self-report.
- 2022 · Firoozan, T.; Khosropour, F.; Mehdizade Zare Anari, A. · *The relationship of the Enneagram personality types and the early maladaptive schemas to dependent personality disorder* · Journal of Positive School Psychology · Result: Supportive · Iran · https://journalppw.com/index.php/jpsp/article/view/11958
  Found: Reported significant relationships between Enneagram types and dependent personality disorder, and between early maladaptive schemas and dependent personality disorder. Convenience sample and cross-sectional design; effect sizes not given in the abstract.
- 2022 · Rakhmanov, S. · *Exploring the relationships between Enneagram personality types and conflict problems in male university students residing in dormitories* · Neliti (repository record) · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://www.neliti.com/publications/641103/exploring-the-relationships-between-enneagram-personality-types-and-conflict-pro
  Found: Examines associations between Enneagram types and the prevalence and nature of dormitory conflict; the abstract gives no sample size or specific results.
- 2022 · Hafızoğlu, Ö. · *Unity vs. conflicts of Enneagram personality types in problem solving* · Fen ve Teknik (DergiPark) · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/pub/fenveteknik/issue/74397/1212996
  Found: Found significant differences between the head, heart and body centres in source-domain distance, similarity mapping and depth of analogical thinking; the author frames the results as a way to reduce conflict and build unity in design teams.
- 2022 · Kimter, N.; Karaalp, Ö. · *Examination of Enneagram personality features in university students in terms of different variables* · ANADOLU 11th International Conference on Social Sciences, Diyarbakır, Türkiye (abstract paper) · Result: Mixed · Turkey · not yet checked · https://avesis.comu.edu.tr/publication/details/b24c18e7-0277-481b-9f89-6fccfecd5920/oai
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2022 · Kundakcı, S. M.; Uzan, S.; Ayverdi, L. · *The relationship between personality types of high school students and their social media addictions* · International Journal of Contemporary Approaches in Education · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.29329/ijcae.2022.499.5
  Found: Social media addiction correlated positively with helper, individualist, loyalist, enthusiast and challenger scores and negatively with reformer, achiever, investigator and peacemaker scores. Cross-sectional self-report data.
- 2022 · Araújo, A. I. P. · *Relationship between morbidity and personality types [Relação entre morbilidade e tipos de personalidade]* · University of Coimbra, Faculty of Medicine (Integrated Master's in Medicine final thesis) · Result: Mixed · Portugal · https://hdl.handle.net/10316/102438
  Found: Enneagram type/instinct was associated with several conditions (e.g., dyslipidaemia p=.005, overweight p=.012, somatisation p=.011); Big Five extraversion and agreeableness differed across the nine types. Small, self-selected sample with self-typing and many tests, so exploratory only.
- 2022 · Augspach, I. · *Linking the nine Enneagram profiles and sub-types with vocational interests* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Supportive · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/28489
  Found: RIASEC scale means differed significantly across some Enneagram bases, and the three instincts correlated with RIASEC scales. Convenience sample; author calls for larger replication.
- 2022 · Bruyninckx, M.; Dontaine, C. · *Assessing Enneagram base using situational scenarios in focus groups [Evaluation de la base ennéagramme à partir de mises en situation proposées lors de focus group]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Mixed · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/28594
  Found: Co-created scenario items and a decision tree for identifying Enneagram base as groundwork for a new questionnaire. No psychometric data yet.
- 2022 · Deneubourg, E. · *Self-knowledge through the Enneagram as a lever for action and performance at work [La connaissance de soi par l'ennéagramme en tant que levier d'action et de performance dans le milieu professionnel]* · UCLouvain, Master [60] in Labour Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Mixed · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/30552
  Found: Argues Enneagram self-knowledge can improve work performance while cautioning about excesses of personal-development training; abstract gives no empirical results – check full text.
- 2022 · Fındıkçı, İ.; Korucu Gümüşoğlu, N. · *Relationship between managers' personality and demographic characteristics: Value Personality Test (DKT) application in family businesses in Turkey [Yöneticilerin kişilik ve demografik özellikleri arasındaki ilişki]* · Sosyolojik Bağlam Dergisi, 3(1), 36-58 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.52108/2757-5942.3.1.3
  Found: Type 6 (27.4%) and Type 1 (22.4%) were most common; centre and type varied significantly by gender, age and employment status but not education or marital status. Descriptive only.
- 2022 · 최영자 · *Korean adults' anger (Korean Adult Anger Scale) and the Enneagram [한국 성인 분노척도와 에니어그램]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 19(2), 113-153 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A108436684
  Found: Anger-thinking and irrational-belief scores differed by centre (heart centre higher than head and gut centres), but anger did not differ significantly across the nine types; self-report, convenience sample.
- 2022 · 송지은 · *Analysis of consumption patterns by Enneagram personality type [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 소비패턴 분석]* · 미래기술융합논문지 (Journal of Advanced Technology Convergence), 1(1), 25-31 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.23152/jatc.2022.01.01.025
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2022 · احمد علوان شبرم (Shubrum, A. A.) · *Enneagram personality patterns (instinct centre) among special-education students [أنماط الشخصية الإنيكرام (مركز الغريزة) لدى طلبة قسم التربية الخاصة]* · مجلة نسق (Nasq Journal), 33(3), 499- · Result: Mixed · Iraq · https://repository.uobaghdad.edu.iq/articles/CxY5zooBVTCNdQwCGabt
  Found: Peacemaker (type 9) was the dominant gut-centre pattern, more so among males.
- 2022 · الغريري، سعدي جاسم; الدباغ، ثائر فاضل · *Enneagram personality type and meaning in life among University of Kufa students [نمط الشخصية على وفق نظام الانيكرام وعلاقتها بمعنى الحياه لدى طلبة جامعة الكوفة]* · Journal of the College of Basic Education (Mustansiriyah University), 24(101), 221-268 · Result: Mixed · Iraq · https://doi.org/10.35950/cbej.v24i101.6798
  Found: Helper, Achiever and Individualist patterns predominated with no differences by gender, major or year; these types correlated positively with meaning in life.
- 2022 · 김정순 · *Personality characteristics of middle-aged women via the Animal Symbol Personality Type test (ASPT) and the Enneagram [동물상징 성격유형검사(ASPT)와 에니어그램(Enneagram)을 통한 중년여성의 성격특성에 관한 연구]* · 한세대학교 심리상담대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T16062770
  Found: Uses Enneagram types as a criterion to examine ASPT validity; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2022 · 이종정 · *Elementary teachers' Enneagram characteristics and creative-convergence competence [에니어그램을 통한 초등교사들의 특징과 창의·융합 역량과의 상관관계 분석]* · 경인교육대학교 교육전문대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T16380681
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract excerpt – check full text.
- 2022 · 김수정 · *Self-compassion and happiness among Enneagram trainees [에니어그램 수련생의 자기연민과 행복에 관한 연구]* · 명지대학교 산업대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T16388509
  Found: Reports levels of self-compassion and mental well-being (13% flourishing) among trainees and demographic differences; no comparison group.
- 2021 · Kastelein, K. · *The reliability and validity of the Open Enneagram of Personality Scales* · Olivet Nazarene University (Honors thesis) · Result: Critical · USA · https://digitalcommons.olivet.edu/honr_proj/131/
  Found: Average alpha only .46, average test-retest .68, and poor CFA fit (CFI .56, TLI .50); the free OEPS did not show strong reliability or validity.
- 2021 · Gjurković, M.; Karan, V. M.; Vukojević, I.; Bošnjak, M.; Šnajder, J. · *PANDORA talks: Personality and demographics on Reddit* · Proceedings of the Ninth International Workshop on Natural Language Processing for Social Media (ACL), 138-152 · Result: Supportive · Croatia · https://doi.org/10.18653/v1/2021.socialnlp-1.12
  Found: In users with both labels, Enneagram types correlated with Big Five traits in expected directions (e.g., Type 7 with extraversion r=.39; Type 5 with extraversion r=-.36; Type 8 with agreeableness r=-.36; Type 4 with neuroticism r=.34). Authors note Enneagram validity is criticised.
- 2021 · Ramos-Vera, C.; Serpa Barrientos, A.; García Ampudia, L.; Nuñez Galvez, C.; Baños Chaparro, J. · *Psychodynamic network structure of Enneagram personality types and healthy personality in male university students* · Multicultural Education, 7(11), 19-31 · Result: Mixed · Peru · http://ijdri.com/me/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/2.pdf
  Found: Type 6 was the most central node (46% predictability); Type 7 and healthy personality acted as bridges; network stability adequate (CS = .52).
- 2021 · Daly, P. J. · *Connections between the Enneagram personality type of Christian university presidents and provosts with student enrollment* · Liberty University (PhD dissertation) · Result: Critical · USA · https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/doctoral/3034
  Found: A leader's type did not predict institutional enrolment size. Type 3 was over-represented (48.5% of leaders).
- 2021 · Weafer, D. E. · *Leadership, emotional intelligence, and the Enneagram: A study of the effects of Enneagram training on college student leaders* · Western Kentucky University (honors thesis) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://digitalcommons.wku.edu/stu_hon_theses/943
  Found: There was no significant change in EQ-i self-awareness (p=.67) or empathy (p=.19), although interviewees reported better perspective-taking, delegation and conflict handling.
- 2021 · Huffman, L.; Lefdahl-Davis, E. M.; Alayan, A. · *The Enneagram and the college student: Empirical insight, legitimacy, and practice* · Christian Higher Education, 21(3), 214-232 · Result: Supportive · USA · https://doi.org/10.1080/15363759.2021.1929566
  Found: Students reported that knowing their type helped personal growth, relationships and spiritual development. Small qualitative pilot, no comparison group.
- 2021 · Al-Obaidi, M. I. · *Fear of (COVID-19) and its relationship to Enneagram patterns among a sample of Yemeni community members* · Research Square (preprint) · Result: Mixed · Yemen · https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-865811/v1
  Found: Peacemaker (9) was the most common type, followed by Achiever (3). Fear of COVID-19 correlated negatively with the Individualist (4) and Peacemaker (9) patterns. This is a preprint that has not been peer reviewed.
- 2021 · Barkanova, O. V. · *Correlation of enneatypes and professional personality types: Possibilities of using Enneagram in professional self-determination of senior adolescents* · AZIMUTH OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH: PEDAGOGY AND PSYCHOLOGY · Result: Mixed · Russia · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.26140/anip-2021-1003-0082
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2021 · Han, S. H.; Kim, I. B.; Lee, S. H. · *A Study on the Pictures by Enneagram Personality Type used to Coach Exhausted Mothers* · The Korea Parents Education Association · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.61400/jpe.2021.18.2.05
  Found: A 27-picture parenting-burnout scale matched mothers' type from existing tests 74.4% of the time overall (66.6% to 83.3% by type).
- 2021 · Yüksel, A.; Kızılgeçit, M. · *Examination of personality traits of Faculty of Theology students in terms of some variables in the context of the Enneagram personality model* · DergiPark (tdpd journal) · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/pub/tdpd/issue/63295/856225
  Found: Men scored higher than women on Types 1, 5 and 8. Type 4 was higher in big-city residents, and Types 5, 8 and 9 were higher among students who saw themselves as very religious.
- 2021 · ابريعم، سامية; قارة، جهاد · *Personality patterns among students of the University of Oum El Bouaghi, Algeria, according to the Enneagram scale [أنماط الشخصية لدى طلبة جامعة أم البواقي- الجزائر وفق مقياس الانيغرام]* · مجلة الرسالة للدراسات والبحوث الإنسانية (Al-Risala Journal of Human Studies and Research) · Result: Mixed · Algeria · not yet checked · https://www.asjp.cerist.dz/en/article/162326
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2021 · Yüksel, A.; Kızılgeçit, M. · *Examination of the personality traits of theology faculty students in the context of the Enneagram personality model in terms of some variables [Enneagram Kişilik Modeli Bağlamında İlahiyat Fakültesi Öğrencilerinin Kişilik Özelliklerinin Bazı Değişkenler Açısından İncelenmesi]* · Türk Din Psikolojisi Dergisi · Result: Mixed · Turkey · not yet checked · https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/1495653
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2021 · Gündüz, E.; Keskin, N. · *A study on the possibility of realising creativity in organisations [Örgütlerde Yaratıcılık Gerçekleştirme Olanağı Üzerine Bir Araştırma]* · İstanbul Gelişim Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.17336/igusbd.680666
  Found: After the 60-hour Enneagram training, managers gained more than subordinates in creative-leadership scores, and the authors say creative-leadership stages were used in a more balanced way. Single-group pre/post design with no control group and self-report measures.
- 2021 ·  · *The type of Enneagram and the meaning of mandalas by the nursing students* ·  · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/6019551dc10fad8e1f5bc584a903e1e8e0d933df
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2021 · De Laet Derache, O. · *Assessing the Enneagram profile using situational scenarios [Evaluation du profil ennéagramme à partir de mises en situation]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Mixed · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/25096
  Found: Identified more and less effective scenarios/items and produced a revised questionnaire; not yet validated empirically. Very small pilot.
- 2021 · De Greef, V.; Cuvelier, J. · *Instinctual subtypes and preferred work activities in primary teachers and future psychologists [Sous-types de personnalités et activités professionnelles privilégiées chez les enseignants du primaire et les futurs psychologues]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Mixed · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/25097
  Found: A qualitative correspondence was found, but quantitatively only a weak significant correlation for two activities.
- 2021 · Pineda Aguilar, W. F.; Dávila Talepcio, J.; Alva Rodríguez, C. L. · *Self-esteem and enneatypes of personality of the primary school teacher, in times of COVID-19* · Revista Ciencia y Tecnología (Universidad Nacional de Trujillo), 17(2), 137-145 · Result: Mixed · Peru · https://doi.org/10.17268/rev.cyt.2021.02.12
  Found: 85.7% of teachers showed low self-esteem; Type 7 (31%) and Type 3 (16.7%) were most common. Purely descriptive, very small sample.
- 2021 · 전윤하 · *Resilience and job satisfaction of elementary teachers by Enneagram type [에니어그램 성격유형별 초등교사의 회복탄력성과 직무만족에 관한 연구]* · Hannam University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15735750
  Found: Type 9 (46.0%) and type 1 (21.7%) predominated; resilience and job satisfaction compared across types.
- 2021 · 이명숙 · *Middle-school students' achievement motivation, goal orientation and school satisfaction by Enneagram type [중학생의 학업성취동기, 성취목표지향성, 학교생활만족도 연구 : 에니어그램 성격유형을 중심으로]* · 경남과학기술대학교 일반대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15745115
  Found: Helper and Achiever scores positively and Investigator scores negatively predicted school-life satisfaction.
- 2020 · Sirin, T. · *Enneagram Turkiye Kisilik Envanteri'nin gelistirilmesi ve psikometrik ozelliklerinin belirlenmesi [Development of the Enneagram Turkey Personality Inventory and its psychometric properties]* · Turkish Studies, 15(2), 1375-1398 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.29228/turkishstudies.42149
  Found: Total alpha .89 with subscales .60-.78 and acceptable CFA fit (RMSEA .06, CFI .92), but test-retest correlations were low (.20-.57).
- 2020 · Saeidi, M.; Komasi, S.; Amiri, M. M.; Azizi, M.; Alikhani, M. · *Is the Enneagram personality system an effective approach in explaining drug addiction?* · Middle East Journal of Rehabilitation and Health Studies, 7(1), e98710 · Result: Mixed · Iran · https://doi.org/10.5812/mejrh.98710
  Found: Eight of nine type scores were associated with addiction status (Types 5, 4 and 1 most strongly); triads were not. Model classified 78.8% correctly. Small case-control sample.
- 2020 · Desmarais, M.; Galiano, O.; Gazemar, V.; Fréchette, J. · *The enneagram model for nursing competencies development: An exploratory qualitative study* · Journal of Nursing Education and Practice, 10(8) · Result: Supportive · Canada · https://doi.org/10.5430/jnep.v10n8p1
  Found: All 9 reported greater self-awareness and saw value for collaboration and leadership, and 4 of 9 reported improved leadership. The sample was small and self-selected.
- 2020 · Aktürk, Z.; Taştan, K. · *Frequency of personality types based on Enneagram in a Turkish sample: A web-based cross-sectional study* · Ortadoğu Tıp Dergisi · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.21601/ortadogutipdergisi.722751
  Found: Type 2 was the most frequent type (20.4%); type frequencies varied with age (e.g., type 8 fell with age).
- 2020 ·  · *造形教育における効果的な教授法の考察(後編): エニアグラムタイプと造形タイプの関係性を探る* · 奈良芸術短期大学研究紀要 (Nara College of Arts Bulletin) · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1520009409493562624
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2020 · Şahin, İ.; Turan, H.; Yıldırım, A. · *Enneagram Kişilik Tipleri ve Akademik Başarı (Kocaeli - İzmit İlçesi 7. ve. Sınıf Örneği)* · Kocaeli Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.35343/kosbed.526020
  Found: Enneagram types showed low but significant correlations with academic achievement. Achiever, perfectionist and adventurer types were most related to grades.
- 2020 · Kwon, H.; Hong, S.; Kim, S. · *An Analysis of Prison Inmates' Personality Type and Implications for Correctional Policy : Application of Enneagram Method* · Psychological Type and Human Development · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.52745/kapt.2020.1.1.23
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2020 · Kwon, H. S.; Hong, S. O. · *Analysis of Prison Inmates' Socio-Demographic Characteristics, Psychological Well-being, Self-esteem, Emotional Regulation, and Relationship with Enneagram Personality Type* · Korean Correction Counseling Psychological Association · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.33614/kccpa.2020.5.1.5
  Found: First-time and repeat offenders differed significantly in Enneagram centre use, self-esteem and psychological well-being. Well-being affected centre use both directly and through self-esteem and emotion regulation.
- 2020 · Kim, K.-M.; Lee, S.-H. · *The Adolescent Learning Attitude Scale Based on Enneagram Personality Type* · Journal of Korean Coaching Research · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.20325/kca.2020.13.6.69
  Found: A 70-item learning-attitude scale based on Enneagram type was developed and reported as reliable and valid. The abstract gives no reliability coefficients.
- 2020 · Sisti, F. · *Enneagramma, motivazione e stile cognitivo Una prospettiva inclusiva per lo studio delle lingue straniere* · EL.LE · Result: Mixed · Italy · https://doi.org/10.30687/elle/2280-6792/2020/02/009
  Found: Tested whether Enneagram type is linked to reasons for studying foreign languages and to exam marks. The abstract states the aims but not the results.
- 2020 · Demir, A.; Rakhmanov, O.; Taştan, K.; Dane, Ş.; Aktürk, Z. · *Development and validation of the Nile Personality Assessment Tool based on Enneagram* ·  · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://opus.bibliothek.uni-augsburg.de/opus4/frontdoor/index/index/docId/101776
  Found: The 27-item tool had Cronbach's α=0.756. Sensitivity and specificity for detecting types ranged from 71.4% to 100%, with overall accuracy of 90.8%.
- 2020 · Rakhmanov, O.; Demir, A.; Dane, Ş. · *The relationships between Enneagram personality types and conflict problems in male university students who stayed in a dormitory* ·  · Result: Supportive · country not stated · https://doaj.org/article/5e1917e032e7493f9e47789a745d8b49
  Found: Rooms where at least half the students shared a type differed in conflict-resolution scores from other rooms. The authors recommend grouping students by type, but the design is cross-sectional.
- 2020 · Demir, A.; Rakhmanov, O.; Dane, Ş. · *Validity and reliability of the Nile Personality Assessment Tool based on Enneagram for English-speaking people* ·  · Result: Supportive · country not stated · https://doaj.org/article/81d02f0b3cf1457098c7669d075d22dd
  Found: Test-retest agreement was high (Cohen's κ=0.89). Sensitivity and specificity ranged from 65% to 100%, with overall accuracy of 89.9% against the author's typing as gold standard.
- 2020 · Caudle, C. · *Using the Enneagram as a lens for culturally sustaining pedagogy in the ninth grade English language arts classroom* · University of Central Florida · Result: Mixed · USA · https://stars.library.ucf.edu/etd2020/191
  Found: Suggests that matching novels to students using Enneagram analysis of characters helped differentiate literature choice and supported reading self-efficacy and enjoyment. Qualitative, single classroom context.
- 2020 · Gökkaya, A. · *Examination of parents' Enneagram knowledge, parental attitudes and forgiveness levels according to some variables [Anne babaların; enneagram bilgisi, ebeveyn tutumları ve affedicilik düzeylerinin bazı değişkenlere göre incelenmesi]* · Maltepe University · Result: Mixed · Turkey · not yet checked · https://openaccess.maltepe.edu.tr/xmlui/handle/20.500.12415/6961
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2020 · Darroux, D. A. · *The role of emotional intelligence in chaplaincy: an analysis of EI in the delivery of patient-centered care* · Liberty University (doctoral) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/doctoral/2712
  Found: Most chaplains typed as Ones (61.5%), followed by Twos and Threes, and EI was judged important for patient-centred care. The Enneagram analysis is descriptive only, with a very small sample.
- 2020 · 김경미; 이소희 · *A youth learning attitude scale based on Enneagram personality types [에니어그램 성격유형에 기반 한 청소년 학습태도 척도]* · 코칭연구 (Korean Journal of Coaching) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://db.koreascholar.com/Article?code=404222
  Found: The authors developed a 70-item learning attitude scale and report acceptable reliability and validity by gender, centre and retrospective college-student comparisons. The abstract gives no coefficients.
- 2020 · Laborda Velasco, A. · *Application of the Enneagram in team leadership and management in companies [Aplicación del eneagrama en la dirección y gestión de equipos en la empresa]* · Universidad de Alcalá (Máster Universitario en Dirección de Proyectos Informáticos) · Result: Mixed · Spain · not yet checked · http://hdl.handle.net/10017/44713
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2020 · González Vargas, E. · *Personal growth of mediators through the Enneagram self-knowledge tool [Crecimiento personal de los mediadores y mediadoras a través de la herramienta de autoconocimiento, eneagrama]* · Universitat Jaume I · Result: Mixed · Spain · not yet checked · http://repositori.uji.es/xmlui/handle/10234/191065
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2020 · 권후선; 홍상욱 · *Relationships among social and demographic characteristics, psychological well-being, self-esteem, emotion regulation and Enneagram personality types of prisoners [재소자의 사회 및 인구학적 특성, 심리적 복지감, 자존감, 정서조절 및 에니어그램 성격유형과의 관계 분석]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://devkiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3803619
  Found: First-time and repeat offenders differed significantly in centre use, self-esteem and psychological well-being, but not in emotion regulation. Well-being affected centre use directly and indirectly through self-esteem and emotion regulation.
- 2020 · Shameli, L.; Gholami, S.; Zare, F. · *A comparison of the Enneagram personality triads based on SCL-90 patterns in nurses* ·  · Result: Mixed · Iran · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.22034/ijpb.2020.189478.1110
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2020 · Fernandes, C. · *Operator effect on operational performance of skidding and bucking in Pinus harvesting [Efeito do operador no desempenho operacional das atividades de arraste e traçamento na colheita de Pinus spp.]* · Universidade do Estado de Santa Catarina (UDESC), MSc Forest Engineering · Result: Mixed · Brazil · https://repositorio.udesc.br/handle/UDESC/14961
  Found: Operator Enneagram profile influenced productivity in skidding (Type 1 122.3 vs Type 3 103.7 m3/PMH0) and in bucking at shift level. Only five operators, so profile is confounded with individual and experience.
- 2020 · Auccatoma Morales, R. J. · *Adaptation of the Enneagram-Based Personality Inventory in university students of Metropolitan Lima [Adaptación del inventario de personalidad basado en eneagrama en estudiantes universitarios de Lima Metropolitana]* · Universidad César Vallejo, Lima (licentiate thesis in Psychology) · Result: Mixed · Peru · https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12692/52820
  Found: CFA supported the nine-factor structure (CFI=.93, TLI=.92, RMSEA=.05), but omega reliability ranged widely from .26 to .82, so some type scales are weak. Undergraduate-level thesis.
- 2020 · Núñez Galvez, C. · *Relationship between Enneagram personality types and types of reaction to psychosocial stress in students of Universidad Alas Peruanas, Ica [Relación entre los tipos de personalidad según el Eneagrama y los tipos de reacción al estrés psicosocial]* · Universidad Nacional Mayor de San Marcos (Master's in Clinical and Health Psychology) · Result: Supportive · Peru · https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12672/15495
  Found: Scales showed reliability .84–.99; each enneatype correlated positively with SIRI stress-reaction types (r=.17–.48, p<.001). Same student sample later analysed in a 2022 Frontiers network study; cross-sectional self-report.
- 2020 · Paul, M. · *Introducing the Enneagram in the company: interpersonal relations in teams and collective bargaining [L'introduction de l'Ennéagramme dans l'entreprise]* · UCLouvain, Master [60] in Labour Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Mixed · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/17019
  Found: Examines how Enneagram introduction affects interpersonal relations in teams and social-dialogue negotiation; abstract gives aims only – check full text for results.
- 2020 · 전향 · *Care services of care workers by Enneagram type [요양 보호사의 에니어그램 유형별 돌봄 서비스에 관한 연구]* · Jeonbuk National University Graduate School of Business (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15680520
  Found: Compared interpersonal caring behaviour and job satisfaction across types; detailed results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2020 · 胡伯堯 (Hu, Po-Yao) · *An empirical study of AI in human-resource application: Evidence from AI Enneagram face recognition [人工智慧應用於人力資源之實證研究: 以AI九型人臉辨識為例]* · National Tsing Hua University, Public Policy and Management (master's thesis) · Result: Critical · Taiwan · https://www.airitilibrary.com/Article/Detail/U0016-2502202114252482
  Found: AI face-based Enneagram typing showed poor accuracy; type-5 clients were judged correctly more often. Relevant caution for automated typing in HR.
- 2019 · Tastan, K. · *Development and validation of a personality type inventory based on Enneagram* · Konuralp Medical Journal (Konuralp Tip Dergisi), 11(1), 112-118 · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.18521/ktd.462049
  Found: Alpha .84; nine components explained over 60% of variance; vs expert-interview type, average sensitivity 83% and specificity 98% (Type 4 sensitivity only 67%). Small sample.
- 2019 · Korf, L.; Cloete, D. · *Testing the iEQ9 reliability and validity* · Integrative9 Enneagram Solutions (company publication) · Result: Supportive · South Africa / international · https://www.integrative9.com/media/articles/35/testing-the-ieq9-reliability-and-validity
  Found: Type-scale alphas .73-.84; EFA recovered nine factors with 60-100% of items loading on their intended type. Not peer reviewed; no test-retest reported.
- 2019 · Roh, H.; Park, K. H.; Ko, H. J.; Kim, D. K.; Son, H. B.; Shin, D. H.; Lee, S. H.; Jung, H. Y.; Heo, D. · *Understanding medical students' empathy based on Enneagram personality types* · Korean Journal of Medical Education, 31(1), 73-82 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.3946/kjme.2019.120
  Found: Types 2 and 6 had the highest empathy and compassionate-care scores, Type 3 the lowest empathy; Feeling-triad students scored higher on compassionate care, consistent with theory.
- 2019 · Tozun, M.; Ayranci, U. · *Accordance between enneagram and ten-item personality inventory with correspondence analysis and social relationship status among university students from Turkey* · International Research Journal of Social Sciences, 8(1), 1-10 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://www.isca.me/IJSS/Archive/v8/i1/1.ISCA-IRJSS-2018-097.php
  Found: Found correspondences between types and Big Five traits that differed by gender (e.g., some types aligned with agreeableness/conscientiousness in men, neuroticism in women).
- 2019 · Komasi, S.; Zakiei, A.; Ghasemi, S. R.; Gilan, N. R.; Veisi, A.; Bagherirad, D.; Saeidi, M. · *Is Enneagram personality system able to predict perceived risk of heart disease and readiness to lifestyle modification?* · Annals of Cardiac Anaesthesia, 22(4), 394-399 · Result: Supportive · Iran · https://doi.org/10.4103/aca.ACA_115_18
  Found: Type 3 predicted greater readiness for lifestyle change (p<.001), Type 8 lower readiness (p=.019), and Type 6 higher perceived heart-disease risk (p=.012).
- 2019 · Wang, Y.; Xu, F.; Qin, F. · *The influence of Enneagram on decision style: Mindfulness as mediator variable* · Open Journal of Social Sciences, 7(4), 266-281 · Result: Mixed · China · https://doi.org/10.4236/jss.2019.74021
  Found: Gut and heart centres were linked to decision-making styles, with mindfulness as a mediator. The head centre showed no such link.
- 2019 · Saeidi, M.; Amiri, M. M.; Ahmadi, M.; Komasi, S. · *The relationship between the Enneagram personality types and health responsibility in patients with substance use disorder: A brief report* · Jundishapur Journal of Health Sciences · Result: Mixed · Iran · https://doi.org/10.5812/jjhs.90424
  Found: Types 1 and 3 correlated positively and type 4 negatively with health responsibility, but the types did not significantly predict it in regression.
- 2019 ·  · *造形教育における効果的な教授法の考察(前編): エニアグラムタイプと造形タイプの関係性を探る* · 奈良芸術短期大学研究紀要 (Nara College of Arts Bulletin) · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1520572359089679232
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · Kim, S. · *A Study on Employment Uneasiness, Appearance Satisfaction and Self Expression by Enneagram Type of Nursing Students* · Korean Association For Learner-Centered Curriculum And Instruction · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.22251/jlcci.2019.19.14.691
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · Kwon, J.-H. · *Effects of Stress Coping Strategy on Happiness by Center Energy of Enneagram Personality Type* · Health & Welfare · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.23948/kshw.2019.09.21.3.7
  Found: Stress-coping styles did not differ significantly between the three Enneagram centres. However, the coping styles that predicted happiness did differ by centre (e.g., problem-focused coping for head types, social support for heart types).
- 2019 · Hong, K.-H.; Kim, K.-M. · *Differences in stress inducing factors and coping strategies according to Enneagram personalities of early childhood teacher* · The Journal of Korea Open Association for Early Childhood Education · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.20437/koaece24-6-04
  Found: Stress triggers differed significantly by Enneagram type in all areas except romantic issues, and active coping differed by type. The results are self-report and cross-sectional.
- 2019 · Jin, Y.-J.; Kim, S.-N.; Shin, Y.-J. · *미용실 선택 요인이 고객만족도에 미치는 영향 : 에니어그램 성격 유형 별 집단으로부터의 증거* · Korean Corporation Management Review · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.21052/kcmr.2019.26.1.06
  Found: The effect of hair-salon selection factors on customer satisfaction differed by Enneagram type, which the authors use for type-based marketing suggestions. They note that some type subgroups were too small for reliable analysis.
- 2019 · Lee, S.-Y.; Kim, H.-W. · *Perception of Anxiety as the passion of the Enneagram Type 6 using Q methodology* · Journal of Korean Coaching Research · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.20325/kca.2019.12.2.27
  Found: Four subjective types of anxiety among Enneagram Sixes were identified (e.g., 'worst-case scenario', 'relationship-anxious'). The study is exploratory and descriptive.
- 2019 · 정미숙; 백종운 · *업무우수자의 에니어그램 성격유형별 직무만족에 관한 연구* · Asia-pacific Journal of Multimedia Services Convergent with Art, Humanities, and Sociology · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.35873/ajmahs.2019.9.8.062
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · سيف محمد رديف; ميسون كريم ضاري · *The personality types (the Enneagram) among the lecturers of Baghdad University and its relation to some variables* · Journal of College of Education for Women (University of Baghdad) · Result: Mixed · Iraq · https://jcoeduw.uobaghdad.edu.iq/index.php/journal/article/view/200
  Found: The Romantic (4) type was most prevalent, followed by Reformer and Helper; several types differed significantly by academic specialisation and academic title. Descriptive, self-report.
- 2019 · Boz, D.; Kardaş, İ.; Altınbay, A. · *The relationship between personality traits of taxpayers receiving accounting services and customer loyalty [Muhasebe hizmeti alan mükelleflerin kişilik özelliklerinin müşteri bağlılığı ile ilişkisi]* · OPUS Uluslararası Toplum Araştırmaları Dergisi · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.26466/opus.612220
  Found: Enneagram traits showed very weak to moderate correlations with customer loyalty and predicted loyalty and its sub-factors. Type 7 had the highest and Type 2 the lowest correlation with loyalty.
- 2019 · 이은주 · *Fellow soldiers' perceptions of maladjusted soldiers (Enneagram Type 4) [동료 병사의 복무 부적응 병사 (에니어그램 4번 유형)에 대한 인식]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A360084
  Found: Fellow soldiers saw maladjusted Type 4 soldiers as either genuinely struggling (personal character, trauma before enlistment) or 'playing tricks' (repeated false behaviour, mood swings). Intended as background for mental-health nursing; small purposive sample.
- 2019 · Çetinkaya, İ. · *Analysis of leadership characteristics of secondary education institution principals: the case of Istanbul* · Beykent University (master's thesis) · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://tez.yok.gov.tr/UlusalTezMerkezi/TezGoster?key=vjszP7PzV0HebcjFEvDfwBhNJ3z9Moqnaz8Sd7mtJfwDHnfCRA9soSK5YEakhN1f
  Found: Most relationships between principals' leadership styles and Enneagram personality types were statistically significant. The abstract gives no sample size or effect sizes.
- 2019 · Johnson, J. D. · *The connection between lead pastors' Enneagram personality type and congregational size* · Southeastern University (EdD dissertation) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://firescholars.seu.edu/coe/37
  Found: Types 3 and 8 were a significantly common profile among megachurch pastors (79% of cases). The author notes this says nothing about leadership quality and may reflect selection processes that favour certain types.
- 2019 · Keskin, N.; Gündüz, E. · *The role of Enneagram teaching in developing creative leadership [Yaratıcı liderlik geliştirmede Enneagram öğretisinin rolü]* · Academic Platform Journal of Education and Change, 2(2), 169–186 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://dergipark.org.tr/en/pub/apjec/article/632271
  Found: The abstract describes the training and measures but reports no numerical results; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · Kurt, A. · *Individual differences in the personal selling process: a study on the Enneagram typology [Kişisel satış sürecinde bireysel farklılıklar: Enneagram tipolojisi üzerine bir araştırma]* · Maltepe University · Result: Mixed · Turkey · not yet checked · https://openaccess.maltepe.edu.tr/xmlui/handle/20.500.12415/4279
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · DeLay, S. · *"I don't have to fit what I thought a leader was, it can be so many things": The relationship between the Enneagram and self-authorship development of student leaders* · Taylor University (MA in Higher Education and Student Development) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://pillars.taylor.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1140&context=mahe
  Found: Emotional intelligence, sense of purpose and reflection emerged as shared themes, plus a type-specific observation for each type group. The author suggests type knowledge can support self-authorship in student leaders.
- 2019 · 이송이; 김혜원 · *A subjectivity study of anxiety perception types among Enneagram Type 6 [에니어그램 6유형의 불안 인식유형에 관한 주관성 연구]* · 코칭연구 (Korean Journal of Coaching) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://db.koreascholar.com/Article?code=374274
  Found: Four subjective anxiety patterns emerged among Type 6s: 'worst-case problem fixation', 'authority-resisting organised responsibility', 'continuous preparation' and 'relationship-anxious'. Exploratory, small sample.
- 2019 · Kwon, J. H. · *Effects of stress coping styles by Enneagram centre of energy on happiness [에니어그램 성격유형의 중심에너지별 스트레스 대처방식이 행복에 미치는 영향]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://dspace.kci.go.kr/handle/kci/495408
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · 윤운성; 김새한별 · *Status analysis of Korean Enneagram personality subtypes [한국형에니어그램성격하위유형 현황 분석]* · 에니어그램연구 (Enneagram Research) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A356703
  Found: Social subtype was most common (42.4%), then self-preservation (34.5%) and sexual (23.1%). Subtype distribution differed by type (χ²=499.4, p<.001), e.g. 55% of Type 6s were self-preservation, 62.5% of Type 4s sexual and 66.5% of Type 2s social. Self-selected course sample.
- 2019 · Ndirangu, S.; Mutisya, S. K.; Gikonyo, J. · *Enneagram personality types (enneatypes) and marital satisfaction* ·  · Result: Mixed · Kenya · not yet checked · https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/07cbe803209669b9a43623e994811f565a4bca55
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · Cheong, M.; 백종웅 · *A study on job satisfaction by Enneagram personality type of excellent workers* · Asia-pacific Journal of Multimedia Services Convergent with Art, Humanities, and Sociology, 9, 697-706 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/4e82844a48bed5788a4cafe3a3b3bb343a3d5180
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · Raimond, A. · *Predictive power of the Enneagram and the Five-Factor Model on vocational decision-making profile [Pouvoir prédictif de l'ennéagramme et du modèle de personnalité en cinq facteurs sur le profil de décision vocationnelle]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Supportive · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/21248
  Found: Both the Enneagram and the Big Five showed predictive power across career decision-making profile dimensions. Effect sizes not given in abstract.
- 2019 · Peeters, A. · *Predicting decision-profile dimensions from Enneagram types [Prédiction du lien entre les dimensions du profil décisionnel sur base des types Ennéagramme]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Supportive · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/22326
  Found: Found links between certain Enneagram types and specific decision-profile dimensions. Abstract gives no effect sizes.
- 2019 · Al Dafaai, R. R.; Diab, B. S.; Abd Al Ghani, H. J. · *Personality types in relation to dental caries and salivary testosterone among teachers in Baghdad city* · Journal of Baghdad College of Dentistry, 31(4) · Result: Mixed · Iraq · https://doi.org/10.26477/jbcd.v31i4.2714
  Found: Caries experience (DMFS) differed significantly across the nine types; no correlation between salivary testosterone and type scores or caries. Cross-sectional, women only.
- 2019 · 이안숙 · *Development of an Enneagram personality-type diagnostic tool and its application to job placement [에니어그램 성격유형진단 도구 개발에 의한 직무배치 적용 연구]* · Myongji University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15350516
  Found: Develops an Enneagram diagnostic tool for organisational job placement (linked to industrial-safety staffing); abstract gives no psychometric figures – check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · 김영호 · *Development of an Enneagram personality-dimension scale for adolescents: Relationships with lifestyle and coping [청소년의 에니어그램 성격차원 척도 개발]* · Daegu University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15370852
  Found: Personality dimensions related systematically to instinctual 'lifestyle' types and coping styles (e.g., achievement dimension with reactive coping), supporting predictive use in adolescent counselling; self-report.
- 2019 · 권후선 · *Analysis of prisoners' personality types using the Enneagram [에니어그램을 활용한 재소자들의 성격유형 분석]* · 영남대학교 행정대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15071185
  Found: Type 7 was overwhelmingly common among surveyed prisoners; descriptive.
- 2018 · Yilmaz, O.; Yildirim, A.; Yucedag, D. · *Assessment of personality from a new perspective: Characterix Personality Types Inventory* · International Journal of Scientific Research and Management, 6(3) · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.18535/ijsrm/v6i3.el02
  Found: Nine dimensions with alphas .73-.88 (total .88) and acceptable CFA fit (CFI .92, NNFI .91); no test-retest reported. Developed by a commercial test provider.
- 2018 · Daniels, D.; Saracino, T.; Fraley, M.; Christian, J.; Pardo, S. · *Advancing ego development in adulthood through study of the Enneagram system of personality* · Journal of Adult Development, 25(4), 229-241 · Result: Supportive · USA · https://doi.org/10.1007/s10804-018-9289-x
  Found: Some participants who received at least 40-50 hours of Enneagram training advanced in ego development; no randomised control.
- 2018 · Perryman, K.; Popejoy, E.; Suarez, A. · *Using the Enneagram to facilitate the supervision relationship: A qualitative study* · Journal of Counseling Research and Practice, 3(1), 16-30 · Result: Supportive · USA · https://doi.org/10.56702/uckx8598/jcrp0301.2
  Found: Themes were self-awareness, awareness of others, rapport and role clarity in the supervisor-supervisee relationship. With n=3, the results do not generalise.
- 2018 ·  · *A study on role sharing in project learning considering personality types of the Enneagram* · Information: An International Interdisciplinary Journal · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1520010380183667456
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 · 성은옥; 남현아 · *Enneagram personality types and stress of nursing students in an area* · The Korean Journal of Psychodrama · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.17962/kjp.2018.21.2.002
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 · Ercin, H. S. · *Evaluation of the relationship between healthy lifestyle behaviours and Enneagram personality types [Sağlıklı yaşam biçimi davranışları ile enneagram kişilik tipleri arasındaki ilişkinin değerlendirilmesi]* · Ankara Yıldırım Beyazıt University (medical specialty thesis) · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://avesis.aybu.edu.tr/advisingTheses/details/fb1358c9-3565-4fd2-bfd7-3be81be2d587/oai
  Found: Type 7 had the highest overall healthy-lifestyle score and Type 5 the lowest. Significant type differences appeared for total score, physical activity (Type 2 vs Type 7) and interpersonal relations (Type 5 lower than Types 1, 2 and 7).
- 2018 · Al-Falahy, S. H. H.; Al-joboury, S. M. R. · *The Enneagram personality types (the feeling centre) and academic self among distinguished students* · Journal of Educational and Psychological Researches (University of Baghdad) · Result: Supportive · Iraq · https://jperc.uobaghdad.edu.iq/index.php/jperc/article/view/144
  Found: Type 3 (Achiever) was the most common type. Types 2, 3, 7, 8 and 1 correlated positively with academic self-concept, and Type 3 alone was a significant predictor in the regression. No gender differences.
- 2018 · 김미혜; 박순형 · *Enneagram experiences of nursing students at a university [일 대학 간호대학생의 에니어그램 경험]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A340410
  Found: Four categories emerged: self-understanding, understanding others, understanding human behaviour, and awareness of the Enneagram. The last category included 'rejection of' and 'regret about' the Enneagram as well as interest.
- 2018 · 성은옥; 남현아 · *Clinical practice stress by Enneagram personality type among nursing students [간호대학생의 에니어그램 성격유형 별 임상실습스트레스]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3655840
  Found: Type 2 was the most common (47.7%) and the feeling centre made up 64.8% of the sample. Stress areas differed by type, for example Type 5 was highest for workload and interpersonal conflict and Type 4 for conflict with patients, and the thinking centre reported more stress in most areas.
- 2018 · 홍길회; 김경미 · *Differences in stressors by Enneagram personality [에니어그램 성격에 따른 스트레스 유발요인 차이]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=30002783
  Found: Type differed significantly for romantic-relationship and values stressors, and centre differed for peer, academic and financial stressors. Harmonic groups differed on family, romance and values stressors, but Hornevian groups showed no differences.
- 2018 · 곽영미 · *A counselling case using Enneagram personality types [에니어그램 성격유형을 활용한 상담 사례]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3639103
  Found: Reports that the client recognised how his thoughts, feelings and cravings drove problem behaviour and felt freer. Single uncontrolled case with the counsellor counselling her own spouse.
- 2018 · 박연희 · *A case of stress relief and improved spousal relationship using the Enneagram [에니어그램을 활용한 스트레스해소와 배우자와의 관계 개선사례]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3639102
  Found: The client identified his type and reported less stress and lethargy and easier relationships. Single uncontrolled case.
- 2018 · 곽영희 · *A habit-improvement counselling case using the Enneagram [에니어그램을 활용한 햇살님의 습관 개선 상담 사례]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3639105
  Found: Reports better sleep, less fatigue and a curbed drinking habit after Enneagram-based counselling with meditation. Single uncontrolled case.
- 2018 · 윤운성; 김새한별 · *Regression analysis of Korean Enneagram type scores by occupation [직종에 따른 한국형에니어그램 성격유형별 회귀분석]* · 에니어그램연구 (Enneagram Research) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A345299
  Found: Occupation significantly predicted every type score (all p<.001), e.g. arts-related jobs for Type 4 (F=42.5) and self-employment for Type 8 (F=41.5). The effect for Type 9 was weak (F=2.4).
- 2018 · Yıldırım, A. N.; Şahin, İ.; Turan, H. · *Analysis of the relationship between Enneagram personality types and academic achievement of 7th and 8th grade students in İzmit, Kocaeli [Kocaeli İli İzmit İlçesi 7. ve 8. Sınıf Öğrencilerinin Enneagram Kişilik Tipleriyle Akademik Başarıları Arasındaki İlişkilerin Analizi]* · International Congress on Social Sciences IV, Targovishte, Bulgaria (abstract, vol. 1, p. 96) · Result: Mixed · Turkey · not yet checked · https://avesis.kocaeli.edu.tr/publication/details/0ace95db-5dc8-4519-8bea-f3a9d52904d5/oai
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 · Moura, D. C. A.; Arreguy-Sena, C.; Greco, R. M.; Pacheco, Z. M. L.; Ribeiro, R. M. · *Communication process in the light of the Enneagram: Teaching/learning between nursing trainees and teachers [Processo comunicacional à luz do Eneagrama: ensino/aprendizagem entre estagiários e docentes de enfermagem]* ·  · Result: Mixed · Brazil · not yet checked · https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/47ca3af4a1d0b68e93f24950688c4f686a53a644
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 · Rouyer, C. · *Assessing personality at work with Enneagram-based tools [L'évaluation de la personnalité au travail à partir d'outils basés sur le modèle de l'Ennéagramme]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Mixed · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/19743
  Found: Tested whether the Career Finder's presumed professional strengths match HPEI types and whether both tools show their theorised factor structure; detailed results not in the abstract – check full text.
- 2018 · Stordeur, M.-F. · *Contributions of the Enneagram to the meaning of career trajectory and entry into training among adults returning to study [Apports de l'ennéagramme sur le sens donné à sa trajectoire professionnelle et à son entrée en formation]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Educational Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Supportive · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/19707
  Found: Weak but significant correlations between some Enneagram bases and motives for entering training; qualitative data supported hypothesised type-specific links. Single-programme sample.
- 2018 · 박지영 · *Job stress, satisfaction, burnout and commitment of restaurant middle managers: Differences by Enneagram type [레스토랑 중간관리자의 직무스트레스가 직무만족, 직무소진 및 조직몰입에 미치는 영향]* · Kyung Hee University Graduate School of Tourism (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T14760612
  Found: Job demands and lack of autonomy differed by type, but relationship conflict, rewards, satisfaction, burnout and commitment did not.
- 2018 · 김은정 · *Job stress and coping of childcare teachers by Enneagram type [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 보육교사의 직무 스트레스와 대처방안]* · Kyonggi University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T14752101
  Found: Compares occupational stress and coping across types; detailed results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2017 · Coker, C.; Mihai, F. · *Personality traits and second language acquisition: The influence of the Enneagram on adult ESOL students* · TESOL Journal, 8(2), 432-449 · Result: Supportive · USA · https://doi.org/10.1002/tesj.281
  Found: Students perceived that knowing their Enneagram type helped them understand their language-learning experience; authors give suggestions for teaching. Very small qualitative sample.
- 2017 · Subaş, A. · *Development of an Enneagram personality scale: A reliability and validity study [Enneagram kişilik ölçeğinin geliştirilmesi]* · The Journal of Social Sciences (Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi), 11(11), 160-181 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.16990/sobider.3478
  Found: Develops a Turkish Enneagram personality scale. Abstract and statistics not retrieved; check the full text before citing results.
- 2017 · Pratiwi, D.; Santoso, G. B.; Saputri, F. H. · *The application of graphology and Enneagram techniques in determining personality type based on handwriting features* · Jurnal Ilmu Komputer dan Informasi, 10(1), 11- · Result: Mixed · Indonesia · https://doi.org/10.21609/jiki.v10i1.372
  Found: Type inferred from handwriting matched questionnaire type for 81.6% of 49 respondents. Small sample, and graphology itself lacks scientific support. (The same study also appeared in International Journal of Computer Applications, 2016.)
- 2017 · Jeong, S.-Y. · *Analyzing Enneagram personality type of students with hearing impairment* · Journal of Special Education & Rehabilitation Science, 56(1), 227-250 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.23944/isers.2017.03.56.1.10
  Found: The Helper type and the heart centre were most common. Type distribution differed by degree of impairment but not by gender, and type predicted learning style and leadership style.
- 2017 · Yoo, S.-H.; Lee, S.-H. · *The development and validation of the Enneagram Easy Scale for Adults* · Korean Journal of Family Welfare, 22(2), 305-327 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.13049/kfwa.2017.22.2.5
  Found: A 45-item short scale was derived from 90 items. Type reliabilities were modest (.58-.73), and correlations with the Vision Enneagram Scale groupings reached .78 (heart centre), .64 (harmonic) and .71 (Hornevian).
- 2017 · Park, S. Y.; Kim, W. G.; Choi, H. R. · *Clinical career preference, nursing professionalism & creative leadership according to Enneagram personality types in nursing students* · Journal of Learner-Centered Curriculum and Instruction, 17(19), 733-750 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.22251/jlcci.2017.17.19.733
  Found: Nursing professionalism did not differ by centre (F=0.08, p=.922). The heart centre scored higher than the body centre on creative leadership (3.58 vs 3.43; F=4.53, p=.012).
- 2017 · Hoekx, C. C. G. M. · *The usefulness of the Enneagram model in the Netherlands: An overview of Enneagram explanations and the usefulness as ascribed by Dutch Enneagram coaches and managers* · Radboud University (thesis) · Result: Mixed · Netherlands · not yet checked · http://hdl.handle.net/2066/175890
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2017 · Marrero, Z. · *The Enneagram: Towards an empirical assessment of disintegration* · University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee Undergraduate Research Symposium (poster) · Result: Mixed · USA · not yet checked · https://dc.uwm.edu/uwsurca/2017/Posters/82
  Found: Built a new measure of disintegration after two earlier attempts found no support, and correlated it with an Enneagram type assessment in a small sample; results not given in the available abstract.
- 2017 · Subaş, A. · *Examining the relationship between school administrators' leadership styles and Enneagram personality types [Okul yöneticilerinin liderlik stilleri ile enneagram kişilik tipleri arasındaki ilişkinin incelenmesi]* · Marmara University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Supportive · Turkey · not yet checked · https://hdl.handle.net/11424/202032
  Found: Developed two new scales and found significant correlations (p<.05) between administrators' Enneagram types and leadership styles.
- 2017 · Jeong, S. Y. · *Relationship between Enneagram personality types and Holland career interest types among students with hearing impairments* · The Journal of Special Children Education, 19(3), 49 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.21075/kacsn.2017.19.3.49
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2017 · Yoo, S. H.; Lee, S. H. [유서현; 이소희] · *Development and validation of a short Enneagram scale for adults [성인용 에니어그램 간편 척도 개발 및 타당화 연구]* · 한국가족복지학 (Korean Journal of Family Welfare) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3526028
  Found: A 45-item short scale was derived from 90 items; type reliabilities were only .58-.73 and correlation with the parent scale was up to .78 (heart centre), so the internal consistency is modest.
- 2017 · Desmarais, M. · *Perceptions of nursing advisors and advanced practice nursing advisors regarding the quality, relevance and impacts of Enneagram training on nursing competencies [Perceptions des conseillères en soins infirmiers ... d'une formation à l'Ennéagramme sur les compétences infirmières]* · Université de Montréal (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · Canada · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.71781/6489
  Found: Explores nurse advisors' views of the quality, relevance and impact of Enneagram training on emotional intelligence and professional competencies; available abstract truncated before results.
- 2017 · Aycan, K. · *The relationship between the Nine Types Temperament Model and active music education practices [Dokuz Tip Mizaç Modeli ile Aktif Müzik Eğitimi Uygulamalarının İlişkisi]* · Gazi Üniversitesi Gazi Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.17152/gefad.337237
  Found: Explored links between pre-service music teachers' temperament types and preferred active music-education methods; very small sample.
- 2017 · Jeong, S. Y. [정소영] · *Analysis of Enneagram personality types of adolescents with hearing impairments [청소년기 청각장애학생의 에니어그램 성격 유형 분석]* · 특수교육재활과학연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3505955
  Found: Helper was the most common type and heart the most common centre; type distribution varied by degree of impairment, and type predicted learning style and leadership style.
- 2017 · 박선영; 김원경; 최하림 · *Differences in nursing professionalism, creative leadership and nursing career preference by Enneagram personality type among nursing students [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 간호대학생의 간호전문직관, 창의적 리더십, 간호진로분야 선호도의 차이]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4010025938653
  Found: No statistically significant difference in nursing professionalism across Enneagram types (F=0.08); the retrieved abstract is truncated, so results for creative leadership and career preference need checking in the full text.
- 2017 · 지해연 · *A study of picture-book reading experiences for self-reflection based on Enneagram psychodynamics [에니어그램심리역동에 따른 자아성찰을 위한 그림책 읽기 경험 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025697804
  Found: Participants reported better self-understanding, acceptance of others and self-reflection after reading picture books chosen by Enneagram type. Very small qualitative sample, no comparison group.
- 2017 · 최민애; 노혜린; 박경혜; 김택중 · *Quality of life and its predictors in medical students: focusing on Enneagram harmonic groups [의대생의 삶의 질 수준과 영향요인 - 에니어그램의 하모닉 그룹을 중심으로 -]* · 에니어그램연구 (Enneagram Research) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A311372
  Found: Type 9 was the most common type and 60% were in the Positive Outlook group. Quality of life did not differ by type, but its predictors differed by harmonic group: psychological, environmental and social domains for the Positive group, the psychological domain for the Competency group, and none for the Reactive group.
- 2017 · 윤혜란 · *A family counselling model using Enneagram psychodynamics [에니어그램심리역동을 활용한 가족상담모델연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025697828
  Found: A family in divorce crisis reconciled after 24 Enneagram-informed sessions that combined temperament dynamics, transactional analysis and communication work. Single uncontrolled case.
- 2017 · 박정임; 이영숙 · *Enneagram-based school-violence prevention role-play group counselling [에니어그램을 적용한 학교폭력 예방교육 역할극 집단상담 사례]* · 아동중심실천연구 (Korean Society of After-School Child Care), 14(2), 19-39 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A105311662
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2017 · 이정숙 · *Psychological and emotional characteristics of domestic-violence perpetrators by personality type: Korean Enneagram and MMPI-2 [가정폭력 행위자의 성격 유형별 특성에 따른 심리ㆍ정서적 현상에 관한 연구 - 한국형 에니어그램과 MMPI-2를 중심으로 -]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램학회), 14(2), 91-138 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A105064500
  Found: Abstract not retrieved (from Kunshin University doctoral dissertation, 2017); check the full text before citing.
- 2017 · 이은하 ( Lee Eun Ha ); 윤혜란 ( Yoon Hye Ran ) · *A trend analysis of Enneagram dynamic psychology research [에니어그램역동심리 연구에 관한 동향 분석]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램역동심리학회), 4(2), 1-18 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A106352238
  Found: Categorised 53 papers published by the Korean Enneagram Dynamic Psychology Society and suggested future directions.
- 2016 · Yilmaz, E. D.; Gencer, A. G.; Unal, O.; Palanci, M.; Kandemir, M.; Selcuk, Z.; Aydemir, O. · *Relation of the nine types of temperament model with personality disorders* · Dusunen Adam: The Journal of Psychiatry and Neurological Sciences, 29(1), 15-28 · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.5350/DAJPN2016290102
  Found: Every type correlated with at least one personality disorder in expected ways; personality disorders explained 19-41% of variance in type scores; scale alphas .68-.83.
- 2016 · Yilmaz, E. D.; Unal, O.; Palanci, M.; Gencer, A. G.; Orek, A.; Tatar, A.; Selcuk, Z.; Aydemir, O. · *The relation between the Nine Types Temperament Model and the Five Factor Personality Model in a Turkish sample group* · British Journal of Medicine and Medical Research, 11(4), 1-11 · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.9734/BJMMR/2016/20303
  Found: Every type correlated at r >= .40 with at least one Big Five factor, and the types predicted 34% or more of variance in Big Five dimensions.
- 2016 · Shin, E.-S.; Lee, S. · *The emotional intelligence, defense mechanism and interpersonal caring behavior by Enneagram personality types in nursing students* · Journal of Korean Academic Society of Nursing Education, 22(4), 514-526 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.5977/jkasne.2016.22.4.514
  Found: No significant differences between the nine types in emotional intelligence or defense mechanisms; types did differ on some caring behaviours (Type 1 highest, Type 5 lowest).
- 2016 · Kim, S. Y.; Ahn, S.-Y.; Koh, A.-R. · *Fashion consumers' purchase decision-making styles related to the Enneagram core values and self-construal levels* · Family and Environment Research (Human Ecology Research), 54(2), 207-225 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.6115/fer.2016.017
  Found: Decision-making styles at each of five purchase stages differed by Enneagram group, and Enneagram core values correlated with self-construal. Statistics not given in the abstract.
- 2016 · Lee, S. Y.; Shim, T. E. · *The analysis of the strength and the weakness for college students by personality: Focusing on Enneagram type 3·6·9* · Journal of the Korea Academia-Industrial Cooperation Society, 17(10), 357-366 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.5762/kais.2016.17.10.357
  Found: Self-reported strengths and weaknesses matched type descriptions. Type 3: goal-oriented and confident but image-conscious. Type 6: responsible and planful but worried and indecisive. Type 9: peaceable and considerate but lazy and conflict-avoidant.
- 2016 · Park, W. K. · *Study on the plants-preference pattern according to personality type (Enneagram) for the creating of healing garden: Focusing young generation* · Journal of the Korea Society of Environmental Restoration Technology, 19(6), 31-40 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.13087/kosert.2016.19.6.31
  Found: Tree, flower and colour preferences differed somewhat by centre (for example, the instinctive centre preferred yellow and the feeling and thinking centres red). Descriptive survey.
- 2016 · Han, S. W. · *A survey study of the adults' art media preferences associated with the Enneagram personality types* · Journal of the Korean Holistic Arts Therapy Association, 3(3), 23-43 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.22588/hatajat/2016.3.3.23
  Found: Preferred art media differed significantly by Enneagram type. Uneven group sizes across types limit the conclusions.
- 2016 · Khudhair, S. Y. [صنعاء يعقوب خضير] · *The exploratory and confirmatory factorial structure of the Riso-Hudson Enneagram Type Indicator* · Journal of Educational and Psychological Researches (University of Baghdad) · Result: Supportive · Iraq · not yet checked · https://jperc.uobaghdad.edu.iq/index.php/jperc/article/view/341
  Found: EFA retained 9 factors (184 of 288 items) explaining 66.3% of variance, each factor matching a type, followed by CFA of the model; supports a nine-factor structure in Arabic.
- 2016 · Sherrill, A. J. · *Enneagram and the way of Jesus: Integrating personality with biblical narratives, spiritual practices and the church calendar* · Fuller Theological Seminary (DMin project) · Result: Mixed · USA · not yet checked · https://digitalcommons.fuller.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1239&context=dmin
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2016 · Park, W. G. [박원규] · *Plant preferences by Enneagram personality type for creating healing gardens: Focusing on young adults [치유정원 조성을 위한 성격 유형별(Enneagram) 식물 선호도에 관한 연구]* · Korean journal (kstudy) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3490469
  Found: Tree and flower preferences differed somewhat by instinct, feeling and thinking centre (e.g., cherry and zelkova first overall); descriptive only.
- 2016 · Kim, J. S.; Jeong, M. S. [김정숙; 정명실] · *Self-esteem and interpersonal relationships by Enneagram personality type in nursing students [간호대학생의 에니어그램 성격 유형에 따른 자아존중감과 대인관계 연구]* · Korean journal (earticle) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A281980
  Found: Type 9 was most common (36.6%); self-esteem (F=3.64) and interpersonal relations (F=6.37) differed significantly by type.
- 2016 · Carreira, S. S.; Franzoni, A. M. B.; Carreira, M. F. · *Enneagram: A self-knowledge tool for people management - bibliometric research [Eneagrama: ferramenta de autoconhecimento para o processo de gestão de pessoas - pesquisa bibliométrica]* · Simpósio de Engenharia de Produção (SIMEPROD) · Result: Mixed · Brazil · not yet checked · http://www.dep.uem.br/gdct/index.php/simeprod/article/download/1007/1009
  Found: Found very few academic publications on the Enneagram in Scopus/Web of Science, concluding the field is still incipient.
- 2016 · Park, H. K.; Kwon, E. S. [박현경; 권은시] · *The relationship between Enneagram personality types and job stress in national psychiatric hospital nurses [국립정신병원 간호사들의 에니어그램 성격유형과 직무스트레스의 관계]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Journal of Enneagram Studies) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A303430
  Found: Gut centre (68%) and Type 9 (38%) predominated; 62% were in the disintegration direction, and developmental level varied significantly across some Enneagram groupings; small single-hospital sample.
- 2016 · Lee, S. R. [이사랑] · *The psychological meaning of repeated dieting experiences among restrained eaters: Focusing on Enneagram heart-centre types [섭식억제자의 다이어트 반복경험에 대한 심리적 의미]* · Korean journal (Kyobo scholar) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025697738
  Found: Identified 8 themes and 33 sub-themes linking repeated dieting to self-image dependent on others' reactions; small qualitative sample.
- 2016 · Lee, S. Y.; Shim, T. E. [이송이; 심태은] · *Analysis of strengths and weaknesses by personality type of university students: Focusing on Enneagram types 3, 6, 9 [대학생의 성격유형별 강점과 약점에 관한 분석]* · Journal of the Korea Academia-Industrial Cooperation Society · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://click.ndsl.kr/servlet/LinkingDetailView?cn=JAKO201608259726503&dbt=JAKO&org_code=O150&site_code=SS1009&service_code=01
  Found: Thematic analysis of students' perceived strengths and weaknesses for core types 3, 6 and 9; abstract truncated, no quantitative results.
- 2016 · Yoon, S. Y. [윤서연] · *Development of a paternal parenting behaviour scale based on Enneagram personality types [에니어그램 성격유형에 기반한 아버지 양육행동 척도 개발]* · Korean Association of Family Relations / 한국가정관리학회 conference proceedings · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.dbpia.co.kr/Article/NODE06748096
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2016 · Lee, S. J. [이수진] · *Conversation characteristics in play of mothers of young children by personality type: Focusing on Enneagram types 5, 6, 7 [유아기 어머니의 성격유형에 따른 놀이에서의 대화 특징]* · 21세기사회복지연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://digital.kyobobook.co.kr/digital/article/articleDetail.ink?barcode=4050026417562
  Found: Type 5 mothers used more factual explanation, Type 6 more checking questions and anxiety expressions, Type 7 more acceptance and excitement; descriptive, sample not stated.
- 2016 · Choi, H. A. [최현아] · *A qualitative narrative inquiry into play-therapeutic parenting experiences of a Type 2 mother of a child with developmental delay [발달지연 자녀를 둔 어머니의 놀이치료적 양육경험에 관한 질적 내러티브 탐구]* · Korean journal (Kyobo scholar) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025697648
  Found: Traces a Type 2 mother's shift from anxiety and self-blame to a more positive view of her child across 60 play-therapy sessions; single case.
- 2016 · Lee, S. Y. [이순영] · *A narrative inquiry report by Enneagram temperament: Gut-centre types 1, 8, 9 [에니어그램 기질별 내러티브 탐구 보고서]* · Korean journal (newnonmun) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=10758123
  Found: Identified core narrative themes for gut-centre types from workshop reports; no reliability data.
- 2016 · Kwon, E. S.; Park, E. J. [권은실; 박은준] · *Effects of job stress on psychological stress and coping among beauty-industry workers in the Enneagram thinking (head) centre [에니어그램 사고(머리)중심 유형에 따른 미용종사자의 직무 스트레스]* · 한국미용학회지 (Journal of the Korean Society of Cosmetology) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://dspace.kci.go.kr/handle/kci/1236896
  Found: Among head-centre workers, unmet work expectations and excessive workload partly predicted chronic fatigue and emotion-focused coping; Enneagram used only to define the subgroup.
- 2016 · Sempels, J. · *Enneagram, vocational interests and career adaptability: links between the HPEI, the IRMR and the CAAS-French [Ennéagramme, intérêts professionnels et adaptabilité de carrière]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Mixed · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/21141
  Found: Analyses links between Enneagram type, vocational interests and career adaptability; results not stated in the abstract – check full text.
- 2016 · Al-Dafaai, R. R.; Diab, B. S.; Abd Al-Ghani, H. J. · *Personality types in relation to periodontal health status and salivary dehydroepiandrosterone among teachers in Baghdad city* · Journal of Baghdad College of Dentistry, 28(4) · Result: Mixed · Iraq · https://doi.org/10.12816/0033226
  Found: Individualist (Type 4) scores differed between healthy periodontium and calculus codes; no correlations between DHEA and type scores. Same sample as the 2019 caries paper.
- 2016 · 장효주 · *Effects of Enneagram personality type on self-efficacy and job satisfaction of beauty-industry workers [미용종사자의 성격유형에 따른 자기효능감 및 직무만족에 미치는 영향]* · Tongmyong University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T14040331
  Found: Type 9 was most common; self-efficacy and job satisfaction were reported highest among type 8; descriptive group comparisons.
- 2016 · 한미애 · *Effects of the TREASURE Talk coaching model on mothers of young children by Enneagram type [에니어그램 성격유형별 유아기 어머니에 대한 TREASURE Talk 코칭모델의 적용효과]* · Sookmyung Women's University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T13984505
  Found: Analysed type-specific changes in conversation patterns after coaching training, with expert validation of coding; no control group.
- 2016 · 강승구 · *Work-family conflict, job satisfaction and the moderating role of resilience: Comparison by Enneagram type and occupation [가정·직장갈등이 직무만족에 미치는 영향과 회복탄력성의 조절효과에서 에니어그램 성격유형과 직업군별 비교]* · Seoul Venture University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T14001910
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract – check full text.
- 2016 · 최민애 · *Differences in quality of life by Enneagram type among medical students [의학과 학생들의 에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 삶의 질 차이]* · 인제대학교 일반대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Critical · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T14220378
  Found: No differences in quality of life across types in ANOVA; domain predictors of overall QoL varied by harmonic group.
- 2016 · 김세련 · *Drivers' unsafe acts and Enneagram personality types [운전자의 불안전 행동과 에니어그램 성격유형과의 상호관계에 관한 연구]* · 연세대학교 공학대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T14004318
  Found: Gut-centre types 8 and 9 reported more unsafe acts; author suggests type-informed driver selection and safety training (selection use is not supported by predictive data).
- 2016 · 문유란 · *Ego-resilience of early-childhood teachers by Enneagram type [에니어그램 성격유형별 유아교사의 ‘자아탄력성’에 관한연구]* · 인천대학교 교육대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T14196139
  Found: Gut (41.6%) and head (40.8%) centres predominated; type 6 (23.5%) and type 1 (21.4%) most common; resilience compared across types.
- 2015 · Youn, Y.-S. · *The development of Korean Enneagram Simple Personality Type Indicator (KESPTI)* · Journal of Enneagram Studies (Korea), 12(1), 53-78 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A249777
  Found: 2-week test-retest reliability r=.84; validity evidence limited to face validity and type-scale correlations.
- 2015 · Enstedt, D. · *Sleepwalkers and higher selves: The mediatisation of personality and essence in online Enneagram teachings* · Annual Review of the Sociology of Religion, Vol. 6 (Brill), 48-65 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004302549_005
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2015 · Lee, M.-R. · *A study on the effects of Enneagram group counseling on nursing students* · International Journal of Bio-Science and Bio-Technology, 7(5), 235-246 · Result: Supportive · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.14257/ijbsbt.2015.7.5.22
  Found: Self-consciousness, communication competence and interpersonal relationship scores were significantly higher in the counselling group than in controls. Very small sample. (A shorter conference version of the same study appeared in Advanced Science and Technology Letters, 2015.)
- 2015 · Choi, Y.-T.; Yang, H.-S.; Lee, H.-I.; Lim, K.-O. · *Study on college students' department selection factors in relation to promotion of edutainment: Focusing on personal attributes, Enneagram of personality types, and career decision levels* · The Journal of the Korea Entertainment Industry Association, 9(3), 241- · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.21184/jkeia.2015.09.9.3.241
  Found: Enneagram type was a small but significant predictor of department choice (β=.122, p=.037), well behind gender (β=.566). Type 2 was the most common type.
- 2015 · Carpenter, D. G. · *Resonating personality types for couples: An Enneagram application for predicting marital satisfaction* · Walden University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Critical · USA · https://scholarworks.waldenu.edu/dissertations/1597
  Found: Attachment security predicted marital satisfaction, but couples' Enneagram type combinations showed no significant differences in satisfaction and no type x attachment interaction, contrary to the complementary-types hypothesis.
- 2015 · Ring, K. A. · *The Enneagram and the SCARF model: A study of two complementary psychological models* · Kalamazoo College (senior thesis) · Result: Mixed · USA · not yet checked · https://cache.kzoo.edu/handle/10920/29699
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2015 · Araghi, L.; Jafari, A.; Fathi Aghdam, G. · *The study of the relation of positive and negative emotions and self-control with personality types in terms of Enneagram model* · European Online Journal of Natural and Social Sciences: Proceedings · Result: Mixed · Iran · not yet checked · http://european-science.com/eojnss_proc/article/view/4624/2282
  Found: Several types (e.g., Reformer, Helper, Challenger, Peacemaker) and the instinctive and feeling triads correlated negatively with self-control, while some head-centre types correlated positively; single-site self-report sample.
- 2015 · Jung, C. H. [정희정] · *A study on the development and validation of the Observation Inventory of the Preschool Children Enneagram Personality for parents counseling [부모상담을 위한 유아성격검사의 개발과 타당화]* · Korean journal (KCI-listed) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.kci.go.kr/kciportal/ci/sereArticleSearch/ciSereArtiView.kci?sereArticleSearchBean.artiId=ART002053400
  Found: Developed a parent/teacher-rated 9-factor observation scale of preschool children's Enneagram type focused on positive traits and reports reliability and validity checks; abstract gives no statistics.
- 2015 · Son, B. H. [손봉희] · *Analysis of self-portraits of Enneagram types 2, 3 and 4 [에니어그램 2, 3, 4번 성격유형의 자화상 분석]* · Korean journal (earticle) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A251643
  Found: Self-portraits of feeling-triad types were described as positive and expressive with type-specific details; descriptive, unquantified design.
- 2015 · Lee, M. R.; Jeon, H. S. · *Personal types, ego-resilience, and college adaptation in nursing and health care related students* · Journal of the Korea Academia-Industrial Cooperation Society, 16(12), 8861 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.5762/kais.2015.16.12.8861
  Found: Ego-resilience and college adaptation differed significantly by Enneagram type, lowest in types 4 and 5; adaptation was predicted mainly by optimism, confidence, emotion regulation and grades (61.6% variance).
- 2015 · Choi, Y. T.; Yang, H. S.; Lee, H. I.; Lim, K. O. · *Analysis of university students' major selection factors for edutainment: Focusing on personal characteristics, Enneagram and career decision level [에듀테인먼트 활성화를 위한 대학생의 학과 선택요인 분석]* · Korean journal (DBpia/KCI) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://dspace.kci.go.kr/handle/kci/673616
  Found: Choice of major was associated most with gender, then Enneagram type, then career decision level; Type 2 was most common. Cross-sectional self-report.
- 2015 · Kwon, E. S.; Kim, W. B.; Park, E. J. [권은실] · *Effects of job stress on psychological stress and coping among beauty-industry workers in the Enneagram feeling (heart) centre [에니어그램 성격유형 중 가슴중심에 따른 미용종사자의 직무 스트레스]* · 한국미용학회지 (Journal of the Korean Society of Cosmetology) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3317434
  Found: Among heart-centre workers, job-stress dimensions (especially unmet work expectations) partly predicted chronic fatigue and coping strategies; Enneagram used only to select the subgroup.
- 2015 · Kim, K. Y. [김기열] · *Comparison of invention self-efficacy between gifted-in-invention and general middle school students by Enneagram [에니어그램에 따른 중학교 발명영재학생과 일반학생의 발명 자기효능감 비교]* · 한국실과교육학회지 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://digital.kyobobook.co.kr/digital/article/articleDetail.ink?barcode=4010025065757
  Found: Invention-gifted students were most often Type 4 and general students Type 6; reported type-efficacy correlations of about .90 are implausibly high and should be read with caution.
- 2015 · Lee, E. H.; Kim, Y. R. [이은하; 김영란] · *A qualitative study of Enneagram dynamic psychological phenomena in gut-centre types 8, 9, 1 [에니어그램역동심리현상에 관한 배중심 유형별 질적연구]* · Korean journal (newnonmun) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=193868
  Found: Keyword analysis of workshop self-reports was used to redefine gut-centre dynamics; typing and coding by workshop experts, no reliability statistics.
- 2015 · Lee, E. H.; Jeon, W. M. [이은하; 전원미] · *A qualitative study of Enneagram dynamic psychological phenomena in heart-centre types 2, 3, 4 [에니어그램역동심리현상에 의한 가슴중심 유형별 질적연구]* · Korean journal (newnonmun) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=193867
  Found: Keyword analysis of workshop self-reports was used to redefine heart-centre dynamics; no reliability statistics reported.
- 2015 · Lee, E. H.; Moon, Y. S. [이은하; 문연선] · *A qualitative study of Enneagram dynamic psychological phenomena in head-centre types 5, 6, 7 [에니어그램역동심리현상에 의한 머리중심 유형별 질적연구]* · Korean journal (kstudy) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3697532
  Found: Keyword analysis of workshop self-reports was used to redefine head-centre dynamics; no reliability statistics reported.
- 2015 · Nickname, M.; Ilkhanizadeh, S. · *The correlation between the Enneagram personality types and the rate of sensation seeking* ·  · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/1b0f23a79bfe136186ab7e0a650b17b8a9d376c5
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2015 · 김혜경 · *An exploratory study of early-childhood teachers' turnover intention by Enneagram personality type [에니어그램 성격유형별 유아교사의 이직의도 탐색연구]* · Sookmyung Women's University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T13844137
  Found: Developed type-specific descriptions of the psychological, emotional and behavioural meaning of turnover intention; exploratory, no quantitative validation reported.
- 2015 · 주연진 · *Job satisfaction and turnover intention by Enneagram type among emergency-room nurses [응급실 간호사의 에니어그램 유형에 따른 직무만족과 이직의도]* · Kongju National University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T13664613
  Found: Compares job satisfaction and turnover intention across types; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2015 · Yamashita, K.; Futami, H.; Akechi, H.; Konosu, T. · *A study on the influence of leaders' personality type on decision making in small-group sessions [小規模セッションにおけるリーダの性格特性が集団意思決定に及ぼす影響]* · 人間工学 (Japanese Journal of Ergonomics), 51(Suppl.), S228-S229 · Result: Mixed · Japan · https://doi.org/10.5100/jje.51.S228
  Found: Type-1 leaders produced significantly more task-related utterances than leaders of types 2, 4, 6 and 9, suggesting facilitation style varies by leader type; conference abstract, student sample.
- 2015 · 傅周賞 (Fu, Chou-Shang) · *Relationship between Enneagram personality traits and investment-bias behaviour [九型人格特質與理財偏誤行為之相關性研究]* · National Central University, Department of Finance (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · Taiwan · https://www.airitilibrary.com/Article/Detail/U0031-0412201512052201
  Found: Different Enneagram types showed different patterns of behavioural investment biases; suggests banks could tailor advice by type. Effect sizes not reported in abstract.
- 2015 · 고재순; 도미향 · *Exploring childcare teachers' stress by Enneagram type [에니어그램 성격유형별 보육교사의 스트레스 탐색]* · 코칭연구 (한국코칭학회), 8(1), 41-58 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A100543593
  Found: Head-centre teachers sought praise/encouragement, heart-centre recognition for outcomes, gut-centre recognition of rights and conflict avoidance.
- 2014 · Yilmaz, E. D.; Gencer, A. G.; Aydemir, O.; Yilmaz, A.; Kesebir, S.; Unal, O.; Orek, A.; Bilici, M. · *Validity and reliability of Nine Types Temperament Scale* · Education and Science (Egitim ve Bilim), 39(171) · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://educationandscience.ted.org.tr/article/download/1222/1207
  Found: EFA gave nine factors explaining 39% of variance; CFA fit was borderline (CFI .88, RMSEA .05); alphas .68-.83; 2-week test-retest .65-.93.
- 2014 · 野口 千里 · *エニアグラムに関する研究: 尺度の信頼性と妥当性の検討* · Otemon Gakuin University, Graduate School of Psychology (master's thesis summary) · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · http://www.i-repository.net/il/meta_pub/G0000145OTEMON_403140324
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2014 · Vaida, M.-F.; Pop, P. G. · *Grouping strategy using Enneagram typologies* · 2014 IEEE International Conference on Automation, Quality and Testing, Robotics (AQTR), 1-6 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1109/aqtr.2014.6857844
  Found: Groups built on Enneagram compatibility reportedly showed more communication and better practical results. The abstract reports no statistics.
- 2014 · Lee, J.-H. · *A descriptive research of the defense mechanisms of nursery teachers according to Enneagram personality types* · Korean Journal of Family Welfare, 19(2), 255-278 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.13049/kfwa.2014.19.2.255
  Found: Reported a relationship between Enneagram type and defence mechanisms. The most typical mechanisms were suppression, humour, altruism and anticipation.
- 2014 · Kim, H.-H.; Jang, Y.-R. · *The influence of Enneagram personality styles on information seeking behaviors of undergraduate students of humanities and social sciences studies* · Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science, 48(3), 237-264 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.4275/kslis.2014.48.3.237
  Found: Personality type affected most information-seeking behaviours. However, the three types within each centre did not behave consistently alike, which weakens the centre groupings.
- 2014 · Park, J. W.; Ha, N. S. · *Communication apprehension and performance of using communication skills according to nursing students' Enneagram personality types* · Korean Journal of Stress Research, 22(4), 169-180 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.17547/kjsr.2014.22.4.169
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2014 · Kim, J.-Y.; Kim, S.-G. · *A study on parenting strength by the Enneagram personality type of preschoolers' mothers* · Korean Journal of Family Welfare, 19(3), 573-598 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.13049/kfwa.2014.19.3.573
  Found: Mothers drew on type-specific strengths in parenting, especially when helping children form habits. Qualitative study.
- 2014 · 허진; Kim, S. · *A study on the French learning strategies models of FFL undergraduates by their Enneagram personality types* · Language & Information Society, 22, 107-138 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.29211/soli.2014.22..005
  Found: Groups of types 2 and 7 worked well in collective learning while groups of types 4, 5 and 9 struggled; types 4 and 5 did well in individual learning. Descriptive, and the abstract gives no sample size.
- 2014 · Wong, S. W.; Leung, M.-T. · *Enneagram and parenting as antecedent on achievement goals and self-regulated learning* · Australian Association for Research in Education (AARE) conference · Result: Mixed · Hong Kong · http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED596785.pdf
  Found: Enneagram triads (thinking, feeling, doing) and parenting style predicted academic and social achievement goals, which in turn predicted self-regulated learning; triads related more to social than academic goals. Convenience sample, self-constructed survey.
- 2014 · Albert, J. L. · *First-generation female higher education student affairs personnel: The significance of personality and spirituality* · Doctoral dissertation, ProQuest LLC · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED566002
  Found: Identified a relationship between Enneagram Type Two (Helper) and choosing to work in student affairs. Very small, single-institution sample.
- 2014 · Andre, S. · *Reliability and validation study of the online Instinctual Variant Questionnaire* · Doctoral dissertation, ProQuest LLC · Result: Supportive · country not stated · https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED557642
  Found: IVQ subscales had alphas of 0.82-0.85 and significantly predicted self-reported dominant instinctual variant (all models p<0.001), beating chance classification; age, gender and Enneagram experience did not affect results. Criterion was self-report.
- 2014 · Woldeeyesus, B. M. · *The Enneagram: predicting consistent condom use among female sex workers* · University of South Africa · Result: Mixed · Ethiopia · http://hdl.handle.net/10500/19634
  Found: Tested Enneagram type as a predictor of consistent condom use with HIV-prevention goals. Results are not stated in the retrieved abstract excerpt.
- 2014 · Nettmann, R. W. · *Moving towards, against and away from people: the relationship between Karen Horney's interpersonal trends and the Enneagram* · University of South Africa · Result: Mixed · South Africa · http://hdl.handle.net/10500/13338
  Found: Enneagram types differed on compliance, aggression and detachment and on object-relations dimensions, and each trend had a marker type. The results did not clearly favour one theoretical grouping of types over another.
- 2014 · Wang, N.-C. · *Big Five personality and Enneagram on job performance, organizational citizenship behavior, and job satisfaction [五大與九型人格對工作績效、組織公民行為及工作滿意度的影響]* · National Central University (Taiwan), MBA in-service programme · Result: Critical · Taiwan · https://ir.lib.ncu.edu.tw/handle/987654321/65163
  Found: Neither the Big Five nor the Enneagram predicted job performance. The Achiever type predicted OCB and job satisfaction, and the Peacemaker type predicted satisfaction. Overall the Big Five outperformed the Enneagram, and the author recommends it for hiring.
- 2014 · Park, J.; Ha, N. · *Communication apprehension and performance of communication skills by Enneagram personality types in nursing students [간호대학생의 에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 의사소통 불안과 의사소통 기술 수행]* ·  · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.dbpia.co.kr/Journal/articleDetail?nodeId=NODE06071115
  Found: Type 9 was most common. Communication apprehension and communication-skill performance differed significantly by type. Self-report, cross-sectional data.
- 2014 · Kim, J.; Kim, S.-G. · *Parenting strengths of mothers of preschoolers by Enneagram personality type [유아기 어머니의 에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 양육강점에 관한 연구]* · 한국가족복지학 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://dspace.kci.go.kr/handle/kci/1277117?show=full
  Found: Mothers drew on parenting strengths that matched the characteristics of their type, especially when building children's habits. Qualitative study.
- 2014 · Heo, S.; Yoon, C. · *Correlation between behaviour patterns by Enneagram type and Sasang constitution [에니어그램 유형에 따른 행동방식과 사상체질의 상관관계 연구]* · 뷰티산업연구 (Journal of Beauty Industry) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4010025128193
  Found: Abstract only partly retrieved (correlation design described, results not shown); check the full text before citing.
- 2014 · Kim, S.; Heo, J. · *French learning-strategy models by Enneagram type among introductory college French students [대학 교양프랑스어 수강생들의 에니어그램 성격 유형에 따른 프랑스어 학습전략모델 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3261539
  Found: The authors suggest an ideal learning group could pair Types 2 and 7. Exploratory, small classroom study.
- 2014 · Lee, H.; Kim, H. · *A phenomenological study of 'ambivalence' in Enneagram Type 6 [에니어그램 6번 유형의 '양가감정'에 관한 현상학적 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A228852
  Found: Five categories emerged, including 'having two opposite minds' and 'balancing within the opposite extremities'. Small qualitative sample.
- 2014 · Mo, A.-R.; Lee, S.-H. · *An analysis of the characteristics of the leadership of middle managers at early childhood education institutions using the Enneagram personality types [에니어그램 성격유형을 활용한 유아교육기관 중간관리자의 리더십 특성 분석]* · Journal of Child Welfare and Development · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://digital.kyobobook.co.kr/digital/article/articleDetail.ink?barcode=4010026991767
  Found: Leadership characteristics differed by type: for example, Type 5 showed sincerity and challenge, Type 8 responsibility, and Type 9 modesty and consideration.
- 2014 · Kim, H. · *Health-promoting behaviours of nursing students by Enneagram type [간호대학생의 에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 건강증진행위]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article.aspx?sn=229731
  Found: Type 9 was most common. Dietary-guideline scores and moderate activity differed by type (highest in Type 8), and alcohol intake was highest in Type 7.
- 2014 · Bae, K.; Park, Y. · *Learning styles by Enneagram personality type [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 학습스타일 분석]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A240362
  Found: Learning-perception style differed significantly by centre (χ²=10.42, p=.005), and 47% of students were gut types.
- 2014 · Lee, E. · *Adolescent personality patterns using the Enneagram adolescent personality test [에니어그램 청소년용 성격검사를 활용한 청소년인성 패턴사례에 관한 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=67520
  Found: Defined dominant patterns per type from adolescent test profiles and developed a preventive counselling guide. Descriptive.
- 2014 · Lee, E. · *Children's personality patterns using the Enneagram children's test [에니어그램 아동용 성격검사를 활용한 아동인성 패턴사례에 관한 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=67521
  Found: Defined nine personality patterns from children's test profiles for use in child counselling. Descriptive.
- 2014 · Lee, E. · *Adult personality patterns using the Enneagram adult personality test [에니어그램 성인용 성격검사를 활용한 성인인성 패턴에 관한 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025697444
  Found: Examined patterns of temperamental versus social personality by type in adult test profiles. Descriptive.
- 2014 · Jeon, W. · *An exploratory study of human-figure-drawing characteristics of Enneagram Types 2, 5 and 8 [에니어그램 2, 5, 8유형의 인물화 특성에 대한 탐색적 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025697378
  Found: Explored whether type-typical features appear in human-figure drawings, so that they are not misread as pathology. Exploratory.
- 2014 · Kim, H.; Jang, Y. · *Effects of Enneagram personality types on the information-seeking behaviour of humanities and social-science students [에니어그램 성격 유형이 인문사회과학 대학생들의 정보추구행태에 미치는 영향 연구]* · Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://scholar.ndsl.kr/schDetail.do?cn=JAKO201431057370275
  Found: Personality affected most information-seeking behaviours, but the three types within each centre did not behave consistently alike, which questions the centre grouping.
- 2014 · Park, D.; Park, S. · *Anger experience, anger expression and interpersonal relationships of high school students by Enneagram type [고등학생의 에니어그램 성격 유형에 따른 분노 경험, 분노 표현 및 대인관계]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.dbpia.co.kr/journal/articleDetail?nodeId=NODE06602248
  Found: Gut types were most common (38.6%), and Type 9 was the most common type (31.5%). Gut types had the highest anger-out scores (M=18.11). Cross-sectional self-report.
- 2014 · Kwon, E.; Park, J.; Kim, D.; Park, E. J. · *Differences in stress level and coping style of beauty-industry workers by Enneagram characteristics [에니어그램 특성에 따른 미용종사자의 스트레스 수준과 대처방식의 차이]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://dspace.kci.go.kr/handle/kci/1235532?show=full
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2014 · Lee, E. · *Developing work-preference factors with the Enneagram and their use in work coaching [에니어그램을 활용한 업무선호요인개발 및 업무코칭에의 활용]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=67522
  Found: Defines four work-preference elements (work type, preferred work, work method, work conflict) and nine type-specific variants for work coaching. Little or no empirical testing in the abstract.
- 2014 · Choi, Y.; Park, S. Y. · *Factors influencing college freshmen's stress-coping styles: Enneagram type and self-efficacy [대학 신입생의 스트레스 대처방식에 미치는 영향력요인에 관한 연구]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A229732
  Found: Centre type, self-efficacy, department and gender partly influenced stress-coping style; region of origin did not.
- 2014 · Alves, A. D. · *Seeking oneself: Enneagram and self-knowledge [Buscar-se a si mesmo: eneagrama e autoconhecimento]* · Universidade do Estado do Rio Grande do Norte, MA in Social and Human Sciences · Result: Mixed · Brazil · https://sucupira.capes.gov.br/sucupira/public/consultas/coleta/trabalhoConclusao/viewTrabalhoConclusao.jsf?popup=true&id_trabalho=656290
  Found: Participants described a strong link between Enneagram-based self-knowledge and personal change. Qualitative, single-provider study with no outcome measures.
- 2014 · Salazar Sánchez, M. J. · *Ethical prohibitions and personality types in public servants of the Pillco Marca District Municipality, Huánuco 2014 [Prohibiciones éticas y tipos de personalidad en servidores públicos de la Municipalidad Distrital de Pillco Marca]* · Universidad César Vallejo (Master's in Public Management) · Result: Mixed · Peru · https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12692/4482
  Found: Reported a significant link between type and ethical breaches, with Types 7, 3 and 8 linked to specific violations. Convenience sample and strong causal language not supported by the design.
- 2014 · 조훈정 · *Differences in job stress and coping by Enneagram type among school health teachers [보건교사의 에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 직무스트레스 및 대처방식의 차이]* · Inje University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T13545009
  Found: Compares job stress and coping across types; detailed results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2014 · 이지명 · *Enneagram-centred group art therapy and parenting stress of mothers of kindergarten children [에니어그램 중심 집단 미술치료]* · 대한안전경영과학회 학술대회논문집, 2014, 331-338 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A102652139
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2013 · Sutton, A.; Allinson, C.; Williams, H. · *Personality type and work-related outcomes: An exploratory application of the Enneagram model* · European Management Journal, 31(3), 234-249 · Result: Supportive · UK · https://doi.org/10.1016/j.emj.2012.12.004
  Found: Each type showed a distinct pattern of traits, values and motives; Enneagram type predicted work attitudes about as well as values and motives, and in one case better than the Big Five.
- 2013 · 이성룡 · *An analysis of team performance based on member formation: Approached by the three triads of Enneagram* · Journal of Engineering Education Research, 16(1), 75-83 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.18108/jeer.2013.16.1.75
  Found: Team project performance varied with the mix of head, heart and gut types in the team. The English abstract does not report the effect sizes.
- 2013 · Ko, J. A.; Lee, S. H. · *An analysis of the supervision styles of supervisors in social welfare centers according to the Enneagram personality types* · Korean Journal of Family Welfare, 18(4), 539-556 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.13049/kfwa.2013.18.4.539
  Found: Heart-centre supervisors showed supportive styles, head-centre supervisors educational styles and body-centre supervisors administrative styles. Qualitative study with a small sample.
- 2013 · 서유리 · *Differences of awareness & preference for colors based on character types of Enneagram: For first & second year high school students* · Journal of Korea Society of Color Studies, 27(2), 95-108 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.17289/jkscs.27.2.201305.95
  Found: Thinking- and instinctive-centre students preferred green and feeling-centre students preferred red. Colour recognition and preference differed by type. Descriptive survey.
- 2013 · Dimond, A. M. · *Because minds can't sit in classrooms without bodies: making use of the Enneagram as a tool for embodied education* · Creighton University · Result: Mixed · USA · https://dspace2.creighton.edu/xmlui/handle/10504/45367
  Found: Qualitative case studies suggest that using the Enneagram for self-reflection helped students see themselves as active participants in learning. No quantitative outcomes.
- 2013 · Park, C.; Ko, Y.; Kim, S.; Lee, M.; Heo, S.; Cho, K. · *Psychological characteristics of alcohol-dependent patients using the Enneagram [에니어그램을 활용한 알코올 의존자의 심리적 특성]* · 중독정신의학 (Journal of Korean Academy of Addiction Psychiatry) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://digital.kyobobook.co.kr/digital/article/articleDetail.ink?barcode=4010025918161
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2013 · Park, J. W.; Choi, J. K. · *Clinical practicum experiences of nursing students in psychiatric settings by personality types of Enneagram [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 간호학생의 정신간호학 실습 경험]* · Korean Journal of Stress Research · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://kmbase.medric.or.kr/Main.aspx?menu=01&d=KMBASE&m=VIEW&i=0389420130210030213
  Found: Main themes were emotions in patient relationships, the wish to be therapeutic, and task pressure. Practicum experiences differed by Enneagram centre.
- 2013 · Vieira, J. M. F. S. · *Coaching with the Enneagram: leading to grow [Coaching com eneagrama: Liderar para crescer]* · ISCTE – University Institute of Lisbon · Result: Mixed · Portugal · http://hdl.handle.net/10071/10203
  Found: Assessed the Enneagram as a method in executive coaching for managers to raise emotional intelligence and leadership effectiveness. The retrieved abstract does not give outcome figures.
- 2013 · Ahn, H.-J.; Jun, I.-O. · *A study on the relationship between emotional clarity and cognitive emotion regulation by Enneagram personality types of a child [아동의 에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 정서인식명확성과 인지적 정서조절과의 관계]* · The Journal of Play Therapy (놀이치료연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://kmbase.medric.or.kr/Main.aspx?menu=01&d=KMBASE&m=VIEW&i=1022520130170020017
  Found: Emotional clarity correlated positively with most types (5, 7, 2, 3, 4, 8, 1) but not Types 6 and 9. Use of adaptive and maladaptive emotion-regulation strategies differed by type.
- 2013 · Ko, J.; Lee, S. · *Supervision characteristics of social welfare middle managers by Enneagram personality type [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 사회복지기관 중간관리자의 슈퍼비전 특성 분석]* · 한국가족복지학 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://dspace.kci.go.kr/handle/kci/1277114
  Found: Supervisor styles (supportive, educational, administrative) and sub-styles such as helper, facilitator and reflector mapped onto Enneagram centres and types.
- 2013 · Seo, Y. · *Differences in colour perception and preference by Enneagram type among 1st–2nd year high school students [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 색채인지도 및 선호도 차이]* · 한국색채학회논문집 (Journal of Korea Society of Color Studies) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://dspace.kci.go.kr/handle/kci/1156434
  Found: Students recognised the five traditional Korean colours well and preferred red, yellow and white. Type differences in colour perception and preference are not detailed in the retrieved abstract.
- 2013 · Yoon, U.; Jin, J.; Kim, S. · *Development and validation of the Korean Enneagram Personality Subtype Test [한국형에니어그램성격하위유형검사 개발 및 타당화]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A210278
  Found: 243 candidate items were reduced to 81 and then to a final 27-item subtype test, judged consistent with prior studies. Small validation samples.
- 2013 · He, H.; Wu, J.; Gao, J.; Li, M.; Zhou, L. · *Application of the Enneagram in psychological nursing of patients undergoing vitrectomy with gas or silicone-oil tamponade [九型人格在玻璃体切割联合气体或硅油填充术病人心理护理中的应用]* ·  · Result: Mixed · China · not yet checked · https://doaj.org/article/86b762e5ae624b42b7d685f6b72b11bb
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2013 · Cristellotti, M.; Cosenza, C.; Martins, G. · *Construction of an objective personality test based on the Enneagram of Claudio Naranjo: A fuzzy approach [Construção de um Teste Objetivo de Personalidade Baseado no Eneagrama de Claudio Naranjo: uma abordagem Fuzzy]* ·  · Result: Mixed · Brazil · not yet checked · https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/865cf289c1f189edb566be4850b536b327fcbc8c
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2013 · 전수영 · *Development of a clothing consumption attitude scale using personality typology: An Enneagram approach (CCATIE) [성격 유형론을 활용한 의류소비태도 척도의 개발]* · Yonsei University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T13283788
  Found: Develops CCATIE, an integrated Enneagram/clothing-consumption scale, with clothing and Enneagram experts; abstract gives no psychometric figures – check full text.
- 2013 · 최연택; 하채수 · *Stress-coping by adolescent personality type and stressor: Korean Enneagram types [청소년의 성격유형에 따른 스트레스원별 스트레스대처방식에 관한 연구 : 한국형에니어그램 성격유형을 중심으로]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램학회), 10(1), 79-101 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A99909959
  Found: Stressors (friends, appearance) differed by type but coping styles did not; economic and grade problems best predicted coping.
- 2013 · 백정희 · *Middle-school students' Enneagram types, academic achievement and career maturity [중학생의 에니어그램 성격유형과 학업성취수준 및 진로의식간의 관계]* · 인제대학교 교육대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T13303853
  Found: Only type 3 (Achiever) scores were higher among high achievers; other types did not differ.
- 2012 · Wagner, J. P. · *A comparison of the nine Enneagram personality styles and Theodore Millon's eight personality patterns* · The Enneagram Journal, 5(1), 21-34 · Result: Supportive · USA · https://ieaninepoints.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2012-IEA-Journal_Jerome-Wagner.pdf
  Found: Each type's Millon profile was in the direction expected from theory (e.g. Type 2 highest on dependent pattern, Type 3 on narcissistic/self-assured), giving concurrent validity; some type subsamples were small (N=19-83).
- 2012 · Jung, Y.-M. · *Influences of Enneagram personality types on OPAC searching and satisfaction* · Journal of the Korean Society for Information Management, 29(3), 169-186 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.3743/kosim.2012.29.3.169
  Found: Groups based on Enneagram centres differed significantly on perceived search ease, search time, sufficiency of time, usefulness of results and ease of process. Hornevian groups differed on familiarity with, and interest in, the queries.
- 2012 · Kilianová, J. · *Enneagram: Development of a personality type test [Enneagram – Vývoj testové metody k určení osobnostního typu]* · Charles University (National Repository of Grey Literature) · Result: Supportive · Czech Republic · http://www.nusl.cz/ntk/nusl-305543
  Found: The new test was reliable, with good psychometric quality and acceptable criterion validity, and the data supported nine enneagram types. The retrieved abstract is cut off where it begins to qualify the construct-validity results.
- 2012 · Sayyed-Hosseinian, S.-H.; Azimipour, P.; Karami, A.; Yazdi, S. M.; Kesha, G. · *Study of the psychometrical features of Enneagram personality types* ·  · Result: Mixed · Iran · not yet checked · https://www.sid.ir/En/Journal/ViewPaper.aspx?ID=280890
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2012 · Lee, J. · *Job satisfaction by Enneagram personality type among Korean medicine clinic staff in Changwon [창원시 소재 한의원 종사자의 에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 직무만족도 연구]* · 동의생리병리학회지 (Journal of Physiology & Pathology in Korean Medicine) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.dbpia.co.kr/Journal/ArticleDetail/NODE02377829
  Found: 64.3% of staff were in the instinctive (gut) centre. The study compared job satisfaction across types to inform HR and training programmes; type differences are not detailed in the retrieved abstract.
- 2012 · Yip, L.-Y.; Leung, M.-T. · *The structural relationship between personality types, achievement goals, achievement emotions and self-regulated learning strategies of undergraduates in Hong Kong* · AARE Annual Conference 2012, Sydney · Result: Supportive · Hong Kong · https://www.aare.edu.au/data/publications/2012/Yip12.pdf
  Found: Enneagram types predicted achievement goals and emotions. 'Questioner' (Type 6) predicted more negative emotions, and 'Performer' (Type 3) predicted positive emotions and better learning strategies. Self-report, cross-sectional data.
- 2012 · Kim, M. S. · *A study on the relation of parents' ways of reading picture books and their Enneagram personality types [부모의 그림책 읽어주기 방법과 에니어그램 성격유형과의 관계연구]* · Korean Journal of Family Welfare (한국가족복지학) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3035258
  Found: Gut types tended to simplify or shorten the text, head types read it verbatim, and heart types added movement and touch. Parents read in ways that fit their type's characteristics. Descriptive survey.
- 2012 · Mo, A.-R.; Ahn, H.-J. · *A qualitative study on the job satisfaction by Enneagram personality types of child care teachers [에니어그램 성격유형별 보육교사의 직무만족에 관한 질적 연구]* · The Korean Journal of Child Education (아동교육) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://www.papersearch.net/google_link/fulltext.asp?file_name=12301102.pdf
  Found: Sources of job satisfaction differed by centre: head types valued children remembering lessons, heart types valued interaction and recognition, and gut types valued practical progress. Relationships with parents, directors and colleagues also differed by type.
- 2012 · Jung, Y. · *OPAC search tendencies and satisfaction by Enneagram personality type [에니어그램 성격 유형에 따른 OPAC 탐색 성향과 만족도]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.dbpia.co.kr/Journal/ArticleDetail/NODE01981800?q=%5B%EC%A0%95%EC%98%81%EB%AF%B8%C2%A7coldb%C2%A77%C2%A726%C2%A73%5D&Multimedia=0&SearchAuthor=%EC%A0%95%EC%98%81%EB%AF%B8&isFullText=0&specificParam=0&SearchMethod=0&Sort=1&SortType=desc
  Found: Centre-of-intelligence groups differed significantly in ease of searching, search time, usefulness of results and perceived ease; Hornevian groups differed in query familiarity and interest.
- 2012 · Park, J.; Shin, D. · *Self-efficacy of youth on probation through Enneagram group counselling [에니어그램 집단상담을 통한 보호관찰 청소년의 자기효능감에 관한 연구]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Journal of Enneagram Studies) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A192474
  Found: Participants reported more social support, psychological recovery and self-efficacy after Enneagram group counselling. Small, uncontrolled study.
- 2012 · Pyeon, I.; Yoon, C. · *Enneagram personality types and major-choice tendencies of beauty-department college students [에니어그램 성격유형과 뷰티학과 대학생의 전공 선택 성향과의 관계연구]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A192468
  Found: Choice of specialisation was significantly associated with centre (not gender): heart types leaned to make-up, head types to skin care, and gut types to hair.
- 2012 · Park, H.; Kwon, E. · *The Enneagram and mental health: types, levels of development, integration/disintegration and life satisfaction of chronic psychiatric patients [에니어그램과 정신건강 - 만성정신질환자의 ...]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A192476
  Found: The most common types were 2, 6, 9 and 5, and the mean development level was 5. Schizophrenia clustered in Type 6 and alcoholism in Type 2; Type 4 had the lowest life satisfaction. Small, descriptive study.
- 2012 · Ahn, H.-J.; Mo, A.-R. · *A study on the relationship between the child's perceived mother's overprotection and the child's problematic behaviors by the child's Enneagram personality type [아동의 에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 아동이 지각한 어머니의 과보호와 아동의 문제행동과의 관계]* · Korean Journal of Family Welfare (한국가족복지학) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3104418
  Found: Links between perceived overprotection and problem behaviour varied by type. For Type 4, overprotection related to depression/anxiety, withdrawal and aggression; for Type 1, overprotection explained 27.8% of depression/anxiety.
- 2012 · Kim, S.; Koh, A.-R. · *Underlying factors of clothing consumers' complaint behaviour: an Enneagram-based analysis [의류 소비자의 불평행동 기저요인]* · Korean Society of Consumer Studies Conference (한국소비자학회 학술대회) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.dbpia.co.kr/Article/2956136
  Found: Enneagram type helped explain complaint motives, complaint decision processes and face-saving communication with store managers. Qualitative and exploratory.
- 2012 · Bravo Celedón, I. M. · *Uses and potential of the Enneagram in the coaching process [Usos y potencialidades del eneagrama en el proceso de coaching]* · Universidad de Chile · Result: Mixed · Chile · not yet checked · http://repositorio.uchile.cl/bitstream/2250/106366/1/index_15118.html
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2012 · Choucroun, P. · *An exploratory study of the Enneagram typology in couple counseling: A qualitative analysis* ·  · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/f5cc8652f8971502a95769f52453b1cec79ff2d4
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2012 · 손영신 · *Interpersonal caring behaviour and job satisfaction by Enneagram type among nurses in small/medium hospitals [중소병원 간호사의 에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 대인돌봄행위와 직무만족도]* · Dankook University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12740415
  Found: Interpersonal caring behaviour differed by Enneagram type (notably head-centre and social instinct) and correlated positively with job satisfaction.
- 2012 · 유성수 · *Enneagram types, job stress, job satisfaction and organisational commitment of recreation workers [레크리에이션 종사자의 에니어그램 성격유형과 직무스트레스, 직무만족, 조직몰입의 관계]* · Kyonggi University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12719509
  Found: Examines relationships between nine types and seven job-stress factors, satisfaction and commitment; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2012 · 최인숙 · *Personality type and job satisfaction of female public officials using the Enneagram [여성공무원의 성격유형과 직무만족의 관계에 관한 연구]* · Kyungwon University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12793417
  Found: Situates the study in New Public Management reforms; results not in retrieved abstract – check full text.
- 2012 · 장수경 · *Job stress and coping by Enneagram type among school administrative staff [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 학교 행정직원의 직무스트레스 수준 및 대처방식의 차이]* · Changwon National University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12972034
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract – check full text.
- 2012 · 장세걸 · *Enneagram types of juvenile delinquents and characteristics of delinquency types [비행청소년의 에니어그램 유형과 비행유형의 특성]* · 전북대학교 행정대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Critical · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12926749
  Found: No meaningful correlation between Enneagram type and delinquency type; types 2 and 3 were over-represented relative to Korean norms.
- 2011 · Scott, S. A. · *An analysis of the validity of the Enneagram* · College of William & Mary (PhD) · Result: Supportive · USA · https://scholarworks.wm.edu/etd/1550154163/
  Found: After item refinement, a nine-factor solution matched the nine theorised types and replicated in the second half of the data; all subscale alphas above .70.
- 2011 · Stevens, K. L. · *Comparisons of Enneagram types and five-factor model traits of graduate psychology students* · The Chicago School of Professional Psychology · Result: Supportive · USA · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.23097
  Found: Reported significant, largely theory-consistent correlations between WEPSS scales and Big Five traits; one of the nine studies pooled by Hook et al. (2021).
- 2011 · Hur, Y.; Lee, K. H. · *Analysis of medical students' Enneagram personality types, stress, and developmental level* · Korean Journal of Medical Education, 23(3) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.3946/kjme.2011.23.3.175
  Found: 51.7% of students were in a 'disintegration' (stressed) state; Type 9 was most common (32.9%) and most stressed (73.5% disintegrated). Descriptive, no external criterion.
- 2011 · Kim, S.; 허진 · *Consideration of the academic accomplishment and the learning style of university students as general French language based by their Enneagram personality types* · Language & Information Society, 15, 183-223 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.29211/soli.2011.15..007
  Found: Types 3 and 1 had higher French achievement and types 7 and 8 lower grades. Type was not closely related to preferred learning style.
- 2011 · Kim, M.; Kim, H. · *The development of an Enneagram Personality Type Inventory for coaching young people [청소년 코칭을 위한 에니어그램 성격 유형 검사 개발]* · Journal of the Korea Safety Management and Science, 13(4), 263 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.12812/ksms.2011.13.4.263
  Found: Produced a 144-item inventory with Cronbach's alpha of .77-.86 across the nine types in 4,008 students; validity evidence is not described in the abstract.
- 2011 · Yoo, Y.; Park, K.; Choi, W. · *A study of the relationship between the Egogram and the Enneagram [이고그램(Egogram)과 에니어그램(Enneagram)의 관계연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=28382
  Found: Most types showed theoretically plausible correlations with Egogram ego states (e.g. Type 2 with nurturing parent, Type 7 with free child), but Type 8 showed none.
- 2011 · Cameron, C. · *Sorority women, presidential men, and the Enneagram: An analysis of personality and leadership* · University of Richmond, Jepson School of Leadership Studies (honors thesis) · Result: Mixed · USA · not yet checked · https://scholarship.richmond.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2288&context=honors-theses
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2011 · Jung, Y. · *Correlation between OPAC search tendency and satisfaction and Enneagram personality types [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 OPAC 검색 성향 및 만족도의 차이]* · Korean Society for Information Management conference proceedings (한국정보관리학회 학술대회 논문집) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.dbpia.co.kr/Article/NODE01673550
  Found: Examined differences in web OPAC search tendencies and satisfaction by type; the abstract gives no results.
- 2011 · Park, D. · *The type of anger and anger expression according to Enneagram personality types and their impact on interpersonal relationships* · Korean Academy of Nursing conference (한국간호과학회 학술대회) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.dbpia.co.kr/Article/NODE02334771
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2011 · Vaida, M.; Pop, F.; Cremene, M.; Alboaie, L. · *Creating optimal groups of students in e-learning using alternative methodologies* · Conference paper (ACTA Press) · Result: Mixed · Romania · https://doi.org/10.2316/p.2011.734-008
  Found: Groups formed with the method showed more communication among members in case studies; no controlled comparison is described.
- 2011 · Cardona Mazariegos, G. M.; Olla de León, C. A. · *The Enneagram and its application to administrative personnel selection at Dunbar International [El eneagrama y su aplicación a procesos de selección de personal a nivel administrativo en el Dunbar International]* · Universidad de San Carlos de Guatemala · Result: Supportive · Guatemala · http://www.repositorio.usac.edu.gt/11691/1/13%20T%282036%29.pdf
  Found: Concludes both the DISC and Enneagram tests are valid for describing personality in selection; based on a small purposive sample with no reported statistics.
- 2011 · Ji, M.; Kim, Y.; Lee, D. · *Leader competencies by Enneagram personality type [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 리더의 역량연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A163240
  Found: Preferences for leadership competencies differed significantly by type in all domains except principle-orientation and achievement passion.
- 2011 · Yoon, U.; Park, H.; Cho, J. · *Occupational preferences and work values by Enneagram personality type [에니어그램 성격유형별 직업선호 및 직업가치에 대한 연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A163246
  Found: Preferred occupations differed by type (e.g. Type 4 design/broadcasting, Type 7 finance/insurance, Type 8 management/planning), as did work values; the sample was Enneagram course participants.
- 2011 · Son, S.; Kim, N.; Choi, J. · *Differences in psychological well-being and peer relationships by Enneagram type [에니어그램 유형에 따른 심리적 안녕감과 또래관계의 차이]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A163247
  Found: Psychological well-being differed by type, but peer relationships did not differ meaningfully.
- 2011 · Kim, M.; Yoon, U. · *University students' stress, school-life disorder and coping by Enneagram type energy level [에니어그램 성격유형 에너지 수준에 따른 대학생들의 스트레스상황, 학교생활장애 및 대처방식에 관한 연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A163238
  Found: For Types 4, 5, 6, 8 and 9, higher energy levels were linked to more stress and school-life disorder; coping differences were significant for 7 of 9 types.
- 2011 · 임혜경 · *Effects of nurses' Enneagram-type characteristics on the hospital and nursing job through internal marketing [에니어그램을 이용한 간호사의 유형별 특성이 내부마케팅활동으로 병원과 간호사 직무에 미치는 영향]* · Kyung Hee University Graduate School of Business (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12509900
  Found: Compares job satisfaction, organisational commitment and burnout across types from an internal-marketing perspective; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2011 · 정미경 · *Job stress level and coping by Enneagram type among hospital employees [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 병원종사자의 직무스트레스 수준과 대처방식]* · Gyeongnam National University of Science and Technology (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12392316
  Found: Compares job stress and coping across types; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2011 · 曾雅芳 (Tseng, Ya-Fang) · *The study of Enneagram and work values: Post-80s generation as an example [九型人格與工作價值觀關聯性之研究－以80後世代為例]* · Chang Jung Christian University, Department of Business Administration (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · Taiwan · https://doi.org/10.6833/CJCU.2011.00012
  Found: Workers of different types differed in growth, respect and interpersonal work values; types 2, 7 and 9 were more common and 1, 3 and 8 less common than in earlier cohorts. Small qualitative sample.
- 2011 ·  · *Personality types of Damascus University students according to the Riso-Hudson scale (the Enneagram system) [أنماط الشخصية لدى طلبة جامعة دمشق وفق مقياس ريسو – هيدسن]* · University of Damascus (research paper) · Result: Mixed · Syria · not yet checked · https://shamra-academia.com/show/5729fc71033b6
  Found: Achiever type dominated in science and education faculties, followed by Loyalist; descriptive only.
- 2011 · 김희주; 박가영; 박지영; 송예빈; 심지현; 이수연; 이지영; 장주희; 정영민 · *Stress-coping behaviours by nursing students' Enneagram personality types [간호대학생의 에니어그램 성격유형에 따른스트레스 대처방식]* · 이화간호학회지 (이화여자대학교 간호과학대학), -(45), 61-75 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A82580524
  Found: Compares coping behaviours across types; detailed results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2011 · 김영화 · *A study of an Enneagram personality test for children [아동용 에니어그램 성격유형검사 연구]* · 배재대학교 교육대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12304299
  Found: Developed a 108-item self-report children's test via expert review; reliability/validity figures not in retrieved abstract.
- 2011 · 손승현 · *Emotional creativity of gifted versus average students by Enneagram type [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 영재학생과 일반학생의 정서 창의성 비교 분석]* · 인천대학교 교육대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12323450
  Found: Compares emotional creativity across types and giftedness; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2010 · Pop, F.-C.; Vaida, M.-F.; Cremene, M. · *An alternative strategy for grouping students in eLearning using an Enneagram methodology and eye tracking* · 2010 9th International Symposium on Electronics and Telecommunications (ISETC), 395-398 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1109/isetc.2010.5679364
  Found: Groups formed by Enneagram/NLP compatibility reportedly communicated more and got better practical results. Evidence comes from case studies with no statistics or control group reported.
- 2010 · Sepehrian, F. · *Primary construction of an Enneagram personality types scale* ·  · Result: Mixed · Iran · not yet checked · https://www.sid.ir/En/Journal/ViewPaper.aspx?ID=255769
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2010 · Kang, M. J.; Hah, Y. S. · *Clinical nurses' job stress and stress coping style according to Enneagram personality type [간호사의 에니어그램 성격 유형에 따른 직무 스트레스와 스트레스 대처방식]* · Korean Journal of Stress Research, 18(1), 1-10 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://dspace.kci.go.kr/handle/kci/1740382?show=full
  Found: Type 9 was most common (46.7%). Type 4 reported the highest job stress and Type 7 the lowest, but there was no significant correlation between type and job stress; Type 6 relied most on seeking social support.
- 2010 · Lee, J.; Kim, M. · *Effects of dental hygienists' personality types (MBTI and Enneagram) on number of job changes and length of service [MBTI와 에니어그램을 이용한 치과위생사들의 성격 분석 유형이 이직 횟수 및 근속년수에 미치는 영향]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://click.ndsl.kr/servlet/LinkingDetailView?cn=JAKO201056539820176&dbt=JAKO&org_code=O150&site_code=SS1009&
  Found: Abstract truncated in record; check the full text before citing.
- 2010 · Yoon, Y.; Yoon, U. · *Enneagram personality types and the purchase decision-making process [에니어그램 성격유형과 구매의사결정과정에 관한 연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A134174
  Found: Types 5 and 7 chose products on function, Type 3 trusted objective information and planned purchases, and Type 4 trusted brands and bought impulsively; post-purchase evaluation did not differ by type.
- 2010 · Kim, W.; Lee, S. · *An adolescent Enneagram scale for youth coaching [청소년 코칭접근을 위한 청소년 에니어그램 척도]* · Korean Journal of Coaching Research (코칭연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://db.koreascholar.com/article?code=243909
  Found: An 80-item scale was retained (items r>=.40), with corrected item-total correlation of .89 and test-retest reliability of .90; no factor-analytic or external validity evidence.
- 2010 · Noh, H. · *Applying the Enneagram to promote self-understanding in a medical interviewing course [의료면담 강좌에서 자기이해 촉진을 위한 에니어그램의 적용]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A134185
  Found: Students rated the Enneagram sessions as interesting and satisfying and said they aided self-understanding; satisfaction self-report only, no control.
- 2010 · Kim, S.; Lee, S. · *Motivating upper-elementary students to learn through the Enneagram [에니어그램을 통한 초등학교 고학년 학습동기부여방안]* · Journal of Parent Education (부모교육연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=22724
  Found: Proposes type-specific ways to motivate learning (e.g. giving Type 5 children chances to show competence); no statistics in the abstract.
- 2010 · 김경보 · *Job stress level and coping of employees by Enneagram personality type [에니어그램 성격 유형에 따른 직장근로자의 직무스트레스 수준 및 대처방식]* · Yeungnam University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12187460
  Found: Compares work stress and coping across types; detailed results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2010 · 최연택; 하채수 · *Academic self-efficacy by Korean Enneagram personality type [성격유형별 학업적 자기효능감에 대한 연구 : 한국형에니어그램 성격유형을 중심으로]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램학회), 7(2), 159-179 · Result: Critical · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A82508173
  Found: Only self-regulatory efficacy differed by type; type did not predict overall academic self-efficacy (p=.701).
- 2010 · 김정미 · *Analysis of marital quarrels over children by Enneagram personality type [에니어그램 성격유형별 자녀문제로 인한 부부싸움 특성 분석]* · 兒童硏究 (숙명여자대학교 아동연구소), 23(1), 1-18 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A82690299
  Found: Identified type-specific patterns in how quarrels about children start and unfold; descriptive qualitative design.
- 2010 · 박계현 · *Motives for juvenile delinquents' misdeeds by Enneagram type [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 비행청소년의 비행동기 탐색]* · 兒童硏究 (숙명여자대학교 아동연구소), 23(1), 19-34 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A82690300
  Found: Delinquency motives by type resembled those of non-delinquent people of the same type; qualitative.
- 2010 · 이은미 · *Feedback styles among teachers based on the Enneagram [에니어그램에 기반한 교사간의 피드백 스타일 분석 연구]* · 숙명여자대학교 대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12114271
  Found: Describes type-specific feedback styles to reduce conflict among staff; qualitative.
- 2009 · Killen, J. · *Toward the neurobiology of the Enneagram* · The Enneagram Journal (International Enneagram Association), July 2009 · Result: Mixed · USA · https://ieaninepoints.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2009-IEA-Journal_Jack-Killen.pdf
  Found: Proposes that head, body and heart triads reflect regulation of three mammalian emotion systems; explicitly a hypothesis with no brain data.
- 2009 · Akatsuka, M. · *コンピテンシー評価とエニアグラムを用いたチームマネジメントシステムの構築* · Journal of Japan Industrial Management Association, 60(2), 59- · Result: Mixed · Japan · https://doi.org/10.11221/jima.60.59
  Found: Built a team-formation system that selects members on competency and then checks compatibility with the Enneagram. The evaluation covered flexibility and processing speed only, not whether Enneagram-based compatibility improves team outcomes. (The 2008 conference version of the same system was merged into this record.)
- 2009 ·  · *エニアグラムを用いた新人看護師への指導方法の有効性* · 日本医学看護学教育学会誌 (Japanese Journal of Medical and Nursing Education) · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1520291856271523712
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2009 · Delobbe, N.; Halin, P.; Prémont, J.; Wuidar, D. · *Measuring personality at work: Development and validation of a new instrument based on the Enneagram* · Conference paper, Université catholique de Louvain (DIAL) · Result: Supportive · Belgium · http://hdl.handle.net/2078/117909
  Found: Developed the HPEI: 108 items were reduced to 59, and the factor structure and scale reliabilities were confirmed in 330 adults from diverse organisations; tests of convergence with the MBTI and Big Five were still planned.
- 2009 · Lee, J.; Sung, K.; Eom, H. · *Prediction of obesity by Sasang constitutions and the Enneagram in university students [사상체질과 에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 대학생의 비만 예측]* · Journal of Korean Medicine for Obesity Research · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://click.ndsl.kr/servlet/LinkingDetailView?cn=JAKO200927742024231&dbt=JAKO&org_code=O150&site_code=SS1009&
  Found: Abstract truncated in record; check the full text before citing.
- 2009 · Cho, J.; Kim, N. · *Relationship between VIA character strengths and virtues and Enneagram personality types [VIA 분류체계의 성격적 강점 및 덕성과 Enneagram 성격유형과의 관계]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A115604
  Found: Several VIA virtues correlated positively with many types (e.g. wisdom/knowledge with all but Type 6), and temperance correlated negatively with Type 4; the pattern is broad and not very type-specific.
- 2009 · Kim, Y.; Chung, H. · *Anger expression style by the Enneagram personality types of college students [남녀대학생의 에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 분노표현 방식]* · The Korean Journal of Community Living Science, 20(4), 539 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://www.koreascience.or.kr/article/ArticleFullRecord.jsp?cn=SHSHCG_2009_v20n4_539
  Found: Gut-centre students expressed anger outwardly more than head- and heart-centre students, and there were gender differences; convenience sample, centre-level analysis only.
- 2009 · Moon, S. · *An exploratory study on developing an Enneagram personality type scale for fathers of school-age children [아동기 아버지의 에니어그램 성격유형 척도개발에 관한 탐색적 연구]* · Journal of Parent Education (부모교육연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025301815
  Found: Produced an 86-item scale with type reliabilities of .75-.87; no external validity evidence is reported.
- 2009 · Yoon, Y.; Yoon, U. · *Enneagram centres of intelligence and the purchase decision-making process [에니어그램 힘의 중심별 성격유형과 구매의사결정과정에 관한 연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A115606
  Found: Heart types chose more on appearance and convenience and bought more impulsively, and head types responded more to advertising; there were no differences in information search, evaluation of alternatives or post-purchase behaviour.
- 2009 · Kim, M. · *Coping styles of domestic violence perpetrators by Enneagram type energy level [가정폭력행위자들의 에니어그램 성격유형 에너지 수준에 따른 대처방식에 관한 연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A115591
  Found: Higher type-energy levels were linked to stronger authoritarianism and sharper gender-role attitudes, and more balanced energy to better stress coping and communication; cross-sectional self-report.
- 2009 · Lee, W. · *Analysis of parents' habits by Enneagram type: Exploring intergenerational transmission [에니어그램 성격에 따른 부모의 습관 분석]* · Journal of Parent Education (부모교육연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025301770
  Found: Lists the top five habits parents of each type want and do not want to pass on to their children; descriptive only.
- 2009 · Lee, S.; Lee, S. · *An exploratory study on developing items for an Enneagram parenting attitude scale for mothers of young and school-age children [유아·아동기 어머니를 위한 에니어그램 양육태도 척도 문항 개발에 관한 탐색적 연구]* · Journal of Parent Education (부모교육연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://ekspe.newnonmun.com/article=20875
  Found: Selected 85 items with item-total correlations of .36-.71, type reliabilities of .67-.79 and total alpha=.91; no external validation.
- 2009 · Kim, S. · *A study on the Enneagram and colour preference [에니어그램과 색채선호도에 관한 연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A115594
  Found: Reports some correspondence between type-related and colour-related psychological tendencies, though not perfect; the abstract gives no sample size or statistics.
- 2009 · Kwon, H.; Jeon, M.; 김희영; Ham, M.; Youn, M. · *Public health college students' health promoting behaviors according to Enneagram personality type* · Journal of the Korean Data Analysis Society, 11, 2487-2499 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/2722b61b81246dc7e1df24eb09d57678e3ebb1ee
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2009 · 김응자 · *Development and validation of an adolescent Enneagram personality type scale [청소년 에니어그램 성격유형 척도의 개발 및 타당화]* · Sookmyung Women's University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11577894
  Found: 109 items reduced to 96 (item-total r ≥.40); for 7 of 9 types, students positioned in their 'stress direction' fell into the high-stress group, which the author takes as criterion support (not for types 4 and 7).
- 2009 · 김인옥 · *Relationship between teachers' personality and teaching styles using the Enneagram [에니어그램을 활용한 교사의 성격과 교수유형 (Teaching Styles)의 관계 탐색 연구]* · 兒童硏究 (숙명여자대학교 아동연구센터), 22(1), 21-46 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A82406527
  Found: Describes links between teachers' types and teaching actions/principles to support classroom management; descriptive.
- 2009 · 김진형 · *Interpersonal stress coping of early-childhood centre directors by Enneagram type [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 유아교육 기관장의 대인관계 스트레스 대처방식]* · 숙명여자대학교 교육대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11731098
  Found: Describes type-specific stress situations and coping with teachers, parents and other directors; qualitative.
- 2009 · 최유경 · *Interpersonal stress and coping of early-childhood teachers by Enneagram type [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 유아교사들의 대인관계 스트레스와 대처방식]* · 숙명여자대학교 교육대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11713370
  Found: Describes type-specific stressors (e.g., type 6 when authority is abused) and coping shifts toward stress points.
- 2008 · Giordano, M. E. · *A psychometric evaluation of the Riso-Hudson Type Indicator (RHETI), version 2.5: Comparison of ipsative and non-ipsative versions and correlations with spiritual outcomes* · Loyola College in Maryland · Result: Mixed · USA · https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.23097
  Found: Forced-choice RHETI alphas were as low as .35-.78, while a Likert version exceeded .70; only 48% of respondents had a clearly differentiated top type (3+ points ahead).
- 2008 · Arthur, K. B. · *Attachment styles and Enneagram types: Development and testing of an integrated typology for use in marriage and family therapy* · Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University (PhD dissertation) · Result: Supportive · USA · https://vtechworks.lib.vt.edu/items/1dd2efd5-0274-45a4-9aa0-dbb8480a530f
  Found: Reports support for an integrated attachment-Enneagram typology (e.g., hypothesised attachment style predicted by type-specific attention focus); small, highly trained, non-representative sample.
- 2008 ·  · *心の対話者(看護・介護部門)講座とエニアグラムワーク体験 II* · 東海女子短期大学紀要 (Tokai Women's Junior College Bulletin) · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1050001337651250176
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2008 · Yun, C.; Yun, C. W.; Kim, H.; Seong, E.; Hwang, C. · *Enneagram results in patients with Bell's palsy* · The Journal of Korean Medicine Ophthalmology and Otolaryngology and Dermatology, 21(3), 200 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.koreascience.or.kr/article/ArticleFullRecord.jsp?cn=OOBHC1_2008_v21n3_200
  Found: Types 1 and 9 were overrepresented; descriptive only, very small sample, no comparison group.
- 2008 · Heo, S.; Yoon, C. · *A study on the relation between the Enneagram and color leadership [에니어그램과 컬러리더십의 상관관계 연구]* · Journal of the Korean Society of Cosmetology (한국미용학회지) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=2748988
  Found: Types 1, 2, 3 and 6 related most to 'side' leadership, Type 7 to vision leadership and Type 8 to vision/power leadership; the sample was workshop graduates, a selection bias.
- 2008 · Akatsuka, M.; Kumagai, S. · *Construction of a project team management system that uses competency evaluation and the Enneagram* · Proceedings of the National Conference of the Society of Project Management (Japan) · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · http://ci.nii.ac.jp/naid/110007602845/en/
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2008 · Lee, M.; Chung, B. · *A study on Enneagram personality types, ego-identity, self-efficacy and interpersonal relations among adolescents in high school [고등학생의 에니어그램 성격유형, 자아정체감, 자기효능감, 대인관계에 관한 조사]* · Journal of the Korean Parent-Child Health (부모자녀건강학회지) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.papersearch.net/google_link/fulltext.asp?file_name=1q200075.pdf
  Found: Type 9, the gut centre and the 9w1 wing were most common, and level 5 was the modal development level; the paper is mainly descriptive.
- 2008 · In, B.; Lee, S. · *An exploratory study to identify Enneagram personality types in childhood [아동기 에니어그램 성격유형 파악을 위한 탐색적 연구]* · Journal of Parent Education (부모교육연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://kbns.newnonmun.com/article=18350
  Found: Produced an 83-item children's Enneagram scale; the abstract reports no reliability coefficients and the authors call for further validation.
- 2008 · Kim, E.; Lee, S. · *An approach to teachers as parents: An exploratory study on developing an Enneagram personality scale [부모로서의 교사됨을 위한 접근: 에니어그램 성격척도 개발에 관한 탐색적 연구]* · Journal of Parent Education (부모교육연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://ekspe.newnonmun.com/article=18346
  Found: 81-item scale: overall alpha=.82 but subscales only .45-.75; correlations with RHETI types were .33-.55 except Type 5 (.18), giving moderate convergent validity.
- 2008 · 조주영; 차윤희 · *Self and family factors associated with development level of Enneagram [에니어그램 발달수준과 관련된 개인·가족 요인]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 5(2), 41-64 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75254441
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2008 · 윤서연; 이소희 · *The development and validation study of Enneagram type cards [에니어그램 유형카드의 개발 및 타당화 연구]* · 兒童硏究 (Sookmyung Women's University Child Research Center), 21(1), 95-111 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A82406522
  Found: Developed a 69-item card-sort type measure from 114 candidate items via two expert rounds and item-total correlations ≥.30; no criterion or construct validity data reported in the abstract.
- 2008 · 박혜숙 · *Development of Enneagram QUEST and its feasibility study [에니어그램 QUEST의 개발과 내용타당도 검증]* · 兒童硏究 (Sookmyung Women's University Child Research Center), 21(1), 63-76 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A82406521
  Found: Paragraph/sentence-based oral typing tool; expert agreement rose from 59.7% (round 1) to 78.1% (round 2), with some type descriptions reaching only 20-40% agreement. Content validity only.
- 2008 · 이지현 · *A study on the development of an Enneagram scale (PEPI) [에니어그램의 척도개발에 관한 연구]* · Pai Chai University Graduate School of International Trade (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11297068
  Found: Developed the 108-item PEPI and reported internal-consistency reliability; the author notes validity and standardisation still need testing.
- 2008 · 지미선 · *Occupational stress and coping style by Enneagram personality types [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 직무스트레스 및 대처방식]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 5(1), 83-107 (from Korea University master's thesis, 2008) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75254438
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2008 · 김정미 · *The relationship between Enneagram type, level of job stress and coping in elementary school teachers [초등교사의 에니어그램 성격유형과 직무스트레스 수준 및 대처방식과의 관계]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 5(1), 37-56 (from Daegu National University of Education master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75254435
  Found: Examines differences in job-stress level and coping across types; detailed results not in retrieved abstract – check full text.
- 2008 · 신수경 · *Developing coaching questions based on early-childhood Enneagram personality types [유아 에니어그램성격유형에 기반한 코칭질문개발에 대한 탐색적연구]* · 兒童硏究 (Sookmyung Women's University Child Research Center), 21(1), 77-94 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A82406524
  Found: 54 draft questions in 6 categories were reduced to 38 after expert content validation; no empirical outcome data.
- 2008 · 박성회 · *Job satisfaction by Enneagram personality type in medical services [Enneagram 성격유형에 따른 직무만족에 관한 연구]* · Gyeongsang National University Graduate School of Business (master's thesis) · Result: Critical · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11437763
  Found: Job satisfaction did not differ significantly by Enneagram type; communication, rewards, conditions and motivation predicted satisfaction.
- 2008 · 이소현 · *Enneagram traits, eating habits and food preferences of university students in Gyeongnam [경남지역 대학생의 에니어그램 성격특성과 식습관 및 식품기호도와의 상관관계 연구]* · Kyungnam University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11559225
  Found: Centre groups differed in meal regularity, appetite, overeating and snacking (e.g., head-centre women irregular meals and more overeating).
- 2008 · 윤천성; 김미선 · *Relations between mothers' Enneagram-based personality types and rearing attitudes [에니어그램에 근거한 어머니의 성격유형과 양육태도의 관계]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램학회), 5(1), 9-35 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75254434
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2008 · 박현경 · *Relationship between university students' Enneagram types and Holland vocational personality types [대학생의 에니어그램 성격유형과 Holland 직업선호 유형과의 관계]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램학회), 5(2), 87-121 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75254443
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2008 · 김무영; 윤운성 · *Analysis of Enneagram personality types of military officers [군 간부의 에니어그램 성격유형 분석]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램학회), 5(1), 57-68 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75254436
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2008 · 김은선; 이소희 · *Exploring the applicability of the Riso-Hudson Enneagram QUEST in Korea [리소-허드슨 에니어그램 QUEST 방법의 한국적용가능성 탐색]* · 兒童硏究 (숙명여자대학교 아동연구센터), 21(1), 43-61 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A82406520
  Found: Examined test-retest consistency of a Korean QUEST over three weeks and replication in a second group; figures not in retrieved abstract.
- 2008 · 김미선 · *Trend analysis of Korean Enneagram studies [국내 에니어그램 연구에 관한 동향분석]* · 兒童硏究 (숙명여자대학교 아동연구센터), 21(1), 1-20 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A82406518
  Found: Recommends more scale and programme development and research with children, parents, teachers and clinical groups.
- 2007 ·  · *心の対話者(看護・介護部門)講座におけるエニアグラムワーク体験* · 東海女子短期大学紀要 (Tokai Women's Junior College Bulletin) · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1050282812627958272
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2007 · Lee, E. · *Developing an Enneagram scale for adolescents and practical direction in career decision making [청소년용 에니어그램 성격검사도구 개발 및 진로탐색 활용에 관한 연구]* · The Korean Journal of Child Education · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.kci.go.kr/kciportal/ci/sereArticleSearch/ciSereArtiView.kci?sereArticleSearchBean.artiId=ART001205046
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2007 · Kwon, Y.; Kim, J. H. · *An exploratory study of the Enneagram and travel motivation [에니어그램과 여행 동기에 대한 탐험적 연구]* · Journal of Tourism Sciences (관광학연구) · Result: Critical · South Korea · http://www.dbpia.co.kr/Article/797319
  Found: Found travel motivation was independent of Enneagram type; the authors suggest situational factors and near-universal motives (relaxation, fun, culture) explain this null result.
- 2007 · Park, S.; Hwang, S. · *Pattern analysis of organizational leaders using a fuzzy TAM network* · Journal of Korean Institute of Intelligent Systems, 17(2), 238 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.5391/jkiis.2007.17.2.238
  Found: Shows a fuzzy TAM network can classify leadership patterns, with Egogram variables as inputs and Enneagram-based leadership types as outputs; this is a methods demonstration, not a validation of the Enneagram.
- 2007 · Cardona Tobón, C. M.; Escobar Muñoz, M. N.; Rubio Sánchez, J. M. · *Description of personality traits from a parallel between the Enneagram and the MIPS in ninth- and tenth-semester psychology students in Envigado, 2006 [Descripción de rasgos de personalidad a partir del paralelo entre el eneagrama y el MIPS...]* · Universidad Cooperativa de Colombia · Result: Mixed · Colombia · http://repository.ucc.edu.co/handle/ucc/3534
  Found: The abstract describes the aim (describing personality through the Enneagram alongside the MIPS) but reports no results.
- 2007 · Lee, M. · *Enneagram personality types and learning styles of nursing students [간호대학생의 에니어그램 성격유형과 학습유형에 관한 연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A55426
  Found: Among Type 9 students, the 9w1 wing and level 5 of development were most common, and 50% had a diverging learning style; descriptive only, one college.
- 2007 · Lee, M. · *Relationships among Enneagram personality type, depression and anxiety in nursing students [간호대학생의 에니어그램 성격유형, 우울 및 불안과의 관계]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A55415
  Found: Depression and anxiety did not differ significantly by type (heart types scored highest on depression, head types on anxiety), though a significant positive type-anxiety correlation was reported; small single-site sample.
- 2007 · Lee, S.; Lee, S. · *Development of a parenting attitude scale for mothers of young children based on Enneagram personality types [에니어그램 성격유형에 기초한 유아 어머니의 양육태도 척도 개발에 관한 연구]* · Journal of Parent Education (부모교육연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.newnonmun.com/dlink/16164.pdf
  Found: Produced an 81-item, nine-factor scale; reliabilities ranged .50-.76, with Type 9 weak (alpha=.43, test-retest=.38), so some subscales fall short.
- 2007 · 김권수 (Kim, Kwon Soo) · *The relationship between hotel employees' Enneagram personality types and job satisfaction by job category [호텔직무형태에 따른 종사원의 에니어그램성격유형과 직무만족의 관계]* · 호텔관광연구 (Journal of Hotel and Tourism Research), 9(4), 272-287 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A107077970
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2007 · Kingma, M. · *Utilising a personality typology to resolve subliminal conflict in the workplace* · Cape Peninsula University of Technology (doctoral thesis, Human Resource Management) · Result: Mixed · South Africa · http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.11838/1759
  Found: Develops and applies an Enneagram-based workplace conflict-resolution process; landing page gives no outcome statistics – check full text.
- 2007 · 여승광 · *Relationship between Enneagram types and children's stress-coping behaviour [에니어그램 성격유형과 스트레스 대처행동의 관계 분석]* · 경상대학교 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11099124
  Found: Most type scores correlated with coping behaviours in expected directions, with several non-significant links (e.g., type 1-aggression).
- 2006 · Hellany, A. · *Enneagram: Exploring learning styles of engineering students* · 2006 IEEE GCC Conference, 1-6 · Result: Mixed · Australia · https://doi.org/10.1109/ieeegcc.2006.5686230
  Found: Introduces the Enneagram as a tool to identify engineering students' (and educators') learning preferences; the abstract reports no results.
- 2006 · Song, H. J.; Kim, D. G. · *Enneagram: Understanding personality types* · Korean Journal of Stress Research, 14(1) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.stressresearch.or.kr/journal/download_pdf.php?spage=1&volume=14&number=1
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2006 · Chung, H.-J. · *A study on self-expression and facilitative communication by enneatype among university students* · The Korean Journal of Community Living Science, 17(4), 163 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.koreascience.or.kr/article/ArticleFullRecord.jsp?cn=SHSHCG_2006_v17n4_163
  Found: Assertive self-expression (content, paralinguistic, nonverbal) and the immediacy facet of facilitative communication differed significantly by Enneagram type. Self-report.
- 2006 · 김분한; 김윤숙; 하진 · *간호사의 성격 유형에 대한 주관성 연구* · 주관성연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.dbpia.co.kr/Route/ArticleLink/arid=1487086?arid=1487086
  Found: Five subjective types emerged (self-oriented, caring, give-and-take, social, faithful) explaining 65.81% of variance; they did not map onto the nine Enneagram types.
- 2006 · 윤운성 · *한국형 에니어그램 성격유형 현황분석 II* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A35053
  Found: Type scores varied systematically by age, education and occupation (e.g., teachers higher on Reformer and Thinker, office workers higher on Achiever). Presented as cultural validity evidence but descriptive.
- 2006 · 오현수; 김향선 · *간호대학생의 에니어그램 성격유형과 발달수준 비교연구* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A35063
  Found: About 46% were gut-centre and 32% type 9; 53% were in the disintegration direction; mean developmental level did not differ between the two universities. Descriptive.
- 2006 · 조주영 · *에니어그램 성격유형 분석: 고등학생과 대학생을 중심으로* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A35062
  Found: The gut centre and types 9, 4 and 6 were most common; centre distribution differed by school level and developmental scores differed by type, wing, direction and childhood origin. Descriptive.
- 2006 · Cunha, F. R. B. · *Self-knowledge and personal skills in health promotion [Autoconhecimento e habilidades pessoais em promoção da saúde]* · Universidade de Fortaleza (UNIFOR), MSc in Collective Health · Result: Mixed · Brazil · https://biblioteca.sophia.com.br/terminalri/9575/acervo/detalhe/71806
  Found: Participants linked their Enneagram course experience to personal skills relevant to health promotion. Descriptive qualitative study with purposive sample.
- 2006 · 소은정 · *Correlation between air traffic controllers' Enneagram personality types and job satisfaction [에니어그램을 이용한 관제사의 성격유형과 직무만족간의 상관관계에 관한 연구]* · Korea Aerospace University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10873025
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2006 · 오장순 · *Multiple intelligences and leadership by Enneagram type among gifted-class students [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 다중지능과 리더십]* · Daejeon University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T16714052
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2006 · 권화선 · *Job stress and coping by Enneagram type among middle and high school teachers [중·고등학교 교사의 에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 직무스트레스 및 직무스트레스 대처방식에 대한 연구]* · Kangwon National University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10695250
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract – check full text.
- 2006 · 김새한별 · *Relations between the Enneagram and well-being [에니어그램과 웰빙]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램학회), 3(2), 93-115 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75270840
  Found: Self-intention of well-being differed by type (highest type 4, lowest type 8) and leisure tendency differed by harmonic group.
- 2006 · 유성희 · *Piano learning patterns and teaching methods by students' Enneagram type [에니어그램 유형에 따른 피아노 학습형태와 지도방안]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램학회), 3(1), 63-81 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75270832
  Found: Describes type-specific piano learning tendencies (e.g., type 1 mechanical playing) and recommends tailored teaching; descriptive.
- 2006 · 김인숙 · *Type discrimination for Enneagram spiritual counselling: Questionnaire versus colour-analysis methods [에니어그램 靈性 相談을 위한 類型 判別에 관한 硏究 : 類型判別에 있어 說問紙分析法과 色彩分析法 比較를 中心으로]* · 조선대학교 보건대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11491749
  Found: Questionnaire typing agreed with observer typing at κ=.733; colour-symbol typing agreed with the questionnaire only at κ=.45.
- 2005 · Brown, A.; Bartram, D. · *Relationships between OPQ and Enneagram types* · SHL Group plc, London · Result: Supportive · UK · https://ieaninepoints.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2012-IEA-Journal_Anna-Sutton.pdf
  Found: Types differed on Big Five-related OPQ scales in theoretically expected ways, and OPQ scores classified people into their correct Enneagram type about 75% of the time.
- 2005 · 황임란 · *A comparison of the Enneagram and the MBTI* · Korean Journal of Youth Studies · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.kci.go.kr/kciportal/ci/sereArticleSearch/ciSereArtiView.kci?sereArticleSearchBean.artiId=ART001113824
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2005 · Gallant, H. M. · *The use of the enneagram to improve customer relationships with a motor vehicle manufacturer* · Master's dissertation, Nelson Mandela University · Result: Mixed · South Africa · https://hdl.handle.net/10948/10330
  Found: Formulates a model for using the Enneagram as a psychographic segmentation base to improve customer relationship management; the abstract reports no outcome data.
- 2005 · 이미련; 김순구 · *간호대학생의 에니어그램 성격유형에 관한 조사* · 부모자녀건강학회지 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=2771785
  Found: Type 9 was most common (then 1, 4, 7, 2, 8, 6, 5, 3), the gut centre dominated, and most students were at developmental level 5. Descriptive only.
- 2005 · Anjari Millar, M. A. · *Person, development and the Enneagram [Persona, desarrollo y eneagrama]* · Master's thesis (Ética Social y Desarrollo Humano), Universidad Alberto Hurtado · Result: Mixed · Chile · not yet checked · https://repositorio.uahurtado.cl/handle/11242/5724
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2005 · Jeongmin; 이숙자; 장안나 · *에니어그램 성격 유형과 방어기제와의 관계* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A24975
  Found: Defence-mechanism styles (immature, adaptive, self-inhibiting, conflict-avoidant) and several sub-defences differed significantly by Enneagram type. Self-typed workshop sample.
- 2005 · 오현수 · *간호대학생의 에니어그램 성격유형 연구* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A24978
  Found: About 50% were gut-centre and about 40% type 9; 54% were in the disintegration direction, with health levels in the average range. Descriptive.
- 2005 · 이광자; 손봉희 · *에니어그램 관련 연구논문 분석* · Health & Nursing · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=2475600
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2005 · 손진희 · *에니어그램 유형의 타당화 연구: 6, 1, 2번 유형군을 중심으로* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A24971
  Found: As predicted from psychodynamic theory, the 6-1-2 type group scored higher than the 3-7-8 and 9-4-5 groups on perfectionism and higher than 3-7-8 on anger suppression.
- 2005 · 하영자; 이영순; 천성문 · *초월,영성상담: 에니어그램 성격유형을 활용한 가톨릭 교회 여신도들의 영적 자아발견에 관한 체험분석* · 상담학연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.kiss.kstudy.com/journal/thesis_name.asp?key=3165410
  Found: Participants' spiritual self-discovery stages were closely related to the false-self patterns and virtues of their Enneagram types. Very small qualitative sample.
- 2005 · 김유정 · *에니어그램 성격 유형에 따른 선호하는 향과 색에 대한 분석* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A24970
  Found: Gut types most preferred lemon scent and blue, heart types animal scent and purple, head types rose scent and yellow/green. Descriptive, unvalidated link.
- 2005 · 김희경; 지현순; 류은경; 전미경 · *Comparison of job satisfaction, organisational commitment and burnout by Enneagram personality of hospital nurses (KEPTI) [에니어그램을 활용한 병원간호사의 성격유형과 직무만족도, 조직몰입 및 소진비교]* · 임상간호연구 (Journal of Korean Clinical Nursing Research), 11(1), 109-121 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A45048149
  Found: Type 1 (47.3%) and type 9 (21.0%) dominated; job satisfaction, commitment and burnout were compared across types to inform nursing interventions. Self-report, uneven type distribution.
- 2005 · 김성민 · *Applying the Enneagram to improve relationships between flight instructors and student pilots [敎官과 學生操縱士 간의 人間關係 改善을 위한 에니어그램 適用方案 硏究]* · 慶尙大學校 行政大學院 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10292836
  Found: Flying-score improvement differed by instructor-student type preference pairing; students under forceful 'sturdy' instructors improved more than average.
- 2004 · Newgent, R. A.; Parr, P. E.; Newman, I.; Wiggins, K. K. · *The Riso-Hudson Enneagram Type Indicator: Estimates of reliability and validity* · Measurement and Evaluation in Counseling and Development, 36(4), 226-237 · Result: Mixed · USA · https://doi.org/10.1080/07481756.2004.11909744
  Found: RHETI scales showed mostly theory-predicted relationships with the Big Five, but internal consistency was uneven (alphas .56-.82), so some scales need revision.
- 2004 ·  · *褒められることとライフバランスの関連について: エニアグラムのタイプ分類を利用して* · 日本看護学会論文集 看護教育 (Japanese Nursing Association Proceedings: Nursing Education) · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1520010381300800384
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2004 · Yang, S.; Yang, N.; Cha, J.-H. · *Enneagram personality types, nursing professional attitudes and job satisfaction of the nurses* · Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing Administration · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://kmbase.medric.or.kr/KMID/0614820040100030299
  Found: Type 6 was most common and types 5 and 8 were absent; professional attitudes and job satisfaction did not differ significantly by Enneagram type.
- 2004 · Jiménez, V. H. · *The Enneagram: an alternative for assessing personality [El eneagrama: una alternativa para evaluar la personalidad]* · Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Faculty of Psychology (licentiate thesis) · Result: Mixed · Mexico · not yet checked · https://ru.dgb.unam.mx/bitstream/20.500.14330/TES01000336480/3/0336480.pdf
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2004 · 윤형준 · *The relationship between career anchor types and Enneagram personality types [경력 닻 유형과 에니어그램 성격 유형의 관계]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 1(2), 33-64 (from Korea University master's thesis, 2004) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75270807
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2004 · 백원대 · *NLP preferred sensory modality and Enneagram personality types by job characteristics [직무특성에 따른 NLP 선호감각유형과 에니어그램 성격유형에 관한 연구]* · Kwangwoon University Graduate School of Information and Welfare (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T9299757
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2004 · 조정은; 송정아 · *Effects of Enneagram development level on marital adjustment and satisfaction [에니어그램 발달수준이 결혼적응과 결혼만족에 미치는 영향]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 1(2), 105-123 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75270810
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2004 · 황혜자; 유선림 · *Effects of Enneagram group counselling on college students' interpersonal skills and self-esteem [에니어그램 집단상담이 대학생의 대인관계능력 및 자아존중감에 미치는 효과]* · 學生硏究 (Dong-A University Student Counselling Center), 33, 29-49 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A82690405
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract excerpt – check full text.
- 2004 · 松田 隆一 · *Early development of project leaders using PM-WBS (with Enneagram and coaching) [PM-WBSを活用したプロジェクトリーダ早期育成]* · プロジェクトマネジメント学会研究発表大会予稿集 (Society of Project Management, Spring 2004), 1505 · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.14914/spm.2004.Spring.0_333
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing. Keywords list WBS, Enneagram and coaching for project-leader development.
- 2004 · 이은종 · *Relationship between Korean Enneagram personality types and self-esteem [한국형 에니어그램(Enneagram)성격유형과 자아존중감과의 관계]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램학회), 1(2), 81-103 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75270809
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2003 · Son, B.-H. [손봉희] · *Study on the reliability and validity of the Korean version of the Riso-Hudson Enneagram Type Indicator (RHETI) version 2.5 [에니어그램 성격유형검사 RHETI 한글판의 신뢰도 및 타당도 조사]* · Master's thesis, Graduate School of Clinical Health Science, Ewha Womans University · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://dspace.ewha.ac.kr/handle/2015.oak/175022
  Found: Overall alpha .69 (.77 after removing 51 items), subscales .52-.85; RHETI type matched self-diagnosed type in 89.9% of cases. Sample already trained in the Enneagram, which inflates agreement.
- 2003 · 주석진 · *Development of a scale for discriminating Enneagram types [에니어그램 유형 판별을 위한 척도개발]* · Daegu University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T8938326
  Found: 90 items showed reliability above .80 (α and Guttman split-half), but validity was questionable because correlations among related factors were lower than expected; items were theory-derived only.
- 2003 · 이자영 · *Correlation between children's Enneagram types and perceived parental rearing attitudes [자녀의 에니어그램 성격유형과 자녀가 지각한 부모의 양육태도 사이의 상관관계-대구 경북지역 대학생을 중심으로]* · 대구대학교 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T8938286
  Found: Tests links between type and perceived parenting; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2002 · Kim, N. S.; Lee, K. F.; Lee, S. · *Relationship with the types of Enneagram and Type A/B personality* · Journal of Korean Academy of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 11(2), 159 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.12934/jkpmhn.2002.11.2.159
  Found: Type 7 was most common; the gut triad made up 40.7% of the sample. Examined how Enneagram types relate to Type A/B behaviour.
- 2002 · Nurmala, A. · *Nine illusions about objectivity: The Enneagram approach to developing interpersonal communication in organisations* · Master's thesis, University of Helsinki · Result: Mixed · Finland · not yet checked · http://hdl.handle.net/10138/12604
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2002 · 이광자 · *간호사의 에니어그램 유형분석* · Health & Nursing · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=2008638
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2001 · Dameyer, J. J. · *Psychometric evaluation of the Riso-Hudson Enneagram Type Indicator* · California Institute of Integral Studies (PhD) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://ieaninepoints.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2012-IEA-Journal_Anna-Sutton.pdf
  Found: 82% got the same RHETI type on retest, but alphas ranged .35-.84 and only 42% were assigned the same type by the RHETI and the WEPSS, showing two leading Enneagram tests often disagree.
- 2001 · Newgent, R. A. · *An investigation of the reliability and validity of the Riso-Hudson Enneagram Type Indicator* · The University of Akron (UMI No. 3005901) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED468827.pdf
  Found: RHETI type scales had alphas .56-.82; each type scale split into two factors rather than one; theory-consistent correlations with NEO PI-R Big Five. Partial support with recommended revisions.
- 2001 · 윤운성 · *에니어그램 성격검사의 개발과 타당화* · Korea Research Foundation (KRM) research report · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.krm.or.kr/krmts/link.html?dbGubun=FRBR&metaDataId=4b76f6dc19c6b4c90119e5c42fb41fb4
  Found: Developed the 91-item Korean Enneagram Personality Type Indicator; type subscale alphas .51-.80 and test-retest reliability .89, with percentile norms and occupational/gender differences reported.
- 2001 · 윤운성 · *The Enneagram Personality Type scale: Its development and validity* · Sun Moon University (Semantic Scholar record) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/ecbeb9cb979c9b40255ec1e62e74972b48ca1443
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2001 · 김병채; 김혜영 · *Assessment of Enneagram types by Riso-Hudson and Baron-Wagele written tests compared with types assessed in an Enneagram workshop [지필 검사(Riso-Hudson검사와 Baron-Wagele검사)에 의한 에니어그램 성격유형 평가 : 에니어그램 워크숍에 의해 평가된 성격유형과의 비교를 통하여]* · 학생생활연구 (창원대학교 학생생활연구소), 14, 35-67 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A3002964
  Found: Early Korean convergent-validity check of RHETI and Baron-Wagele tests against workshop typing; agreement statistics not retrieved – check full text.
- 2001 · 양현숙 · *Relationship of Enneagram types with learning styles and achievement goals [에니어그램(Enneagram)의 성격유형과 학습유형 및 성취목표와의 관계]* · 한양대학교 교육대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T8122759
  Found: Examines correlations between type, learning behaviour type, achievement goals and grades; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2000 · Daniels, D. N.; Price, V. A. · *The Essential Enneagram: The definitive personality test and self-discovery guide (Essential Enneagram Test validation data)* · HarperCollins (book reporting Stanford validation study) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://ieaninepoints.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2012-IEA-Journal_Anna-Sutton.pdf
  Found: Paragraph choice matched final type well above chance (11%), from 37% (Type 8) to 68% (Type 9); mean kappa .53 for validity and .59 for 4-week test-retest. Developer-run, not independently peer reviewed.
- 1999 · Wagner, J. P. · *Wagner Enneagram Personality Style Scales (WEPSS): Manual* · Western Psychological Services · Result: Supportive · USA · https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.23097
  Found: Alphas .78-.88; test-retest .62-.91 (6 weeks) and .55-.86 (8 months); agreement with self-identified type kappa .74-.88. Nine factors emerged but without clean simple structure (items cross-loaded). Developer-run data.
- 1999 · Hara, F.; Watanabe, K.; Ishigaki, H. · *Computer-aided creation of visual impression on CG face* · 8th IEEE International Workshop on Robot and Human Interaction (RO-MAN '99), 159-164 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1109/roman.1999.900333
  Found: Identified 59 facial 'impression units' whose combinations best convey each of the nine Enneagram types on a computer-generated face. This is an engineering study, not a test of Enneagram validity.
- 1999 · Chawla, B. · *A critical enquiry in to enneagram as an ancient technique for judging personality types* · Doctoral thesis, Department of Psychology, M. S. University of Baroda · Result: Mixed · India · not yet checked · https://shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/handle/10603/71917
  Found: Retrieved abstract text covers background only; findings not available. Check the full text before citing.
- 1998 · Emerick, D. · *Movement within the Enneagram: a pilot study* · Northeastern State University, Oklahoma (thesis) · Result: Mixed · USA · not yet checked · https://digitallibrary.nsuok.edu/works/publication-dissertation/03vb3-8mh55
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 1997 · 海野 和夫 · *登校拒否の改善支援のための視点 その3: カウンセリングへのエニアグラムの活用* · Proceedings of the Annual Convention of the Japanese Association of Educational Psychology, 39, 536 · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.20587/pamjaep.39.0_536
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 1997 · Schneider, J.; Schaeffer, B. · *The enneagram typology: A tool for understanding and counseling sex addicts* · Sexual Addiction & Compulsivity, 4(3), 245-278 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1080/10720169708404230
  Found: Type 1 was over-represented among long-term recovering addicts and Type 8 among the women. Small convenience sample, types assigned by interview, no comparison group.
- 1996 · Leeper, G. C. · *A study of reliability of the Aspell Enneagram Inventory* · Master's research project, University of Texas of the Permian Basin · Result: Critical · USA · https://falconcommons.utpb.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1086&context=utpb-edu
  Found: Per-item reliability was low (mean correlation 0.55); about 70% gave similar results on both administrations but correlations were too low to be considered reliable.
- 1996 · Kim, C.-Y.; Chung, J. · *A study on pilots' characteristics and preferred personality types classified by the Enneagram [Enneagram에 의한 조종사 성격 특성과 선호 성격 유형에 관한 연구]* · Journal of the Korean Society for Aviation and Aeronautics, 4(1), 39-61 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.koreascience.kr/article/JAKO199628835895167.page
  Found: Aims to identify Korean airline pilots' types, the types they prefer and how type interactions affect crew task performance for crew resource management; the available abstract does not report results. Check the full text before citing.
- 1995 · Twomey, J. A. · *The enneagram and Jungian archetypal images* · Chicago School of Professional Psychology (PsyD) · Result: Critical · USA · https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED468827.pdf
  Found: Found no support for the theory that people move to predictable other types under stress or security.
- 1995 · Warling, D. L. · *An examination of the external validity of the Riso-Hudson Enneagram Type Indicator (RHETI)* · University of Guelph · Result: Supportive · Canada · https://ieaninepoints.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2012-IEA-Journal_Anna-Sutton.pdf
  Found: RHETI scales correlated significantly with comparable 16PF traits and supported distinctions between types; test-retest correlations for RHETI scales reported in the .72-.94 range (with Dameyer 2001).
- 1994 · Sharp, P. M. · *A factor analytic study of three enneagram personality inventories and the Vocational Preference Inventory* · Texas Tech University (EdD) · Result: Critical · USA · https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED468827.pdf
  Found: The three Enneagram inventories combined produced only six factors (not nine), and Enneagram type was only weakly related to vocational preference.
- 1994 · Thrasher, P. · *The enneagram: Movement between types, an inventory, and a criterion measure* · Loyola University of Chicago (Dissertation Abstracts International-B, 55, 1217) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED468827.pdf
  Found: Inventory agreed well with self-identified type (mean kappa .63; subscale alphas .85-.93), but there was no support for movement along the stress/security arrows, and significant others typed people accurately only if they knew the system.
- 1986 · Gamard, W. S. · *Interrater reliability and validity of judgments of enneagram personality types* · California Institute of Integral Studies (Dissertation Abstracts International-B, 47, 3152) · Result: Critical · USA · https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.23097
  Found: Expert typing agreement was low: overall kappa about .20, experienced judges .25 vs .17 for less experienced; 2.5-year judge test-retest kappa .48-.55. Judges were more confident than their accuracy justified.
- 1983 · Wagner, J. P.; Walker, R. E. · *Reliability and validity study of a Sufi personality typology: The enneagram* · Journal of Clinical Psychology, 39(5), 712-717 · Result: Mixed · USA · https://doi.org/10.1002/1097-4679(198309)39:5<712::AID-JCLP2270390511>3.0.CO;2-3
  Found: Self-typing was stable (at least .79 agreement); types showed highly significant, theory-congruent differences on MBTI and Millon scales. Agreement between the inventory and self-identified type was only fair (kappa .28 first administration, .40 second).
- 1981 · Wagner, J. P. · *A descriptive, reliability, and validity study of the enneagram personality typology* · Loyola University of Chicago (Dissertation Abstracts International-A, 41, 4664) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED468827.pdf
  Found: About 80% of people kept the same self-identified type over time; the nine types differed significantly on MBTI and Millon scales. The new inventory's predictive validity was better than chance but weak (kappa .28-.40); early subscale alphas ranged .37-.82.
- 1979 · Randall, S. · *The development of an inventory to assess enneagram personality type* · California Institute of Asian Studies · Result: Mixed · USA · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.23097
  Found: One of the first Enneagram inventories; Hook et al. (2021) report significant correlations between interview-assigned type and this self-report measure. Detailed statistics not retrieved.
- 1975 · Zinkle, T. E. · *A pilot study toward the validation of the Sufi personality typology* · United States International University (Dissertation Abstracts International-B, 35, 2418) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED468827.pdf
  Found: Item test-retest stability ranged widely (.58 to .98); inventory type agreed with expert judges for only 56% of people. Reviewers describe reliability as variable and validity as questionable.
- n.d. · Vicente Pereira Justo Carnero, J. · *The use of the Enneagram as a leadership and talent management tool [O uso do eneagrama como ferramenta de liderança e gestão de talentos]* · Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Rio de Janeiro (PUC-Rio) · Result: Mixed · Brazil · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.17771/pucrio.acad.7799
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.

## Level D · Before-and-after (146 studies)

- 2026 · Iamkrasin, S. · *The process of developing drama students holistically with the Enneagrams* · APARN 2025 Conference proceedings, 218-230 · Result: Supportive · Thailand · https://doi.org/10.62788/aparn2025-paper7
  Found: The author reports better character analysis, self-awareness and growth in physical readiness, teamwork, resilience and professional skills. Uncontrolled practice-based design.
- 2026 · Hamad, A. M. Y. · *Effectiveness of a guidance program according to Enneagram model to strengthen psychological immunity among 100-200m runners in Wasit Education Directorate team* · Journal of Applied Movement and Sport Science, 2(1) · Result: Mixed · Iraq · https://doi.org/10.65575/jamss.v2i1.130
  Found: The baseline showed weaknesses in psychological immunity; the abstract describes the programme but gives no clear post-programme effect figures. Small sample, no control group described, and the Enneagram typing method is unusual (TAT).
- 2026 · Bilmez Selen, M. · *The effect of personality types on stress perception among dental faculty trainee students* · Selcuk Dental Journal · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.15311/selcukdentj.1666849
  Found: Mean DES stress was 3.02; Type 1 (perfectionist) reported the highest stress (3.31) and Types 5, 7 and 9 lower; gender and socioeconomic effects were not significant. Single-institution self-report data.
- 2026 · 장유리 · *Multiple-case study of Enneagram type 2: The 'meditation-counselling Enneagram programme' [에니어그램 2번 성격유형의 다중사례연구]* · Dongbang Culture University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T17398237
  Found: Change was attributed to combining Enneagram reflection with meditation, imagery and behavioural contracts, reducing fear of rejection; small case series.
- 2026 · 심민정 · *Developing an Enneagram-based book-curation programme (DESA model) for children's picture books [에니어그램 기반 북큐레이션 프로그램 (DESA 모델) 개발 연구]* · Myongji University Graduate School of Industry (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T17396769
  Found: Expert agreement on type-matching of books varied widely (I-CVI 0.20-1.00 across criteria), showing inconsistent expert typing of book content.
- 2025 · Herbst, T. H. H. · *Exploring leadership personality: A key for higher education transformation* · Transformation in Higher Education, 10 · Result: Supportive · South Africa · https://doi.org/10.4102/the.v10i0.577
  Found: Type 1 was most common (26%), followed by Type 3 (16%) and Type 5 (12%), and 46% of leaders fell in the 'compliant' social style. The author links this profile to rigidity in transformation efforts. The study is descriptive with no outcome measures.
- 2025 · Kayserili, M. · *The effect of Enneagram personality types on rational and intuitive decision-making styles* · İnsan ve Toplum Bilimleri Araştırmaları Dergisi, 14(2), 1007-1027 · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.15869/itobiad.1655904
  Found: Types 1, 2, 3 and 9 together explained 62% of variance in rational decision-making; type had no effect on intuitive decision-making.
- 2025 · Wang, T. · *An Analysis of the Mechanisms Underlying Core Psychologi cal Dilemmas in Enneagram Types and Proposed Intervention Strategies* · Psychology of China · Result: Mixed · China · https://doi.org/10.35534/pc.0710212
  Found: The author argues that each type's core dilemma ties to a specific cognitive bias or emotion-regulation pattern, and proposes metacognitive and CBT strategies. The evidence is mainly theoretical with a small qualitative sample.
- 2025 · Zortul, S. · *The effect of employees' personality types on teamwork in family medicine practice in secondary health institutions: a hospital example* · Current Research in Health Sciences, 2(3), 94-101 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.62425/crihs.1711056
  Found: Examines differences in teamwork attitudes by personality type and demographics; abstract truncated before results – check full text.
- 2025 · 한철운 · *Effect of Enneagram instinct-based acceptance on communication of midlife couples [에니어그램 본능 기반의 수용이 중년 부부의 의사소통 증진에 미치는 영향]* · Myongji University Graduate School of Industry (master's thesis) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T17172695
  Found: Understanding instinctual variants increased mutual acceptance and improved communication quality; design details limited.
- 2024 · Lee, S. H.; Yoo, Y. K. · *Forgiveness Psychotherapy Using the Enneagram in A Client with Depressive Disorder Case Study* · Korean Association of Christian Counseling & Psychology · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.23909/kjcc.2024.2.35.2.149
  Found: After the programme, depression, anxiety and anger fell and forgiveness and self-esteem rose; self-harm and chest pain also decreased. This is a single case with no control.
- 2024 · Sağıroğlu Ten, G. · *The effect of Enneagram personality types in-service training on teachers' student knowledge qualification* · Trakya University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · Turkey · not yet checked · https://tez.yok.gov.tr/UlusalTezMerkezi/TezGoster?key=cr4SkWLaRMhkDRBjqthpsR8LftsOWlVA-mv4aYG9Owc1SzES5XLt6HyDZQDpvxU0
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2024 · 김경희 · *Development and effects of a self-growth horticultural programme for heart-centre middle-aged women [에니어그램 가슴중심 중년기 여성의 자기성장 원예활동 프로그램 개발과 효과]* · Dankook University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T17086109
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2023 · Erkasap, A.; Ülgen, B. · *An investigation on the effect of enneagram types on organisational dissent* · Multidisciplinary Business Review, 16(1), 1-20 · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.35692/07183992.16.1.2
  Found: Types 9 and 2 predicted less organisational dissent and Types 7 and 6 predicted more. Type 7 strongly predicted voicing dissent openly, while Types 5 and 6 predicted keeping it hidden.
- 2023 · Kayserili, M.; Ülgen, B. · *The effect of managers' Enneagram personality types on ethical behavior perceptions and management styles [Turkish]* · İstanbul Ticaret Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 22(46), 608-635 · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.46928/iticusbe.1280774
  Found: Enneagram type had a low effect on managers' ethical behaviour perceptions, a moderate effect on democratic-participative management style and a high effect on autocratic style.
- 2023 · Ventura, P. M. A. · *Stress and well-being at work in primary health care teams: self-knowledge as a prevention strategy [Stress e Bem-estar no Trabalho em Equipas de Cuidados de Saúde Primários: Autoconhecimento como Estratégia de Prevenção]* · University of Coimbra, Faculty of Medicine (Integrated Master's in Medicine final thesis) · Result: Mixed · Portugal · https://hdl.handle.net/10316/111440
  Found: Quality of life rose after the course (p=.038); no significant change in stress, job well-being, self-awareness or self-compassion. Small uncontrolled pilot.
- 2023 · 김동윤; 박영진 · *Effect of Enneagram personality traits on nail-art choice and satisfaction [에니어그램 성격 특징이 네일아트 선택과 만족도에 미치는 영향]* · 한국휴먼이미지디자인 (Korean Journal of Human Image Design), 5(2), 121-134 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A108748790
  Found: Compared preference and satisfaction for type-matched versus self-chosen nail designs; a consumer-personalisation application with small, uncontrolled design.
- 2023 · 신은선 · *Nursing students' experience of interpersonal caring in an Enneagram-based care intervention programme [에니어그램 기반 돌봄중재 프로그램에 참여한 간호대학생의 사람돌봄 경험]* · 문화기술의 융합 (Journal of Convergence for Information Technology/culture), 9(6), 637-645 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A108846635
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2023 · 김지영 · *Developing a self-exploration programme for youth communication-competency education based on the Korean Enneagram [청소년의 의사소통역량교육을 위한 자아탐색프로그램 개발 연구]* · University of Suwon (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T16741052
  Found: Develops a Korean-Enneagram self-exploration programme to build youth communication competency; no outcome data in abstract.
- 2023 · 윤운성; 김새한별 · *Korean society before and after the COVID-19 pandemic as seen in Korean Enneagram Personality Type Test results [코로나-19 팬데믹 전후 한국형에니어그램성격유형검사에 나타난 한국사회 분석]* · 에니어그램 (한국에니어그램학회), 20(2), 71-98 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A108964242
  Found: Mean scores for types 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7 and 9 differed significantly pre- vs post-pandemic, interpreted as societal psychological change; non-equivalent online samples.
- 2022 · Pinheiro de Mendonça, I. C.; De Andrade Bastos, A. · *Programa de intervenção para a saúde mental em atletas e treinadores a partir do eneagrama* · Revista Brasileira de Psicologia do Esporte · Result: Mixed · Brazil · https://doi.org/10.31501/rbpe.v11i1.12352
  Found: No new data. The paper reviews Enneagram-based human-development interventions and their mental-health outcomes as a basis for a programme for athletes and coaches.
- 2022 · 권주희 · *Case study of a meditation-counselling programme using the Enneagram: Type 7 [에니어그램을 활용한 명상상담 프로그램 적용 사례연구]* · Dongbang Culture University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T16817106
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2021 · Boz, D.; Duran, C.; Meral, H. · *The effect of Enneagram personality types on job performance [Enneagram kişilik tiplerinin iş performansı üzerindeki etkisi]* · Elektronik Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 20(79), 1248-1261 · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.17755/esosder.727441
  Found: All types correlated positively with self-reported job performance, highest for Type 1 (r=.56, β=.44) and lowest for Type 7 (r=.22, β=.16). The authors suggest using type in hiring, which the wider evidence does not support.
- 2021 · Yang, Y. · *Effects of the Enneagram Group Counseling Program on Self-reflection and Interpersonal Relationship in Counseling Graduate Students* · The Journal of Humanities and Social sciences 21 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.22143/hss21.12.1.127
  Found: Self-reflection improved significantly compared with the control group, but interpersonal relationships did not. The sample was small and all measures were self-report.
- 2021 · Park, S.-H.; Lee, M.-N. · *A Case Study on Enneagram Personality Types, Interpersonal Relationships and Job Stress* · Asia-pacific Journal of Convergent Research Interchange · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.47116/apjcri.2021.11.16
  Found: The client reported better self-understanding and coping with interpersonal difficulties and job stress after Enneagram-informed counselling. This is a single case with no control.
- 2021 · 신나경 · *Effect of entrepreneurship on start-up intention by Enneagram personality type [에니어그램 성격유형에 따른 기업가정신이 창업의지에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구]* · Kookmin University Graduate School of Global Entrepreneurship (master's thesis) · Result: Critical · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15778514
  Found: Innovativeness and proactiveness predicted start-up intention; Enneagram type did not moderate the entrepreneurship–intention link and intention did not differ by type, though entrepreneurship levels did.
- 2021 · 정다훈 · *Developing an Enneagram-type-based programme for students struggling in mathematics [에니어그램 성격 유형에 기반한 수학 학습부진아 프로그램 개발 연구]* · Seoul National University of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15890558
  Found: Type-tailored maths activities were applied to three under-achieving pupils, who reported high satisfaction; no achievement outcome data.
- 2021 · 김민아 · *Effect of Enneagram personality type on choice of major [에니어그램 성격유형이 전공 선택에 미치는 영향 연구]* · Pai Chai University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15778094
  Found: Reports type differences in choice of major and suggests type-informed major/course selection; details not in retrieved abstract.
- 2020 · Navabifar, F.; Atashpour, H.; Golparvar, M. · *The effect of a premarital educational program based on nine personality types (Enneagram) on emotional expressiveness of couples preparing for marriage* · Iranian Journal of Psychiatry and Clinical Psychology, 26(1), 2-15 · Result: Mixed · Iran · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.32598/ijpcp.26.1.3128.1
  Found: Premarital Enneagram-based programme on emotional expressiveness; abstract not retrieved - check full text for results.
- 2020 · Navabifar, F.; Atashpour, S. H.; Golparvar, M. · *The effectiveness of an Enneagram typology training package on emotional self-regulation of couples in the premarital stage* ·  · Result: Mixed · Iran · not yet checked · https://socialworkmag.ir/article-1-530-en.html
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2020 · 김정희 · *Development and effectiveness of a Korean Enneagram parent-education programme using bibliotherapy [독서치료를 활용한 한국형에니어그램 부모교육프로그램 개발 및 효과 검증]* · Sun Moon University (doctoral dissertation); related articles in 에니어그램연구 17(2) and 18(2) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15681641
  Found: Qualitative data showed greater self-understanding, emotion regulation, acceptance of children and subjective happiness; quantitative results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2020 · 민요달 · *Development and effectiveness of an Enneagram programme for counsellor self-reflection [상담자 자기성찰을 위한 에니어그램 프로그램 개발 및 효과 검증]* · Seoul Buddhist Graduate University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15631349
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · Yu, K.; Shin, J. · *The Effects of the School Violence Prevention Program on Post-Traumatic Growth Using the Enneagram* · Korean Association For Learner-Centered Curriculum And Instruction · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.22251/jlcci.2019.19.21.1145
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · Jin, Y.-J.; Kim, S.-N.; Shin, Y.-J. · *The effect of selection factors on customer satisfaction in hair salons: evidence from customers with different Enneagram personality types* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A349012
  Found: Type 2 was the most common type. Five selection factors and three satisfaction factors were identified, and the link between them differed by Enneagram type, so the authors recommend type-aware salon marketing.
- 2019 · Min, Y.-D.; Sung, S. · *The effects of Enneagram group counseling on clinging and decentering* · Journal of the Korea Contents Association, 19(4), 502 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.5392/jkca.2019.19.04.502
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · Kim, H. · *The development and effectiveness of emotional leadership by Enneagram for nurse leaders* · Journal of the Korean Applied Science and Technology, 36(3), 737 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.12925/jkocs.2019.36.3.737
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · Techathaweerit, P.; Choochom, O. · *The effect of integrating Enneagram and existential group counseling on spiritual intelligence in working adults* · Srinakharinwirot University · Result: Mixed · Thailand · not yet checked · http://ir-ithesis.swu.ac.th/dspace/handle/123456789/279
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · 유경희; 신재한 · *Effects of an Enneagram-based counselling programme for victims and perpetrators of school violence on post-traumatic growth [에니어그램을 활용한 학교폭력 피․가해 학생 상담프로그램이 외상후성장에 미친 영향]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4010027442211
  Found: The retrieved abstract is truncated before the results; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · 공주현 · *Effects of a type-matched reading-guidance programme: Focusing on Enneagram type 6 [성격유형을 적용한 맞춤 독서지도 프로그램의 효과 연구]* · Sangmyung University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T15395394
  Found: Evaluates emotional intelligence and career maturity after type-matched reading; very small uncontrolled sample.
- 2018 · Ho, G. · *The box is where we began: Evaluating Enneagram-based leadership development for Catholic school leaders in Indonesia* · Lamar University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · Indonesia · not yet checked
  Found: Positive change in leadership versatility but no significant change in insight (per Hook et al. 2021). I could not access the original.
- 2018 ·  · *The effect of introducing new educational methods with consideration to the Enneagram personality type model on the attitude of students in programming practice classes* · Information: An International Interdisciplinary Journal · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1522262180793112448
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 · Won, H.-J.; Park, S.-H. · *The effect of communication ability of nursing college students on adjustment to college life by Enneagram personality type* · Health & Welfare, 20(4), 159-177 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.23948/kshw.2018.12.20.4.159
  Found: Different communication sub-skills predicted college adjustment within each centre; goal-setting ability mattered across centres. Cross-sectional design.
- 2018 ·  · *A cases of Enneagram counselling strategy programs* · Journal of Meditation based Psychological Counseling, 18(1) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.12972/mpca.20180002
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 ·  · *Enneagram program analysis in South Korea: Focused on Enneagram education, spirituality, counseling program* · Journal of Meditation based Psychological Counseling, 18(1) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.12972/mpca.20180003
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 ·  · *A case of relieving stress and improvement of relationship with spouse by Enneagram program* · Journal of Meditation based Psychological Counseling, 18(1) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.12972/mpca.20180004
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 ·  · *Counseling cases using personality types of Enneagram* · Journal of Meditation based Psychological Counseling, 18(1) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.12972/mpca.20180005
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 · 김응자 · *Effects of an Enneagram programme on university students' self-understanding [에니어그램 프로그램이 대학생의 자기이해에 미치는 효과]* · 코칭연구 (Korean Journal of Coaching) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://db.koreascholar.com/Article?code=351781
  Found: Self-understanding improved significantly after the programme, including stability, goal orientation, role recognition, self-acceptance and self-assertion. No control group.
- 2018 · Kuit, W. · *Development and evaluation of the coach-athlete relationship enhancement intervention* · Nelson Mandela University · Result: Supportive · South Africa · http://hdl.handle.net/10948/22508
  Found: The Enneagram-based CARE intervention significantly improved coach–athlete relationship quality (closeness, commitment, complementarity, co-orientation). Participants also reported better mutual understanding, self-awareness and team relationships.
- 2018 · 최종환 · *A teaching method for 'self-exploration writing' using the Enneagram in a university liberal-arts course [대학 교양 교과에서 에니어그램을 활용한 ‘자기탐색 글쓰기’ 지도 방법 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://digital.kyobobook.co.kr/digital/article/articleDetail.ink?barcode=4010026808579
  Found: The retrieved abstract is truncated. It describes designing an Enneagram-linked self-exploration writing method and judging how well it met liberal-arts writing goals; check the full text for results.
- 2018 · 김동성 · *An analysis of Enneagram programmes in Korea: education, spirituality and counselling programmes [국내 에니어그램 프로그램 분석 : 에니어그램 교육, 영성, 상담 프로그램을 중심으로]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3639101
  Found: Maps the theories, structure and workshop features of Korean Enneagram programmes, and picks out three elements for an integrated mindfulness–Enneagram programme: finding one's basic type, childhood, and growth through conscious reflection. Descriptive, no outcome data.
- 2018 · 주혜옥 · *Using the Enneagram in a special education programme for parents of school-violence perpetrators [학교폭력특별교육 학부모프로그램에서의 에니어그램 활용]* · 에니어그램연구 (Enneagram Research) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A345298
  Found: The body (gut) centre was most common among parents, and 88.7% were Types 1, 2 or 9. Parents reported improved self-reflection and understanding of their children on post-programme evaluations. No control group.
- 2018 · 이소윤 · *A counselling case using an Enneagram counselling strategy programme: improving conflict with parents [에니어그램 상담전략 프로그램을 통한 상담사례-부모와의 갈등개선을 중심으로]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3639100
  Found: The client learned to notice and express emotions, and anxiety linked to conflict with parents eased. Single uncontrolled case.
- 2018 · 차연희 · *Implementation and effects of reading guidance applying Enneagram personality types [에니어그램 성격유형을 적용한 독서지도 실행 및 효과 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050027143035
  Found: The retrieved abstract is truncated before the results; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 · Koch, K. A. · *Examining the effect of Enneagram competence on empathy in college students* · Baylor University · Result: Supportive · USA · https://baylor-ir.tdl.org/handle/2104/10383
  Found: Enneagram competence significantly predicted empathy. The author cautions that knowing the Enneagram without applying it in relationships may do more harm than good. The repository page gives no sample size.
- 2018 · 김동성 · *An integrated programme of mindfulness meditation and the Enneagram: Focusing on Korean Enneagram programmes [알아차림 명상과 에니어그램의 통합 프로그램 연구]* · Dongbang Culture University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T14783792
  Found: Analysed domestic Enneagram programmes and designed a three-step (self-understanding, self-discovery, ...) mindfulness-Enneagram programme; no outcome data.
- 2017 · 박순례; 정애리; Yoo, S. · *The effect of group program using Enneagram on prostituted women's self-esteem and perceived stress* · The Women's Studies, 94(3), 141-173 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.33949/tws.2017.94.3.005
  Found: Self-esteem rose and perceived stress fell relative to controls. Very small, non-randomised sample.
- 2017 · Park, J. S. [박진성] · *A case of improving interpersonal relationships through the Enneagram Four Noble Truths counselling strategy program [에니어그램 고집멸도 상담전략 프로그램을 통한 대인관계 개선 사례]* · Korean journal (kstudy) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3637718
  Found: Describes one client's interpersonal improvement after an 8-session Enneagram meditation counselling programme; single case, no standardised measures reported.
- 2017 · 박순례; 유순화; 정애리 · *Effects of an Enneagram-based group programme on self-esteem and perceived stress of women victims of sex trafficking [에니어그램을 활용한 집단프로그램이 성매매피해여성의 자아존중감과 지각된스트레스에 미치는 효과]* · 여성연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4010026094637
  Found: Abstract not retrieved in full; check the full text before citing.
- 2017 · 김정희; 윤운성 · *Effects of an Enneagram-based reading-counsellor training programme on self-esteem and parenting efficacy of parents of elementary pupils [에니어그램에 기반을 둔 독서상담사 양성프로그램이 초등학생 자녀를 둔 학부모의 자아존중감과 양육효능감에 미치는 효과]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 14(2), 63-90 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A105064499
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2017 · 김정훈 · *Effect of Enneagram type on vocational preference: Mediating role of Enneagram (development) level [에니어그램 유형이 직업선호도에 미치는 영향]* · Daehan Theological Graduate University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T16718195
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2016 · Lee, G.; Kim, S. · *The effects of an Enneagram program on codependency, anger, and interpersonal relationship in wives of alcoholics* · Journal of Korean Academy of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 25(3), 166 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.12934/jkpmhn.2016.25.3.166
  Found: Tested an Enneagram programme for codependency, anger and relationships; abstract not retrieved - check full text for effect sizes.
- 2016 · Kim, S.-M.; Ryu, C.-S.; Chung, J.-I. · *The effects of Enneagram personality types in the robot programming classes: Centering around the robot department students of a technical high school* · International Journal of u- and e-Service, Science and Technology, 9(9), 121-128 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.14257/ijunesst.2016.9.9.13
  Found: Students in different centres preferred visual vs text programming tools differently, and achievement differed by tool preference. The abstract reports no statistics.
- 2016 · Kim, S. · *Nudge effect of the French writing strategies based on the learners' Enneagram personality types* · Etudes de la Culture Francaise et des Arts en France, 55, 417-456 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.21651/cfaf.2016.55..417
  Found: More frequent type-tailored nudges were associated with better French writing grades and motivation. No control group.
- 2016 · Kim, D. S. [김동성] · *Effects of a program integrating mindfulness meditation and the Enneagram on office workers' stress relief [알아차림 명상과 에니어그램을 통합한 프로그램이 직장인의 스트레스 완화에 미치는 영향]* · Korean journal (kstudy) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3509963
  Found: Mindful attention correlated inversely with job stress, and 11 of 14 follow-up participants reported reduced job stress; no control group and high attrition.
- 2016 · Ahn, S. Y.; Kim, I. R.; Koh, A. R. [안서영; 김이랑; 고애란] · *Meaning transfer by consumer personality type: Focusing on TV beauty programs [소비자 성격유형에 따른 의미전이]* · Korean journal (papersearch) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.papersearch.net/google_link/fulltext.asp?file_name=02806460.pdf
  Found: Head, heart and body-centred consumers took different cultural meanings from TV beauty programmes; small exploratory sample.
- 2016 · Kim, S. M. [김선미] · *The nudge effect of French writing learning strategies using learners' Enneagram types [학습자의 에니어그램 성격유형을 활용한 프랑스어 쓰기 학습전략의 넛지 효과]* · Etudes de la Culture Francaise et de Arts en France · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.dbpia.co.kr/journal/articleDetail?nodeId=NODE06613507
  Found: Type-informed teacher nudges at high frequency were associated with improved French writing grades; no control group.
- 2016 · Ryu, K. O.; Park, J. W. [류권옥; 박재원] · *Effects of the Enneagram psychodynamic test on adolescents' self-concept: Participants of the 'Classroom of Love' [에니어그램 심리역동검사가 청소년의 자아개념에 미치는 영향]* · Korean journal (newnonmun) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=10755367
  Found: Evaluated an Enneagram-based programme for police-referred youth on self-concept; abstract does not report results, and there was no control group.
- 2016 · Kim, J. H.; Yoon, U. S. [김정희; 윤운성] · *Development of an Enneagram psychomotor character education program for adolescents [청소년 인성계발을 위한 에니어그램심리운동 인성교육 프로그램의 개발]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Journal of Enneagram Studies) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A303431
  Found: No outcome data: designs an Enneagram plus psychomotor character-education programme aligned to Korea's 2015 Character Education Act.
- 2016 · Jeong, Y. G. [정용구] · *Development and use of an integrated healing program for inmate rehabilitation [재소자 교정을 위한 통합적 치유프로그램개발과 활용]* · Korean journal (newnonmun) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.newnonmun.com/dlink/10758125.pdf
  Found: Developed an Enneagram-based healing programme for prisoners through two expert ratings and a pilot, revised from participant reports; no outcome statistics.
- 2016 · 김슬아 · *Developing an Enneagram group counselling programme to improve middle-school students' self-directed learning [중학생의 자기주도학습능력 향상을 위한 에니어그램 활용 집단상담 프로그램 개발]* · Korea National University of Education Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T14047602
  Found: Evaluates self-directed learning ability against controls; result figures not in retrieved abstract.
- 2015 · Cho, H.-Y.; Han, Y.-O.; Paek, J.-H. · *A study on the effects of reading guidance using a happy point books, focused on Enneagram personality type 2* · Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science, 49(1), 69-88 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.4275/kslis.2015.49.1.069
  Found: Emotional intelligence and self-esteem improved after the programme, and pupils were highly satisfied. One-group design with no control.
- 2015 · Delvo, M. K. · *The Enneagram as a facilitator of self-awareness in emerging leader programs* · University of Minnesota (Master of Liberal Studies final project) · Result: Mixed · USA · not yet checked · http://hdl.handle.net/11299/174949
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2015 · Choi, J. H. [최정혜] · *Development of a children's self-leadership program applying Enneagram coaching [에니어그램 코칭을 적용한 유아 셀프리더십 프로그램 개발]* · 코칭연구 (Korean Journal of Coaching) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://db.koreascholar.com/Article?code=306327
  Found: No outcome data: describes an 8-chapter Enneagram-coaching self-leadership program for young children.
- 2015 · Cho, H. Y.; Han, Y. O.; Baek, J. H. [조현양] · *A study on the effect of reading guidance using growth-point books [성장지향점 도서를 활용한 독서지도 효과에 관한 연구]* · 한국문헌정보학회지 (Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.dbpia.co.kr/Journal/ArticleDetail/NODE06292018
  Found: Emotional intelligence and self-esteem rose after the programme and students were satisfied; no control group, small sample.
- 2015 · Lee, J. Y. [이지영] · *Development of an adolescent character education program using the Enneagram [에니어그램을 활용한 청소년 인성교육 프로그램 개발]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Journal of Enneagram Studies) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A249776
  Found: No outcome data: designs an Enneagram-based character-education programme for adolescents with planned evaluation measures.
- 2015 · 김남북 · *Process and effects of Korean Enneagram group counselling on the ego-identity of juvenile prisoners [소년수형자의 자아정체감에 미치는 한국형에니어그램 집단상담의 과정 및 효과분석]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 12(2), 43-71 (from Kyonggi University master's thesis, 2014) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A101735746
  Found: 12 of 20 were gut-centred; ego-identity improved after a dynamic theory-plus-activity programme; no control group.
- 2014 · Choi, G. · *The study on the job stress reduction of EAP utilizing Enneagram: focused on the service workers in the facilities for the disabled* · Theology and Society · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.kci.go.kr/kciportal/ci/sereArticleSearch/ciSereArtiView.kci?sereArticleSearchBean.artiId=ART001943973
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2014 · Kim, E.; Lee, J. · *Effects of an Enneagram-centred group art therapy programme on parenting stress of non-employed mothers of young children [유아를 둔 미취업 어머니의 양육스트레스 감소를 위한 에니어그램 중심 집단미술치료 프로그램 효과]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A240364
  Found: The programme significantly reduced parenting stress compared with controls. Very small sample.
- 2014 · 이용오 · *Effectiveness of an Enneagram character-education programme for elementary students [에니어그램을 통한 초등학생 인성교육 프로그램의 효과성에 관한 연구]* · 대한안전경영과학회 학술대회논문집 (Korea Safety Management & Science conference), 2014, 295-310 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A102652144
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2014 · 권은실 · *Effect of stress level on coping by Enneagram type among beauty-industry workers [에니어그램 성격유형별 미용종사자의 스트레스 수준이 대처방식에 미치는 영향]* · Seokyeong University Graduate School of Beauty Arts (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T13419710
  Found: Job-expectation dissatisfaction predicted chronic fatigue among types 5, 6, 7 and 8, with type 8 reporting the most job-related psychological stress.
- 2014 · 좌영자 · *Effects of an Enneagram career-exploration programme on middle-school students' career maturity [에니어그램 진로탐색프로그램이 중학생의 진로성숙에 미치는 효과]* · Jeju National University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T13535518
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2013 · Lee, D. · *Effects of an Enneagram-based Four Noble Truths meditation counselling programme on anger reduction [에니어그램(Enneagram)에 기초한 고집멸도 명상상담 프로그램이 분노 감소에 미치는 효과성 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3246256
  Found: The participant's rate of repeated anger fell over 3 months of counselling. The change was attributed to breathing and mindfulness practices and the therapeutic relationship, so the Enneagram's specific contribution is unclear.
- 2013 · Yoon, U.; Lim, H.; Park, H. · *Exploratory development of an Enneagram spiritual meditation programme [에니어그램 영성 명상 프로그램 탐색 연구 개발]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A210286
  Found: No data. Proposes a draft Enneagram spirituality and meditation programme.
- 2013 · Yoon, U.; Jo, J. · *Development of an Enneagram healing programme focusing on NLP and EFT [에니어그램 힐링 프로그램 개발 - NLP와 EFT를 중심으로]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A210284
  Found: No outcome data. Combines the Enneagram with NLP and EFT techniques in a healing programme.
- 2013 · Moon, H. · *Effects of an Enneagram group counselling programme on the job attitudes of junior military officers [에니어그램에 기초한 집단상담프로그램이 군 초급간부의 직무태도에 미치는 효과]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article.aspx?sn=210277
  Found: Job characteristics (variety, autonomy, significance) and job satisfaction (achievement, peer and superior relations) rose significantly after the programme.
- 2013 · Yoon, U.; Lee, J.; Jo, J.; Choi, J. · *Development of the 'Happiness Plus' Enneagram coaching programme [행복더하기 에니어그램코칭 프로그램 개발]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A210287
  Found: No outcome data. Builds a coaching model (self-observation, self-understanding, self-transformation, self-completion) from the Enneagram, positive psychology and Wilber's quadrants.
- 2013 · 오은정 · *Effects of an Enneagram career programme on middle-school students' ego-resilience and career maturity [에니어그램 진로프로그램이 중학생의 자아탄력성과 진로성숙도에 미치는 영향]* · Changwon National University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T13261953
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2013 · 오명숙; 박현경; 윤운성 · *The effect of Korean Enneagram stage training on psychological well-being and life satisfaction [한국형에니어그램 단계교육이 심리적 안녕감 및 생활만족도에 미치는 영향]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 10(1), 103-127 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A99909960
  Found: Participants at higher training stages (4, 4.5, 5) reported higher well-being, personal growth, self-acceptance and life satisfaction; cross-sectional, self-selection and programme-developer authorship limit causal claims.
- 2013 · 김혜영 · *Development and effects of a children's Enneagram programme [아동용 에니어그램 프로그램 개발 및 효과]* · Changwon National University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T13109419
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2012 · 강호선 · *A study on the effects of Enneagram programs on the professional domestic violence counselors empowerment* · Korean Journal of Family Social Work, 36, 61-92 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.16975/kjfsw.2012..36.003
  Found: Self, organisational and client-change empowerment reportedly improved significantly relative to a control group, and participants rated the programme as effective. Very small sample.
- 2012 · Jang, K. · *Development and effects of an Enneagram-based self-encouragement programme for children from multicultural families [에니어그램을 활용한 다문화가정아동의 자기격려 프로그램 개발 및 효과]* · 코칭연구 (Coaching Research) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://db.koreascholar.com/article.aspx?code=243932
  Found: Self-encouragement scores rose after the programme in children of all three centres. There was no control group and the sample was small.
- 2012 · Yoon, U.; Ryu, J.; Kim, M. S. · *A preliminary study on developing an Enneagram-based family therapy programme [에니어그램을 활용한 가족치료 프로그램개발의 시안연구]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A192473
  Found: No outcome data. Describes the development of an Enneagram family therapy programme for dysfunctional families and counsellors.
- 2012 · Rasta, M.; Hosseinian, S.; Ahghar, G.; Azad, I. · *A survey on the effectiveness of nine-type personality training (Enneagram) on the mental health (anxiety and self-esteem) of school girls* ·  · Result: Mixed · Iran · not yet checked · https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/944f092c6bf3d37e4d3163ea36b799ce865aa07a
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2011 · Koo, H. · *Effects of the Enneagram group counseling program on self-esteem, anxiety and interpersonal relationships in nursing students* · Journal of Korean Academic Society of Nursing Education, 17(3), 444-453 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.5977/jkasne.2011.17.3.444
  Found: Evaluated effects on self-esteem, anxiety and relationships; abstract not retrieved - check full text for results.
- 2011 · Sepehrian, F.; Galavandee, H. · *The effect of Enneagram training on decrease of marital conflict* ·  · Result: Mixed · Iran · not yet checked · https://www.sid.ir/En/Journal/ViewPaper.aspx?ID=221294
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2011 · Lee, S.; Kim, E.; Park, H. · *The change in the father's role through the Enneagram Emotional Leadership Program* · Korean Journal of Family Welfare · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.kci.go.kr/kciportal/ci/sereArticleSearch/ciSereArtiView.kci?sereArticleSearchBean.artiId=ART001591169
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2011 · Shin, Y. · *Experiences of Enneagram Type 4 people and nursing intervention [에니어그램 4번 유형의 경험과 간호중재]* · Hanyang University repository · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://repository.hanyang.ac.kr/handle/20.500.11754/139947
  Found: Describes the lived experience of Type 4 people (e.g. themes of spiritual growth, self-acceptance, seeking change and support) to inform nursing interventions.
- 2011 · Choi, K. · *A theoretical review of Enneagram programmes for improving academic ability [학업능력 향상을 위한 에니어그램 프로그램의 이론적 고찰]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A163241
  Found: Reviews prior studies linking type to learning styles, goals and motivation, and recommends type-specific learning coaching programmes; based on secondary sources.
- 2011 · Jin, J. · *Relationship between leadership programme types and Enneagram personality types [리더십 프로그램 유형과 에니어그램 성격유형간의 관계 연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A163245
  Found: Programme effects differed by type and group: soldiers gained more from acquisition-type programmes and civilians from awareness-type programmes.
- 2011 · 김주희 · *Effects of an Enneagram parent-coaching programme on mothers' parenting stress [에니어그램을 활용한 부모코칭프로그램이 어머니의 양육스트레스에 미치는 효과]* · Sookmyung Women's University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12288423
  Found: Evaluates change in parenting stress after the Korea Parent Coaching Center Enneagram workshop; outcome figures not retrieved.
- 2011 · 조주영 · *The effect of the Enneagram Career Guidance Program on university students' career maturity [에니어그램진로지도 프로그램이 대학생의 진로성숙에 미치는 효과]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 8(2), 189-229 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A60020371
  Found: Career identity and self-efficacy improved after the programme and participants rated it helpful; no randomisation reported.
- 2011 · 곽영현 · *Effects of a Korean Enneagram programme on male high-school students' self-understanding [한국형 에니어그램 프로그램이 남자고등학생의 자기이해에 미치는 영향]* · Changwon National University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12544035
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2011 · 최숙희 · *Developing a communication programme for adolescent-mother conflict regulation using the Enneagram [청소년 자녀와 어머니의 갈등조절을 위한 의사소통 프로그램 개발]* · Hannam University Graduate School of Interdisciplinary Theology (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12274072
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2010 · Godin, J. · *The effect of the Enneagram on psychological well-being and unconditional self-acceptance of young adults* · Iowa State University · Result: Mixed · USA · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.31274/etd-180810-2243
  Found: Tested whether learning the Enneagram improves psychological wellbeing and unconditional self-acceptance; full results not retrieved here - check the dissertation before citing an effect.
- 2010 · Hendrati, F. · *Improving marital harmony in couples in the early years of marriage through a modified Enneagram programme [Peningkatan keharmonisan perkawinan pada pasangan suami-istri di tahap awal usia perkawinan melalui penerapan modifikasi program Enneagram]* · Universitas Gadjah Mada (repository) · Result: Mixed · Indonesia · not yet checked · https://repository.ugm.ac.id/94483/
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2010 · Yoon, U.; Cho, J.; Park, H. · *A draft study for developing an Enneagram-based career guidance programme [에니어그램을 활용한 진로지도 프로그램개발의 시안연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article.aspx?sn=134183
  Found: No data. Argues the Enneagram's developmental levels add vertical information that MBTI and Holland lack, and proposes an individualised career guidance programme.
- 2010 · 옥혜진 · *An Enneagram-based music programme to improve adjustment of maladjusted students [학교 부적응 학생의 적응력 향상을 위한 음악프로그램 연구]* · Seoul National University of Education Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12137641
  Found: Same materials were delivered differently by type (e.g., type 4 favourite-song accompaniment, type 7 varied activities), improving engagement; qualitative.
- 2010 · 박미영 · *Changes in mothers' self-esteem and family functioning after an Enneagram self-understanding programme [에니어그램을 활용한 자기이해 프로그램 실행에 따른 어머니의 자아존중감 및 가족기능의 변화]* · Kwangwoon University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12543185
  Found: Family functioning improved in communication, roles, emotional response and involvement (not behavioural control); type 2 changed most.
- 2009 · Son, B.; Lee, K. · *The effectiveness of an Enneagram programme for self-esteem, interpersonal relationships, and depression of people with chronic mental illness* · Korean Academy of Nursing conference (한국간호과학회 학술대회) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.dbpia.co.kr/Journal/ArticleDetail/NODE02322180
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2009 · Cho, G.; Joo, H. · *The effect of a career exploration programme based on the Enneagram on career decision-making self-efficacy of university students* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.kci.go.kr/kciportal/ci/sereArticleSearch/ciSereArtiView.kci?sereArticleSearchBean.artiId=ART001370042
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2009 · Vitali Aguilar, P.; Walter Fernando · *A teacher personality proposal based on the Enneagram to develop the personal dimension of students in higher pedagogical institutes [Propuesta de personalidad docente basada en la concepción del eneagrama...]* · Universidad Nacional de Trujillo · Result: Supportive · Peru · http://dspace.unitru.edu.pe/handle/UNITRU/5759
  Found: Students' personality levels and 'uncentred' features improved after the programme; no control group.
- 2009 · 김지영 · *Effects of an Enneagram parent-education programme on mothers' ego-identity, understanding of children and parent-child communication [에니어그램을 활용한 부모교육프로그램이 어머니의 자아정체감, 자녀이해 및 부모-자녀 의사소통에 미치는 영향]* · Myongji University Graduate School of Social Welfare (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11749021
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract excerpt; very small uncontrolled sample.
- 2009 · 신영숙 · *Effects of an Enneagram marital-enhancement programme for midlife couples in Cheongyang [에니어그램을 활용한 부부관계향상 프로그램의 효과에 대한 연구]* · Sun Moon University Graduate School of Social Welfare (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11769792
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract excerpt; very small sample.
- 2009 · 이미련 · *Effects of an Enneagram group counselling programme on ego-identity, interpersonal relations and self-efficacy of delinquent adolescents [에니어그램 집단상담 프로그램이 비행청소년의 자아정체감, 대인관계 및 자기효능감에 미치는 효과]* · Kyungpook National University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11597086
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract excerpt – check full text.
- 2008 · 장록주 · *A marital-enhancement programme using the Enneagram [에니어그램을 사용한 부부관계증진 프로그램 연구]* · Hannam University Graduate School of Interdisciplinary Theology (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11151886
  Found: Develops an intimacy programme for midlife couples based on type differences; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2008 · 이선영 · *Effects of an Enneagram group programme on couples' marital satisfaction [부부의 결혼만족에 대한 에니어그램집단 프로그램의 효과에 관한 연구]* · Soongsil University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11381336
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2008 · 박은숙 · *Effects of an Enneagram school-violence prevention programme on interpersonal relations of perpetrators [에니어그램을 활용한 학교폭력 예방프로그램이 학교폭력 가해학생의 대인관계 향상에 미치는 효과]* · Changwon National University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11285862
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2008 · 윤승범 · *Effects of an Enneagram programme on ward nurses' self-esteem and human relationships [에니어그램 프로그램이 병동 간호사들의 자아존중감 및 인간관계에 미치는 영향]* · Korea University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11253338
  Found: No significant effect on self-esteem; independence/responsibility, communication and understanding improved.
- 2007 · Choi, J. · *Applying the Enneagram in a self-growth group counselling programme [자기성장 집단상담 프로그램에서의 에니어그램 적용에 대한 연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A55425
  Found: Participants reported it helped them understand themselves, others and their motives; very small sample, self-report only, no control group.
- 2007 · Oh, J. · *A family-welfare approach to the Enneagram: Focusing on improving marital relationships [에니어그램의 가족복지적접근]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article.aspx?sn=55422
  Found: No data. Proposes a five-stage Enneagram programme to improve marital communication.
- 2007 · 권경숙 · *Effects of an Enneagram education programme on full-time housewives' stress coping and parenting attitudes [에니어그램 교육프로그램이 전업주부의 스트레스 대처방식과 자녀양육태도에 미치는 영향]* · University of Ulsan Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11044611
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract excerpt; small uncontrolled sample.
- 2007 · 고희숙 · *Comparative effectiveness of personality-type programmes in social-work practice: Enneagram vs MBTI [사회복지실천에서 성격유형프로그램의 효과성에 관한 비교 연구]* · Wonkwang University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10857870
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2006 · Cowan, P. L. · *The Enneagram: An action research project to establish the effect of introducing the Enneagram, a model of personality, as an intervention to a team* · MSc dissertation (Change Agent Skills and Strategies), School of Management, University of Surrey · Result: Mixed · UK · http://www.rosemarycowan.co.uk/resources/EnneagramOrganisationalContext.pdf
  Found: Participants reported higher disclosure, better understanding of colleagues and a shift from London-Bristol tensions to teamwork, though some were sceptical of their type. Single team, participant-researcher with a conflict of interest, self-reported outcomes.
- 2006 · Romould, E. J. · *Development of an enneagram educational programme for enhancing emotional intelligence of student teachers* · Doctoral thesis (Shodhganga) · Result: Mixed · India · not yet checked · https://shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/jspui/handle/10603/58377
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2006 · 오은경 · *에니어그램 프로그램이 학교폭력 가해 청소년의 심리적 적응에 미치는 효과* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A35054
  Found: Aggression (p=.006), depression (p=.021) and interpersonal relationships (p=.029) improved significantly, while self-esteem did not (2.93 to 2.95). Sample size and control group not reported in the abstract.
- 2006 · 이광자; 손봉희 · *에니어그램 프로그램이 만성정신질환자의 자아개념, 역할기능, 삶의 만족도에 미치는 영향* · Health & Nursing · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://kmbase.medric.or.kr/Main.aspx?menu=01&d=KMBASE&m=VIEW&i=0388520060180010009
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2006 · Yoon, U.; Cho, S. · *Effects of Enneagram-based group counselling on adolescents' interpersonal relationships and school adjustment [에니어그램을 활용한 집단상담이 청소년들의 대인관계와 학교생활적응에 미치는 효과]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://www.earticle.net/Article.aspx?sn=35061
  Found: Relationships with parents, teachers and friends and school adjustment improved significantly after the programme; no control group is described, so effects cannot be attributed to the programme alone.
- 2006 · 주희진 (Ju, Hee Jin); 조규판 (Cho, Gyu Pan) · *The effect of a self-concept promotion programme using the Enneagram on university students' self-efficacy [에니어그램을 활용한 자아증진 프로그램이 대학생의 자기효능감에 미치는 효과]* · 釜山敎育學硏究 (Busan Educational Research), 19(1), 41-61 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75631631
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2006 · 김상구 · *Effects of an Enneagram programme on self-esteem and human relationships [에니어그램 프로그램이 자아존중감 및 인간관계에 미치는 영향]* · Yonsei University Graduate School of Political Science and Economics (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10728497
  Found: Hypothesised improvements in self-esteem and relationships; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2006 · 도경숙 · *Effects of an Enneagram peer-counselling programme on middle-aged women's self-actualisation [에니어그램을 활용한 동료상담 프로그램이 중년여성의 자아실현에 미치는 효과]* · Catholic University of Korea Graduate School of Social Welfare (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11006132
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2005 · 이영호; 황경란; 김종호 · *자녀 양육태도 변화를 위한 에니어그램 부모교육 집단프로그램에 관한 연구* ·  · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025234249
  Found: Between groups, the experimental group changed in affectionate parenting attitude; within group, affectionate, rejecting and autonomous attitudes changed (p<.05). Small sample, self-report.
- 2005 · 전영수; 최병순 · *에니어그램을 활용한 인간관계 향상 프로그램 개발* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A24979
  Found: After the Enneagram leadership programme, officers' task- and relationship-oriented leadership scores rose significantly and organisational climate reportedly improved. Design details and control group unclear.
- 2005 · 차명숙 · *Effects of an Enneagram programme on middle-school students' self- and other-acceptance [에니어그램 프로그램이 중학생의 자아수용 및 타인수용에 미치는 효과]* · Changwon National University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10699200
  Found: Reports positive changes in self-understanding and relationships; abstract excerpt is unclear on design and figures.
- 2005 · 허진 · *Effects of Enneagram group counselling on adolescents' ego-identity [에니어그램 집단상담이 청소년의 자아정체감에 미치는 효과]* · Yeungnam University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10696375
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2004 · 윤운성 · *한국형 에니어그램 집단상담이 실업계 고등학교 학생들의 진로성숙에 미치는 효과* · 교육심리연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.ndsl.kr/ndsl/search/detail/article/articleSearchResultDetail.do?cn=ART001102009
  Found: Examines the effect of a Korean Enneagram group counselling programme on career maturity; the retrieved abstract is truncated and does not report results. Check the full text before citing.
- 2004 · Youn, Y.; 이규복 · *The effect of Korean Enneagram training program related to the career maturity levels of the vocational high school students* · The Korean Journal of Educational Psychology, 18, 367-380 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/0e7ac58e3e9bde2c42314019f636ba1e0a9e2381
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2004 · 정병국 · *Effects of an Enneagram education programme on self-esteem and achievement goals: Comparison with Sasang constitution [에니어그램 교육 프로그램이 자아존중감과 학업성취목표에 미치는 영향]* · Chosun University Graduate School of Environmental Health (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T9939744
  Found: Evaluates self-esteem and learning-goal change; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2004 · 최현미 · *Effects of an Enneagram career-searching programme on adolescents' career identity [에니어그램 진로탐색 프로그램이 청소년의 진로정체감에 미치는 효과]* · Changwon National University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T9855714
  Found: Programme reported to improve career identity and consciousness; design details not in retrieved abstract.
- 2003 · 박기원 · *Using the Enneagram as a personality-development programme for university students [대학생들의 인성개발 프로그램으로서의 애니어그램 활용]* · 學生生活硏究 (Jeju National University Student Life Research Institute), 24, 169-186 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A330006
  Found: No data. Argues for Enneagram-based personality-development programmes in university student services.
- 2003 · 허혜자 · *Development of a children's Enneagram programme [아동용 에니어그램 프로그램 개발]* · Changwon National University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T9469282
  Found: Adapted adult Enneagram workshops for children over two years; many children showed interest in self-understanding. No controlled outcome data.
- 2003 · 이지희 · *Effects of an Enneagram programme on ego defence and self-differentiation [에니어그램 프로그램이 자아방어 및 자아분화 수준에 미치는 영향]* · Pusan National University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10026624
  Found: Results not in retrieved abstract excerpt; small uncontrolled sample.
- 2003 · 홍순우 · *Effects of an Enneagram education programme on adolescents' ego-identity and self-actualisation [에니어그램 교육프로그램이 청소년의 자아정체감과 자아실현에 미치는 효과]* · Korea University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T8909027
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2002 · 이종의 · *Effects of an Enneagram education programme on self-esteem, self-acceptance and parenting attitudes [에니어그램 교육프로그램이 자아존중감, 자아수용, 자녀양육태도에 미치는 영향]* · Myongji University Graduate School of Social Education (master's thesis) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T8627959
  Found: Affectionate parenting rose (42.73→45.76, p<.05), rejection fell (36.88→33.83, p<.05) and autonomy rose (42.03→46.69, p<.001); control-style parenting unchanged.
- 2001 · 윤운성; 이은하 · *Development and application of an Enneagram training programme: University students' ego-identity and life satisfaction [애니어그램 훈련프로그램의 개발과 적용]* · 학생생활연구 (Sun Moon University Student Life Research Institute), 5, 91-127 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75014408
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2000 · 김병채; 김영복 · *Transformation of life through an Enneagram workshop [에니어그램(Enneagram) 워크숍을 통한 삶의 변화]* · 학생생활연구 (창원대학교 학생생활연구소), 13, 43-79 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A2093162
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 1990 · Likhittam, W. · *The comparative effects of the human potential seminar and the enneagram workshop on self-actualization and interpersonal relationships of selected Filipino professionals* · Doctoral dissertation (Counseling Psychology), De La Salle University · Result: Mixed · Philippines · https://animorepository.dlsu.edu.ph/etd_doctoral/670/
  Found: The Enneagram workshop group gained significantly in self-actualisation (p<.05) but gains were not sustained at one-month follow-up; author concluded both interventions were effective.

## Level E · Theory or case (251 studies)

- 2026 · Maia Neto, J. D.; Valente, V. de C.; Fernandez, P. E. C. · *The Enneagram of personality in clinical psychology: Historical foundations, neuroscientific validation, and therapeutic integration* · Revista de Geopolítica, 17(7), e2750 · Result: Mixed · Brazil · https://doi.org/10.56238/revgeov17n7-019
  Found: Concludes RHETI and iEQ9 show acceptable reliability, but the nine-factor structure replicates inconsistently and direct neuroscience evidence is scarce and preliminary despite the title; no randomised trials show better therapy outcomes. Published in a geopolitics journal, an unusual venue.
- 2026 · Moore, M. · *Conceptual hypothesis: An integrative map of mind for coaches* · Global Advances in Integrative Medicine and Health, 15 · Result: Mixed · USA · https://doi.org/10.1177/27536130261469190
  Found: Proposes a single nine-part coaching map that lines the Enneagram up with mainstream models; offered explicitly as a working hypothesis with no data. Author leads a coaching school that uses the model.
- 2026 · Greenberg, S.; Fraser, L. · *Nine types of desire: Clinical and empirical perspectives on use of the Enneagram in psychosexual therapy* · International Journal of Psychosexual Therapy, 1(Suppl), 21-22 · Result: Supportive · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.64207/zpqmx926
  Found: Reports nine patterns of sexual desire linked to the nine types and says Enneagram-informed sex therapy speeds progress and deepens intimacy. Evidence is clinical observation; no controlled data reported.
- 2026 · Wang, T. · *The Historical Development of the Enneagram: From Ancient Symbol to Modern Personality Psychology* · Psychology of China · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.35534/pc.0802028
  Found: No new data. The review traces the Enneagram from Gurdjieff through Ichazo, Naranjo, Riso-Hudson and Palmer-Daniels, and names weak psychometric evidence and a constructed historical narrative as key credibility problems.
- 2026 · Lee, C.; Moon, S. · *A Case Study on Counseling Through the Integrative Application of the Sipseong (十星) in Myeongri Studies and the Enneagram* · Studies on Humanities and Social Sciences · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.62783/shss.8.2.43
  Found: Integrated Sipseong-Enneagram counselling is reported to give a layered understanding of clients' anxiety. The authors acknowledge that three cases cannot be generalised and that interpretation may be subjective.
- 2026 · Liz Rivas, L.; Gutiérrez Gallego, F. J. · *Application of the Enneagram in the age of AI within the legal profession [Aplicación de eneagramas en la era de la IA en el ejercicio de la abogacía]* · Cuadernos de RES PUBLICA en derecho y criminología, 1-34 · Result: Mixed · Spain · https://doi.org/10.46661/respublica.13215
  Found: No data. Proposes a legal-leadership model linking leadership styles to Enneagram types to tailor management style to team, client and conflict in Spanish law firms.
- 2026 · Tiwary, E. · *Understanding susceptibility through trauma, personality types and epigenetics: A conceptual review integrating the Enneagram model with homoeopathic philosophy* · International Journal of Homeopathy & Natural Medicines, 12(1), 10-17 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.11648/j.ijhnm.20261201.12
  Found: No data. Argues Enneagram personality patterns, early trauma and epigenetics can be integrated into the homoeopathic concept of susceptibility; untested proposal.
- 2026 · Demir, A. · *A Fitrah-based developmental model of Enneagram personality [Ein Fitrah-basiertes Entwicklungsmodell der Enneagramm-Persönlichkeit]* · International Journal of Social Sciences, 10(47), 102-117 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.52096/jcsl.07.03.07
  Found: No data. Proposes that Enneagram types arise as secondary adaptive strategies from the interaction of innate fitrah (Islamic anthropology) with early relational experiences, drawing on attachment and developmental psychology.
- 2026 · Srichuea, P.; Srichuea, K.; Promsuwan, K.; Boonprakon, K.; Sangsoda, P. · *Guidelines for developing learners' executive-function (EF) skills through the Enneagram framework [แนวทางในการพัฒนาทักษะสมอง EF ของผู้เรียนผ่านกรอบแนวคิดของนพลักษณ์]* · Journal of Education, Loei Rajabhat University · Result: Mixed · Thailand · https://so03.tci-thaijo.org/index.php/EDUCLoei/article/view/291830
  Found: No data. Maps the strengths and limitations of the nine types onto executive-function dimensions and proposes guidelines for personalised teaching.
- 2026 · 정풍윤 · *Single-case study of change in depression of an Enneagram type-9 client through imagery-method (영상관법) counselling [영상관법을 통한 에니어그램 9번 성격유형 내담자의 우울 경험 변화 과정에 대한 단일 사례 연구]* · Dongbang Culture University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T17565297
  Found: Depression fell from 35 to 11 and stress from 107 to 56; several maladaptive schemas decreased. Single case.
- 2026 · Li, M. · *Rapidly creating client awareness and accelerating client growth and transformation: An innovative application of the Enneagram in executive growth coaching [快速创造客户觉察，加速客户成长蜕变——九型人格在企业高管成长教练中的创新应用]* · 战略实现与教练实践研究 (Research on Strategy Implementation and Coaching Practice), 2(1), 48-53 · Result: Mixed · China · https://doi.org/10.58244/rsicp.263485
  Found: Argues that coaches who know their own and the executive's Enneagram centre (head, heart, gut) build trust faster and speed up client self-awareness within a mindfulness-based coaching approach. No data were collected; it cites only three books.
- 2026 · Pires, A. S.; Gomede, E. · *Gestão de projetos orientada pelo Eneagrama: Desenvolvendo times de alta performance em ESG [Enneagram-guided project management: Developing high-performance ESG teams]* · Revista E&S (Estratégias e Soluções), 7 · Result: Mixed · Brazil · https://doi.org/10.22167/2675-6528-202600483
  Found: The seven team members were seven different types (head centre 43%, heart 29%, body 29%; no Type 4 or 9), and the authors credit this mix for the team's success. No performance data or comparison group, so the link to performance is asserted, not measured.
- 2025 · Criado, J. M.; Gutiérrez, G.; Cano, E. L.; Garzás, J.; González de Lena, M. T.; Moguerza, J. M.; Fernández Muñoz, J. J. · *Effects of personality types on the performance of educational teams* · Behavioral Sciences, 15(3), 312 · Result: Supportive · Spain · https://doi.org/10.3390/bs15030312
  Found: Having a Type 3 or Type 6 on a team raised marks by about 1.5-1.8 points, but some pairings lowered them (Types 3+6 by 3.5 points, Types 1+4 by 3.9). There were many interaction terms for only 29 teams, so the results need replication.
- 2025 · Ha, T.-S. · *Enneagram-based Art Therapy for the Psychological Growth of Single Mothers: A Single-Case Study of Enneagram Type 4* · Asia Counseling and Coaching Society · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.47018/accr.2025.7.1.79
  Found: The participant moved through self-observation, self-understanding and self-transformation, with positive emotional change. This is a single case with no control.
- 2025 · Kara, M.; Kara, N. Ş.; Genç, M. · *The personality structure and mindfulness levels of football players: Enneagram theory* · Journal of ROL Sport Sciences · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.70736/jrolss.612
  Found: Types explained 23-35% of the variance in mindfulness subdimensions; achiever, authentic and compromiser were the strongest predictors. Some type scores were highly inter-correlated (e.g., perfectionist-compromiser r=.63), which raises a question about how well the scale separates types.
- 2025 · Kim, J. · *A Theoretical Study on the Relationship Between Suji Enneagram Personality Types and 2025 Fashion Color Trends* · Journal of the Korean Society of Culture and Sports · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.64786/jkscs.2025.1.1.6
  Found: No data. The paper links Suji Enneagram types to 2025 fashion trend colours for colour marketing and therapy, and calls for empirical work.
- 2025 · Lee, C. · *A Study on Application of the Sibsung (十星) in the Mingri (命理) Science and the Enneagram Personality Types in Contemporary Counseling Psychology* · Studies on Humanities and Social Sciences · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.62783/shss.7.5.58
  Found: No data. The paper maps the Ten Stars (Sibsung) of Korean Myeongri onto the nine Enneagram types to propose an integrated counselling model.
- 2025 · Yilmaz, S.; Yildiz, E.; Kursunlu, S. F. · *The potential impact of enneagram personality types on dental treatment adherence and success: a narrative review* · Brazilian Journal of Health Review · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.34119/bjhrv8n6-186
  Found: No new data. The review suggests Enneagram types may shape dental adherence and dentist-patient communication, and notes that there are no brief, validated tools for clinical settings.
- 2025 · Sarısoy Çakmak, M. · *An evaluation of the Sufi-based Enneagram within the Sufi concepts of ilâh-ı mu'tekad, a'yân-ı sâbite and rabb-i hâs [Tasavvufî Temellere Dayandırılan Enneagramın Tasavvuf Kavramlarından İlâh-ı Mu'tekad, A'yân-ı Sâbite ve Rabbi Has Çerçevesinde Değerlendirilmesi]* · Tasavvuf İlmi ve Akademik Araştırma Dergisi, 55, 57-94 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.70951/tasavvufdergisi.1672467
  Found: No data. Examines the Enneagram's claimed Sufi roots and relates its fixed-type idea to Ibn Arabi's concept of a'yân-ı sâbite.
- 2025 · Cini, A.; Ballotti, S.; Di Dio, M.; Capriotti, S.; Verardo, A.; Martino, I.; Minetto, F.; Natale, F.; Orlando, S.; Defraia, M.; Antoncecchi, M.; Geniola, N.; Roti, S. · *Relational Enneagram: vectors, loves and functions of character [Enneagramma relazionale: vettori, amori e funzioni del carattere]* · Phenomena Journal · Result: Mixed · Italy · https://phenomenajournal.com/index.php/phenomena/article/view/238
  Found: Exploratory analysis identifying relational vectors, love modalities and psychic functions consistent with the Enneagram model in a single autobiography; a single case, so the findings cannot be generalised.
- 2025 · Roegiers, V. · *Contribution to validating Enneagram theory using practical situations [Contribution à la validation de la théorie de l'ennéagramme à partir de situations pratiques]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Mixed · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/45256
  Found: Tested whether concrete scenarios help identify Enneagram type; abstract reports aims and limitations rather than quantitative accuracy. Small qualitative validation step.
- 2025 · Foret, E. · *Enneagram theory and career decision-making difficulties [La théorie de l'Ennéagramme et les difficultés à prendre des décisions en orientation professionnelle]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Supportive · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/45116
  Found: Several Enneagram bases correlated with career-indecision dimensions; lack of self-information and occupational information were strongly explained by Enneagram base. Self-report, cross-sectional.
- 2025 · Iamkrasin, S.; Maneewattana, C. · *The designing of a learning process for drama students with the Enneagram theory [การออกแบบกระบวนการเรียนรู้เพื่อพัฒนานักเรียนการแสดง ด้วยศาสตร์นพลักษณ์]* · วารสารศิลปกรรมศาสตร์วิชาการ วิจัย และงานสร้างสรรค์ (FARAA, ThaiJO), 12(2), E272493, 1-18 · Result: Mixed · Thailand · https://doi.org/10.60101/faraa.2025.272493
  Found: Students gained understanding of the Enneagram and used it for character analysis; over 95% wanted to apply it in future work. Uncontrolled, self-report.
- 2025 · حسن، سالي صلاح الدين محمد; خليل، صمويل تامر بشرى; عجلان، عفاف محمد محمود · *Clinical dynamics of personality types in light of the Enneagram model in TAT responses: A case study [الديناميات الكلينيكية المميزة لأنماط الشخصية في ضوء نموذج الإنياجرام للاستجابات في اختبار تفهم الموضوع]* · مجلة كلية التربية (أسيوط) (Assiut University Faculty of Education), 41(3), 238-267 · Result: Mixed · Egypt · https://doi.org/10.21608/mfes.2025.427904
  Found: Concludes the Enneagram and TAT can jointly reveal type-specific psychodynamics (case traits concentrated in Helper, Challenger and Enthusiast); single case.
- 2024 · Akça, E.; Ilgın, S. E.; et al.; Yanartaş, Ö. · *Multivariate association between personality beliefs and Enneagram personality theory: A canonical correlation analysis* · Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, 14(4) · Result: Supportive · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.5455/pbs.20240923031422
  Found: Four significant canonical functions: e.g., Types 1 and 6 with obsessive-compulsive beliefs; Types 2, 3, 7, 8 with histrionic/narcissistic/antisocial beliefs; Type 4 with schizoid/borderline/narcissistic beliefs (canonical r .35-.72 in conference version).
- 2024 · Kam, C. · *Enhancing Enneagram therapy with contemporary research on the conscious and unconscious mind* · Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science, 58(2), 711-730 · Result: Mixed · Canada · https://doi.org/10.1007/s12124-022-09685-5
  Found: Argues Enneagram constructs can be linked to modern research on unconscious processing and proposes research directions; no new data.
- 2024 · Kim, H.; Jo, S. · *Military Personnel and Organization Management Plan Considering Enneagram Type* · Studies on Humanities and Social Sciences · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.62783/shss.6.1.6
  Found: No data. The paper proposes classifying military specialties by Enneagram type and building the Enneagram into leadership education; the authors admit the scheme has not been validated.
- 2024 · Zhou, S. · *A Comparison of Myers Briggs Type Indicator of Personality and Enneagram Personality Theory* · Journal of Education, Humanities and Social Sciences · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.54097/gtveh388
  Found: No new data. The author concludes that the MBTI is more widely used and has stronger structural validity and reliability than Enneagram scales.
- 2024 · Lee, H.-S. · *Prospects for Relational Christian Education for the Generation of Young Adults in Crisis: With a Focus on Loder’s Transformational Theory and Enneagram* · Theological Forum · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.17301/tf.2024.3.115.245
  Found: No data. The paper combines Loder's transformational theory with the Enneagram as a framework for relational Christian education for isolated young adults.
- 2024 ·  · *The Application and Practice of Enneagram in Chinese Youth Education* · Advances in Educational Technology and Psychology · Result: Mixed · China · https://doi.org/10.23977/aetp.2024.080504
  Found: No data. The paper describes applications of the Enneagram in Chinese youth education and flags cultural-adaptation, stereotyping and training risks.
- 2024 · Cho, H. J.; Lee, S. H. · *Parenting Difficulties of Preschoolers' Mothers: The Enneagram Head Type* · Journal of Korean Coaching Research · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.20325/kca.2024.17.1.109
  Found: The core phenomenon was 'being absorbed in repetitive parenting situations'. The core category was relying on reason to build alternatives and staying the centre of parenting rather than its slave.
- 2024 · Wang, T. · *Investigate the Use of Enneagram Psychology in Human Resources Selection and Retention-final* · Psychology of China · Result: Mixed · China · https://doi.org/10.35534/pc.0611241
  Found: The survey found weaknesses in the company's HR management. The author recommends Enneagram-informed recruitment, career planning, training and performance systems, but reports no test of the Enneagram's effect.
- 2024 · Ricartti, A. E.; Hernández-Cosain, E. I.; González-Preza, M. A.; Bujanda-Celis, I. S. · *The impact of university educational managers' profiles on educational quality: Enneagram and leadership styles* · Research and Education (REd), no. 11 · Result: Supportive · Mexico · https://doi.org/10.63467/red.11.2024.art6
  Found: Reports a significant relationship between managers' leadership characteristics and educational quality, with certain Enneagram types associated with higher quality. Single institution, very small staff subsamples. (Note: Crossref lists a different title for this DOI; title and authors taken from the publisher page.)
- 2024 · Kaiser, A.; Nissen, M. E. · *Systemic coaching and Enneagramics for organization knowledge flow* · Proceedings of the 57th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS) · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.24251/hicss.2024.666
  Found: No data. Proposes combining vocation coaching with Enneagram dynamics to improve knowledge flow between employees and organisations and to address meaningless work.
- 2024 · Champeau, B. · *Links between Enneagram theory and career decision-making profiles [Les liens entre la théorie de l'ennéagramme et la théorie des profils de prise de décisions relative à la carrière]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Mixed · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/39523
  Found: Examines whether career decision-making profiles justify using the Enneagram in career guidance; abstract does not report results – check full text.
- 2024 · Bruyneel, E. · *Contribution to validating Enneagram theory: word choice and written text as type indicators [Contribution à la validation de la théorie de l'Ennéagramme]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Psychological Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Mixed · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/37931
  Found: Expert analysis of writing style showed promise for identifying dominant base; word-choice method gave no conclusive results. Course-requirement sample may reduce data quality.
- 2024 · Hellin, M.; Toussaint, C. · *Needs of socio-educational teams met by Enneagram training – qualitative interview study [Les besoins des équipes socioéducatives auxquels répond la formation Ennéagramme]* · UCLouvain, Master [120] in Educational Sciences (mémoire) · Result: Supportive · Belgium · https://hdl.handle.net/2078.2/38033
  Found: Interviewees said Enneagram training met needs for competence, relationships and communication and improved mutual understanding in teams. Self-reported perceptions only.
- 2024 · Medina Serrano, R. · *The Enneagram and its practical application: a literature update through interviews with university students in Germany [El Eneagrama y su aplicación práctica: una actualización de la literatura a través de entrevistas con estudiantes universitarios en Alemania]* · International Journal of Auditing and Teaching Practices, 2, 25-43 · Result: Mixed · Germany · https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14839267
  Found: Students reported the Enneagram helped self/other understanding, relationships and identifying soft skills for job interviews. Qualitative case study; 'validation' claims rest on interview perceptions only.
- 2024 · 김정선; 김한나 · *Enneagram counselling for a university student experiencing interpersonal conflict: A single-case study [대인관계 갈등을 경험하고 있는 대학생에 대한 에니어그램 상담]* · 대한에니어그램 (Korean Enneagram Spirituality Society), 10, 43-50 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A109569944
  Found: Client became aware of conflict avoidance and learned healthier emotional expression; single case.
- 2024 · 김문자 · *Single-case study of Enneagram meditation counselling [에니어그램 명상상담 단일사례연구]* · Dongbang Culture University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T17082765
  Found: Explores psychological change through type-matched meditation counselling; single case, descriptive.
- 2023 · Abdelhamid, E.; Ismail, S. S.; Aref, M. · *Approach for Enneagram personality detection for Twitter text: a case study* · International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering, 13(6), 6984-6991 · Result: Mixed · Egypt · https://doi.org/10.11591/ijece.v13i6.pp6984-6991
  Found: Proof-of-concept: the system assigned the Peacemaker (Type 9) type, matching expert typing; one-case demonstration only.
- 2023 · Vallander, S. · *A neuroscientific view on the Enneagram of personality* · Advances in Neurology and Neuroscience, 6(2) · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.33140/an.06.02.06
  Found: Proposes correspondences between types and FEAR, RAGE, GRIEF, SEEKING, CARE, PLAY and LUST systems; no brain-imaging or physiological data.
- 2023 · Blose, T. M.; Yeates, A. C.; Som, M.; Murray, K. A.; Vassar, M.; Stroup, J. · *The Enneagram and its application in medical education* · Proceedings (Baylor University Medical Center), 36, 54-58 · Result: Supportive · USA · https://doi.org/10.1080/08998280.2022.2132591
  Found: Concludes the Enneagram may help learning, relationships and teaming in postgraduate medical training, but notes there is little direct research and more studies are needed.
- 2023 · Kilag; Guerrero; Abella; Samutya; Arcillo; Asentado · *Enhancing educational leadership: Exploring the Enneagram's impact on interpersonal relationships* · American Journal of Science and Learning for Development, 2(6) · Result: Supportive · country not stated · https://inter-publishing.com/index.php/AJSLD/article/download/2094/1814/1970
  Found: Leaders said the Enneagram improved self-awareness, empathy for differences and their handling of team conflict. The sample was very small and the journal is low-profile.
- 2023 · Tlemsani, I.; Mohamed Hashim, M. A.; Matthews, R.; Ndrecaj, V.; Mason-Jones, R. · *An Enneagram approach to strategy* · Administrative Sciences, 13(5), 119 · Result: Mixed · UK · https://doi.org/10.3390/admsci13050119
  Found: Argues the Enneagram can serve as a meta-model for organisational systems, networks, supply chains and creativity, and states that cross-domain empirical research is still needed.
- 2023 · Demir, H.; Çınar, F.; Öztunç, E. · *An analysis of the decision-making styles of Enneagram personality types according to nafs psychology* · Amasya İlahiyat Dergisi, 21, 79-115 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.18498/amailad.1344273
  Found: Describes each type's decision-making style through Islamic nafs psychology (e.g. Type 1's passion is anger, which can make it fear wrong decisions). No data.
- 2023 · Hafızoğlu, O. · *ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE THROUGH THE ENNEAGRAM: STRATEGIC PLANNING - MANAGEMENT DECISION - OPERATIONAL CONTROL* · Yalvaç Akademi Dergisi · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.57120/yalvac.1360003
  Found: No data. The paper offers an Enneagram-based framework linking strategic planning, managerial decision-making and operational control to organisational performance.
- 2023 · Vallander, S. · *The Enneagram and Myers-Briggs Within a Neuroscientific Framework* · OSF Preprints · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.31219/osf.io/9r35j
  Found: No data. The paper proposes that Enneagram patterns map onto midbrain and limbic emotional systems and MBTI patterns onto neocortical cognition. It is an untested preprint.
- 2023 · Schewee, W. A., III · *Examining personality traits of teachers utilizing the Enneagram* · Doctoral dissertation, ProQuest LLC · Result: Supportive · country not stated · https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED634658
  Found: Themes of greater awareness, stronger relationships and more strategic division of labour emerged; teachers' self-descriptions paralleled their type descriptions. Very small, single-school qualitative study.
- 2023 · Jernigan, C. · *The role of elementary school principals' personality traits and servant leadership in building trusting relationships with faculty* · Doctoral dissertation, ProQuest LLC · Result: Mixed · USA · https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED640434
  Found: Both principals saw themselves as moderate-to-high servant leaders and shared the same top four Enneagram types in different orders. Two cases only; no test of a type-leadership link.
- 2023 · Cifuni, M. · *Enneagram in EM* · Journal of Education and Teaching in Emergency Medicine (JETem) · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.21980/j8zm0g
  Found: No data. Describes an Enneagram session to build self-awareness, teamwork and team leadership in emergency medicine; the abstract reports no outcome evaluation.
- 2023 · Youssef, M.; Samir, O. M.; Abdelbary, S. Y. · *Analysing consumer personality types using the Enneagram to stimulate strategic marketing for furniture companies [تحليل أنماط الشخصية للمستهلك باستخدام الإنياجرام لتحفيز التسويق الاستراتيجي لشركات الأثاث]* · مجلة العمارة والفنون والعلوم الإنسانية (Journal of Architecture, Arts and Humanistic Sciences) · Result: Mixed · Egypt · https://doi.org/10.21608/mjaf.2023.234014.3177
  Found: No data. A conceptual design and marketing analysis proposing furniture designs matched to Enneagram consumer types to support targeted marketing.
- 2023 · Sáenz Botero, A. M. · *Enneagrams as a strategy for classifying personality [Los eneagramas como estrategia para clasificar la personalidad]* · Ciencia y Academia · Result: Mixed · Colombia · https://doi.org/10.21501/2744838x.4650
  Found: No data. Reviews the Enneagram's aims, classifications, study methods and claimed effectiveness from various sources.
- 2023 · Bramont-Arias Garcia, L. A. · *The psychology of enneatypes in the last 10 years [La psicología de los eneatipos en los últimos 10 años]* · Universidad Peruana Cayetano Heredia, Faculty of Psychology (licentiate thesis) · Result: Mixed · Peru · https://repositorio.upch.edu.pe/entities/publication/8a24382f-4793-488e-9270-42c81c8e209a
  Found: Concludes enneatype psychology has potential for personality, clinical and social psychology and self-knowledge, but calls for more rigorous empirical testing. Number of included studies not stated.
- 2023 · Catrina, L.-G. · *Development and validation of a questionnaire within the theoretical frame of the Enneagram* · University of Padova, Department of General Psychology (Bachelor's final dissertation) · Result: Critical · Italy · https://thesis.unipd.it/handle/20.500.12608/65801
  Found: Internal consistency was unsatisfactory: Cronbach's alpha for the nine type scales ranged .249–.685, none reaching .70, which casts doubt on validity of this item set.
- 2023 · 김문자 · *Reducing anger with imagery-method (영상관법) counselling using the Enneagram: A single-case study [에니어그램을 활용한 영상관법이 분노 감소에 미치는 영향]* · 불교문예연구 (Dongbang Culture University), 22, 423-442 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A108910953
  Found: Client reported reduced physical and emotional anger; single case without standardised controls.
- 2022 · Franc, M. · *Enneagram w pracy koordynatora rodzinnej pieczy zastępczej* · Forum Pedagogiczne · Result: Mixed · Poland · https://doi.org/10.21697/fp.2021.2.12
  Found: No data. The paper describes adding the Enneagram to case work by foster-care coordinators.
- 2022 · Reda, S. S. A.; Al-Jubouri, H. M. K. · *Selection of young football players according to the playing centers according to the Enneagram theory for personality* · Journal of STEPS for Humanities and Social Sciences · Result: Mixed · Iraq · https://doi.org/10.55384/2790-4237.1144
  Found: An interactive electronic Enneagram scale was built. Personality types were spread evenly across the three playing positions, with no dominant type, so position-based selection by type was not supported.
- 2022 · Kang, S.; Cha, Y. · *An Inquiry into Possibility of Using Enneagram Spirituality in Addiction Recovery : Focusing on the Development of Human Consciousness* · The Korean Society of Culture and Convergence · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.33645/cnc.2022.12.44.12.557
  Found: No data. The paper explores Enneagram levels of consciousness (Gurdjieff, Riso) as a spiritual pathway in addiction recovery and calls for empirical testing.
- 2022 · Yi, K.; Lee, S. · *A Counseling Study on the Improvement of Interpersonal Relationships of Korean Students Studying in the U.S. Using the Enneagram: Focusing on the Case of Type 9* · The Korean Society of Culture and Convergence · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.33645/cnc.2022.12.44.12.923
  Found: The participant showed improved self-insight, understanding of others and interpersonal skills. This is a single case with no standardised outcome data.
- 2022 · Kim, H.-H. · *Christian Education for Self-understanding and Spiritual Maturity: Focusing on the Inner Journey of Enneagram to Discover the ‘True Self’* · Christian Education & Information Technology · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.67558/ksceit.2022.06.73.263
  Found: No data. The paper proposes Christian education aimed at self-understanding and spiritual maturity, built around the Enneagram's 'inner journey' toward the true self.
- 2022 · Leiter, S. K. · *Communicating through the Enneagram: A Christian higher education leadership study in pre-crisis communication* · Doctoral dissertation, ProQuest LLC · Result: Supportive · country not stated · https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED649849
  Found: Concluded that applying the Enneagram to leader-follower relationships would benefit pre-crisis communication preparation. Qualitative, single case; interviewees included Enneagram practitioners.
- 2022 · 지미선 · *A grounded-theory study of how Enneagram learners achieve midlife developmental tasks [에니어그램 학습경험자의 중년기 발달과업 달성과정에 대한 근거이론 연구]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 19(2), 25-65 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A108436681
  Found: Participants described the Enneagram as a self-understanding tool used for midlife tasks; the linked doctoral thesis derived four user types incl. a 'job-utilisation' type reporting improved work competence. Self-selected practitioners, no comparison group.
- 2022 · 배나래 · *Enneagram counselling for an adult woman experiencing interpersonal conflict: A single-case study [대인관계 갈등을 경험하고 있는 성인여성에 대한 에니어그램상담 단일사례연구]* · 한국융합학회논문지 (Journal of the Korea Convergence Society), 13(4), 293-298 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.15207/jkcs.2022.13.04.293
  Found: Client learned to express emotions and thoughts at work rather than suppressing them; single case.
- 2021 · Vaz, S. H. S.; Vasconcelos, H. G.; Prado, L. F. R.; Silva, G. T. G.; Rezende, L. C.; Guedes, G. F. R. B.; Silveira, D. G. · *ENEAGRAMA DE PERSONALIDADES NO PROCESSO DE GESTÃO DE PESSOAS/PERSONALITY ENNEAGRAM IN THE PEOPLE MANAGEMENT PROCESS* · Brazilian Journal of Development · Result: Mixed · Brazil · https://doi.org/10.34117/bjdv7n1-106
  Found: No data. The authors argue that the Enneagram supports selection, role placement, teamwork and productivity in people management, but their claims are not backed by new evidence.
- 2021 · Emilia, G. · *Penggunaan Enneagram Dalam Pembinaan Formasi Spiritual Kristen* · Evangelikal: Jurnal Teologi Injili dan Pembinaan Warga Jemaat · Result: Mixed · Indonesia · https://doi.org/10.46445/ejti.v5i1.334
  Found: No data. The paper reviews historical and empirical work and concludes that the Enneagram can be used in Christian spiritual-formation training, especially on relational topics.
- 2021 · Kam, C.; Bellehumeur, C. R. · *Integrating the enneagram and the anthropological structures of the imaginary for multidimensional maturity in the personality* · British Journal of Guidance & Counselling · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1080/03069885.2021.1909704
  Found: No data. The paper proposes combining the Enneagram with Durand's Anthropological Structures of the Imaginary to guide adult ego development in counselling.
- 2021 · Bayne, H. B.; Fields, K. G.; Nesbit, L. · *The Enneagram as a Tool for Fostering Empathic Connection in Counseling* · The Journal of Humanistic Counseling · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1002/johc.12158
  Found: No data. The authors propose using the Enneagram to build counsellor empathy through self- and other-awareness.
- 2021 · Rodrigues Voltarelli, F.; De Oliveira Gomes, J. K.; Da Silva Pasquali, K.; Grapegia Dal Vesco, D. · *Visão dos Gestores na Perspectiva do Balanced Scorecard e Eneagrama* · Prosppectus - Perspectivas Qualitativas em Contabilidade e Organizações · Result: Mixed · Brazil · https://doi.org/10.22478/ufpb.2763-9606.2021v1n1.59927
  Found: The managers described a mostly indirect, positive interaction between the Enneagram and the learning-and-growth perspective of the Balanced Scorecard. With only three interviewees, the findings cannot be generalised.
- 2021 · Garibaldi, C. · *Enneagramma e sviluppo delle soft skills Un supporto per una didattica inclusiva?* · SAIL · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.30687/978-88-6969-477-6/011
  Found: No data reported in the abstract. The chapter argues that the Enneagram can foster soft skills such as self-awareness and emotional intelligence in teachers and learners.
- 2021 · Wang, Y. · *Enneagram and rural revitalization* · 2021 5th International Conference on Education, Management and Social Science (EMSS 2021) · Result: Mixed · China · https://webofproceedings.org/proceedings_series/ESSP/EMSS 2021/ZL2103009.pdf
  Found: No data. Maps the nine types onto a phased plan for China's rural revitalisation strategy as a metaphor, without testing it.
- 2021 · Sisti, F. · *The Enneagram: An inclusive tool of inquiry for the foreign-language teacher [L'Enneagramma: uno strumento inclusivo di indagine per il docente di lingue straniere]* · SAIL (Edizioni Ca' Foscari) · Result: Mixed · Italy · https://doi.org/10.30687/978-88-6969-477-6/012
  Found: First of a planned series of case studies testing whether exposing students to Enneagram types raises identity awareness and exam marks; the abstract states aims but reports no results.
- 2020 · Alexander, M.; Schnipke, B. · *The Enneagram: A primer for psychiatry residents* · American Journal of Psychiatry Residents' Journal, 15(3), 2-5 · Result: Mixed · USA · https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp-rj.2020.150301
  Found: Introduces the nine types (basic fear, desire and strategy of each) for psychiatry trainees. No data.
- 2020 · 平嶋 祐佳; 有路 憲一 · *「偽りの自己」を生きる子どもたち: エニアグラムの"ちえ"* · Shinshu University (SOAR repository) · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · https://soar-ir.repo.nii.ac.jp/record/21567/files/Arts_and_Science14_06.pdf
  Found: No data (conceptual). Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2020 · Cusack, C. M. · *The Enneagram* · Aries · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1163/15700593-02001002
  Found: No data. The article places the Enneagram in Gurdjieff's 'Work', reviews competing origin claims (Christian, Sufi, Kabbalistic), and traces the post-Gurdjieff personality Enneagram to Oscar Ichazo.
- 2020 · Singletary, J. · *Head, Heart, and Hand* · Social Work & Christianity · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.34043/swc.v47i3.126
  Found: No data. The paper uses the Enneagram's three centres (head, heart, hand) as a framework for Christian spiritual formation and leadership in the helping professions.
- 2020 · Demir, A. · *Enneagram as a personality determination method* · Uluslararası Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 4(18), 25–36 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://www.ceeol.com/search/article-detail?id=972676
  Found: No data. Introduces the three centres and nine types and notes that the Enneagram is viewed as both scientific and unscientific.
- 2020 · Demir, A.; Dane, Ş. · *The comparison of Nursi Character Analysis (NURCA) and Enneagram* ·  · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doaj.org/article/dbbc6b75f05845669ef79d03c0df208a
  Found: No data. Compares a character model drawn from Said Nursi's Risale-i Nur with the Enneagram.
- 2020 · Mármarosi, A. · *The dark side of leadership (hubristic leadership) [A vezetés sötét oldala (hübrisztikus vezetés)]* · Vezetéstudomány / Budapest Management Review · Result: Mixed · Hungary · https://doi.org/10.14267/veztud.2020.03.03
  Found: No data. Uses the Enneagram to propose which leader types are more vulnerable to hubristic leadership, as an untested hypothesis.
- 2020 · Elmeadawy, G. · *Using Enneagram strategy as convincing axes in the design of advertisement messages* · Journal of Architecture, Art & Humanistic Science, 5(21), 611-635 · Result: Mixed · Egypt · https://doi.org/10.21608/mjaf.2019.15497.1259
  Found: No data. Proposes Enneagram types as persuasion axes for advertising design.
- 2019 · Ilieva, R.; Nikolov, M. · *Enneagram approach for intelligent agile integration* · 2019 International Conference on Creative Business for Smart and Sustainable Growth (CREBUS), 1-4 · Result: Mixed · Bulgaria · https://doi.org/10.1109/crebus.2019.8840077
  Found: Proposes using Enneagram profiles to help distributed software teams achieve faster Agile integration. No outcome data reported.
- 2019 ·  · *A Case Study of Meditation-Bsed Enneagram Counseling for ICU New Nurses' Stress on Care of Dying Patients* · Journal of Meditation based Psychological Counseling · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.12972/mpca.20190012
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2019 · Salvador Robles, M. C.; Jurado Jiménez, M. D. · *Comprehensive training of educators and teachers from a psychosocioeducational perspective [Formación integral de educadores y docentes desde una perspectiva psicosocioeducativa]* · International Journal of Developmental and Educational Psychology (Revista INFAD), 5(1), 97 · Result: Supportive · Spain · https://doi.org/10.17060/ijodaep.2019.n1.v5.1567
  Found: Students reported strong interest in the Enneagram and greater awareness of their personal and professional development needs. Qualitative perceptions only; no comparison group.
- 2019 · 조주영 · *Enneagram-based food art therapy and wellness [에니어그램 기반 푸드아트테라피와 웰니스]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050027662352
  Found: No data. Proposes combining food art therapy, wellness and the Enneagram into an integrated counselling and healing approach.
- 2019 · 이안숙 · *Eastern behaviour style and the circularity of arrow theory discovered in the symbolism of the Enneagram diagram [에니어그램 도형의 상징에서 발견된 동양 행동방식과 화살표이론의 순환성]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A360082
  Found: No data. Argues that the Enneagram diagram's circle implies an 'Eastern behaviour style' theory and a circular version of the arrow (movement) theory.
- 2019 · 조성민 · *Analysis of the Enneagram passions and the 27 subtypes [에니어그램의 격정과 27가지 부속유형의 분석]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A360083
  Found: No data. Describes the 27 instinctual subtypes, including countertypes, and their use for self-reflection.
- 2019 · Demir, A. · *Leadership features of Enneagram characters* · Uluslararası Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 3(16), 82–90 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://www.ceeol.com/content-files/document-802490.pdf
  Found: No data. Describes the leadership style of each of the nine types and highlights the leadership potential of Types 8, 9 and 1.
- 2019 · 박명석 · *Effects of meditation-based Enneagram counselling on the stress of a new ICU nurse who experienced a patient's death: a single-case study [명상에 기반한 에니어그램 상담이 환자의 임종을 경험한 중환자실 신규 간호사의 스트레스에 미치는 영향 - 단일사례연구 -]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3745094
  Found: After counselling, the nurse faced unresolved childhood guilt, reframed death and recommitted to nursing instead of quitting. Single case, qualitative.
- 2019 · 이지명 · *Cognitive behavioural therapy applying the Enneagram: focusing on cognitive restructuring [에니어그램을 적용한 인지행동치료 : 인지적 재구성 과정을 중심으로]* · 아동가족치료연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3673178
  Found: No data. Maps points of contact between CBT cognitive restructuring and the Enneagram (schemas, stress triggers, self-monitoring, case conceptualisation).
- 2019 · 최학수 · *An integrative approach to self-exploration, understanding and growth: a case study of Type 5 [자기 탐색과 이해, 성장을 위한 통합적 접근 - 5유형(전지욕구)의 사례연구 -]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://devkiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3739725
  Found: Type 5 features appeared consistently across conscious, preconscious and unconscious material, and combining these sources was useful for self-awareness. The author acknowledges the limits on generalising from one case.
- 2019 · 류권옥 (Ryoo, Kwon Ok); 정수진 (Jeong, Su Jin) · *Case studies on adolescents' social networks using Enneagram psychological dynamics: Heart centre [에니어그램심리역동을 활용한 청소년의 사회적 관계망에 관한 상담사례 연구]* · 에니어그램 (Korean Society of Enneagram Dynamic Psychology), 6(2), 19-42 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A106539778
  Found: Describes counselling of heart-centre youth on relationships with parents, friends and teachers; descriptive.
- 2018 · Kam, C. · *Integrating divine attachment theory and the Enneagram to help clients of abuse heal in their images of self, others, and God* · Pastoral Psychology, 67(4), 341-356 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.1007/s11089-018-0817-1
  Found: No data (conceptual). Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 · Matise, M. · *The Enneagram: An enhancement to family therapy* · Contemporary Family Therapy, 41(1), 68-78 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.1007/s10591-018-9471-0
  Found: No data (conceptual). Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 · Choi, J.-H. · *A study on 'self-search writing' teaching method using Enneagram in the college subject of liberal arts: Focusing on the Riso & Hudson theory* · Journal of Learner-Centered Curriculum and Instruction, 18(19), 1041-1062 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.22251/jlcci.2018.18.19.1041
  Found: No data. Proposes an Enneagram-linked self-exploration writing method; the abstract describes no outcome evaluation.
- 2018 ·  · *Counselling Cases for Habit Improvement of Sunshine Using Enneagram* · Journal of Meditation based Psychological Counseling · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.12972/mpca.20180006
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2018 · Lee, S. Y.; Cho, H.-J. · *Career Coaching for Children and Adolescents in the Fourth Industrial Revolution : Applying enneagram personality theory* · Journal of Korean Coaching Research · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.20325/kca.2018.11.1.57
  Found: No data on Enneagram outcomes. The paper sorts career-related documents into occupation, talent, education and competence themes, then argues that Enneagram-based coaching can help young people find personality-linked competencies.
- 2018 · Moura, D. C. A.; Arreguy-Sena, C.; Greco, R. M.; Lessa Pacheco, Z. M.; Ribeiro, R. M. · *PROCESSO COMUNICACIONAL À LUZ DO ENEAGRAMA: ENSINO/APRENDIZAGEM ENTRE ESTAGIÁRIOS E DOCENTES DE ENFERMAGEM* · Revista de Enfermagem e Atenção à Saúde · Result: Mixed · Brazil · https://doi.org/10.18554/reas.v7i1.2284
  Found: Faculty and students were typed with the Enneagram, and the authors describe how type differences shaped teaching-learning communication. The study is descriptive with a very small sample and has no outcome measures.
- 2018 · Mendoza, J. · *Eneagrama, Educación e Investigación “Un pasaje epistemológico de una sabiduría universal Milenaria en tiempos postmodernos”* · GACETA DE PEDAGOGÍA · Result: Mixed · Venezuela · https://doi.org/10.56219/rgp.vi37.735
  Found: No data. The author argues on onto-epistemological grounds for using the Enneagram as a teaching tool for self-knowledge in Venezuelan universities.
- 2018 · Spencer, R. M. · *Mind, heart, and body: Conductors use the Enneagram to reflect on musical practice* · Boston University (OpenBU) · Result: Mixed · USA · https://hdl.handle.net/2144/32688
  Found: Three conductors used their RHETI results to reflect on how personality showed up in rehearsal; the cross-case analysis suggests the Enneagram is useful for reflective practice. Descriptive, three cases only.
- 2018 · สนิท สัตโยภาส · *Using Enneagram theory to study causal factors behind differing personal characteristics: a case study of undergraduates at Chiang Mai Rajabhat University* · Journal of Graduate Research · Result: Mixed · Thailand · https://so02.tci-thaijo.org/index.php/banditvijai/article/view/134763
  Found: Students attributed their type to parenting, teachers, local culture and childhood experiences, and found the Enneagram activities enjoyable and helpful for understanding themselves and others. Descriptive, self-report only.
- 2018 · 최재숙 · *The Enneagram and Paul Tillich's ontological theology: awareness of finitude and transformation of being [에니어그램과 폴 틸리히의 존재신학 : 유한성 자각과 존재의 변화]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A340412
  Found: No data. Argues that self-transformation through the Enneagram has limits that Tillich's theology of acceptance can address.
- 2018 · 이은하; 최학수 · *A career orientation model based on the Enneagram psychodynamic system [에니어그램 심리역동체계에 기초한 경력지향에 대한 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050026455317
  Found: No data. Proposes an Enneagram career-orientation model (values, interests, abilities, motives, needs mapped to job attributes, activities and environment); the authors note its components are not yet validated.
- 2018 · 박현경 · *The Enneagram and the Fourth Industrial Revolution: the orientation and role of the Enneagram system for the talent profile of the 4IR era [에니어그램과 4차 산업혁명 - 4차 산업혁명 시대에 요구되는 인재상으로서의 에니어그램 시스템의 지향과 역할 -]* · 에니어그램연구 (Enneagram Research) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A345293
  Found: No data. Argues that the Enneagram's levels of development can support the ethical, self-reflective, emotionally intelligent talent the 4IR is said to need.
- 2018 · 윤혜란 · *Temperament colours according to Enneagram psychodynamics: focusing on core needs [에니어그램심리역동에 따른 기질별 컬러에 관한 연구 -핵심욕구 중심으로-]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050026424447
  Found: No data. Proposes a colour for each Enneagram type based on core needs and energy; untested.
- 2018 · 최연택; 김보연; 양창진; 송수현 · *On the possibility of typing personality from the Ten Gods of Saju Myeongri, compared with Korean Enneagram type theory [사주명리학 십신(十神)의 성격유형화 가능성에 관한 연구 - 한국형에니어그램 성격유형론을 중심으로 -]* · 에니어그램연구 (Enneagram Research) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A345296
  Found: No data. Argues that the 'Ten Gods' of Korean four-pillars astrology resemble Enneagram types structurally; the authors say clinical testing and standardisation are needed.
- 2018 · สุภัค วงศ์ดี; มณฑล สรไกรกิติกูล · *Application of the Enneagram in human resource development [การใช้นพลักษณ์ในการพัฒนาทรัพยากรมนุษย์]* · Journal of HR Intelligence (Thammasat University), 13(1), 99-117 · Result: Mixed · Thailand · https://so03.tci-thaijo.org/index.php/hri/article/view/211675
  Found: No data. Proposes the Enneagram as a framework for HRD – type-based training activities, individual development plans and career plans to build leadership strengths.
- 2017 · Schwarz, E.; Zarrabi, S. · *DAS²-theory of personality: A cognitive approach to the Enneagram* · Psychology, 8(11), 1802-1815 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.4236/psych.2017.811118
  Found: No data. Proposes rebuilding the nine types from cognitive and ethological concepts (three stances towards power, each applied from superiority or inferiority); the authors acknowledge it still needs empirical testing.
- 2017 · Ide, P. · *Ennéagramme et transcendantaux. Interprétations croisées [The Enneagram and the transcendentals: Cross interpretations]* · Nouvelle revue théologique, 139(4), 619-638 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.3917/nrt.394.0619
  Found: No data. Maps the nine types onto the medieval transcendentals and discusses three main objections to the Enneagram.
- 2017 · Park, S. H.; Kim, M. H. [박순형; 김미혜] · *A note on the origin and history of the Enneagram [에니어그램의 기원과 역사에 대한 소고]* · Korean journal (earticle) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A330922
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Traces the Enneagram from Sufi transmission through Gurdjieff and Ichazo to its introduction in Korea.
- 2017 · Tondowidjojo, J. · *The Enneagram as a map of self-image [Eneagram sebagai peta gambaran diri]* · Jurnal Pendidikan Agama Katolik (JPAK), 17(9) · Result: Mixed · Indonesia · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.34150/jpak.v17i9.46
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Presents the Enneagram as a system of nine archetypes linked to Jungian theory.
- 2017 · Kim, M. H. [김미혜] · *A concept analysis of 'lust', the passion of Enneagram Type 8 [에니어그램 8번 유형의 격정 '정욕'에 대한 개념분석]* · Korean journal (earticle) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A330923
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Identifies attributes, antecedents and consequences of Type 8's passion.
- 2017 · Yılmaz, E. D.; Gök, C.; Ünal, Ö.; Özkan, A.; Selçuk, Z. · *A proposal about a prediction strategy from normality to psychopathology according to Nine Types Temperament Model* · Journal of Psychiatry and Psychiatric Disorders · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.26502/jppd.2572-519x0023
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Proposes a model predicting psychopathology from NTTM (Enneagram-derived) temperament types.
- 2017 · Yılmaz, E. D.; Üstündağ, M. F.; Ünal, Ö.; Palancı, M.; Gök, C. · *Psychological root of morality: A proposal according to Nine Types Temperament Model* · Clinical Psychiatry · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.21767/2471-9854.100038
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Argues temperament types are the root of virtues and vices.
- 2017 · Maschio, T. R. A.; Soczek, K. L. · *The Enneagram as a self-knowledge tool and its relationship with cognitive-behavioural theory [O Eneagrama como ferramenta de autoconhecimento e sua relação com a Teoria Cognitivo-Comportamental]* · Revista IESSA · Result: Mixed · Brazil · not yet checked · http://www.iessa.edu.br/revista/index.php/tcc/article/view/91
  Found: Surveyed people who had encountered the Enneagram on whether its self-knowledge supports personal development and openness to CBT; results not given in the abstract.
- 2017 · Rodrigues, A. C. · *The Enneagram as a tool in organizations [O enigma como ferramenta nas organizações]* · Universidade Federal de Sergipe (undergraduate monograph) · Result: Mixed · Brazil · not yet checked · https://ri.ufs.br/handle/riufs/6752
  Found: Identified predominant personality types among staff and leaders of a university infrastructure unit to analyse interpersonal relations; descriptive.
- 2017 · Park, S. M. [박선미] · *An exploratory study of Enneagram psychodynamics and natural healing alternatives: Focusing on heart energy [에니어그램 심리역동과 자연치유 대안의 탐색연구]* · Korean journal (newnonmun) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=10776945
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Links heart-centre types to touch and natural-healing options.
- 2017 · 신명수 · *Adaptation process of a Korean Enneagram Type 6 child in a shelter for abused children [에니어그램 6번 유형 아동이 학대피해아동쉼터에서의 적응과정]* · 에니어그램연구 (Enneagram Research) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A311374
  Found: Describes how a Type 6 child moved from self-defeating, oppositional behaviour towards cooperation over 72 sessions of Enneagram-informed therapy. Single uncontrolled case, interpretive only.
- 2017 · 고영선 · *Exploring the correlation between Enneagram psychodynamics and physical health: an approach using auricular health counselling [에니어그램 심리역동과 신체적 건강과의 상관성 모색 - 귀 건강상담학을 활용한 접근 -]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025697835
  Found: No data. Proposes links between the three centres (head, heart, body) and particular body systems, and suggests ear-massage self-care by centre; untested.
- 2017 · 류권옥; 김소연 · *A case study of children's problem behaviour using Enneagram psychodynamics (heart-centre children) [에니어그램심리역동을 활용한 아동의 문제행동사례에 관한 연구 (가슴중심 아동을 중심으로)]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=10766191
  Found: Reports that meeting the child's Enneagram-related needs and giving self-object experiences in counselling reduced problem behaviour. Uncontrolled case report.
- 2017 · 김동성 · *An examination of the mutual relationship between Satipatthana (mindfulness) meditation and the Enneagram [염지관(念止觀) 명상과 에니어그램의 상호관계성 고찰]* · 한국불교학 (Korean Buddhist Studies) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3501278
  Found: No data. Argues that mindfulness meditation and Enneagram work complement each other, with the three centres matching categories of mental phenomena.
- 2017 · 이은하 · *Development of an ENLP model combining Enneagram psychodynamics and NLP, and its applications [에니어그램심리역동을 활용한 ENLP 모델개발과 활용모형에 관한 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025697859
  Found: No data. Proposes a counselling model linking Enneagram psychodynamics to NLP neurological levels; not empirically tested.
- 2017 · 류권옥; 최수정 · *A counsellor's experiential narrative using Enneagram psychodynamics (interaction by centre of intelligence) [에니어그램심리역동을 활용한 상담자의 경험 내러티브 (힘 중심에 의한 상호작용 상담사례)]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3697577
  Found: Draws on Fairbairn's object relations and Enneagram psychodynamics to describe how the client's mother–daughter relationship shaped counsellor–client interaction. Descriptive single case.
- 2017 · 신명수 · *Art therapy single-case study of an Enneagram type-4 adolescent [에니어그램 4번 유형 청소년의 미술치료 단일사례연구]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 14(2), 35-62 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A105064498
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2016 · Lee, K.-M. · *Complementarity between Kabbalah and Enneagram for the change of individuals and community: Its implications and insights for Christian education* · Journal of Christian Education in Korea, 48, 13-41 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.17968/jcek.2016..48.001
  Found: No data (conceptual). Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2016 · Jung, H. J.; Song, G. J. [정희정; 송금자] · *A study on methods of personality education for children and adolescents through use of the Enneagram [에니어그램 활용을 통한 아동·청소년 인성교육 방안연구]* · 코칭연구 (Korean Journal of Coaching) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://db.koreascholar.com/Article?code=321665
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Proposes school, family and community uses of the Enneagram in national character-education policy.
- 2016 · Hwang, I. R. [황임란] · *The Enneagram and levels of development of consciousness [에니어그램과 의식의 발달 수준]* · Korean journal (kstudy) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3509964
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Integrates Gurdjieff's and Riso's levels of development with Maslow's hierarchy.
- 2016 · Gallegos Núñez, B. A. S. · *Approaches to personality types according to the Enneagram [Aproximaciones a los tipos de personalidad según el Eneagrama]* · PsiqueMag · Result: Mixed · Peru · not yet checked · http://181.224.246.213/index.php/psiquemag/article/download/142/44
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Reviews Gurdjieff's, Naranjo's and Pangrazzi's contributions to the Enneagram as a personality typology.
- 2016 · Jeong, M. S. [정명실] · *Heart-centred Enneagram types and trauma [에니어그램의 가슴중심 유형과 트라우마]* · Korean journal (earticle) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A281978
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Discusses trauma patterns and recovery for types 2, 3 and 4.
- 2016 · Lee, H. A. [이혜안] · *The Enneagram and self-insight: Focusing on the Gurdjieff Work [에니어그램과 자기통찰: 구르지예프 워크를 중심으로]* · Korean journal (kstudy) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3509966
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Reviews Gurdjieff's teachings as a route to self-integration.
- 2016 · Fernández-Caballero Pérez, M. · *The Enneagram, a tool for mediation [El Eneagrama, una herramienta para la mediación]* · Revista de Mediación · Result: Mixed · Spain · not yet checked · https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=5662721
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Proposes the Enneagram for clarifying needs and managing emotions in conflict mediation.
- 2016 · Ji, M. S. [지미선] · *The relationship between transformative learning in adult learning and the Enneagram [성인학습에서의 전환학습과 에니어그램 관련성 연구]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Journal of Enneagram Studies) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A303432
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Maps transformative learning concepts onto Enneagram self-observation, self-understanding and transformation.
- 2016 · Lee, S. Y. [이숙영] · *An exploratory study of self-leadership by Enneagram temperament and career preparation behaviour [에니어그램 기질별 셀프리더십과 진로준비행동 간의 탐색연구]* · Korean journal (kstudy) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3697566
  Found: No outcome data: defines type-specific self-leadership concepts via literature and 9-expert rating for career guidance.
- 2016 · Lee, E. H.; Park, S. M. [이은하; 박선미] · *An exploratory study on preferred senses of Enneagram heart-centre energy [에니어그램 가슴중심 에너지의 선호감각에 관한 탐색적 연구]* · Korean journal (newnonmun) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.newnonmun.com/dlink/10758122.pdf
  Found: Heart-centre types reported touch as their preferred sense; sample and statistics not given in abstract.
- 2016 · Kim, S. M. [김선미] · *French speaking learning strategies using French learners' Enneagram personality types [프랑스어 학습자의 에니어그램 성격유형을 활용한 프랑스어 말하기 학습 전략]* · 인문과학연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.dbpia.co.kr/Journal/ArticleDetail/NODE06650776
  Found: Heart-centre groups scored best on theory learning and team task performance, and top teams included Types 2 and 3; team composition by type was linked to task results, but samples were unequal and design uncontrolled.
- 2016 · Jeong, Y. G. [정용구] · *Using family therapy through an Enneagram psychodynamic approach [에니어그램 심리역동적 접근을 통한 가족치료의 활용방안 연구]* · Korean journal (Kyobo scholar) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025697693
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Proposes type-specific communication, boundaries and empathy for family therapy.
- 2016 · Ryu, K. O. [류권옥] · *Understanding media-addicted adolescents: Focusing on correlation with Enneagram psychodynamic temperament [미디어 중독 청소년에 관한 이해]* · Korean journal (Kyobo scholar) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025697662
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Links type-specific psychological addictions to adolescent media addiction counselling.
- 2016 · Lee, E. H. [이은하] · *A brief adolescent counselling model using Enneagram psychodynamics: The NAKEY model [에니어그램심리역동을 활용한 청소년단기상담모델연구]* · Korean journal (newnonmun) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=10755360
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Proposes a five-stage brief counselling model for adolescents.
- 2016 · Lee, E. H. [이은하] · *A study of the correlation between Enneagram psychodynamics and mind-body healing [에니어그램심리역동과 심신치유의 상관성 연구]* · Korean journal (newnonmun) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.newnonmun.com/dlink/10755359.pdf
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Links Enneagram centres with somatic awareness and mind-body healing.
- 2016 · Lee, E. H.; Yoon, H. R. [이은하; 윤혜란] · *Enneagram psychodynamics and natural healing approaches: Focusing on life energy and energy healing [에니어그램심리역동과 자연치유적 접근에 관한 연구]* · Korean journal (koreanstudies) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://search.koreanstudies.net/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3697559
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Proposes type-specific natural-healing approaches.
- 2016 · Lee, E. H.; Ji, H. Y. [이은하; 지해연] · *Correlation between preferred colours by level of consciousness and Enneagram psychodynamics [의식수준에 따른 선호컬러와 에니어그램심리역동간의 상관성 연구]* · Korean journal (newnonmun) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=10758121
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Maps colours to types and levels of consciousness from prior literature.
- 2016 · 정용구 (Jung, Yong Koo) · *Research on integrated leadership using Enneagram psychological dynamics [에니어그램심리역동을 활용한 통합리더십에 관한 연구]* · 에니어그램 (Korean Society of Enneagram Dynamic Psychology), 3(1), 99-117 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A106352288
  Found: No data. Proposes a spiritually and psychologically integrated leadership model built on Enneagram dynamics, contrasted with authentic and adaptive leadership.
- 2016 · 이은하 (Lee, Eun Ha) · *Cases of couple counselling using Enneagram psychological dynamics [에니어그램심리역동을 활용한 부부상담사례에 관한 연구]* · 에니어그램 (Korean Society of Enneagram Dynamic Psychology), 3(2), 97-117 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A106352297
  Found: Describes how type-related conversation styles, affection, conflict coping and habitual feelings were addressed in couple counselling; descriptive case material only.
- 2016 · الدريج، محمد · *The Enneagram model (nine personality types) and its use in education, competency building and leadership development [نموذج الإينياجرام : تساعية أنماط الشخصية وتوظيفه في التربية وتكوين الكفاءات وتأهيل القيادات]* · مجلة كراسات تربوية (Cahiers pédagogiques), 2, 7-30 · Result: Mixed · Morocco · https://doi.org/10.12816/0027963
  Found: No data. Introduces the Enneagram's history and components and argues for its use in training and leadership development.
- 2015 · Lim, H. S. [임희숙] · *The spirituality of the Enneagram: Its meaning and practice [에니어그램의 영성 – 그 의미와 실천]* · Korean journal (earticle) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A251640
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Argues the Enneagram offers a holistic spirituality beyond character study.
- 2015 · Lee, E. J. [이은재] · *Enneagram spiritual training for the belly (gut) type [장형(腸形) 인간의 에니어그램 영성수련]* · Korean journal (earticle) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A251642
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Re-examines Enneagram spiritual practice for gut-centre types.
- 2015 · Choi, J. S. [최재숙] · *The Enneagram and the spirituality of types 2, 3 and 4 [에니어그램과 2, 3, 4번 유형의 영성]* · Korean journal (earticle) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A251641
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Describes disidentification from type and links it to restoration in Christian spirituality.
- 2015 · Ryu, K. O.; Lee, S. M. [류권옥] · *Counseling techniques by Enneagram type for adolescents: Focusing on heart-centred adolescents [청소년의 에니어그램 유형별 상담기법]* · Korean journal (newnonmun) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=10751163
  Found: No data: proposes Enneagram-dynamics counselling strategies for heart-centre adolescents illustrated with a case.
- 2015 · Ryu, K. O. [류권옥] · *Application to adolescent counseling through self psychology and empathy by Enneagram temperament [자기심리학과 에니어그램 기질별 공감을 통한 청소년 상담에의 적용]* · Korean journal (newnonmun) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://ekspe.newnonmun.com/article=193870
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Links self psychology with type-specific empathy for adolescent counselling.
- 2015 · Lee, E. H.; Kim, S. J. [이은하] · *Development of occupational value cards by Enneagram temperament and their use in career counseling [에니어그램 기질별 직업가치카드개발 및 진로상담에의 활용]* · Korean journal (kstudy) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://kiss.kstudy.com/thesis/thesis-view.asp?key=3697537
  Found: No outcome data: developed Enneagram-type occupational value cards via literature review and 3-expert rating for youth career counselling.
- 2015 · Jeong, Y. G.; Choi, H. A. [정용구; 최현아] · *Play therapy case study of an Enneagram heart-power child with peer relationship difficulties [또래관계에 어려움을 보이는 에니어그램 가슴파워 아동의 놀이치료사례연구]* · Korean journal (Kyobo scholar) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025697565
  Found: Describes how an achievement-oriented heart-centre child's needs appeared in play therapy themes; single case, no quantitative outcomes.
- 2015 · Kim, Y. S.; Lee, E. H. [김영순; 이은하] · *Basic needs in reality therapy and application of the Enneagram [현실치료의 기본 욕구와 에니어그램의 적용]* · Korean journal (Kyobo scholar) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025697572
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Maps reality therapy's five basic needs onto the nine Enneagram core needs for counselling.
- 2015 · Lee, E. H.; Jeong, Y. G. [이은하; 정용구] · *Development and application model of the Enneagram psychodynamic behavioural pattern sentence completion test [에니어그램심리역동 행동패턴검사 개발과 활용모형에 관한 연구]* · Korean journal (newnonmun) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=10751159
  Found: Developed a projective sentence-completion test based on Enneagram dynamics using literature review and expert rating; no reliability or validity statistics reported.
- 2015 · Kim, S. S. [김성숙] · *Applying the Enneagram psychodynamic system in psychodrama [심리극 속에 나타난 에니어그램심리역동체계의 활용방안 연구]* · Korean journal (Kyobo scholar) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://scholar.dkyobobook.co.kr/searchDetail.laf?barcode=4050025697482
  Found: No data: conceptual/theoretical paper. Describes how centre-specific emotional dynamics can inform psychodrama warm-up and rapport.
- 2015 · Tartari, J. S. · *Identifying lead users for innovation-oriented virtual communities of practice using the Enneagram [Identificação de lead users para comunidades de prática virtuais voltadas à inovação utilizando o eneagrama]* · Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Graduate Program in Knowledge Engineering and Management (MSc) · Result: Mixed · Brazil · https://repositorio.ufsc.br/xmlui/handle/123456789/169528
  Found: Proposes recommendations for selecting lead users for innovation projects using Enneagram-based attitude profiles. Conceptual/review-based; no empirical validation of the guidelines.
- 2014 · Yılmaz, E.; Gençer, A.; Ünal, Ö.; Aydemir, Ö. · *From Enneagram to Nine Types Temperament Model: A proposal* · Education and Science, 39(173), 396-417 · Result: Mixed · Turkey · https://doi.org/10.15390/es.2014.1288
  Found: Proposes the Nine Types Temperament Model, a reworking of the Enneagram as a temperament model, and describes how the nine types behave under stress and relaxation. This is the founding paper behind the later NTTM validation studies already in the library.
- 2014 · 김혜경 · *How to treat the passion of Enneagram type 6* · Qualitative Research, 15(1), 64-77 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.22284/qr.2014.15.1.64
  Found: The central phenomenon was 'being captured by fear'. Outcomes ranged from lethargy or aggression to 'being the owner of my life', depending on how participants faced themselves. Qualitative, with no comparison group.
- 2014 · Lee, K. · *Suicide problems in Korean society and Enneagram characteristics [한국사회의 자살문제와 에니어그램 특성]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A228850
  Found: No data. Maps four Korean suicide patterns (acute stress, chronic stress, active attempts, mental illness) onto Enneagram type characteristics.
- 2014 · Kim, J.; Lee, J. · *A concept analysis of 'deceit', the passion of Enneagram Type 3 [에니어그램 3번 유형의 격정 '기만'에 대한 개념분석]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A228853
  Found: No data. Defines attributes of the Type 3 passion 'deceit' to guide maturity and growth work.
- 2014 · Kim, H. · *Managing the passion of Enneagram Type 6 [에니어그램 6번 유형의 격정 다스리기]* · 질적연구 (Journal of Qualitative Research) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://repository.hanyang.ac.kr/handle/20.500.11754/132969
  Found: The central phenomenon was 'being captured by fear'. Outcomes ranged from lethargy or aggression to 'being the owner of my life', depending on mental-health level and self-facing.
- 2014 · Kim, E.; Lee, J. · *Effects of Enneagram-centred art therapy on self-esteem and sociability of a child with school maladjustment: a single-case study [에니어그램 중심 미술치료가 학교부적응 아동의 자아존중감과 사회성에 미치는 영향]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A229734
  Found: Self-esteem and sociability improved after the programme. A single case cannot be generalised.
- 2014 · Jung, Y. · *Strengths development using the Enneagram and information-perception systems [에니어그램과 정보인식체계를 활용한 강점개발에 관한 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://papersearch.net/google_link/fulltext.asp?file_name=5p000012.pdf
  Found: Relates centres and energy flows of each type to sensory information-perception (visual, auditory, etc.) to guide strengths development. No clear empirical results in the abstract.
- 2014 · Lee, E.; Lee, Y. · *A counselling model based on ego-consciousness phenomena and Enneagram psychodynamics [자아의식현상과 에니어그램심리역동에 관한 상담모델 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.newnonmun.com/dlink/67528.pdf
  Found: No data. Builds a counselling model combining Enneagram psychodynamics with Gestalt and cognitive approaches.
- 2014 · 이양선 (Lee, Yang Seon) · *Development of learning-attitude elements using the Enneagram and application to learning coaching [에니어그램을 활용한 학습태도요소개발 및 학습코칭에의 활용]* · 에니어그램 (Korean Society of Enneagram Dynamic Psychology), 1(1), 135-157 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A106352327
  Found: No data. Defines four learning-attitude elements (style, preference, method, conflict) and maps them to the nine types for learning coaching.
- 2014 · 이은하 (Lee, Eun Ha) · *Development of Enneagram parenting-attitude factors and application to parent education [에니어그램을 활용한 부모양육태도요인개발 및 부모교육에의 활용]* · 에니어그램 (Korean Society of Enneagram Dynamic Psychology), 1(1), 111-133 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A106352326
  Found: No data. Proposes four parenting-attitude elements and type-specific healthy response styles for parent education.
- 2013 · Xu, Z.; Huang, J. · *Study on the Enneagram model of brand personality* · Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Science and Social Research (ICSSR 2013) · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.2991/icssr-13.2013.55
  Found: Reported support for hypotheses that similarity between a brand's personality and a consumer's Enneagram type influences brand choice. The abstract gives no sample size or effect sizes.
- 2013 · Hücker, F.-J. · *Das Enneagramm: Selbsterkenntnis auf brüchigem Fundament [The Enneagram: Self-knowledge on a fragile foundation]* · Wege zum Menschen, 65(4), 346-353 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.13109/weme.2013.65.4.346
  Found: No data (conceptual critique). Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2013 · Cuyás, E. B.; Campanella, M. I. · *Enneagram: definition and foundation* ·  · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doaj.org/article/e4dbcde9f3f54ca9bb265fd69f395ae0
  Found: No data. Integrates the Enneagram with the body-centred Focusing method in a workshop design.
- 2013 · Yang, Q. · *The application of the Enneagram in mushroom management* · Value Engineering · Result: Mixed · China · http://en.cnki.com.cn/Article_en/CJFDTotal-JZGC201316101.htm
  Found: No data. Uses the Enneagram to analyse new employees' performance during their early 'mushroom management' stage, to improve job placement.
- 2013 · Liang, H. · *The application of Enneagram theory in higher vocational education* ·  · Result: Mixed · China · http://en.cnki.com.cn/Article_en/CJFDTOTAL-XZQJ201311011.htm
  Found: No data. Proposes uses in class management, teaching, mental-health tutoring and career planning.
- 2013 · Blažević, J. · *Contextual reflection on the Enneagram [Kontekstualno promišljanje o eneagramu]* · Nova prisutnost, 11(2), 265–277 · Result: Mixed · Croatia · http://hrcak.srce.hr/106395
  Found: No data. Reviews Croatian Enneagram literature, its esoteric and numerological origins, and New Age associations, and closes with critical observations on its psychological and spiritual claims.
- 2013 · Jin, J.; Choi, S. H. · *Item response analysis of the Korean Enneagram Personality Type Indicator [에니어그램 성격유형검사의 문항반응 연구]* · Korean Academy of Welfare Counseling · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://kotsa.newnonmun.com/article=58899
  Found: IRT and KEPTI classifications agreed 57.22% of the time. The authors judged the test sound, but 17 items needed revision (earlier reported α=.90, retest r=.89).
- 2013 · Yoo, S.; Jung, D. · *A study on HR management using Enneagram principles [에니어그램 원리를 이용한 HR관리에 관한 연구]* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A259597
  Found: No data. Proposes using types for job placement, type-fit communication and stress management, self-leadership and motivation.
- 2013 · Jeong, J. · *Enneagram personality types and Saju (Four Pillars) personality types, focusing on the day stem [에니어그램 성격유형과 사주명리학의 성격 유형에 대한 연구]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A210288
  Found: No data. Compares the Enneagram with Saju (Four Pillars) personality typing.
- 2013 · Hwang, I. · *Enneagram levels of development and Wilber's levels of consciousness [에니어그램의 발달 수준과 윌버의 의식 수준에 대한 연구]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A210285
  Found: No data. Compares Gurdjieff and Riso's levels of development with Wilber's levels of consciousness.
- 2013 · He, Y.; Zhao, Y.; Tian, Y. · *Dialogue, insight, enhancement: applying a three-stage method in an Enneagram course [对话、感悟、提升——三段法在九型人格课程中的应用]* · 长春教育学院学报 (Journal of Changchun Education Institute) · Result: Mixed · China · http://www.cqvip.com/QK/89411X/201319/1002792928.html
  Found: No data. Describes a three-stage method (dialogue, insight, enhancement) for an Enneagram elective, claimed to improve teaching effect.
- 2012 · Sutton, A. · *"But is it real?" A review of research on the Enneagram* · The Enneagram Journal, 5, 5-20 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://ieaninepoints.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2012-IEA-Journal_Anna-Sutton.pdf
  Found: Concludes questionnaires like RHETI and WEPSS are reasonably reliable but validity is less certain; types are distinguishable on established measures; no support yet for stress/security movement. Evidence 'promising, but by no means definitive'.
- 2012 · 김정선; 이정섭 · *Recovery process of scrub nurses' presence through Enneagram* · Qualitative Research, 13(2), 117-130 · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://doi.org/10.22284/qr.2012.13.2.117
  Found: The core category was 'recovery of presence': nurses described regaining their professional presence by understanding themselves and accepting others through the Enneagram. Qualitative, with no comparison group.
- 2012 · Satyopas, S. · *Contemplative education: an innovation for developing desirable Thai characteristics, Part 3: the Enneagram [จิตตปัญญาศึกษา ... ตอนที่ 3: ศาสตร์แห่งนพลักษณ์ (Enneagram)]* · Ganesha Journal · Result: Mixed · Thailand · https://so01.tci-thaijo.org/index.php/pikanasan/article/view/100556
  Found: No data. Describes the Enneagram as a contemplative-education tool for self-understanding and compassion, taught through group self-examination activities.
- 2012 · Chai, J. · *The role of Enneagram theory in higher education* · The Guide of Science & Education · Result: Mixed · China · https://en.cnki.com.cn/Article_en/CJFDTOTAL-KJDS201205050.htm
  Found: No data. Proposes that vocational-college teachers analyse students' Enneagram types and individualise teaching methods accordingly.
- 2012 · Yang, H. · *Ideas for introducing the Enneagram to an economic management course* · Journal of Hebei Energy Institute of Vocation and Technology · Result: Mixed · China · https://en.cnki.com.cn/Article_en/CJFDTOTAL-HBXY201201036.htm
  Found: No data. Authors report informally that using the Enneagram in management teaching raised student engagement, team spirit and cooperation; no formal evaluation.
- 2012 · Mezianova, S. · *Using Enneagram in small businesses as a way for sustainable development* · Journal of Management and Sustainable Development (University of Forestry, Sofia) · Result: Mixed · country not stated · http://oldweb.ltu.bg/jmsd/files/articles/33/05-33_Sandra_Mezianova_Paper_2012.pdf
  Found: No data. Argues that in small firms, where every employee matters, the Enneagram (types, wings, stress/security moves) can help explain motivation and attitudes to work.
- 2012 · Mishra, A.; Gahlot, H. · *Enneagram styles as personality paradigms* · International Journal of Engineering Sciences & Management, Jan–Apr 2012 · Result: Mixed · India · http://www.ijesmjournal.com/issues%20PDF%20file/Jan-Apr_2012/4.pdf
  Found: No data. Presents the nine styles as worldviews (core beliefs/schemas) that shape perception, feeling and interpersonal style.
- 2012 · Kim, J.; Lee, J. · *Scrub nurses' experience of recovering presence through the Enneagram [에니어그램을 통한 수술실 간호사의 존재감 회복경험]* · 질적연구 (Journal of Qualitative Research) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · http://dspace.kci.go.kr/handle/kci/342681
  Found: The core category was 'recovery of presence': through the Enneagram, nurses came to understand themselves and accept others. Small qualitative sample with no comparison group.
- 2012 · Jeong, J. · *A study of Enneagram personality types and tarot-card personality types (Universal Waite deck) [에니어그램의 성격 유형과 타로카드의 성격 유형에 대한 연구]* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A192475
  Found: No data. Compares the nine types and three centres with the 22 tarot archetypes for self-development purposes.
- 2012 · 유정은 · *Parent education as school lifelong education: Enneagram parent education for elementary parents [학교 평생교육으로서의 부모교육 사례연구]* · Sogang University Graduate School of Education (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T12898107
  Found: Case study of an Enneagram parent-education course run by a school; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2011 · Wiltse, V.; Palmer, H. · *Hidden in plain sight: Observations on the origins of the Enneagram* · The Enneagram Journal (first published in the 2009 edition; reprinted July 2011) · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://narrativeenneagram.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Hidden-in-Plain-Sight-Helen-Palmer-1.pdf
  Found: Argues that ideas behind the Enneagram are older than Evagrius and that his writings already contain the nine-point structure. An interpretation of history, not a tested claim.
- 2011 · Richmer, H. R. · *An analysis of the effects of enneagram-based leader development on self-awareness: A case study at a midwest utility company* · Spalding University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · USA · not yet checked
  Found: Mixed effects on self-reflection/self-awareness (per Hook et al. 2021). I could not access the original.
- 2011 · Kern, E.; Perryman, K.; Suarez, A. · *Using the Enneagram to facilitate resolution of supervisory conflict* · Journal of Counselor Practice · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.22229/htq402186
  Found: No data (conceptual). Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2011 · Han, J. · *Understanding Enneagram personality types and implications [에니어그램 성격 유형에 대한 이해와 시사점]* · Theory and Practice of Education (교육이론과 실천) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · http://www.papersearch.net/google_link/fulltext.asp?file_name=71400554.pdf
  Found: No data. Summarises type characteristics, levels of development and inter-type connections, and discusses applications in education.
- 2011 · Deng, X.; Zhang, G. · *Interpreting college students' 'depressed' mood through Enneagram theory [运用“九型人格”理论解读大学生的郁闷心态]* · 世纪桥 (Century Bridge) · Result: Mixed · China · http://www.cqvip.com/QK/81684X/201113/38782172.html
  Found: No data. Argues that students' low mood around emotions, jobs and life meaning shows up differently by Enneagram type and proposes type-based ways to address it.
- 2011 · 조윤주 (Cho, Youn Ju); 정종진 · *A case study on middle-aged female teachers' self-reflection experience through the Enneagram [중년 여교사의 에니어그램을 통한 자아성찰 경험에 관한 사례 연구]* · 교육연구 (Kongju National University Institute of Education), 25, 47-73 (from Daegu National University of Education master's thesis, 2008) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A105287825
  Found: Workshop participants reported inner change and growth through self-reflection; limited range of types and short duration noted by the authors.
- 2010 · Bland, A. M. · *The Enneagram: A review of the empirical and transformational literature* · Journal of Humanistic Counseling, Education and Development, 49(1), 16-31 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1002/j.2161-1939.2010.tb00084.x
  Found: First journal review of Enneagram research; described the model and summarised a small empirical base. Hook et al. (2021) judged it brief and limited in scope.
- 2010 · Tapp, K.; Engebretson, K. · *Using the Enneagram for client insight and transformation: A type Eight illustration* · Journal of Creativity in Mental Health, 5(1), 65-72 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1080/15401381003627277
  Found: No data. Sets out a step-by-step process for using the Enneagram with counselling clients, illustrated with a Type 8 case.
- 2010 · Pfab, A. · *Die Persönlichkeitstypologie Enneagramm: Nutzen für Mediation und Verhandlung [The Enneagram personality typology: Uses for mediation and negotiation]* · Zeitschrift für Konfliktmanagement, 13(1) · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.9785/ovs-zkm-2010-14
  Found: No data (conceptual). Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2010 · 손봉희 · *Health continuum and internal experiences of Enneagram type 9 [에니어그램 9번 유형의 건강 연속성과 내적 경험]* · Ewha Womans University (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11926804
  Found: Built a substantive theory of type-9 movement along the health continuum; very small, self-selected sample.
- 2009 · Weeks, R.; Burke, D. · *Transforming organizations using the Enneagram: A law firm case study* · The Enneagram Journal, 2(1), 6-23 · Result: Supportive · country not stated · not yet checked
  Found: Reported gains in productivity and lower staff turnover after Enneagram work (per Hook et al. 2021). This is an uncontrolled case study in a community journal; I could not access the original.
- 2009 · Mhunpiew, W. · *Development of a career counseling center model for preparing students for the world of work using Enneagram personality theory* · Scholar: Human Sciences (Assumption University) · Result: Mixed · Thailand · https://assumptionjournal.au.edu/index.php/Scholar/article/view/868
  Found: Epicure (7), Mediator (9), Trooper (6) and Giver (2) were the most common types among Thai students; a type-tailored career-counselling centre model was developed and endorsed by experts.
- 2009 · Cuyás, E. B.; Campanella, M. I. · *Enneagram: Definition and foundations [Eneagrama: definición y fundamentos]* · Miscelánea Comillas: Revista de Ciencias Humanas y Sociales · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://revistas.upcomillas.es/index.php/miscelaneacomillas/article/download/871/738
  Found: No data. Integrates Enneagram theory with Gendlin's body-centred Focusing method in a workshop design.
- 2009 · Yoo, J. · *Using the Enneagram for healing and growth in marital relationships [부부 관계의 치유와 성장을 위한 에니어그램 활용방안 연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A115593
  Found: No data. Proposes Enneagram education to improve couples' communication and marital satisfaction.
- 2009 · Park, H. · *Korean emotions and the Enneagram: Jeong and han from an Enneagram perspective [한국인의 정서와 에니어그램]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A115605
  Found: Argues jeong and han reflect the gut centre and Type 9, consistent with Type 9 and the gut centre being most common among 7,695 online test-takers; a self-selected sample.
- 2009 · Yoon, U. · *A sociocultural approach to the Enneagram [에니어그램의 사회문화적 접근]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A115600
  Found: No data. Discusses culture, personality and the Enneagram centres (head, heart and gut cultures) and calls for an integrated, healthy Enneagram culture.
- 2009 · 이호철 · *Improving ROTC cadets' branch classification using Enneagram personality analysis [학군사관 후보생 병과분류 개선에 관한 연구 : 에니어그램 성격분석 방법을 중심으로]* · 배재대학교 행정심리대학원 (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T11568127
  Found: Proposes Enneagram-informed military branch classification; no validation of placement outcomes reported.
- 2008 · Ribeiro, L. M. L. V. · *Entrepreneurship and emotional intelligence: The Enneagram as an instrument of self-knowledge [Empreendedorismo e Inteligência Emocional: o eneagrama como instrumento de autoconhecimento]* · Universidade Federal Rural do Rio de Janeiro · Result: Mixed · Brazil · https://rima.ufrrj.br/jspui/handle/20.500.14407/15197
  Found: EI correlated positively with entrepreneurship. The hypothesis that EI differs by Enneagram type was refuted, and the type-entrepreneurship link was only partly supported.
- 2008 · Bulla Varela, O. F. · *Psychographic segmentation based on Enneagram theory in the clothing purchase process [Segmentación psicográfica basada en la teoría del eneagrama a partir del proceso de compra de ropa]* · Universidad de los Andes · Result: Mixed · Colombia · not yet checked · https://hdl.handle.net/1992/20663
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2007 · Sutton, A. · *Implicit and explicit personality in work settings: An application of Enneagram theory* · University of Leeds (PhD) · Result: Supportive · UK · https://ieaninepoints.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2012-IEA-Journal_Anna-Sutton.pdf
  Found: 53 of 62 theory-derived predictions were confirmed and only one went in the opposite direction.
- 2007 · Ormond, C. H. · *The effects on emotional intelligence and team effectiveness of a newly formed corporate team learning the Enneagram* · Institute of Transpersonal Psychology (doctoral dissertation) · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Effects_on_Emotional_Intelligence_an.html?id=2Pq-tgAACAAJ
  Found: Team effectiveness improved. There was no significant change in emotional intelligence, team development, perceived stress or positive states of mind (Hook et al. 2021); with only 8 people, the study could detect only large effects.
- 2007 · Matise, M. · *The enneagram: An innovative approach* · Journal of Professional Counseling: Practice, Theory & Research, 35(1), 38-58 · Result: Mixed · USA · https://doi.org/10.1080/15566382.2007.12033832
  Found: Maps the nine styles onto DSM-IV criteria, Developmental Counseling Theory and Transactional Analysis and suggests counselling approaches for each style. No empirical data.
- 2007 · 藤波 進 · *人を育てる『性格のデザイン』: エニアグラム* · パフォーマンス教育 (Performance Education), 5 (contributed paper) · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · https://ci.nii.ac.jp/naid/40015655544
  Found: No data (conceptual). Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2007 · Luckcock, T. · *The soul of teaching and professional learning: An appreciative inquiry into the Enneagram of reflective practice* · Educational Action Research · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ828222
  Found: No data. Uses the Enneagram's nine modes to reflect on strengths of teaching and proposes it as a tool for teachers' reflective practice and professional learning.
- 2007 · Jervis, J. P. · *The Enneagram: Symbolism and community in the age of Aquarius* · Concordia University (Spectrum Research Repository) · Result: Mixed · Canada · https://spectrum.library.concordia.ca/975807/
  Found: No data. Argues the Enneagram and its communities are representative of New Age thought and practice (human potential, self-help, charismatic teachers).
- 2007 · Cho, B.; Yang, H. · *Studies on rapport forming in the sales field for customer service improvement: Focused on the Enneagram* · Journal of the Korea Academia-Industrial Cooperation Society · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.kci.go.kr/kciportal/ci/sereArticleSearch/ciSereArtiView.kci?sereArticleSearchBean.artiId=ART001229193
  Found: Proposes type-specific approaches to building rapport with customers and supports them with a survey of 375 typed respondents; the abstract gives no statistics and overstates the Enneagram's proven effectiveness.
- 2007 · Ryu, J.; Choi, M. · *Case study of Enneagram-based art therapy for depressive symptoms in a female victim of domestic violence [가정폭력피해여성의 우울증상에 대한 에니어그램을 활용한 미술치료 사례연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Supportive · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A55420
  Found: Depression scores fell markedly and the KEPTI developmental level rose from unhealthy (7-9) to average (4-6); a single case, so the evidence is anecdotal.
- 2007 · Han, J. · *Childhood experience and patterns of relationship addiction: An Enneagram and object-relations approach [어린시절 경험과 관계중독의 패턴연구]* · Enneagram Research (에니어그램연구) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A55424
  Found: No data. Links each type's childhood messages to patterns of relationship dependency (codependency) through object-relations theory; the author states it is non-statistical.
- 2007 · 윤천성 · *Approach to business administration of the Enneagram, focused on leadership [에니어그램의 경영학적 접근 - 리더십을 중심으로]* · 에니어그램연구 (Korean Enneagram Society), 4(2), 115-133 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A75254429
  Found: No data. Argues the Enneagram can be grafted onto management to analyse member dispositions and guide leadership development.
- 2006 · Lapid-Bogda, G. · *Developing communities of leaders through the Enneagram* · OD Practitioner, 38(4), 57-62 · Result: Supportive · country not stated · https://theenneagraminbusiness.com/enneagram-resources/books-research-and-case-studies/
  Found: Reports improved self-awareness, communication and working relationships among leaders after an Enneagram programme (summarised in Hook et al. 2021). Outcomes are descriptive and come from the consultant who ran the programme. OD Practitioner is a practitioner journal.
- 2006 ·  · *福祉経営とエニアグラム: 福祉職場における人間関係論* · 現代と文化: 日本福祉大学研究紀要 (Nihon Fukushi University Bulletin) · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1050564288379886208
  Found: No data (conceptual). Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2006 · Kalé, S. H.; De, S. · *Using the Enneagram for internal marketing in service establishments* · Bond University Business Publications · Result: Mixed · country not stated · http://epublications.bond.edu.au/business_pubs/24
  Found: No data. Argues the Enneagram can be used for internal marketing and other marketing issues in service firms.
- 2006 · Taylor, L. E. · *The Enneagram: A tool for self-reflection, critical appraisal and introducing spirituality in the classroom* · Canadian Society for Spirituality and Social Work conference (May 2006) · Result: Mixed · Canada · http://www.stu.ca/~spirituality/TheEnneagram2.pdf
  Found: No data. Proposes the Enneagram as a tool for critical thinking, self-other reflection and introducing spiritual values in social work education rather than for labelling.
- 2006 · Serra i Llansana, L. G. · *The Enneagram of passions: Repercussions of the dominant passions according to the Enneagram in the sphere of relationships [El eneagrama de las pasiones]* · Doctoral thesis (Dialnet) · Result: Mixed · Spain; Italy · https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/tesis?codigo=144436
  Found: Built a theory that each type's dominant passion distorts relationships with self, others, things and the divine. Participants were all from Naranjo's SAT programme; no quantitative test.
- 2006 · 양재학 · *Instructor management and effective flight-teaching methods by personality type: Enneagram theory in Air Force flight training [성격유형에 적합한 교관관리와 효과적인 비행교수법에 관한 연구]* · Gyeongsang National University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T10880578
  Found: Linked instructors' types and teaching styles to student pilots' grade changes in basic flight training; results not in retrieved abstract.
- 2005 · Kamineni, R. · *The next stage of psychographic segmentation: Usage of Enneagram* · Journal of American Academy of Business, Cambridge, 6, 315-320 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://silo.tips/download/the-next-stage-of-psychographic-segmentation-usage-of-enneagram
  Found: Proposes using the nine types for consumer market segmentation. It is purely conceptual with no empirical test.
- 2005 · Bergquist, W. H.; Goldberg, M. · *The Enneagram and executive coaching: Engaging an appreciative perspective to enrich the use of Enneagram wisdom* · International Journal of Coaching in Organizations, 3(3), 15-20 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://researchportal.coachfederation.org/Document/Pdf/2850.pdf
  Found: No data. Warns against superficial workshop use and proposes a ten-step appreciative executive-coaching process combining reflective, instrumented and observational coaching.
- 2005 · 박범석 · *교육과 종교의 관계에서 본 에니어그램* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A24982
  Found: No data. Discusses the Enneagram's integrative and transcendent view of the person as a model of holistic, non-denominational religious education.
- 2005 · 황임란 · *상담과 성격유형: 개인상담에서의 에니어그램 적용에 대한 일 연구* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A24969
  Found: No outcome data. Describes how type, developmental level and integration/disintegration were used across the stages of an individual counselling case.
- 2005 · 안현숙 · *의사소통이론에 따른 가족상담사례: 에니어그램 성격유형의 성장과 발달단계에 대한 이해를 중심으로* · 에니어그램연구 · Result: Mixed · South Korea · https://www.earticle.net/Article/A24980
  Found: Argues Enneagram growth and developmental levels are a useful guide in family therapy; author notes a single family sample and unresolved reliability questions.
- 2004 · Kaluzniacky, E. · *Enneagram personalities* · In Managing Psychological Factors in Information Systems Work (IGI Global), 62-104 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-59140-198-8.ch002
  Found: No data. Introduces the Enneagram for information-systems professionals and positions it as complementary to MBTI (MBTI explains how we function, the Enneagram why).
- 2004 · Cutting, B.; Kouzmin, A. · *A synthesis of knowing and governance: Making sense of organizational and governance polemics* · Corporate Governance, 4(1), 76-114 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1108/14720700410521989
  Found: No data. Builds a 'JEWAL' framework combining Aquinas, Lonergan, Jung, Weber and the Enneagram to explain governance, management theories and a consciousness-based character typology.
- 2004 · Sarasola, M. R. · *The Enneagram: An approach to the hidden side through mental models [El eneagrama: una aproximación al lado oculto desde los modelos mentales]* ·  · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · http://hdl.handle.net/11162/33969
  Found: No data. Uses the Enneagram's nine traits to describe micropolitics and organisational culture in schools.
- 2003 · Kale, S. H.; Shrivastava, S. · *The enneagram system for enhancing workplace spirituality* · Journal of Management Development, 22(4), 308-328 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1108/02621710310467596
  Found: Argues the Enneagram can build workplace spirituality and, through that, harmony and profitability. No data were collected and no hypotheses were tested.
- 2003 · Sayre-Adams, J. · *The Enneagram: A means to psychological and spiritual awareness* · Spirituality and Health International, 4(4), 24-31 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1002/shi.192
  Found: No data. Overview of the Enneagram's origins, the types, stress and growth directions, and the Riso-Hudson Levels of Development.
- 2002 · Newgent, R. A.; Parr, P. E.; Newman, I. · *The Enneagram: Trends in validation* · ERIC Document ED468827 · Result: Mixed · USA · https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED468827.pdf
  Found: Concludes much early Enneagram evidence was anecdotal, expert typing reliability was 'at best fair', and psychometric rigour was increasing but still insufficient.
- 2002 · 이광자 · *에니어그램의 정신간호적용에 관한 연구* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.papersearch.net/google_link/fulltext.asp?file_name=20700307.pdf
  Found: No data (literature review). Concludes the Enneagram offers growth and treatment directions useful for psychiatric nursing and notes most Korean studies are pre/post workshop evaluations.
- 2002 · Lee, Y. J. · *A study on leadership types of sports coaches based on personality* ·  · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.papersearch.net/google_link/fulltext.asp?file_name=0l100102.pdf
  Found: No data. Derives a leadership style for sports coaches of each Enneagram type (e.g., Type 1 task-oriented, Type 2 servant leadership, Type 8 authoritative).
- 2002 · 송예순 · *Effects of an Enneagram workshop on mothers' internal locus of control and educational attitudes [에니어그램 워크숍이 어머니의 내적 통제성과 교육 태도에 미치는 영향]* · Changwon National University (master's thesis) · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T9957976
  Found: Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2001 · van Berkel, R. · *Het enneagram als begeleidingsinstrument bij supervisie en coaching [The Enneagram as a guidance tool in supervision and coaching]* · Supervisie en Coaching, 18(3), 46-56 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1007/bf03079603
  Found: No data. Describes how the Enneagram can be used as a tool in supervision and coaching.
- 2001 · Kamineni, R.; Kale, S. N. · *Using the enneagram for market segmentation* · Conference paper (Adelaide Research & Scholarship repository) · Result: Mixed · country not stated · http://hdl.handle.net/2440/104793
  Found: No data. Illustrates how the Enneagram could serve as a base for psychographic market segmentation; authors note further conceptual and empirical work is needed.
- 2001 · Kalé, S. H.; Shrivastava, S. · *Applying the enneagram to manage and motivate people* ·  · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.922.135
  Found: No data. Makes a case for using Enneagram types to inform HR sub-functions and foster intrinsic motivation.
- 2001 · Kalé, S. H.; Shrivastava, S. · *Guidelines for introducing the Enneagram in the workplace* · Conference paper (Swinburne University of Technology repository) · Result: Mixed · country not stated · http://hdl.handle.net/1959.3/207174
  Found: No data. Argues for using the Enneagram to enhance workplace spirituality and offers action-learning guidelines for practitioners.
- 2000 ·  · *エニアグラムパーソナリティータイプから捉えたモチベーション理論の考察* · 杏林社会科学研究 (Kyorin University Journal of Social Sciences) · Result: Mixed · Japan · not yet checked · https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1520290884325454208
  Found: No data (conceptual). Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 2000 · 윤운성 · *에니어그램 성격검사의 고찰과 기업에의 활용* · Andragogy Today · Result: Mixed · South Korea · not yet checked · http://www.newnonmun.com/article=37207
  Found: No data. Reviews Enneagram personality testing and argues for its use in companies to improve self-awareness and interpersonal relations.
- 1999 · Shannon, J.; Schreiber, B.; Riley, C. A. · *Leading from any position* · The Serials Librarian, 36(1-2), 5-13 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1300/j123v36n01_02
  Found: No data. Describes an Enneagram leadership workshop covering communication style, leadership attributes and challenges by type.
- 1997 · Geldart, W. J. · *Fuzzy information, man, and the enneagram* · 1997 IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, vol. 1, 657-662 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1109/icsmc.1997.625828
  Found: No data. Presents the enneagram as a trivalent information model and proposes an 'enneagram of Jungian processes' model of consciousness.
- 1996 · Morris, L. R.; Cramer, S. F. · *The enneagram and the library* · Library Management, 17(4), 20-29 · Result: Mixed · USA · https://doi.org/10.1108/01435129610115335
  Found: Introduces the nine types and maps typical responses to library workplace situations. No data collected.
- 1994 · Stalfa, F. J. · *The pastoral care of sin: The Enneagram in pastoral care and counseling* · Journal of Pastoral Care, 48(1), 65-74 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1177/002234099404800108
  Found: No data. Argues that the Enneagram helps pastoral counselling address 'shadow' and sin by inviting dialogue with one's distortions without invalidating the self.
- 1994 · Van Beeck, F. J. · *Fantasy, the capital sins, the Enneagram, and self-acceptance: An essay in ascetical theology* · Pro Ecclesia, 3(2), 179-196 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.1177/106385129400300206
  Found: No data (conceptual). Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 1992 · Moore, J. · *New lamps for old: The Enneagram débâcle* · Religion Today, 8(1), 8-12 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.1080/13537909208580682
  Found: No data (conceptual critique). Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 1992 · Edwards, A. C. · *Competitiveness and apartheid in the new age: The Enneagram schools* · Religion Today, 7(2), 11-15 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · not yet checked · https://doi.org/10.1080/13537909208580666
  Found: No data (conceptual). Abstract not retrieved; check the full text before citing.
- 1992 · Wolf, K. H. · *Concatenation diagrams in personality typology: Examining enneagrams* · Social Behavior and Personality, 20(2), 101-109 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.2224/sbp.1992.20.2.101
  Found: No data. Argues enneagrams are over-simplistic nine-factor diagrams that cannot capture all interconnections and proposes more complex concatenation diagrams.
- 1991 · Edwards, A. C. · *Clipping the wings off the enneagram: A study in people's perceptions of a ninefold personality typology* · Social Behavior and Personality, 19(1), 11-20 · Result: Critical · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.2224/sbp.1991.19.1.11
  Found: People did not see adjacent-number types (wings) as most similar, so the wing hypothesis was not supported; only Types 4 and 5 were grouped together more than chance.
- 1988 · Moore, J. · *The enneagram: A developmental study* · Religion Today, 5(3), 1-5 · Result: Mixed · country not stated · https://doi.org/10.1080/13537908808580627
  Found: No data. Traces the Enneagram from Gurdjieff into pseudo-Sufism, Arica, transpersonal psychology and liberal Catholicism, and calls its lineage 'problematic'.
- 1987 · Deeken, A.; 中谷 晴代 · *The Enneagram: As a means of self-discovery [THE ENNEAGRAM : 自己発見の一手段として]* · 聖霊女子短期大学紀要 (Seirei Women's Junior College Bulletin) · Result: Mixed · Japan · https://ci.nii.ac.jp/naid/110000190236
  Found: No data. A descriptive introduction to the Enneagram's claimed Sufi origins, Ichazo's role and the nine types.

## Books worth reading (46)

- *Character and Neurosis*: An Integrative View · Claudio Naranjo · 1994 · Gateways / IDHHB · Shelf: Psychology & clinical · The psychiatrist who shaped the modern Enneagram links each type to classic psychiatric character theory. · Rests on: theory / clinical observation · https://www.ipgbook.com/character-and-neurosis-products-9780895560667.php
- *Ennea-type Structures*: Self-Analysis for the Seeker · Claudio Naranjo · 1990 · Gateways / IDHHB · Shelf: Psychology & clinical · Naranjo's own early account of the nine character structures, the source many later authors build on. · Rests on: theory / clinical observation · https://mitpressbookstore.mit.edu/book/9780895560636
- *Enneatypes in Psychotherapy* · Claudio Naranjo (ed.) · 1995 ·  · Shelf: Psychology & clinical · Talks by clinicians on working with each type in therapy, from a 1993 symposium. · Rests on: clinical observation · https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/499869.Enneatypes_in_Psychotherapy
- *The Enneagram*: Understanding Yourself and the Others in Your Life · Helen Palmer · 1988 · Harper & Row (later HarperOne) · Shelf: Foundations · The book that brought the narrative, people-describing-themselves approach to a wide audience. · Rests on: practitioner experience (panel interviews) · https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/311055
- *The Enneagram in Love and Work*: Understanding Your Intimate and Business Relationships · Helen Palmer · 1995 · HarperSanFrancisco (HarperCollins) · Shelf: Relationships · Type-by-type pairings at home and at work, with concrete notes on how each pair clashes and connects. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/the-enneagram-in-love-and-work-helen-palmer/1100616656
- *The Wisdom of the Enneagram*: The Complete Guide to Psychological and Spiritual Growth for the Nine Personality Types · Don Richard Riso, Russ Hudson · 1999 · Bantam · Shelf: Foundations · A detailed guide to the nine types, including the levels of health that show how each type can look at its best and worst. · Rests on: theory / practitioner experience · https://penguinrandomhouse.ca/books/154581/the-wisdom-of-the-enneagram-by-don-richard-riso-and-ross-hudson
- *Personality Types*: Using the Enneagram for Self-Discovery · Don Richard Riso, Russ Hudson · 1987 · Houghton Mifflin · Shelf: Foundations · The detailed source text for the levels of development, with long, careful type chapters. · Rests on: theory / practitioner experience · https://www.publishersweekly.com/9780395405758
- *Understanding the Enneagram*: The Practical Guide to Personality Types · Don Richard Riso, Russ Hudson · 1990 · Houghton Mifflin · Shelf: Foundations · Practical guidance on telling look-alike types apart and on wings, arrows and mistyping. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://www.abebooks.co.uk/9780618004157/Understanding-Enneagram-Practical-Guide-Personality-0618004157/plp
- *The Spiritual Dimension of the Enneagram*: Nine Faces of the Soul · Sandra Maitri · 2000 · Tarcher / Putnam · Shelf: Spiritual depth · A clear, psychologically grounded account of each type's core pattern and what lies beneath it. · Rests on: theory / practitioner experience · https://penguinrandomhouse.com/books/348504/the-spiritual-dimension-of-the-enneagram-by-sandra-maitri
- *The Enneagram of Passions and Virtues*: Finding the Way Home · Sandra Maitri · 2005 · Tarcher / Penguin · Shelf: Spiritual depth · An in-depth study of each type's driving emotional habit and its opposite quality. · Rests on: theory / practitioner experience · https://www.penguin.com.au/books/the-enneagram-of-passions-and-virtues-9781585427239
- *Facets of Unity*: The Enneagram of Holy Ideas · A. H. Almaas · 1998 · Diamond Books (later Shambhala) · Shelf: Spiritual depth · The deepest treatment of the Enneagram's view of reality behind each type; demanding but foundational. · Rests on: theory · https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/facets-of-unity-a-h-almaas/1103164649
- *The Complete Enneagram*: 27 Paths to Greater Self-Knowledge · Beatrice Chestnut · 2013 · She Writes Press · Shelf: Foundations · A detailed guide to the 27 subtypes, which many practitioners use to type more carefully. · Rests on: practitioner experience / theory · https://parnassusbooks.net/book/9781250450524
- *The 9 Types of Leadership*: Mastering the Art of People in the 21st Century Workplace · Beatrice Chestnut · 2017 · Post Hill Press · Shelf: Work & leadership · Each type as a leader: strengths, blind spots, and how to work with and develop them. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://leadershipnow.com/leadershop/9781682611487.html
- *The Enneagram Guide to Waking Up*: Find Your Path, Face Your Shadow, Discover Your True Self · Beatrice Chestnut, Uranio Paes · 2021 · Hampton Roads · Shelf: Self-development & practice · A step-by-step growth path for each type, short enough to use with clients. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://www.simonandschuster.co.uk/books/The-Enneagram-Guide-to-Waking-Up/Beatrice-Chestnut/9781642970319
- *The Essential Enneagram*: The Definitive Personality Test and Self-Discovery Guide · David N. Daniels, Virginia A. Price · 2000 · HarperOne · Shelf: Foundations · A short, well-tested self-typing guide by a Stanford psychiatrist; good first book to hand out. · Rests on: clinical observation, plus a paragraph test the publisher describes as research-tested · https://blackwells.co.uk/bookshop/product/The-Essential-Enneagram-by-David-N-Daniels-Virginia-Ann-Price/9780061713163
- *The Enneagram, Relationships, and Intimacy*: Understanding One Another Leads to Loving Better and Living More Fully · David Daniels, Suzanne Dion · 2018 · Morgan James Publishing (2024 edition) · Shelf: Relationships · A psychiatrist's guide to each type in close relationships, with all 45 pairings. · Rests on: clinical observation / practitioner experience · https://indiepubs.com/products/the-enneagram-relationships-and-intimacy
- *Bringing Out the Best in Yourself at Work*: How to Use the Enneagram System for Success · Ginger Lapid-Bogda · 2004 · McGraw-Hill · Shelf: Work & leadership · Applies the types to everyday work skills: feedback, conflict, teams, decisions, leadership. · Rests on: practitioner experience (organisational consulting) · https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/bringing-out-the-best-in-yourself-at-work/ginger-lapid-bogda/1122974002
- *What Type of Leader Are You?*: Using the Enneagram System to Identify and Grow Your Leadership Strengths and Achieve Maximum Success · Ginger Lapid-Bogda · 2007 · McGraw-Hill · Shelf: Work & leadership · Leadership competencies mapped to each type, with development actions for each. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://leadershipnow.com/leadershop/9780071477192.html
- *Bringing Out the Best in Everyone You Coach*: Use the Enneagram System for Exceptional Results · Ginger Lapid-Bogda · 2010 · McGraw-Hill · Shelf: Coaching · A coaching method adapted to each type: how they get stuck and what helps them move. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://www.mhprofessional.com/bringing-out-the-best-in-everyone-you-coach-use-the-enneagram-system-for-exceptional-results-9780071664479-usa
- *The Enneagram Development Guide* · Ginger Lapid-Bogda · 2011 · Enneagram in Business · Shelf: Coaching · A practical workbook of development activities for each type and subtype. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/the-enneagram-development-guide-ginger-lapid-bogda-phd/1103662293
- *Transform Your Team with the Enneagram*: Build Trust, Decrease Stress, and Increase Productivity · Ginger Lapid-Bogda · 2022 · Enneagram in Business Press · Shelf: Work & leadership · Uses the Enneagram for team-level work: trust, stress and how teams get stuck. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://bookshop.org/p/books/transform-your-team-with-the-enneagram-build-trust-decrease-stress-and-increase-productivity-ginger-lapid-bogda-phd/aa316bba49f821e1
- *Development by Design*: The Enneagram and The Law of Three · Ginger Lapid-Bogda · 2026 · Enneagram in Business · Shelf: Coaching · A newer practitioner book linking type development to the Enneagram's Law of Three. · Rests on: theory / practitioner experience · https://intl.allstora.com/products/development-by-design-the-enneagram-and-the-law-of-three
- *The 9 Ways of Working*: How to Use the Enneagram to Discover Your Natural Strengths and Work More Effectively · Michael J. Goldberg · 1999 · Marlowe & Company (now Balance, Hachette) · Shelf: Work & leadership · Lively, story-led chapters on how each type works, decides and gets along at work. · Rests on: practitioner experience (consulting) · https://www.hachettebookgroup.com/titles/michael-j-goldberg/the-9-ways-of-working/9781569246887
- *The Enneagram at Work*: Unlocking the Power of Type to Lead and Succeed · Jim McPartlin · 2021 · St. Martin's Essentials (Macmillan) · Shelf: Work & leadership · A recent, readable leadership book that turns each type into concrete workplace advice. · Rests on: practitioner experience (executive coaching) · https://readings.com.au/product/9781250777225/the-enneagram-at-work--jim-mcpartlin--2021--9781250777225
- *Nine Lenses on the World*: The Enneagram Perspective · Jerome Wagner · 2010 · NineLens Press · Shelf: Research & academic · A psychologist's thorough, research-aware account of each type's worldview, values and defences. · Rests on: theory, informed by the author's own questionnaire research (WEPSS) · https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/8686740
- *The Enneagram Spectrum of Personality Styles*: An Introductory Guide · Jerome Wagner · 1996 · Metamorphous Press · Shelf: Research & academic · A short, balanced introduction by a psychologist who developed a published Enneagram questionnaire (WEPSS). · Rests on: theory, informed by the author's questionnaire research · https://libblogs.luc.edu/alumniauthors/?p=3259
- *The Road Back to You*: An Enneagram Journey to Self-Discovery · Ian Morgan Cron, Suzanne Stabile · 2016 · InterVarsity Press · Shelf: Self-development & practice · A popular, warm and humorous introduction; useful to know because many clients have read it. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://ivpress.com/the-road-back-to-you-hardcover
- *The Path Between Us*: An Enneagram Journey to Healthy Relationships · Suzanne Stabile · 2018 · InterVarsity Press · Shelf: Relationships · How each type behaves in relationships, with practical advice; Christian publisher, broad appeal. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://ivpress.com/the-path-between-us-hardcover
- *The Sacred Enneagram*: Finding Your Unique Path to Spiritual Growth · Christopher L. Heuertz · 2017 · Zondervan · Shelf: Spiritual depth · A major contemplative-Christian treatment of the types and spiritual practice. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://www.harpercollinschristian.com/9780310348276/the-sacred-enneagram
- *Awareness to Action*: The Enneagram, Emotional Intelligence, and Change · Robert Tallon, Mario Sikora · 2006 · University of Scranton Press · Shelf: Coaching · Links the types to emotional intelligence and behaviour change in a business setting. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://www.press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/distributed/A/bo4343030.html
- *The Enneagram Field Guide*: Notes on Using the Enneagram in Counseling, Therapy, and Personal Growth · Carolyn S. Bartlett · 2003 · Stellar Press · Shelf: Psychology & clinical · A therapist's notes on using the types in counselling sessions. · Rests on: clinical observation · https://www.abebooks.com/Enneagram-Field-Guide-Notes-Using-Counseling/32249840588/bd
- *Personality and Wholeness in Therapy*: Integrating 9 Patterns of Developmental Pathways in Clinical Practice · Daniel J. Siegel, the PDP Group · 2024 · W. W. Norton & Company · Shelf: Psychology & clinical · A leading neuroscience-minded psychiatrist reframes the nine patterns for clinical practice. · Rests on: theory / clinical observation · https://mitpressbookstore.mit.edu/book/9781324016298
- *The Enneagram Map to Your Deeper Self*: Living Beyond Your Type · Sandra C. Smith · 2024 · Hampton Roads (Red Wheel/Weiser) · Shelf: Self-development & practice · A recent growth-focused book on moving beyond type habits, endorsed by Maitri. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://blackwells.co.uk/bookshop/product/The-Enneagram-Map-to-Your-Deeper-Self-by-Sandra-C-Smith-author-Sandra-Maitri-foreword/9781642970609
- *The 9 Points of Potential*: The New Enneagram Test to Discover Your Strengths and Master Leadership, Communication and Collaboration in the Workplace · Ingrid Stabb · 2025 · Hay House · Shelf: Work & leadership · A new workplace-focused book on strengths, communication and collaboration by type. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://www.angusrobertson.com.au/ebooks/the-9-points-of-potential-ingrid-stabb/p/9781401995416
- *When Working Together Doesn't Work*: An Enneagram Guide to Productive Relationships with Coworkers · Joey Stabile Schewee · 2026 · IVP · Shelf: Work & leadership · A new, practical guide to coworker friction by type (Christian publisher, workplace focus). · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://ivpress.com/when-working-together-doesn-t-work
- *The Creative Moment*: Awaken Creativity Through the Enneagram · Russ Hudson, Catherine R. Bell · 2026 · Hay House · Shelf: Self-development & practice · Russ Hudson's first new book in years, on how each type blocks and opens creativity. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/the-creative-moment-russ-hudson/1147568382
- *What's My Type?*: Use the Enneagram System of Nine Personality Types to Discover Your Best Self · Kathleen V. Hurley, Theodore E. Dobson · 1991 · HarperSanFrancisco (HarperOne) · Shelf: Foundations · An early popular introduction from the Enneagram's first wave; dated but part of the field's history. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://www.powells.com/book/whats-my-type-use-enneagram-system-9780062504210
- *九型人格*: Chinese edition of Helen Palmer, The Enneagram · 海伦·帕尔默 (Helen Palmer) · 2018 · 华夏出版社 · Shelf: 中文 (Chinese) · Palmer's classic in simplified Chinese, a reliable first book for Chinese-reading clients. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://product.suning.com/0070153176/12429740481.html
- *九型人格：了解自我、洞悉他人的秘诀*: Chinese edition of Riso & Hudson (original English title not confirmed on the page opened) · 唐·理查德·里索、拉斯·赫德森 (Don Richard Riso, Russ Hudson) · 2013 · 南海出版公司 · Shelf: 中文 (Chinese) · The widely read simplified Chinese Riso & Hudson edition, so clients and coaches share the same vocabulary. · Rests on: theory / practitioner experience · https://book.douban.com/subject/20440139/comments/
- *九型人格2*: Chinese edition of Riso & Hudson, Understanding the Enneagram: The Practical Guide to Personality Types · 唐·理查德·里索、拉斯·赫德森 (Don Richard Riso, Russ Hudson) · 2010 · 南海出版公司 · Shelf: 中文 (Chinese) · The practical typing companion in Chinese, useful for telling look-alike types apart. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://book.douban.com/review/13079046/
- *에니어그램: 이해와 적용*: Enneagram: Understanding and Application · 윤운성 (Yun Un-sung) and co-authors · 2018 · Hakjisa (학지사), Korea · Shelf: Asia · A university-level Korean textbook by a leading Korean Enneagram scholar at Sun Moon University. · Rests on: theory and practice, academic · https://m.yes24.com/Goods/Detail/61409456
- *9つの性格*: The Nine Personalities: finding your true self and better relationships · 鈴木秀子 (Suzuki Hideko) · 1997 · PHP研究所, Japan · Shelf: Asia · The best-known Japanese introduction, by a scholar and Sacred Heart sister who led a whole book series on the Enneagram. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://www.kinokuniya.co.jp/f/dsg-01-9784569557564
- *自分探し、他人探し*: Finding yourself, finding others: an introduction to the Enneagram · 鈴木秀子 (Suzuki Hideko) · 1997 · 同朋舎, Japan · Shelf: Asia · Published in a series for business people, an early Japanese take on the Enneagram at work. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://ci.nii.ac.jp/ncid/BA33065071
- *九型人格學*: Enneagram Studies · 胡挹芬 (Hu Yi-fen) · 2016 · 養沛文化館, Taiwan · Shelf: Asia · By one of Taiwan's most established Enneagram teachers, with an HR background. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://www.eslite.com/product/1001233622506095
- *人盡其才：九型人格與管理*: Making the most of talent: Enneagram and management · 孫天倫 (Sun Tianlun) · 2006 · 明報出版社, Hong Kong · Shelf: Asia · Described as the first Chinese-language book applying the Enneagram to leadership and talent management. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://ra.lib.hksyu.edu.hk/jspui/handle/20.500.11861/4514
- *Influential Selling with the Enneagram*: Unlocking the Power of Personality & Persuasion · Granville D'Souza, DBA · 2025 · Printed in Singapore (author's own edition) · Shelf: Asia · One of the few Enneagram books written in Southeast Asia, applying the nine types to selling and persuasion. · Rests on: practitioner experience · https://www.amazon.com/stores/Granville-Ed-DSouza/author/B0994HNGTS

## How to cite
Business Enneagram Asia. Enneagram Research Library. https://businessenneagramasia.com/research/ (accessed <date>).

Know a study or book we missed? Use the "Reach out to us" form on the web page.

